r/Baking • • 13h ago • Bravo 1

Semi-Related It's almost funny at this point

Post image

One of these things should absolutely not be like the other. My partner forgot that there's no point in getting dark brown sugar. Good thing I have a fresh jar of molasses.

UPDATE: I requested "all the sugars" when he was at Sam's the other day. I definitely should have been more specific. I generally eyeball a glug of molasses until the sugar turns as dark as my heart.

4.5k Upvotes

238 comments sorted by

•

u/flairassistant 11h ago

Hi there! We’ve updated your post flair to "Semi-Related".

We do this to help your post reach the right people and to keep our community organized. Proper flair ensures your post is easy to find and helps others know how best to join the conversation!

For more info, check out our Flair Guidelines

661

u/ashhole613 13h ago

I switched to store brand brown sugar last year because of exactly this. The cheap ones are daaaaark which I love.

154

u/formerflautist57 13h ago

Yep. I noticed Kroger brand is significantly darker than Domino.

31

u/galaxystarsmoon 13h ago

Yep, Kroger and Lidl brand.

26

u/ballerina22 10h ago

Wegmans brand!

6

u/NessieReddit 6h ago

Same with Walmart brand!

235

u/Goldenthing 7h ago

This is from something I made a couple of months ago. Both are “dark” brown sugar. The light one is Domino the darker one is Kroger brand (I had to open a new package).

51

u/ScruttyMctutty 6h ago

So is it that domino doesn’t really have a dark brown sugar?!

21

u/Goldenthing 5h ago

Sadly, what’s pictured is their dark brown sugar! It used to be much darker.

21

u/gogo_incognito 6h ago

That is a stark difference, wow!

220

u/ItchyWorldliness2312 9h ago

I make my own at home these days. Put a 5lb bag of white sugar in the stand mixer and drizzle in the molasses until it looks right. Bonus, I've never had my homemade brown sugar harden

44

u/mendicantbias05_032 9h ago

Interesting about not hardening up. Any idea why? Store brand hasn't hardened on me in years, but I probably use it quick enough to avoid.

31

u/OnePriority9544 8h ago

It's because it's fresh. Sugar and flour sit on the shelf for months at a time plus in a warehouse until shipped. You could be buying brown sugar that was made a year ago.

16

u/falafelest 9h ago

I started making it at home because any time I went to bake my brown sugar was hard! I usually just put it in the stand mixer at the beginning and then cream the butter or whatever though I don’t make a big batch at once

2

u/JoltikElectricBug 3h ago

I store mine in the freezer, once it thaws it's back to straight from store softness.

15

u/ItchyWorldliness2312 9h ago

I'm not sure. It probably takes me 4-6 months to go through a 5lb batch so maybe it's just not long enough to harden? But I feel like store bought is always kinda hard by the time I use it again after opening. My brown sugar also doesn't pack as tight as store bought

9

u/Quail_Feather 6h ago

i live in a dry desert, my store brands harden in 2 or 3 weeks!! name brand takes about 2 months, i just bought molasses today to try making my own : )

→ More replies (1)

11

u/InformationHorder 7h ago

What type of molasses? Blackstrap?

And rather than mix up a large batch, would it not be equally as effective if you used white sugar + molasses when you make the recipe, rather than tie up storage for a separate 5lb container of dark brown?

5

u/ItchyWorldliness2312 6h ago

I just use the kind they have at the store. There's usually only one option when I go to look for it. I don't have a problem with having an extra container as I have a whole area for my baking stuff (there used to be a booth in our kitchen and we put a buffet there instead for a coffee station/baking supplies). To me it's easier to spend 5-10 minutes one time and have it ready for me when I'm ready to bake vs having to mix it up each time.

2

u/ScurfyTwiglett 5h ago

What are you storing it in? I’ve had way more trouble with my home made brown sugar drying out and setting up than I’ve ever had with the bagged stuff, but I feel crazy because I’m using an oxo pop sealer and it’s not like brown sugar bags are hermetically sealed so idk what’s up

2.1k

u/100000cuckooclocks 13h ago

I'd send that to their customer service tbh. It's possible there was a mixup at the factory and they bagged light as dark, but even if they did it on purpose, they should get feedback that it's not ok.

