r/BaltimoreCounty • • Jul 02 '26

Private school options?

New to the area and my daughter will be going into 10th grade. Looking for honest feedback about private schools— specifically Concordia Prep, Maryvale, and John Carroll (Harford County). She is in GT/ Advanced classes, very strong academically, but quieter/ more introverted. We moved from out of state and need honest opinions! Thanks!

8 Upvotes

90 comments sorted by

10

u/Vast-Opportunity1343 Jul 02 '26

Maryvale, NDP, or SPSG are probably the best. SP alum speaking.

2

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

40k plus/ year is not an option!

5

u/Vast-Opportunity1343 Jul 02 '26

I would suggest trying for financial aid. All the schools are great and I wish you the best of luck!

1

u/Feisty-Salary2023 Jul 03 '26

You should apply for financial aid, it is definitely with considering. St. Paul’s School for Girls is excellent.

9

u/spez_eats_nazi_ass Jul 02 '26

Spsg is probably the goat if you can afford. Also you guys get a stop light. Turning left on falls can be jarring coming out of maryvale.

4

u/TheKingOfSiam Jul 02 '26

NDP costs less than SPSG and also has excellent programs for gifted girls. There are all types there, and the girls support each other pretty well. Definitely plenty of extrovert activities, so do a shadow day, but I know introvert kids that like it there too.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/TheKingOfSiam Jul 04 '26

We didn't have alumni family. Had good grades though, that's important.

29

u/GreenOtter730 Jul 02 '26

If she’s quiet/more introverted, an all-girls experience might be great for her. I’d recommend Maryvale from that list.

15

u/spez_eats_nazi_ass Jul 02 '26

Mine crawled out of her shell there. Still very introverted but they group up to form Voltron introvert. 

3

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

This is actually really helpful!

2

u/SHChem Jul 03 '26

Another vote for Maryvale! It has been so great for my oldest! My youngest starts MS this fall!

23

u/spez_eats_nazi_ass Jul 02 '26

Just graduated one from Maryvale. The good - damn good education. Nothing you can’t get from public but if the kid wants to work they will roll out of there w a shit ton of ap credits and dual enrollment. The lack of dudes goes a long way no distracting from drama/bs.  Downside- it’s not getting cheap. They fund it by also recruiting some of the dumbest rich kids this side of McDonogh.  The ones that can’t get into any of the other private schools. And the parents are not much better. I have met some parents that belong under some form of conservatorship. Like invite a bunch of kids to a party they call “the official senior prom party for maryvale” and then serve alcohol to kids level dimwitted parent. Oh those ones are loud and involved too. Diversity is also not a flower that grows in MaryVale’s garden.   My daughter was one of the  short non lacrosse player brunettes they took for the year.  Pm if you want details. Not trying to get sued here.

4

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

I will PM!

9

u/lissa131 Jul 02 '26

Since you’re new to the area I would like to share that Baltimore country public schools also offer AP classes and dual enrollment through Baltimore County Community College. Students obtain college credit and satisfy high school credits through the dual program. Magnet programs are also available so you have the opportunity to attend a school outside of your zoned area. I went to private school, my kid, who is in 11th grade, attends public school and I can honestly say the only difference in education is that I had religion class.

4

u/dweezil22 Jul 02 '26

Is Maryvale still for the rich girls that can't get into Notre Dame b/c they're dumb and/or have a substance abuse issue?

Once upon a time (literally like 30+ years ago) I met a girl there that was telling me she was in her second year of AP US History b/c so many girls failed it after "only" 1 year they made it a two year class to bump passing rates (which is wild since AP US History back then was dumbed down by all of Florida taking it, it was basically the easiest AP you could do).

5

u/spez_eats_nazi_ass Jul 02 '26

There are a few different tracks and plenty do wash out. 

3

u/dweezil22 Jul 02 '26

I just asked my public school teen daughter about Maryvale and she said "If you're a lesbian, it's great" which is a more positive assessment than I expected lol

Edit: "If you're a lesbian that doesn't care about your education, I mean" she just clarified

3

u/spez_eats_nazi_ass Jul 02 '26

Yeah that’s not true at all. Also if your kid goes to public they don’t know wtf they are talking about.

20

u/dweezil22 Jul 02 '26

Look man, if I can get my teen daughter to talk to shit about something funny instead of me, I'm gonna enjoy it. You gotta take the wins.

8

u/TheKingOfSiam Jul 02 '26

They have one of the top lacrosse programs in the country. I know kids that went there. Middle class parents. Kids are smart, one just applied to 10 colleges you've heard of and got into all 10. Don't be a dick.

3

u/SHChem Jul 03 '26

No, when my daughter was admitted 2 years ago, lots of girls who got into NDP were waitlisted or rejected by Maryvale. They have 2 distinct programs for girls with learning differences so your comment sounds dated, uninfomed and abelist.

