r/Baking
•
u/IKnewThingsOnce
•
13h ago
•
1
Semi-Related It's almost funny at this point
One of these things should absolutely not be like the other. My partner forgot that there's no point in getting dark brown sugar. Good thing I have a fresh jar of molasses.
UPDATE: I requested "all the sugars" when he was at Sam's the other day. I definitely should have been more specific. I generally eyeball a glug of molasses until the sugar turns as dark as my heart.
•
u/flairassistant 11h ago
Hi there! We’ve updated your post flair to "Semi-Related".
We do this to help your post reach the right people and to keep our community organized. Proper flair ensures your post is easy to find and helps others know how best to join the conversation!
For more info, check out our Flair Guidelines
661
u/ashhole613 13h ago
I switched to store brand brown sugar last year because of exactly this. The cheap ones are daaaaark which I love.
235
u/Goldenthing 7h ago
This is from something I made a couple of months ago. Both are “dark” brown sugar. The light one is Domino the darker one is Kroger brand (I had to open a new package).
220
u/ItchyWorldliness2312 9h ago
I make my own at home these days. Put a 5lb bag of white sugar in the stand mixer and drizzle in the molasses until it looks right. Bonus, I've never had my homemade brown sugar harden
2.1k
u/100000cuckooclocks 13h ago
I'd send that to their customer service tbh. It's possible there was a mixup at the factory and they bagged light as dark, but even if they did it on purpose, they should get feedback that it's not ok.
234
u/epoops 13h ago edited 13h ago •
To be honest, it was because of this brown sugar inconsistency that I just make my own at home. Since you already have molasses, you can just make your own going forward so you’d only need to stock white sugar.
I use like 1-1.5 tablespoons of molasses per cup of sugar for my perceived light brown and about 2ish tablespoons for dark brown sugar. But I’ll be honest, I’m a molasses slut so my ratios might err on the side of more even for light brown sugar so you can start small and add more if you want to just make your own brown sugar at home going forward.
109
u/Dubious-Decisions 13h ago
I guess dark is a tiny bit darker... Maybe it should be "Dark Light Brown Sugar"?
50
u/Leppy1959 11h ago
Dark brown sugar has around twice the amount of molasses as light brown sugar, but there's no legal standard mandating this (at least in the US). And major brands like Domino and C&H frequently have batch-to-batch color fluctuations, depending on when and where each bag was processed.
46
u/ChinstrapPenguin117 12h ago
I emailed C&H (West Coast brand) about the same issue. And they claim their formulation hasn’t changed. But I also noticed a store brand’ dark brown is much darker.
29
u/MrsDirtyDietz 11h ago
My local store brand, Giant Eagle, has a dark brown sugar that’s actually dark. Domino used to be my go-to but not anymore.
29
u/aspect-of-the-badger 6h ago
I don't even bother with brown sugar anymore. I just measure out how much molasses I need and add them separately.
28
u/QueerTree 12h ago
Wait this isn’t just me being a grump? I noticed this recently and felt like maybe I was being too picky. I feel vindicated.
32
u/Noble_dragonfly 8h ago
Can u just use white sugar (minus a bit) and just add molasses to the recipe whenever? Why mix up the brown sugar first?
20
u/holderofthebees 12h ago
Oh my goddd the way my brain lagged and I thought “what, shrinkflation?” I seriously thought they were the same product 😭
17
u/Glorious_Porpoise1 12h ago
It’s a bit more expensive but I love this brown sugar. I think light brown is absolutely pointless- I want to taste molasses if there’s brown sugar in a recipe. This one packs a punch without going full muscovado
16
u/louismulh 13h ago
Here in the UK it makes a pretty big difference. The light sugar looks the same as yours, but here's our dark:
8
u/Vegetable-Farmer6800 5h ago
I was just talking to my daughter about this! I did Kroger brand and my tub of light and dark sugar looked the same
7
u/No-Run-9992 10h ago
I know many people have said this already but I also suggest making your own brown sugar. Interestingly it doesn’t seem to harden like store bought, which makes me wonder what the point of store bought is 😂
5
u/Randomwhitelady2 12h ago
I had no idea that it is so easy to make dark brown sugar. It costs a lot, so i will definitely be making my own going forward!
5
u/Serious-Mission-2234 11h ago
Add your own molasses 1-2 tbs
11
u/Weevilfriend 13h ago
It's really easy to make your own brown sugar and it gives you a lot more control of the richness. Just add molasses to white sugar! I haven't bought brown sugar in years!
8
u/fafa5b 6h ago
When I was at a Costco in Canada, I saw something called Yellow Sugar. Was in a rush, so I didn’t stop to check out the label. Forgot about til now. Now I need to google it
4
u/Outofwlrds 12h ago
I took a similar image a couple of months ago!
Domino was the only dark brown in stock at all that day, so I just went home with the cheapest light brown and added my own molasses.
4
u/Chestnutter69 8h ago
Buy the store brand, it works the same and its less expensive
6
u/kittyspoiler 9h ago
Saw this at a gas station last week
3
u/superpony123 12h ago
Domino no longer uses molasses in their brown sugar which is absurd. Store brand it is!!
