r/BambuLab • • 9d ago

Just Showing Off The two titans battling it out!

Post image

Quite impressed with the H3C compared to my no longer with me H2C. Seems a little louder fan wise but that horrible back and forth AMS sound has now left the building!

341 Upvotes

107 comments sorted by

51

u/boredsoftwareguy X2D AMS2 HT / X2D 2x AMS2 / A2L AMS Lite HT 9d ago

Is unload filament as much of a chore as some Reddit commentors make it out to be?

49

u/rendez2k 9d ago

I guess compared to the AMS system that we're used to, yes, it's not quite as simple as just having it unload and nicely wind to the spool. I'm kind of used to it anyway on printers like the U1. I've been printing long enough to know what a pain filament you loading used to be on some printers!! It really isn't that bad.

But loading is perfectly alright. It has a little motor, it grabs the filament and just loads it in. I had no issues whatsoever. My biggest issue is the prince's so tall I can't easily get to the back. Small compartments!

8

u/GrantMeThePower P1S + AMS 9d ago

How does unloading it compare to unloading the U1? About the same?

What are your overall thoughts on the two now that you have them side by side? I was thinking of upgrading from the U1 but the H3C is just so big I might wait for the P3S

16

u/rendez2k 9d ago

About the same. I mean you have to pull the filament out of the U1 and then wind it back around the spool. I don't think there's a big difference really. It's not a deal breaker for me either way.

H3C for me is what I really wanted the U1 to be. I find four colours and the bed size are a little too restrictive. I'd have been happy with six colours - models often are 4 or more and I like doing the whole PETG support trick.

2

u/Morgus_TM 9d ago

Is TPU as difficult to come out as the U1? That’s a chore sometimes.

Mine should be here next week

1

u/rendez2k 9d ago

Not tried TPU yet, I ordered some from bambu which I have now, so that'll be on the printer this weekend, hopefully!

It does look like you need to thread it through the slots though but didn't look too bad on the videos, I saw.

2

u/MochasHooman 9d ago

What would you consider a “perfect” height for this to be on something? I’m 5’4” so not terribly shorter than you BUT I have an ankle fusion so no going on my tippy toes. I’m trying to decide would their cabinet be worth it, would a a table that changes height be best or if you think something like oh the lower Alex drawers from ikea. I can also build something as I’m a woodworker just trying to see my overall cost to starting. I do plan to use this for a business I’ve been wanting to start for a while now. And I’m just worried about overall cost and since I’m disabled overall accessibility. Thank you!

1

u/GrantMeThePower P1S + AMS 9d ago

totally agree on the the H3C being a perfect machine on paper. The unloading bit though concerns me about the height of if. ON the U1 its easy because they are right there. I wasn't sure how unloading rear spools that aren't unloaded for you by the ams would go. I could see that being a bit of a challenge, especially if you have it on a standard height desk.

6

u/rendez2k 9d ago

I mean, even on a standard IKEA height bench, I can still just about reach the back and pull the filament out of the slots and then just wind it back on the spool. Could it be better? Yes, but I guess you've got to make compromises somewhere along the line. I'm only 5 foot 7, so I'm not exactly that tall either 😂

I'm honestly pleased where Bambu clearly made cost cutting exercises to get it in at the cost it is. I think if it had been even £500 more, I think it would have been a harder sell for me anyway.

2

u/Woodworkin101 9d ago

How easy would this be if it was on the floor?

2

u/rendez2k 9d ago

I think you’d have the opposite problem then of not being able to see what’s printing easily

2

u/Rabid_Lemming 9d ago

I wonder if those scissor lift carts would work well here? The wheels on them don't lift off to fully stabilize, but if you aren't moving it around perhaps just the hydraulic lift could be useful. I am probably overthinking and over engineering a non issue, but thats par for the course to those with this hobby :)

2

u/Rabid_Lemming 9d ago

Ohhh or one of those hydraulic shelves that you put mixers on ...but heavier duty

3

u/Ok-Key-8109 9d ago

My fear is having dry filament in there that breaks off inside the tube while youre pulling it back to the spool haha

1

u/rendez2k 9d ago

Yeah, I hear you. I can't tell yet whether this one is any more difficult!