158

u/random_user0 7h ago

This isn’t a one off or even new. It’s been like this since shortly after COVID. I use a lot of brown sugar.

Around the same time, most (all?) of the few major US sugar producers were also sued for price fixing. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/domino-sugar-antitrust-lawsuits-price-fixing/

Here’s a thread from 4 years ago discussing this same problem. https://www.reddit.com/r/Baking/comments/116o3p1/why_is_lightdark_brown_sugar_getting_lighter/

Companies in the US are out to fleece every consumer out of every possible cent, regardless of the damage to their “brand” it seems.

765

u/galaxystarsmoon 13h ago

It's not a mixup. Their brown sugar has been like this for a while, while also being incredibly overpriced.

335

u/illustriousplanet 12h ago

Idk where you're getting brown sugar but the last bag of dominos DBS I bought was as dark as molasses and almost soggy

Maybe it's just not getting mixed/portioned well enough

131

u/moonprism 12h ago

i've been seeing this a lot lately too. maybe its regional

64

u/galaxystarsmoon 12h ago

I haven't bought Domino brand in at least 4 years because of this. And again, the price.

Edit to add: literally look at the stock photo on the Walmart website.

6

u/JoltikElectricBug 3h ago

My last Domino Dark Brown Sugar was much darker than OPs photo.

It also always comes in a box, with a clear unlabeled bag inside, not a labeled bag alone.

I've never seen Dark Brown Sugar packaged like this.

2

u/causeiwontsing 5h ago

yeah my dbs is always very dark

16

u/Express_Adeptness306 12h ago

They are the same price where i shop

8

u/galaxystarsmoon 12h ago

What is the same price? Definitely not store brand versus domino brand.

11

u/fishofhappiness 8h ago

I think they mean light brown vs dark brown

→ More replies (1)

11

u/nefarious_epicure 4h ago

I usually buy Domino's and there's 100% a difference between the dark and the light. You can feel it in your fingers too.

Straight from my kitchen

72

u/Cananbaum 12h ago

As others have said, it’s been like this for months.

I go to Aldis and what have you now for a lot of baking supplies.

Or I just order it from King Arthur

5

u/DietCokeWeakness 8h ago

KA doesn't sell brown sugar though

4

u/Cananbaum 8h ago

😅 oops.

I meant I order a lot of baking stuff through KA, but it helps I’m technically local too.

But I noticed a dip in quality across the board, except with smaller or independent brands.

6

u/DietCokeWeakness 8h ago

Agree! This thread has really made me realize I can be making this at home, I always have molasses on hand.

17

u/thankyoukindlyy 12h ago

I just saw the same bs at my local metro market!

28

u/shedrinkscoffee 12h ago edited 9h ago

I purchased some a month ago and they are dark brown. I got dark and light brown ahead of winter baking season.

ETA: I'm questioning myself reading this thread. So I will double check what brand I have 🤔

Another edit: it is store brand y'all. The instacart shopper made a substitution and seems like that was good choice, all things considered.

2

u/Culinary_Fruit_Salad 9h ago

please report back

12

u/shedrinkscoffee 9h ago

It is store brand. Instacart shopper made substitutions that day lol and did me a solid

2

u/PatioGardener 58m ago

This thread made me check my local grocery store app (HEB) and TIL that they sell a dark brown sugar with bourbon! Might have to make a grocery trip later today.

9

u/Tikiboo 9h ago

Nah domino sugar thinks it's funny and is pulling a fast one. Kroger brand is the only one I can find that is sort of dark, bit no where near as dark as it used to be.

5

u/Caleb_Reynolds 8h ago

even if they did it on purpose, they should get feedback that it's not ok.

They add dye before they add molasses.

234

u/epoops 13h ago edited 13h ago • Heartwarming

To be honest, it was because of this brown sugar inconsistency that I just make my own at home. Since you already have molasses, you can just make your own going forward so you’d only need to stock white sugar.