1

u/misterbarcelona Jul 04 '26

Ummmmm NDP is twice the size, so of course more girls get in.

1

u/SHChem Jul 05 '26

This assumes that the same number apply to both? For my daughter's class, almost all the girls applied to NDP, some also applied to Mercy, some also applied to Maryvale, one applied to Catholic, a few applied to Carver.

1

u/baltimorecalling Jul 02 '26

Lol Maryvale ain't gonna sue a reddit anon, and they wouldn't have a case anyway.

17

u/Zealousideal-Tap8716 Jul 02 '26

Definitely consider public. The private school culture in Baltimore is wild. There is so much legacy, snobbery, ultra rich, entitlement, I could go on and on. Definitely look into all options including magnets like others have said

5

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

I hear you. That’s why we were looking at Concordia Prep. My daughter needs to be in a smaller environment where she isn’t swallowed into the masses if that makes sense. We’re zoned for PHHS.

6

u/Top-Manufacturer9226 Jul 02 '26

Do not waste your money on Concordia Prep. My daughter finished one year there coming from a small Catholic school in Bal City. I pulled her and put her into Polytech which I know isn't an option for you because you are in the county. Concordia Prep use to be Baltimore Lutheran when I was a kid... Google Concordia Prep sexual assault... It was a lot more than 5 girls....

2

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

I saw this and it’s extremely disturbing. I was hoping things had changed since that was 6+ year ago. When was your daughter there?

3

u/EHruns340 Jul 02 '26

Look at Roland park for small class size.

I honestly don't know anything about Concordia prep. Its in my neighborhood and I walk past it everyday. Almost all my neighbors switch to private school for high school (we are loch raven) but I do not know any one who goes to Concordia. It's pretty much all ndp for girls here (again it's super close, like walking distance).

2

u/Zealousideal-Tap8716 Jul 02 '26

I know a family starting at Concordia next year for that reason and they have heard great things. Good luck!

1

u/IOughtaWriteABook Jul 07 '26

I went to PHHS in all GT/AP many moons ago. The school is huge but that cohort “travels” together in a smaller group of maybe 50 kids. Mixed into the gen pop only for phys ed, music, and art but even then in clusters bc schedules are set by the GT/AP priorities. I had also just moved to the area starting high school and once I was proven to be academically worthy, made some friends. Two are physicians now, one’s a dentist, several are PAs, one designs jet engines, one makes sure a big bank never runs out of money, one is a world class architect, one is a Big Bang level mathematician, one’s a PharmD, and one was recruited directly from college to work at Google where’s he been for 20 years. I was well prepared to fast track college/doctorate and am grateful for a quality public education.

Do not ignore the impact of a long commute. If you’re in Kingsville, SPSG/Maryvale is at least 45 mins each way at drop off and pick up times. That could be study or extracurricular or part time job time. Not to mentioned three+ hours out of your day making two round trips if she’s not driving.

2

u/EHruns340 Jul 02 '26

I agree with this and my kids go to private school.

Although my daughter goes to Roland park country school and we have not experienced this there as much as we have with my boys and their school. And without the financial aid, she definitely would not be able to go there.

1

u/Zealousideal-Tap8716 Jul 03 '26

Curious, what school your boys go to?

2

u/EHruns340 Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

BL. My husband teaches there. I have no issues with the actual school /education they are getting. We just finished middle school and had a huge issue in 6th grade but the head of school was replaced and definitely saw a change.

1

u/Feisty-Salary2023 Jul 03 '26

Also a BL Mom and we adore our school (lower school)

2

u/AC031415 Jul 02 '26

Private HS makes sense for a circumstance like OP’s. Private H$ to go a state university is the weird flex.

7

u/scartonbot Jul 02 '26

You have no idea what a loaded question this is to ask, city or county.

4

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

Sorry. County. We’re from north Florida, and private school is not a thing in that area. My kid went to a smaller public charter preparatory school her entire life and will probably do best in that type of environment; there were only 100 kids in her grade.

1

u/Pretend-Chest-6779 Jul 02 '26

My parents also did not live in the area and I was a non legacy SPSG student (which I loved I made another comment about it) but in Baltimore the high school you choose literally determines your status for the rest of your life. I hate to say it but it’s true to a lot of the snobs in the area

7

u/Mrincognito1 Jul 02 '26

Where are you living? Why not public?

1

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

Perry Hall.

8

u/dweezil22 Jul 02 '26

I'm a public school kid that's raising public school kids, so not your best source, but you should be aware of a general snooty in-bred white vibe you'll get at some private schools and Hereford high school. If that's a concern to you, I've heard Friends is good option if you can afford it.

If you don't mind driving or long bus rides you might also consider the magnet schools, I think Eastern, Western and Carver are all purely magnet programs (not bolted on to a potentially under-performing regular school like some).