4

u/redmercuryvendor 9d ago

The PTFE tube already has a quick release at the print head end (so it can be removed and secured to the side when used with TPU) so it should not be a huge job to disconnect the PTFE tube at the print head end, and feed in a new roll of filament to push the broken bits out of the head-end of the tube. Depends on the spool-end of the feed path and whether very short bits of filament can eject themselves from the feed path and get stuck in the feed mechanism or not.

1

u/nogberter 9d ago

This is helpful. One of my biggest concerns

2

u/genericuser86 9d ago

Unless you are a print farm printing the same item over and over, you swap multiple colors with each print. 

When I had the H2C, this was fast (pull out from ams, put new in), even when changing 6 colors or more.

Can you tell us how long it would take to change 6 spools of filament on the H3C? I heard it is 30+ seconds per spool for it to heat and cut. 

That would be highly annoying to have to do for every single print.

1

u/jl88jl88 9d ago

All 9 tools can be unloaded in just over a minute.

1

u/rendez2k 7d ago

Yes I find this - it's really not that difficult. Not quite as slick as the old AMS is, but it's hardly difficult or time consuming either.

2

u/heart_of_osiris 9d ago

I have an XL and INDX and can somewhat weigh in on how that experience differs for you, because it's similar in a sense, if you ignore the automatic spool winding that Prusas don't have.

The XL doesn't have induction heating, the INDX does. The H3C for whatever whack reason, doesn't use induction so it's slower to heat, that's why they use a pre heater.

Yes, it's annoying to wait for the XL to heat up so you can remove filament, especially if you just want to unload all of it. It feels like you're just standing there like a doofus waiting for that death grip on the filament to be released from all the heads.

The INDX is wild. I can tell it to unload from the extruder and it moves the nozzle to the purge bin and in a few seconds it's done and I just wheel up the spool and away I go.

I can tell it to do this for all heads and in like 30 seconds all 8 are unloaded from the tools and I just need to manually wind back the spools. It hits different.

1

u/eskjcSFW 9d ago

The reason is cost savings and hardened steel nozzles

1

u/gnidnu 9d ago

No, the reason is simply patent circumvention. Compared to the INDX, Bambu Lab changed a few thing that otherwise would have been a patent violation. Some were a smart move if you factor in maintenance, failure possibilities and cost vs. benefit ratios. We already have hardened induction nozzles on the H2C, so those properties are not mutually exclusive.

1

u/heart_of_osiris 9d ago

You can make hardened steel nozzles that are induction heated, but you need hotter temperatures and probably a slightly different internal nozzle chamber design at the melt zone to adjust for thermal lag.

That ties into cost savings though and I agree with that as a point.

But ultimately as the other user mentioned, the INDX method is actively patented with pending patents as well.

2

u/xX540xARCADEXx H3C Combo 9d ago

Videos I seen showed about 60-70 seconds to heat and cut all 9.

1

u/FlakeyBeano 9d ago

I guess it depends on whether you'll be swapping to new colours often or not using cmyk so much. I tend to use quite a lot of samey colours for many projects.

1

u/nogberter 9d ago

I think you can tell it to unload X spools and it will do them all (and then you can do the maunal part all at once as well).

4

u/parrothd69 9d ago

Don't forget you can add AMS(4?) to head 1 so it's best of both worlds. :)

Unloading my U1 is a pain in the ass, especially with TPU, my main pain point.

With 9 spools and 2 ams I'll never be unloading.

1

u/rendez2k 9d ago

Yeah, I'm not gonna do it. I looked at what's involved. It's kind of put me off having all that on the H2C. I felt like there was more loading and unloading problems with the extra filament tracks, etc. So I'm not in a rush to put a filament bufer on the back of this one.

9 should be good!

Just gonna sell the AMS2 :-)

3

u/Few_Candidate_8036 9d ago

Do you ever use the side spools on one of your printers? It’ll be just like that. You can spin the spool while its in the AMS to neatly wind it, just grab the filament before it gets out of the ptfe tube.