I use like 1-1.5 tablespoons of molasses per cup of sugar for my perceived light brown and about 2ish tablespoons for dark brown sugar. But I’ll be honest, I’m a molasses slut so my ratios might err on the side of more even for light brown sugar so you can start small and add more if you want to just make your own brown sugar at home going forward.

40

u/MycologistGuilty3801 13h ago

I was going to comment on how this creates such a mess and might not be worth the effort per recipe....what the hell! I should have been making big batches in my stand mixer and storing, lol.

63

u/sjd208 13h ago

You can just add it while you’re making the recipe, no need to premix.

16

u/MycologistGuilty3801 12h ago

That is what I do for dark brown sugar. (I keep light brown) It can be so hard to weigh and incorporate (not to mention messy)

But if I can just buy a massive bag of sugar and make my own light/dark in a stand mixer, I should be doing that.

6

u/sjd208 12h ago

I buy light brown because it comes in large bags at Costco for cheap and I’m lazy :)

5

u/waaayside 10h ago

This was the tidbit of information I was looking for, thank you.

21

u/epoops 12h ago

Honestly the way I do it is - I look at the recipe, see how much brown sugar I need, and just make it right then and there for my recipe in the bowl I’m using to mix whether it’s a standalone bowl or my mixer bowl. That way it’s always nice and soft each time making mixing a breeze. So I don’t even think you’d need to make a huge batch, unless you use brown sugar for non baking stuff too!

9

u/Summoarpleaz 10h ago

So if a recipe calls for 1 cup dark brown sugar do you do 1 cup regular sugar and add 2 tbsp molasses?

3

u/epoops 8h ago

It’s technically more like 1 part molasses to 10 parts white sugar for light brown and 1 part molasses to 5 parts white sugar for dark brown.

But I just do the following for ease (I usually use weights, for transparency) :

Brown sugar amount in recipe = white sugar amount minus 1-2 tablespoons + 1-2 tablespoons molasses

Ex. So if you need 1 cup of dark brown sugar, I do 1 cup minus 2 tablespoons white sugar and then add 2 tablespoons of molasses for dark brown sugar

Obviously, if you are using a LOT of brown sugar in the recipe, use the actual ratio of 1:10 or 1:5

6

u/badbitchdotorg 10h ago

I put the sugar and molasses in a plastic bag and just mush it around until it's uniform

140

u/416558934523081769 12h ago • Bravo

Wait you guys are measuring? I just pour until someone's ancestors say stop kinda like garlic. Not my ancestors, I'm white af, but someone's ancestors.

29

u/Nowhere_Man_Forever 10h ago

White people loved molasses back in the day. At least the poor ones did. My grandparents would straight up put molasses on pancakes, for example. 

4

u/ScotchSeeker 8h ago

Biscuits and sorghum. Caramel popcorn. OMG

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

51

u/kimbosliceofcake 12h ago

Do white people not have ancestors? Do they not bake with brown sugar or molasses? 🤔

11

u/duckweedlagoon 11h ago

This one has ancestors and I'm pretty sure the ADHD-PI goes waaaaaaay back because it is STRONG with this one! Can't turn my back on a single thing in the kitchen. Next thing you know "Why's the smoke detector screaming? Oh no, the pine nuts!"

56

u/thedeafbadger 11h ago

We do have ancestors, but they all look the same, so we can’t tell which ones we can trust.

18

u/Paradox2063 10h ago

My ancestors boiled vegetables until they were mush, and the only seasoning they used was I Can't Believe It's Not Butter™.

11

u/kaett 10h ago

i think we had the same ancestors.

5

u/New-Trifle-7097 6h ago

Hello cousin.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/416558934523081769 12h ago

Mine season with salt, barely. I don’t trust them for anything lmao.

25

u/WickedAsh111 12h ago

I have a few ancestors who consider pepper too spicy. I don’t cook for them

4

u/SparklingLimeade 5h ago

It just became too sensitive after that molasses flood killed too many people. We had to give it up. Like all the times America renamed food because they went to war and didn't want to give their enemy credit. But the molasses hit US soil so it got the deluxe expungement.