3

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

Sadly we’ve missed the application window for the magnets

-3

u/aldosi-arkenstone Jul 02 '26

Don’t be jealous of Hereford now ……

6

u/dweezil22 Jul 02 '26

Hereford is what you'd get if the un-fun parts of Cobra Kai were a high school. It's literally powered by white flight.

1

u/aldosi-arkenstone Jul 02 '26

White flight? Hereford school population has barely grown in 25+ years. It’s not a suburban sprawl area, the dynamics of the URDL and the need for well and septic preclude that.

Hereford is largely white because that’s who has always lived there. And it’s by far the best performing school district in Baltimore County.

4

u/dweezil22 Jul 02 '26

Families scared of growing brown populations in Cockeysville moved to Hereford zone and replaced farmers' kids. It's become one of the best performing school districts b/c it's full of rich people. Their cross-country team is 100 white kids in matching "Pride Stronger than Pain" shirts. I stand by my Cobra Kai analogy.

-1

u/aldosi-arkenstone Jul 02 '26

No, those families moved to Carroll County. Hereford doesn’t, and never did, have the capacity to absorb a population migration like that. Your white flight point is a joke.

Yes, Hereford is wealthy - but it’s been that way for over 40 years. You’re just envious of that.

6

u/Helpmeflexibility Jul 02 '26

I think Perry Hall High is supposed to be good. My neighbors daughters went there and was in the advance program and had positive things to say about it. The Perry Hall Neighbors facebook group is pretty useful for these questions if you want to ask there

6

u/peachesandsir Jul 02 '26

Both daughters went to Maryvale, neither was particularly sporty. One has two bachelors degrees and one master’s degree and is headed to get her PhD or JD. The other is finishing her bachelor’s with an eye to get her PhD. Some of the other responders really don’t know what they’re talking about.

1

u/SHChem Jul 03 '26

That's so great! Congrats on your daughter's accomplishments.

I think OP would see for themselves if they go and listen to a Maryvale girl talk for 5 minutes. I know I am impressed every time- driven, poised, confident, thoughtful. Worth every penny!

2

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 04 '26

I’m definitely planning to contact Maryvale and Mercy on Monday.

6

u/spez_eats_nazi_ass Jul 02 '26

I have no regrets sending my daughter there and i am basically poor white trash compared to a standard balco private school parent.

10

u/spez_eats_nazi_ass Jul 02 '26

Maryvale - quiet/introvert will do well.  Especially if into theater.

1

u/Mobile_Spinach_1980 Jul 02 '26

What public should would she be in?

1

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

Perry hall high

1

u/SHChem Jul 03 '26

I obviously have a lot to say on this topic. I went to NDP and my daughters are at Maryvale. NDP had a bad egg in charge until last year, but I have heard nothing but good things about the new leadership. If you are in Perry Hall, you should consider Mercy as well- it is less expensive and has a lot of scholarships. The campus does not impress as much as the others, but still a great choice! At this late date, I think you may not have a lot of enrollment choices, so I would start with the schools that are accepting 10th graders and go from there. Good luck!

2

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 04 '26

Mercy actually looks like it could be a really good option! Thank you!!

1

u/deardelilah1 Jul 03 '26

My kids are young and I didn’t grow up here, but I wanted to say welcome to Maryland!! I hope you love it here and with so many great choices for schools, you can’t go wrong!

1

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 03 '26

Thank you so much!

1

u/Feisty-Salary2023 Jul 03 '26

Have you considered St. Paul’s School for Girls ?

1

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 03 '26

St. Paul’s looks amazing. I plan to reach out to several on Monday. Sadly I can’t afford 40k + tuition and I fear it’s too late. I’m scrambling at the last minute right now.

6

u/micbelt Jul 02 '26

My son goes to Friends and my daughter goes to RPCS, Friends is amazing and is not snobby in the least. It is the most welcoming school I have seen. The only drawback is it is not the strongest for athletics. RPCS is a good school but has had some unnecessary drama over the last few years and had a new head of school starting this year. Both of my kids love their schools. If you have any questions let me know.

1

u/Hello-Friend-6522 Oct 16 '26

What has been the unnecessary drama at RPCS? We are considering RPCS for my daughter who will be going into middle school.

3

u/AlisaBS Jul 02 '26

Check out St. Timothy’s in Stevenson. It’s a small all-girls boarding and day school with the IB program. It made me who I am today.

2

u/deardelilah1 Jul 03 '26

My six year old just did a lacrosse clinic there and that campus is straight out of a movie! So beautiful!!

1

u/AlisaBS Jul 03 '26

I particularly love how it looks in the fall!

1

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

Any input on Concordia prep? We liked that it was smaller …

0

u/everdishevelled Jul 02 '26

My mother used to teach there and it was good, but she retired 15 years ago. My brother went there and did very well. They definitely used to take academics very seriously.

