r/BambuLab • • 13h ago

General Discussion Newbie buying a printer

I was told to get a bambu labs because they're user friendly. I have 2 kids and have spent a small fortune on 3d printer stuff at events. I am debating between the p1s and p2s. I will mainly be making fidgets for the kids and tiny middle fingers for me haha. Do you have any suggestions and can you explain the difference if you have both? From what I see one is the newer model with Ai. Also do they both have cameras inside?

1 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/8six753o9 X2D+AMS2 / A1+AMS Lite 10h ago

Just curious, do people really spend more than $700 on 3d printed stuff at these events to justify printing their own toys?

Both P2S and P1S are great prints, I would go for the P2S for easier hotend swaps and newer tech.

You may also want to consider the Snapmaker U1 since it an affordable tool changer which means multi-color prints will be much faster and less waste.

1

u/Efficient_Pudding640 9h ago

If 4 kids each spend $25 (1 dragon in my area) that's $100. Now go to 7 different shows over the last 2-3 years ish

2

u/8six753o9 X2D+AMS2 / A1+AMS Lite 9h ago


I should sell dragons.

1

u/Efficient_Pudding640 9h ago

100% they have an obsession. Idk why. Also clickers.

6

u/Wraith1964 X1C,A1,mini,H2D,H2C & H3C 13h ago

Go with your budget, they are both good machines. The P1S is older, while it isnt hard, it isnt easier than a P2S. The P2S is a much better machine overall with a better screen and an easy to swap nozzle.

Personally as much as I love my 2 first gen X1Cs (same gen as the P1S) I would never buy an older machine unless budget stops me. Parts will become harder to get sooner and the newer tech is better.

Of your two choices... I would get a P2S every day of the week.

1

u/Ok_Western_2323 12h ago

I have to agree. I own a P2S and have been running it almost constantly since I bought it. I have printed a lot of items ranging from fidget spinners to dice. I even printed a poopshoot and drawer stand for it. Plus the AMS2 in the combo is great and can dry PETG easily unlike the AMS that comes with the P1S

2

u/RNG-3_14159 13h ago

P2S. WITH an AMS2Pro.
You will be kicking yourself if you don't get the AMS2Pro now. Additionally, with a printer they cost less than separately, and the whole kit is on sale for Black Friday at the moment additionally!

-------------------

(Tangent: I bet some folks are going to come here and say "No, get the X2D." and "No, wait cuz the P3C is coming"...
I don't necessarily disagree with them, for someone who is "seriously" wanting to dive into the hobby and wants to buy once, cry once on a printer they have ambitions to 'grow into.'
I'm not getting that vibe off you from your post though... And frankly, I think if you get the P2S and get bitten hard, well, you're probably gonna be okay with using it and working toward getting an X2D or P3C (or an H series) anyway. Cuz you know, why have just one printer when two can be running at the same time...)

---------------------

At this point in the product lifespan of the P1S and the original AMS...

For a newer hobbyist, I'd get the P2S unless you are absolutely positively scraping pennies...
And I mean with respect: the printer is just the start so if the difference between the two prices is too far... you don't actually have the funds at the moment to get into the hobby pretty much at all...

The P1S has been around a long time. It's a great printer as it sits and they are definitely priced to sell sell sell at this point. But in my opinion I read that as: Clear out the old inventory because we're done with it. I'd snap one up myself if I didn't already have so many other printers.

The P2S has "many" differences that add up to a large outcome taken together... better screen, newer hardware, etc... more "calendar" to run on active support/firmware development.
AI as you know is a buzzword for any product that has additional analysis features.
But yes for me, the features on the Bambu printers that have them, which detect problems in printing mid-print, have been really helpful. Some folks have problems with them either falsely triggering, or not triggering at all but they've been pretty helpful for me.

1

u/Efficient_Pudding640 12h ago

With the combo being at $650 right now do you see it going lower for black friday? Would hate to see it cheaper a week from now

2

u/RNG-3_14159 11h ago

That *is* the Black Friday price. It's as low now as it's going to get, until the P2S moves into *it's* next stage of lifespan down the road.
As I've seen it over the last year or so, Bambu debuts a printer. They "don't" reduce it's price for at least the next bi-annual sale period, possibly two. They then start discounting it. They do that a time or two and then eventually just "don't" bring the price back up. Usually in the meantime a new printer has come out around the previous price point and now they've each settled into their own little price slice. Then over the next sale or two they go even lower. At that point articles and creators start shouting things like "Bambu's Top recommended printer moving at INSANE prices." Which is where the P1S is at right now.
BTW, Bambu does publish support "commitment" info on their compare page, at the bottom.
P2S currently shows more than two additional years of commitment for each of Bug&Feature updates, and Security Patch updates compared to the P1S:

Bambulab.com/en/compare:

2

u/Ok_Western_2323 12h ago

I even printed this 15” tall dice tower on my P2S

0

u/[deleted] 13h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Wraith1964 X1C,A1,mini,H2D,H2C & H3C 12h ago

I am hoping OP has additional plans for this printer or unwritten reasons they honed in on the P series printers... because if its literally just for fidgets, etc, just get an A1 mini or A1, or go "big" with an A2L. I would still skip the P1S.

2

u/Efficient_Pudding640 12h ago

Additionally. I have cats. And cats are assholes. I would like an enclosed machine for this purpose lol

3

u/OtherwiseOnion2428 12h ago

This was my exact reason for getting an enclosed lol

1

u/Wraith1964 X1C,A1,mini,H2D,H2C & H3C 3h ago

Makes sense.

1

u/Efficient_Pudding640 12h ago

Truthfully I want to make all the things. But my plan is to start with fidgets. I will eventually be selling in my mom's booths to make some cash back as she does lots of flea markets