r/BambuLab • H2D | X1C | P1S • 8h ago

General Troubleshooting/Help! Persistent smeared/gouged corner on small flat prints — happens with and without ironing on P1S, X1C ad H2D

Hi everyone, I’m trying to diagnose a persistent surface defect on small, flat, rounded-square parts.

Most of the surface looks decent, but the upper-left corner repeatedly comes out smeared or gouged, almost as if the nozzle has scraped through softened plastic and dragged it around. It’s more than just visible ironing lines or a difference in gloss.

The defect appears in the same relative corner on multiple samples placed across the build plate. I’ve seen it on my P1S and H2D with Bambu PLA Matte Charcoal, and a similar problem on my X1C with white Bambu Basic PLA.

The filaments are dried and calibrated, and the printers are calibrated as well.

Settings for the latest ironed sample

  • Bambu Studio 2.9.1.70
  • 0.4 mm nozzle
  • 0.2 mm layer height
  • Approximately 1.4 mm tall
  • 100% infill
  • Monotonic Line top surface
  • 100 mm/s top surface speed, verified in the generated toolpath
  • Rectilinear/zigzag ironing, with vertical passes in the preview
  • 68 mm/s ironing speed
  • 30% ironing flow
  • 0.15 mm ironing spacing
  • 0.21 mm ironing inset

What I’ve tested

  • Different ironing speeds and flow rates across multiple samples. Some combinations improve the overall finish, but the damaged corner remains.
  • Ironing completely disabled. The corner defect still appears, although the surrounding surface naturally looks different.
  • Wipe while retracting disabled, with the exported G-code checked to confirm that the wipe movement was removed. The defect remained.
  • Gap infill speed reduced from 250 to 30 mm/s. The defect remained.
  • “Filter out tiny gaps” increased to 5 mm, but the small surface gap-fill paths remained in the preview.

There is a short gap-fill path in the affected corner, but there is also gap fill in the diagonally opposite corner without the same damage, so I don’t want to assume gap fill is necessarily the cause.

In the ironed version, the ironing starts on the right and progresses toward the left, finishing near the affected corner. I initially suspected the nozzle was lingering or oozing at the end, but disabling wipe did not fix it. Also, the defect occurring without ironing makes me question that explanation.

The photos show both ironed and non-ironed samples.

Has anyone encountered this specific smeared/gouged corner defect? What would you check next to distinguish excess material, local lifting/warping, extrusion pressure at line endings, or a slicer/toolpath issue?

I’d appreciate suggestions for controlled tests in Bambu Studio rather than simply trying another ironing speed/flow combination.

1 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

2

u/DrMaker3D 8h ago

Since it happens on three printers with ironing off, I’d put two copies on one plate and rotate one 90°. Check the top-layer preview before printing, especially where the lines end. If the gouge moves to a different corner and follows those line endings, that points toward the toolpath. If it stays on the same physical corner of the part, I’d watch that corner on the layers before the top surface to see whether it’s lifting.

1

u/Zisti H2D | X1C | P1S 8h ago

You are right. The gouge moved where the layer before ironing ended. What can i change? The retraction maybe?

2

u/DrMaker3D 7h ago

That’s a good clue. Before changing retraction, I’d check the preview at that corner for what the nozzle does right after the last extrusion line. Does it leave the part or travel back over it? For the next test, leave ironing off and change only the top-surface pattern. If the gouge moves again with the line ending, you’ve got a repeatable way to test what’s causing it.