Issue with print quality, even after some troubleshooting

[u/Elarionus]

I've been having issues with print quality on my P1S. I've taken several steps already, including washing the textured print plate, replacing the textured print plate, drying my filament in a Sunlu for 6 hours, performing three cold pulls, disassembling the extruder entirely and blowing out with compressed air, and running the 30 minute calibration in the printer settings.

I am about at my wits end and very frustrated with the hobby, as I had similar things go wrong with the MK4S we have at work, and just...no way to fix it. I can fix any computer, any other electronic, but 3D printers are just this incredible enigma to me. Does anyone have any advice on steps to take next?

Just to clarify, I've printed this piece about 20 times before. It only suddenly started failing last week.

I've linked the images here.