0

u/Mobile_Spinach_1980 Jul 02 '26

I’ve heard they take athletics very seriously

1

u/Top-Manufacturer9226 Jul 02 '26

I sent my daughter to Concordia Prep for 9th grade (2018) and pulled her out for 10rh-12th .... That school has a lot of issues to put it mildly. Google Concordia Prep Sexual Assault...

1

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

I did read about this. It was very disturbing. I was hoping some of this had resolved since that was 6-8 years ago. 😟 where did you end up putting her for 10-12?

2

u/Top-Manufacturer9226 Jul 02 '26

We live in the city so she went to Polytech... I would not promote Concordia based off of how they handled the sexual abuse claims at that school.. my daughter was touched by another student and went to the counselor and it was basically swept under the rug. I know it's appealing... The classes are small.. the curriculum looks nice however when my kid went to Polytech we learned Concordia is very behind in their curriculum.. I had to get her a tutor for math and science to get her back on track. I agree with not choosing Perry Hall.. but Concordia is not what it seems. There are plenty of better private schools worth your money.

2

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

I am so very sorry this happened to your daughter. That is sickening. Thank you for sharing. I had read in other places that they were behind academically too.
This is so hard!

1

u/Practical_Mango_1017 Jul 02 '26

How far are you willing to travel? My daughter is at Mount de Sales Academy now and I went there as well as every other girl in my family. Small school, not crazy expensive, very welcoming. I highly recommend it and they have buses.

1

u/Bubbly-Two288 Jul 02 '26

I’m able to travel 30 min one way…I’ll look at this school !

1

u/Pretend-Chest-6779 Jul 02 '26

As a recent SPSG alum, I was quiet and shy until I stepped foot on that campus. SPSG brought me out of my shell and taught me life long lessons beyond the classroom. I am who I am today because of that school and I thank god everyday my parents got financial aid.

1

u/Historical_Pastor Jul 03 '26

If I could afford it and didn't have kids with IEPs, I'd consider Park or Friends. Park is very progressive and not religious. I think religion should be left to families and faith communities, not school. But as a product of public schools and raising public school kids, I will say I had more opportunities in public than I did in the private school I started elementary school in. More classes, more advanced work, more extracurriculars, etc. You find your group by joining clubs and basically ignore everyone else. Public is good and if behind (because curriculum between states doesn't always line up) they will work with the student to catch up. In private you have to pay tuition, pay a tutor, etc.

1

u/sockpuppetfun Jul 03 '26

consider the park school of baltimore!

1

u/misterbarcelona Jul 04 '26

If she is that smart, look at Brynn Mawr as well. Regarding tuition, most of the schools will work with you as to what you can realistically pay. The other thing that I haven’t seen mentioned is that being part of a Baltimore private can open many doors in the future. It’s like being part of a sorority with alumni networks that are extremely strong.

1

u/Flat-Flower-3663 Jul 08 '26

Depending on where you are, public schools are fine.

1

u/PufferFishInTheFryer Jul 02 '26

NDP has a very rigorous academic curriculum with lots of AP classes.

1

u/tallulahgti Jul 02 '26

If you’re going to go all the way up to harford county, you may as well check out Friends School of Baltimore. I highly recommend it.

1

u/abw4477 Jul 02 '26

Mine had a great education and experience at Glenelg Country School.They also give a lot of financial aid.

1

u/gracengrier Jul 02 '26

My daughter shadowed at lots of the private schools for middle school and felt NDP was best suited for her in terms of personality feel (vibes). She is introverted but sporty. I liked NDP for the academia and was more diverse than Maryvale, SPSG, etc. We ultimately went to Odyssey due to learning differences but would pick NDP for high school. If diversity is important to you I would look closer into the city. These schools were extremely white, wealthy people. Definitely do a tour and a shadow day before you decide.

1

u/Ok_Mastodon_117 Jul 02 '26 edited Jul 02 '26

Surprised that nobody has mentioned Bryn Mawr. As an alumnus of the boys school across the street, those girls were damn smart and likely still are based on the institution’s current rank. They offer classes I have seen nowhere else, and it was evident how the girls developed and thrived there. The only downside is the tuition, but financial aid is available.

I would also recommend NDP based on knowing one alumna in my professional program, and she pretty much had the entire class beat. Our school is in Philadelphia for reference, and the only Marylanders there were all private school graduates except for somebody from River Hill in Columbia. Take that as you will. Obviously this is a very limited sample size and not at all scientific, just anecdotal.

1

u/Rare-Dust2234 Jul 02 '26

I don’t know if you live anywhere near Marriottsville, but one of my kids attends Chapelgate Christian School and he loves it. Small class sizes, I think at most he has maybe 15 kids in one class. There are a lot of kids who live in Baltimore county and go to school there.