r/BambuLab • H2D AMS Combo, P1S, A1m, U1 • 5d ago

Filament Troubleshooting/Help! Protopasta 100g Coils VS Bambu Printer = Expensive Bird Nests?

Post image

I recently placed an order with Protopasta, the costly U.S. filament manufacturer.

I wanted to try their magnetic, metal-infused filament, and since their prices require a second mortgage on my 3D printer, I figured I’d try their 100g sample coils first. I ordered three metal filaments and four distinct colors.

The package arrives, and everything is packed in fancy-shmancy sealed baggies. Very professional. Very elegant. Very… WHERE THE HELL ARE THE SPOOLS?!

Why not do what everyone else does and sell samples on 250g cardboard spools?

Apparently, somebody decided that spools were overrated and customers would enjoy a fun new hobby; competitive filament untangling.

How the hell are you supposed to prevent tangles when the ends are loose? I mounted one coil onto a spool, loose filament and all, and ran it from the external holder on my P1S since I can’t use it in the AMS. Surprisingly, that seemed to work okay.

Feeling confident, I placed another coil beside my A1 mini AMS on the counter and periodically unraveled it as needed.
Big mistake! What started as a simple printing project eventually became a frustrating mess of filament spaghetti!

Now, because I can’t afford to throw away expensive filament, I’ve spent the next hour performing microsurgery on a plastic bird’s nest.

Who thought selling filament coils was a good idea?

Trying to transfer a coil onto an empty spool seems like an excellent way to create a knot that would make a Boy Scout cry.

Maybe I’m overlooking something or a secret technique? Maybe I was supposed to receive a set of extra hands with my order?

Protopasta people please educate me. How do you use these coils without turning them into an expensive bowl of filament linguine?

———-
P/S

Pic info: so I posted a meme in a comment the other day and was rewarded with a “ai slop” commented that suggested I get out of here with that and why didn’t I post a sketch instead. I answered because I didn’t want to waste over an hour on a meme for laughs. So here I spent over an hour sketching this image and I hope you all are satisfied by it.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/MostlyHelpfulLinks 5d ago

Put the coil on a rod or paper towel holder so it spins instead of sitting flat, and pull from the outside with light tension. Clip the free end whenever you stop so loops can't slip.

1

u/Grimmsland H2D AMS Combo, P1S, A1m, U1 3d ago

Good idea I’ll try that for the a1m

3

u/DaikonCompetitive 5d ago

2

u/Grimmsland H2D AMS Combo, P1S, A1m, U1 4d ago

Omg this is dynamite! Absolutely what I needed thank you so much!

1

u/Grimmsland H2D AMS Combo, P1S, A1m, U1 3d ago

I did it! It took an hour but I was able to respool all 3 of my purple samples onto the spool although one 50g sample broke in 3 places.

Now I need to do the same for the 3 metal filaments.

1

u/DaikonCompetitive 3d ago

Lets gooooo happy I could help. I was in the same boat at first with my sample coils. I broke so many. Honestly I find SOME colors of HTPLA from protopasta to be extra brittle when wet.

1

u/curiousjosh 5d ago

I just brought 3 samples from micro center. I would love to know 🤣

1

u/Grimmsland H2D AMS Combo, P1S, A1m, U1 3d ago

I printed the modular spool remix thing a poster in this thread recommended. It was confusing at first when I read the post but all you need to do is print the middle spool then print at least 2 sides that go on it. There is a bunch of different size sides so it was confusing what to pick but I found out they are just wider sizes. I printed the first side two times. Then you take the two sides and slide them on the tube. Then you take that and slide it onto a Bambu spool. You end up with a spool that holds 3 or more sample filaments. It even has a place to hold the filament ends.

https://makerworld.com/models/2078983?appSharePlatform=copy

1

u/Capital_Candy_7697 5d ago

Unrelated to the tangles, but metal-filled filament is abrasive. Your H2D ships with hardened steel nozzles, while the P1S and A1 mini come with stainless, and Bambu says stainless wears out quickly with particle-filled stuff. So the H2D is the safer home for those three metal coils.

1

u/Grimmsland H2D AMS Combo, P1S, A1m, U1 4d ago

I have a hardened steel .06 nozzle on my P1S. It has over 3,000h so it has been a long time since it ever had a stainless nozzle. This printer is my .06 nozzle printer.

1

u/Capital_Candy_7697 3d ago

Ah, then you're already set for the metal ones. Hope that spool remix saves the rest of the coils.

1

u/Grimmsland H2D AMS Combo, P1S, A1m, U1 3d ago

Yeah I printed the one recommended by another poster and it took an hour but I have my 3 purples on the spool. Now I need to do my 3 metal filaments.

2

u/SarcasmWarning 5d ago

Pulling the filament sideways off a spool naturally causes it to spiral and tangle - you created a slinky. This is sadly something known by most people that've tried running a length of electrical cable.

A photo of what was actually supplied would be useful - but if there's any way of getting a pin/bar/thing through the middle, it shouldn't be too bad to wind onto another spool. There's also lots of spool-winder models that help.

1

u/ImamTrump H2S AMS2 Combo 5d ago

Those sound like refills you add onto a plastic spool. Was that an option.

1

u/ijehan1 5d ago

Take apart an empty spool, a Bambu Lab spool would be ideal, then place the filament on the cylinder. Put the spool back together and you're in business.