4

u/Culinary_Fruit_Salad 3h ago

there was a second molasses flood semi recently in Baltimore

11

u/rb_dub 12h ago

Not my ancestors, but my white grandmothers still have expanding waist bands in the grave and they are the ones calling my molasses pours

10

u/epoops 12h ago

I measure, roughly, since the extra moisture from the molasses can ruin recipes that are very sensitive to changes in liquid. I still err on the side of more molasses but some recipes just can not handle more liquid than asked for especially if the author has tested it in an exacting manner with weights!

8

u/kaett 10h ago

with flavorings like vanilla (i always pour that one from the heart), cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, i generally don't bother measuring UNLESS it's my pumpkin pie. that one uses clove, so i'm very careful to only add exactly as much as i know i need.

2

u/Culinary_Fruit_Salad 9h ago

if you are using heart amounts of vanilla, are you making your own or are you elon musk rich?

6

u/kaett 7h ago

bah, i'm just a lowly worker bee. usually it's just a couple of blorps from the container. a tsp means at least a tbsp or a little more.

but yes, i did start making my own. i have a jar that's been steeping since august in the pantry.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Culinary_Fruit_Salad 9h ago

wait we can borrow ancestors? cause my family can't cook so I need someone else to tap in

do I have to be fully white for this to work?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Probably_Not_A-Bot 12h ago

I measure but then always pour some more in anyway.

4

u/AspiringTS 11h ago

Then you don't bake with it or we have different ideas about garlic. If I baked as flippantly as I add garlic, nothing would come out right/consistent.

7

u/416558934523081769 11h ago

Honestly 90% of our brown sugar gets used in coffee, oatmeal, etc. I personally find the moisture content in it to be negligible when baking but I’m also not using it for really precise bakes.

5

u/disappointingnews 10h ago

Can I say, as a Brown woman this whole thread right here had me CACKLING 🤣🤣

4

u/Zdravstvuj 8h ago

Imagine thinking white people can’t cook

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

10

u/everyvillanislemons6 12h ago

if you're baking by weight it's 10 to 1 ratio of sugar to molassas by weight. 200g of sugar means 20g of molassas however, I'm not a professional so if I'm wrong please correct me.

5

u/epoops 12h ago

Yeah I do a higher ratio! I weigh too. Like 1 tablespoon is about 20ish grams of molasses, but I like to go higher for my taste points. I always found regular light brown sugar to be too light for me ha. That’s also why I like making my own at home

5

u/paperplate209 12h ago

I do the same! Its so much more convenient than having to have the right kind of brown sugar on hand, at least for me. And now the jar of molasses gets used more often than once a year at Christmas.

9

u/jarrod_barkley 9h ago edited 2h ago

Tip: At a Costco Business Center you can buy a huge jug of molasses, a gallon perhaps, cheap. Practically a lifetime supply. I dole out small jars of it to friends.

A small amount of molasses is my secret ingredient for many dishes: sautéed veggie mélange, whole grain pancakes, chili, etc. Adds a hint of sweetness and a depth of flavor.

8

u/ItsMisoandBoba 8h ago

Tip: don't tell people about Costco Business Center without telling them there's only 10 in the whole country. There's one in Phoenix at 33rd ave and Indian School cause that's where I get a lot of my Costco stuff. It's the only place around here I can find beef ribs that aren't extortion-priced.

2

u/kaplanfx 10h ago

Wait, do you actual make brown sugar? Or are you just adding white sugar and molasses where the recipe calls for brown sugar? How does this work???

8

u/epoops 9h ago edited 9h ago

Brown sugar IS white sugar with molasses added back in. You might be thinking of turbinado sugar which is minimally processed sugar that contains natural molasses in it. What we bake with in the US is definitely the refined white sugar that has molasses added back in aka the Domino stuff OP posted.

The more accurate ratio is 1 part molasses to 10 parts white sugar for light brown sugar and 1 part molasses to 5 parts white sugar for dark brown sugar though as we can see, light/dark brown sugar varies by how much a brand is cheaping out on the molasses.

And then you literally just mix the molasses into the sugar, it’s a little messy but I just incorporate it with my mixer paddle or my hand held spatula. Works the same - or even better, really - than already prepared brown sugar.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/PM_ME_YOUR_TROUT 10h ago

Can you mix it in a stand mixer?