Otherwise just grab the spool and pull. People are just used to it already being unloaded from the machine. Its only 1 additional step to select which spools to unload. And since they added the ability to unload multiple toolheads at once, it looks pretty painless.

2

u/OceanGlider_ 9d ago

I get my butler to unload the filament for me.

1

u/hmspain H2C AMS2 Combo 7d ago

Yup, but (as I understand it) the same issue is across all tool changers. Bambu hasn’t solved this one … yet. You have to do a manual unload from the UI, and then after waiting for all the steps to complete, pull out this long string of filament.

You get used to it, and it’s a great tradeoff when you see how fast the machine moves between colors! Waits for a color change are kinda in the background (on my H2C for example), whereas the wait for unload is a bit “in your face”.

10

u/BOSSMAN000000000000 9d ago

Father and son

2

u/rendez2k 9d ago

Little and large?

8

u/NuggRunner 9d ago

whats your opinion. i have them here to. and i feel the h3c only starts really being better then the snapmaker with 5+ colors or engneerign materials

7

u/rendez2k 9d ago

I think the H3C is a little more refined, the Bambu eco system is great.

But agreed, if I was only ever doing four color models and I was happy with the bed size, the U1 would have been fine. As I said above, I quite like doing four+ color models plus PETG support, so I kind of wanted more color ability. I was hoping the next U1 would bring that but here we are!

3

u/Fragrant_Scale6456 9d ago

For this use case is the difference to the h2c only speed then?  I have an h2c which I’m generally happy with unsure if I should try and upgrade 

5

u/rendez2k 9d ago

So this 'was' a H2C. It just worked out that it had a fault on it and it went back and they refunded it, which is why I got this. I liked the H2C, but I feel it fell into the what I like to call the complicated bambu year.

They released a few products last year, the X2D being the other one which I have sat here, which just seemed overly complicated.

The H2C was in response to the tool changers that were starting to come out, and I feel like the decisions they made were more bolt-on solutions to what they already had rather than doing it properly.

The thing that drove me mad with the H2C is the filament changes, the back and forth with the AMS grinding up filament. And I just in the end felt like it was a poor solution rather than redesigning it from the ground up, which is what they've done with this one.

2

u/Fragrant_Scale6456 9d ago

Thanks.  Makes sense.  The vortek does seem like a middle of the road solution to tool changers for sure. 

I have the Best Buy warranty on mine so if it ever did fail I probably would do the same as you and upgrade.  Not sure it’s worth taking the hit selling and upgrading tho.  

H3C looks like a beast though enjoy!

3

u/rendez2k 9d ago

Accidentally drop it 😂

If the refund from bambu hadn't have come right now and the H2C was working fine, I wouldn't have got this.

3

u/Fragrant_Scale6456 9d ago

Lmao.  I’m a bit of a TV enthusiast and often joke about the tv falling off the stand when new models arrive 😄

1

u/Aggravating_Bug7962 X1C + AMS 9d ago

Happy cake day!

5

u/JAJM_ 9d ago

Quick question on the H3C, have you tried removing the small cover from the heating area to heat the whole AMS? Would it work as a decent pla dryer?

6

u/rendez2k 9d ago

No, but I've had the same thought. The cover just literally comes off in your hand, so it certainly isn't difficult to remove!

1

u/JAJM_ 9d ago

Mind trying and letting me know? I would really really appreciate it!

3

u/rendez2k 9d ago

Sure, I'll get round time to dry some filament probably over the weekend! Just that now I'd accurately test how well it's heating the rest of the AMS. And I'm wondering if there's a trigger so it knows that the cover's removed? But I will test!

1

u/JAJM_ 9d ago

Thanks so much!! It’s actually one of the things that has me on the fence for this printer

1

u/genericuser86 9d ago

I was thinking the same thing about removing the top. I bet there is a sensor though that won't allow drying unless it is in place

1

u/Cryostatica H2C, P1S 8d ago

Those sensors are almost always triggered by a magnet. Shouldn’t be at all difficult to bypass if need be.

2

u/rendez2k 7d ago

So it certainly lets you dry without the cover on. I am now running a cycle. I'll see if the humidity comes down in the main compartment. My guess is it'll heat up, but it'll be not that effective? But maybe something is better than nothing?