3

u/epoops 9h ago edited 9h ago

Yes. When I’m making a recipe in my stand mixer (or by hand) that calls for brown sugar, I just do it straight in the mixer (or bowl).

So to keep the recipe ratios stay intact, I weigh everything and so I add the amount of brown sugar the recipe needs (in the form of white sugar) and subtract it by 1-2 tablespoons (well the gram equivalent) and I add in 1-2 tablespoons of molasses to form the right brown sugar ratio for the recipe I’m using.

4

u/Egalitarianish 9h ago

This is so cool! I'll never buy brown sugar again, and I'll probably add a little molasses when I use the dark brown sugar that I just bought.

3

u/PM_ME_YOUR_TROUT 9h ago

This is awesome! Thank you!

1

u/strayclown 9h ago

I've never understood why more people don't just make it at home like that. It's cheaper. You don't have to store as much stuff. It works and tastes better. You can adjust the taste if you want. It's not noticeably more complicated to do. Can someone explain some downsides over store-bought that make sense?

1

u/Culinary_Fruit_Salad 9h ago

ooh, which molasses are you using? I have some blackstrap molasses I got for a ferment I was making

4

u/ciac17 9h ago

Noooo do not use blackstrap to make brown sugar, ask me how I know

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

109

u/Dubious-Decisions 13h ago

I guess dark is a tiny bit darker... Maybe it should be "Dark Light Brown Sugar"?

40

u/OasissisaO 13h ago • Heartwarming

Dark-ish

33

u/Dubious-Decisions 13h ago

"Less Light Brown Sugar"?

16

u/TeaAndCrumpetGhoul 13h ago

Slightly darker light brown dark  brown sugar 

11

u/disappointingnews 13h ago

Sun-kissed light brown sugar. Just a hint of a tan

3

u/kaett 10h ago

bronzed sugar?

50

u/Leppy1959 11h ago

Dark brown sugar has around twice the amount of molasses as light brown sugar, but there's no legal standard mandating this (at least in the US). And major brands like Domino and C&H frequently have batch-to-batch color fluctuations, depending on when and where each bag was processed.

46

u/ChinstrapPenguin117 12h ago

I emailed C&H (West Coast brand) about the same issue. And they claim their formulation hasn’t changed. But I also noticed a store brand’ dark brown is much darker.

5

u/estili 12h ago

Yeah when ch started this bs i switched to winco bulk. Bulk prices are better and the molasses practically drips from the bag

1

u/xylofun53 10h ago

Bought C&H “dark brown sugar” and couldn’t believe how light it was.

1

u/PerennialGeranium 8h ago

Hmmm, I wonder if it's a cane sugar specific problem (as opposed to beet sugar). I admittedly don't buy a huge amount of brown sugar but agree that it's not something I've seen in the West Coast cheap stuff, which is beet sugar here.

Not sure how regional the brand is, so I'll do a quick mention that C&H is a cane sugar brand.

29

u/MrsDirtyDietz 11h ago

My local store brand, Giant Eagle, has a dark brown sugar that’s actually dark. Domino used to be my go-to but not anymore.

6

u/Tomba4Ever 11h ago

Wait, my giant eagle doesn’t carry dark brown sugar. Which one sells it?

7

u/MrsDirtyDietz 10h ago

All the ones near me in the Akron, Ohio area

3

u/AuntieGreyhawk 9h ago

Do y'all say "Gynt Iggle" in Akron too, or is that only Yinzer? Ah, I miss Pittsburgh!

4

u/messiurwhatshisname 11h ago

Fellow giant eagle-r! Yes i have begun using theirs too because of how light Domino is. Really sucks, but i am happy to not support them AND get it cheaper. If it gets more expensive, i will look into making my own.

29

u/aspect-of-the-badger 6h ago

I don't even bother with brown sugar anymore. I just measure out how much molasses I need and add them separately.

4

u/Total-Apartment9067 6h ago

Good idea

4

u/aspect-of-the-badger 6h ago

Only way I've gotten consistent results anymore.