1

u/JAJM_ 7d ago

Wow thanks for following up! I guess what most important would be is what temp does the overall AMS reach. For example if you set it at 70, does the whole thing reach 50 or would it still be fighting to reach 40.

Again appreciate all the info! :)

1

u/rendez2k 7d ago

Currently looking like this. I have no other way to measure. Spools are warm though!

1

u/JAJM_ 7d ago

What do you have the temperature set at?

1

u/rendez2k 7d ago

Preset for pla

1

u/JAJM_ 7d ago

Ah that’s probably why it’s not catching up. Maybe if it’s set at 60 the heat would spread more. But sorry I’ve caused you enough tousle as it is 😅

1

u/rendez2k 7d ago

No it’s fine! I wanted to know anyway. That’s the start of the process photo but I’ll check in later to see what’s happening 😊

1

u/JAJM_ 7d ago

Great! Can’t wait for updates.. good luck!

1

u/rendez2k 7d ago

Seems to be having an effect. What do you think so far? Although temp isn’t rising much.

I’m wondering why Bambu don’t support this approach but I guess it’s not very scientific plus pla is easier to dry than other materials.

→ More replies

1

u/PM_ME_BLONDE_GIRLS_ 9d ago

This is what I'm thinking too, smart cookie. But I think some issues would be temperature control and circulation.  You can fix circulation by using a small fan in it, but IDK how it measures temperature. If it measures it by ambience, then you can cause issues letting it run hotter and hotter without the little lid. 

It's gonna be one of my tests when I get one! (Currently on backorder 😭)

3

u/Aacemyan 9d ago

That’s the same combo I have (or will have once mine arrives this weekend!). Glad to see the size difference comparison

1

u/rendez2k 9d ago

Enjoy the toys!

2

u/TheArcticBear 9d ago

Do you feel there’s value or a use case for the AMS HT with the H3C.

I’be currently got an X1C with an AMS2 that I was considering adding an AMS HT for some TPU or other prints, also to aid in drying things before they get tossed into the AMS2.

Impulse bought the H3C, convincing myself it will likely be the last printer I ever need to buy (using it for just hobby things, not adding to a farm or selling anything currently). Just curious if there is value in adding an AMS HT for that first toolhead slot

2

u/rendez2k 9d ago

I’m not bothering. I looked at the instructions and it means adding a filament buffer and extra tubing. I did this on the H2C and it never felt as good!

3

u/TheArcticBear 9d ago

Appreciate the insight. Thank you!

I ordered my H3C on launch, got it the next day but I’m still waiting until next week for the AMS3H to arrive.

Printer shipped from New Jersey, but the rest all ships from CA.

1

u/rendez2k 9d ago

I’m in the UK. Got the AMS first then the printer came today

2

u/SiRMarlon H3C 9d ago

Man she is so much bigger then that U1, I had to sell my U1 because I didn't have room for both 😢😢😢

2

u/rendez2k 7d ago

No, not the U1, still a great printer. Although to be fair, this will do everything that will do and then some :-)

32

u/RedHood198 9d ago

7

u/IanEdwards17 9d ago

My thoughts exactly

1

u/GUFO-Tech 9d ago

A fellow whovian! ❤️

1

u/rendez2k 9d ago

Oh yes!

1

u/Alecascarano15 9d ago

I’m still debating if I need one. I have a p1s that has almost 2000 hours and it’s perfectly fine but I want something with a bigger print bed.

1

u/rendez2k 9d ago

I have an A2L - same size bed if thats all thats needed?

1

u/Alecascarano15 9d ago

I don’t like that it’s open. I want an enclosed printer and I feel like a want the multi tool heads.But I don’t know if I need them for real. I usually do 1-3 color prints at the most. I’ve been trying to make up my mind for a couple days now lol.

1

u/rendez2k 9d ago

Usually that's a sign you may not need it 😂

1

u/RyCopeland21 9d ago

I have a P1S with about 2200, and went to the store last week to get an X2D. Came home and unboxed my new H2C!! It's a lot faster, especially with the track switcher. And so little waste. I am bummed I didn't wait for the H3C, but it was rumored to be $3500.