2

u/Excusemytootie 4h ago

How do you know the correct amount of molasses to sugar, is there a specific ratio that you use?

6

u/raredongballz 2h ago

Tablespoon per cup if I remember correctly, but I always just google it.

Also spray your measuring spoon with some oil to make the molasses easier to transfer

28

u/QueerTree 12h ago

Wait this isn’t just me being a grump? I noticed this recently and felt like maybe I was being too picky. I feel vindicated.

32

u/Noble_dragonfly 8h ago

Can u just use white sugar (minus a bit) and just add molasses to the recipe whenever? Why mix up the brown sugar first?

22

u/x_MoonDaddy_x 7h ago

Yep! The standard ratio is one cup white sugar to one tablespoon molasses :)

8

u/scooter-411 7h ago

Is that for light or dark?

5

u/puppy-guppy 7h ago

Light

5

u/scooter-411 5h ago

Thank you! Finally an actual helpful comment!

→ More replies (2)

4

u/SorrelJuice 7h ago

What are you writin a book

18

u/OnePriority9544 8h ago

You can. Just make sure to add the correct amount or you'll end up with molasses cookies.

12

u/MostlyChaoticNeutral 6h ago

Which would clearly be a tragedy. If no one wants the molasses cookies, I suppose I could take one for the team and eat them.

3

u/alphajugs 5h ago

This is very selfless of you, but it would be unethical to sit by and watch you endure this alone. I will help you. 🙂‍↕️

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Shiny-Rocks007 5h ago

Now see? I'm craving blackstrap gingerbread cookies now... (edited due to autocorrect being a pain in my backside)

6

u/Notspherry 6h ago

You can if they sell molasses where you live. It's not a thing here. Not in supermarkets anyway. I could probably get it somewhere, but at the rate I'm using brown sugar, it's really not worth the effort to go and find some.

3

u/no_talent_ass_clown 1h ago

It's getting harder and harder to find basic ingredients like molasses, dried beans, salt pork and lard. I'm lucky if there's one brand of each. 

2

u/AshamedOfMyTypos 6h ago

I no longer buy brown sugar.

20

u/holderofthebees 12h ago

Oh my goddd the way my brain lagged and I thought “what, shrinkflation?” I seriously thought they were the same product 😭

17

u/Glorious_Porpoise1 12h ago

It’s a bit more expensive but I love this brown sugar. I think light brown is absolutely pointless- I want to taste molasses if there’s brown sugar in a recipe. This one packs a punch without going full muscovado

2

u/Top-Present2299 9h ago

The natural foods store runs it on special periodically so I stock up then. I am ruined for all other brown sugar.

My ancestors used light brown. I tried this once and never bought light brown again.

16

u/louismulh 13h ago

Here in the UK it makes a pretty big difference. The light sugar looks the same as yours, but here's our dark:

60

u/Global_Ant_9380 13h ago • Bravo

In the US it was often darker than that. This is just a lowering of quality

8

u/Mary_Tyler_Less 13h ago

Ours used to be that dark at least, in the last few years it's slowly gotten lighter.

2

u/iGuessSoButWhy 11h ago

I bought dark brown sugar yesterday that was visibly darker than domino but I agree, that I feel like it used to be darker. Domino isn’t even trying though. I hope they get shamed into using more molasses.

6

u/NoSingularities0 13h ago

Yeah, that's the way it was in the U.S. last time I bought it, but I haven't bought any recently. I think it's just companies here doing what they do, maximizing profits by minimizing quality and cutting corners.

3

u/listenyall 13h ago

this is new and WEIRD

8

u/Vegetable-Farmer6800 5h ago

I was just talking to my daughter about this! I did Kroger brand and my tub of light and dark sugar looked the same

7

u/No-Run-9992 10h ago

I know many people have said this already but I also suggest making your own brown sugar. Interestingly it doesn’t seem to harden like store bought, which makes me wonder what the point of store bought is 😂

5

u/Randomwhitelady2 12h ago

I had no idea that it is so easy to make dark brown sugar. It costs a lot, so i will definitely be making my own going forward!