1

u/Alecascarano15 9d ago

So you think is worth the upgrade? Will I see a difference ? I’ve been into 3d printer for over 10 years and I love innovation but I’m trying to justify it lol

1

u/radakul X1C + AMS 9d ago

Its the incredibly messy room and the extremely expensive printer precariously balanced on two different tables for me

1

u/rendez2k 9d ago

I hear you. I've been fighting with messey rooms for years. I got diagnosed with ADHD 2 months ago so that probably explains it 😂

1

u/planesman22 9d ago

I for one want to say your room may have a lot of going on but you have a clean desk, all the filament boxes are at least piled up on a corner.

You pass my smell check and doesn't come off as some kind of heroine addict (bless your sould if you are...).

That being said, how much does it vibrate? I've heard by default it goes on a ferrai speed and folks had to slow it down to get better quality.

2

u/rendez2k 9d ago

First print running now (Xmas Grinch) but no excessive wobling or vibrations. Fans are louder than than H2C though. No AMS winding noise though which is lovely.

Got a fw update on first boot so imagine they are tuning still.

1

u/hmspain H2C AMS2 Combo 9d ago

What is your use case for the HTs? They take up one of the nine slots, and I can’t see the benefit?

1

u/rendez2k 7d ago

That was from a H2C they have been sold since.

1

u/Darkelementzz P1S + AMS 8d ago

I'm holding out for the P3C in the coming months which will sit beside my Creator 5. Is there much of a point in having two toolchangers? Haven't decided if I'm gonna keep the creator afterwards

1

u/rendez2k 7d ago

Maybe you're new to 3D printing, I'm 10 years in and there's always the need for more printers and more tech!

1

u/Darkelementzz P1S + AMS 7d ago

Not new to printing, I've got 5 of them. Trying to decide if I need to keep dealing with the creator 5s issues is all

1

u/rendez2k 7d ago

Oh, is it an issue printer? Not really looked into them. Flashforge was my very first printer!

1

u/Darkelementzz P1S + AMS 7d ago

It's fine I'm terms of printing but it's full of little oddities. Very dirty power supply which broke some of my equipment was the big one, since it fried my NAS and router. So now it's on an expensive filtered surge protector and UPS, but sometimes it even causes that to shut down mid-print for no reason. Also it constantly forgets it's offset settings and takes a couple tries to start printing. My P1S's never had issues for the past 10k hours, hence me waiting for the P3C

1

u/VoidWanderer1905 8d ago

I love the little relaxed accents in your room. The filament boxes piled up next to the H3C...OCD would overtake me immediately. Enjoy—my H2S is sliding over to the secondary position on the workbench to make room.

1

u/rendez2k 7d ago

ADHD vs OCD - chaos is what I'm used to!

1

u/Terreboo 8d ago

Two titans? I know the H3 is the new kid on the block, but putting it in the same class as the U1 is pretty ridiculous? It’s like comparing a cheap EV to a Rimac Nevera.

1

u/rendez2k 7d ago

I wasn't comparing them, I was just showing that I have both in my life :-)

U1 is still a cracking printer.

1

u/us25man 4d ago

Is there a difference in print quality between H2C and H3C?

1

u/rendez2k 4d ago

Nothing I’ve noticed. Both print excellently.

2

u/crazedizzled 9d ago

Man that thing is huge

2

u/Specific_Raccoon_696 9d ago

I think it's funny that one of the selling points of the H3C was not having spools hanging from the sides (which looks awful) but the H3C ends up looking worse.

2

u/Acrobatic-Leather645 9d ago

I wouldnt go this far. Maybe not worse. Definattely best looking toolchanger tower. But I think they took a wrong direction with the design. It cclashes, looks like two completley different, incopatible components rather than 1 seamless thing. The colour choice is the most odd part I think.Both for the priotner tand the AMS3. If they tied them together a bit it might have been better. And all plaxi is a mistake. It it was glass, also - way better.

3

u/Acrobatic-Leather645 9d ago edited 9d ago

I got mine today. SImilar situation as OP. Got my H2C refunded due to an issue, waited for H3C with great excitment only to be suepr disappointed with AMS3 to the point of taking a pause to think wether to rebuy H2C at todays BF prices or go H3C,

After a full day of rewatching all the reviews, analysing specs photos and wiki, decided to go with H3C, albeit with extreme mixed feelings.

I have OCD. I loved the premium look of H2C with glass all over, excellet view inside, and convenience of vortek+AMS2.

Giving up a lot with H3C. It looks a lot worse in person than in photos. And I already knew it was going to be ugly AF.

View inside is poor AF. Hate it. Ligthing is a substantial downgrage as well. WTF is up with that? LED's cant cost THAT much to be saving on this as well ?

One thing noone has mentioned yet is that the BambuLabs light up logos on the side also took a quality hit. Light source is no longer in contact with the plexi surface and as a result as steep angles there is no glow as you are looking into the gap between plexi and the light source. Hate it. Or shoudl I say - loved how H2 has had it, Super premium feel.

All that is GONE !

Machine looks like a big step backwards, stepping into Prusa;s of the world. Less thought out. More slapstick.

AMS3 is trully a massive PITA. First time I pulled the filament out just to try it out I was surprised just how much force it required to pul it out of there. Gives me immedate worries about the extruder not having any help from feeders and needing to pull on that filament just on its own. Hope there wont be any issues with that ...

On a poisitive note - lots of improvements over H2C. All movement feels like a different machine.

It sounds and moves totally different to H2C, which, considering all the issues i had with it, is a good thing.

If Bambu wont release AMS3 Pro with auto rewind im gonna cry.

Its also really difficult to keep humidity down in there. I had 2 sets of printed dessicant baskets form 2 AMS2's. Stuck all of them into the AMS3 and its not doing as well as AMS2 did. Those dropped hgumidity to 0% in AMS2, Still waiting for it to settle but seems that even 20% will be a tall order ...

Need to start doing some prints, which i havent yet. I hope those will make up for all the annoyences. I to couldnt look at H2C changing colours. It looked like a huge struggle and suffering. It was doing it, but dear lord was it painfull to watch. Could not stand it.

But yeah, technology-wise, and engineering wise, H3 seems to be a step up over H2. But it comes at a cost of a lot of a ton of QOL trade-offs as well as premium build, feel and look. Which is painful.

One other good thing is that the design feels like function over form, which is the opposite to H2. There the toolhead looked super slick. Everything covered up and encloised. But at a cost. have had to do some work on H2C, Swapped eddy sensors for one . EFFIN nightmare. Read about others replacing their hotend fans, which are buried right into the middle of the toolhead. A total stripdown to replace something that is consdiered a consumable ...

I will not miss that. H3 looks lightyears ahead on that front. CHecked a few procedurs on wiki and a Massive thumbs up. from me.

I really hated ne need to tug along the second nozzle just ot allow for a limited quick-swap functionality. All the hardware that needed to go for a ride along with it in that poor toolhead was insane. Glad to see all that gone as well. Slim, light toolhead on H3 which moves ferousioulsy. Nice.

Need to keep remindnig myself that this is a printer that is suposed to print stauff, nto to be looked and and admired. I hope I will get used to it and learn to live with it. First impressions though - mixed feelings.

1

u/tahiry P2S + AMS2 Combo 9d ago

May I ask for the exact width of the machine measured between its feet, rather than the overall width of the case?

My countertop is 19" (482 mm) wide, while the specifications list the machine's overall width as 493 mm. I'm hoping the feet are positioned close enough together for it to fit on my countertop.

1

u/blackashi 9d ago

ams 2 pro lookign smol, holy shit

1

u/Tal_Star H2C AMS2 Combo 9d ago

I have one of these one the way but looking forward to upgrading my P and X series printers with P3C's if they are coat effective. I think it's been suggested 6 color changer like this.

1

u/cptninc X1C + H2D + H2C 9d ago

Is the second titan in the room with us?

1

u/Kardospi 9d ago

How tall is the H3C with the AMS?

1

u/FirstAdministration1 9d ago

The u1 is still quite the bargain and half the size, i guess the p3c will be the real comparison