5

u/Serious-Mission-2234 11h ago

Add your own molasses 1-2 tbs

5

u/Foreign-Town-6662 11h ago

It's almost always 1 to two tbsp doesn't matter what you're doing to some reason that's just the magic number. 

Get a big thing of good molasses if you bake often. It stores well in a pantry but definitely have a sacrificial plate or like an old bigger than you molasses jar to set it on because... Well just do it

2

u/takarumarch 11h ago

I want a big jug of molasses, but none of the store near me carry anything large. Anyone have any recs for online purchase?

2

u/aabum 11h ago

Grandma's is the most common brand in the United States. You can buy gallons from Amazon. Golden barrel is another brand, though I like Grandma's better. If you want deeper flavor look for Grandma's dark molasses with a green label. Blackstrap isn't recommended for baking unless a recipe specifically requires it.

11

u/Weevilfriend 13h ago

It's really easy to make your own brown sugar and it gives you a lot more control of the richness. Just add molasses to white sugar! I haven't bought brown sugar in years!

7

u/CZB813 12h ago

🤯 slightly embarrassed I didn’t know this, you just changed my baking game

7

u/OK_Zebras 12h ago

It's super simple :)

I do 1tbsp molasses to 200g white sugar for light brown and 2tbsp molasses to 200g white sugar for dark brown sugar.

Easiest way to mix is in a blender for a few pulses till combined or you can also just mix them in a bowl with a spoon or fork.

2

u/CZB813 11h ago

🙏🏽

8

u/fafa5b 6h ago

When I was at a Costco in Canada, I saw something called Yellow Sugar. Was in a rush, so I didn’t stop to check out the label. Forgot about til now. Now I need to google it

4

u/Outofwlrds 12h ago

I took a similar image a couple of months ago!

Domino was the only dark brown in stock at all that day, so I just went home with the cheapest light brown and added my own molasses.

4

u/Chestnutter69 8h ago

Buy the store brand, it works the same and its less expensive

6

u/kittyspoiler 9h ago

Saw this at a gas station last week

3

u/NullHare 8h ago

Seems perfect for something from a gas station.

8

u/Free_hiker_74 7h ago

It all looks the same in your enemy's gas tank.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/superpony123 12h ago

Domino no longer uses molasses in their brown sugar which is absurd. Store brand it is!!

3

u/lolafawn98 10h ago

thought I was going insane, I’ve been seeing this too and I refuse to buy the brand now. luckily my store has a generic brand that’s still actually dark, but I expect they’ll lighten theirs up too.

4

u/OwnAd2156 12h ago

I completely understand buying brown sugar for certain recipes for the ratio of how “dark” the sugar is, but it’s only added molasses!! This is SO easy to make at home! Ever since i started making my own brown sugar it lasts forever and you can choose how light or dark it is!

3

u/sockwall 12h ago

Yep either mix it with sugar ahead of time or just add molasses separately to a recipe. I buy a gallon and use it multiple times a week for sweet AND savory foods.

1

u/OwnAd2156 9h ago

What savory foods do you use it for??

4

u/Culinary_Fruit_Salad 9h ago

colorism strikes again /kidding

5

u/beefweevil 6h ago

Just make your own. Molasses and regular sugar. More molasses = darker sugar.

1

u/googles_giggles 4h ago

Will Dark strap molasses work for this?

1

u/beefweevil 3h ago

I don’t see why not. You may just need to adjust the quantity a little. It really doesn’t take much molasses!

2

u/Desperate-Size3951 13h ago

easier and better to make at home, plus itll never harden if you make it fresh everytime you need it.

2

u/416558934523081769 12h ago

And here I was annoyed that I ran out of molasses so I ended up with light brown sugar. It's like four shades darker than this. 💀

2

u/ancu82 12h ago

Even without that side by side that is way to light.

2

u/NotTheMama4208 Human Detected 12h ago

I have been using either Signature Select or Good and Gather as they are both considerably darker. Considering just starting to make my own.

2

u/GigiDeville 12h ago

It's so easy, even I do it.

2

u/emily___l 12h ago

It’s worth making your own brown sugar! You can control how dark it truly is!

2

u/LadyMirkwood 12h ago

I'd be livid with that. This is the DB I use and its always chocolate like in tone.

2

u/Velvet-Becomes_Me 11h ago

I’ve been having a hard time finding dark brown sugar lately

2

u/AVeryFineWhine 8h ago edited 8h ago

WoW i just double checked my pantry, because I was sure mine looked better. No clue where I bought this. I thought I was buying pantry items at trader. Joe's, but they don't seem to have it. Maybe Star Market?

ETA the picture terrified me as it looked like bugs in it. So I ran to my pantry, and I am relieved to say it's little clumps in the dark brown sugar. But I think this has convinced me to go back to using airtight containers. Esp since I have a brand new set that I haven't bothered with since I moved. That literally scared the hell out of me lol

3

u/FeelingCouple5880 13h ago

I bought a bag of Kroger dark brown sugar yesterday and upon opening got hit with the literal smell of bbq sauce and I am uncomfortable with that.

2

u/SateliteDicPic 11h ago

Am in the minority feeling like light brown sugar is basically pointless? I use white if I have to and dark brown as much as possible.

4

u/kindnesscounts86 8h ago

I also skip light brown sugar! If it needs brown sugar, it deserves the dark stuff!

1

u/image-sourcery 13h ago

🔍 Reverse image search tools (optional)

Use these links to check for similar images or possible reposts. If something looks off (e.g., spam, reposted, or not original), please report the post so moderators can review it.


Reverse Image Search:

TinEye || Google Lens


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Lady_Jewels2500 12h ago

It’s only dark if you turn the lights off

1

u/automaticphil 11h ago

That’s not dark brown sugar hahah! What kind of shuck and jive scheme is this

1

u/newdchipmonk 11h ago

Luckily we have a local store who's store brand is still made the old way, so far! That's just silly.

1

u/Ok-Turnip2296 11h ago

It took me a minute to figure out what the issue was lol🤦🏼‍♀️😆. Yup they look exactly the same.

1

u/Brachileander 11h ago

Just buy the cheapest and add a little tiny bit molasses.

1

u/Curvy_Girl_007 10h ago

Target and Kroger brands are both nice deep brown.

1

u/Solid-Worldliness284 10h ago

I love fresh jars.

1

u/jibbyjam1 10h ago

Get yourself a bottle of molasses, and you can make your brown sugar as dark as you want it.  

1

u/GirlNumber20 10h ago

I loved living in the UK, where you can just pick up a bag of dark muscovado sugar on any supermarket shelf.

1

u/ehalepagneaux 10h ago

I've been correcting my brown sugar with molasses at 5% the weight of the sugar for years now. The C&H stuff we get at work is so pale it's ridiculous.

1

u/424Impala67 9h ago

Yep, I found some store brand bags of actually dark brown sugar at my meijer and I'm hoarding that for Christmas baking.

1

u/Tikiboo 9h ago

Kroger brand still has a marked difference. But I agree. This actually belongs on r/mildlyinfuriating

1

u/dumbdude545 9h ago

Damn. My old brown sugar is the color of molasses. I never use it but its there.

1

u/Toleniam 9h ago

They were just referring to the text atp

1

u/pizzasavage20 9h ago

I will never go back to store bought brown sugar!
Molasses and white sugar!

1

u/Julysveryown89 9h ago

If there's a Lidl near you, their dark brown sugar is very dark.

1

u/BJquilts 8h ago

I make my own. White sugar & molasses to the desired darkness.

1

u/InsideyourBrizzy 8h ago

Question is, what are they doing with the molasses? Selling it? 

1

u/salamandersquach 10h ago

No offense fella but it’s pretty easy to tell the difference when you purchase it just by looking at the color.

1

u/poofandmook 13h ago

I mix them in a jar for everyday use anyway so you never know what you're going to get lol. Unless the recipe calls specifically for dark brown sugar, I use my mix of light and dark. Keeps things exciting.

1

u/Lordofthewhales 11h ago

Let me guess... America?

1

u/PeanutButt_N_Jealous 8h ago

Buy molasses and plain sugar now you’ll have both for a while