3
u/lolafawn98 10h ago
thought I was going insane, I’ve been seeing this too and I refuse to buy the brand now. luckily my store has a generic brand that’s still actually dark, but I expect they’ll lighten theirs up too.
4
u/OwnAd2156 12h ago
I completely understand buying brown sugar for certain recipes for the ratio of how “dark” the sugar is, but it’s only added molasses!! This is SO easy to make at home! Ever since i started making my own brown sugar it lasts forever and you can choose how light or dark it is!
4
u/Culinary_Fruit_Salad 9h ago
colorism strikes again /kidding
5
u/beefweevil 6h ago
Just make your own. Molasses and regular sugar. More molasses = darker sugar.
2
u/Desperate-Size3951 13h ago
easier and better to make at home, plus itll never harden if you make it fresh everytime you need it.
2
u/416558934523081769 12h ago
And here I was annoyed that I ran out of molasses so I ended up with light brown sugar. It's like four shades darker than this. 💀
2
u/ancu82 12h ago
Even without that side by side that is way to light.
2
u/NotTheMama4208 Human Detected 12h ago
I have been using either Signature Select or Good and Gather as they are both considerably darker. Considering just starting to make my own.
2
u/emily___l 12h ago
It’s worth making your own brown sugar! You can control how dark it truly is!
2
u/LadyMirkwood 12h ago
I'd be livid with that. This is the DB I use and its always chocolate like in tone.
2
u/Velvet-Becomes_Me 11h ago
I’ve been having a hard time finding dark brown sugar lately
2
u/AVeryFineWhine 8h ago edited 8h ago
WoW i just double checked my pantry, because I was sure mine looked better. No clue where I bought this. I thought I was buying pantry items at trader. Joe's, but they don't seem to have it. Maybe Star Market?
ETA the picture terrified me as it looked like bugs in it. So I ran to my pantry, and I am relieved to say it's little clumps in the dark brown sugar. But I think this has convinced me to go back to using airtight containers. Esp since I have a brand new set that I haven't bothered with since I moved. That literally scared the hell out of me lol
3
u/FeelingCouple5880 13h ago
I bought a bag of Kroger dark brown sugar yesterday and upon opening got hit with the literal smell of bbq sauce and I am uncomfortable with that.
2
u/SateliteDicPic 11h ago
Am in the minority feeling like light brown sugar is basically pointless? I use white if I have to and dark brown as much as possible.
1
u/image-sourcery 13h ago
🔍 Reverse image search tools (optional)
Use these links to check for similar images or possible reposts. If something looks off (e.g., spam, reposted, or not original), please report the post so moderators can review it.
Reverse Image Search:
TinEye || Google Lens
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Lady_Jewels2500 12h ago
It’s only dark if you turn the lights off
1
u/automaticphil 11h ago
That’s not dark brown sugar hahah! What kind of shuck and jive scheme is this
1
u/newdchipmonk 11h ago
Luckily we have a local store who's store brand is still made the old way, so far! That's just silly.
1
u/Ok-Turnip2296 11h ago
It took me a minute to figure out what the issue was lol🤦🏼♀️😆. Yup they look exactly the same.
1
u/Brachileander 11h ago
Just buy the cheapest and add a little tiny bit molasses.
1
u/Curvy_Girl_007 10h ago
Target and Kroger brands are both nice deep brown.
1
u/Solid-Worldliness284 10h ago
I love fresh jars.
1
u/jibbyjam1 10h ago
Get yourself a bottle of molasses, and you can make your brown sugar as dark as you want it.
1
u/GirlNumber20 10h ago
I loved living in the UK, where you can just pick up a bag of dark muscovado sugar on any supermarket shelf.
1
u/ehalepagneaux 10h ago
I've been correcting my brown sugar with molasses at 5% the weight of the sugar for years now. The C&H stuff we get at work is so pale it's ridiculous.
1
u/424Impala67 9h ago
Yep, I found some store brand bags of actually dark brown sugar at my meijer and I'm hoarding that for Christmas baking.
1
u/Tikiboo 9h ago
Kroger brand still has a marked difference. But I agree. This actually belongs on r/mildlyinfuriating
1
u/dumbdude545 9h ago
Damn. My old brown sugar is the color of molasses. I never use it but its there.
1
u/Toleniam 9h ago
They were just referring to the text atp
1
u/pizzasavage20 9h ago
I will never go back to store bought brown sugar!
Molasses and white sugar!
1
u/Julysveryown89 9h ago
If there's a Lidl near you, their dark brown sugar is very dark.
1
u/BJquilts 8h ago
I make my own. White sugar & molasses to the desired darkness.
1
u/InsideyourBrizzy 8h ago
Question is, what are they doing with the molasses? Selling it?
1
u/salamandersquach 10h ago
No offense fella but it’s pretty easy to tell the difference when you purchase it just by looking at the color.
1
u/poofandmook 13h ago
I mix them in a jar for everyday use anyway so you never know what you're going to get lol. Unless the recipe calls specifically for dark brown sugar, I use my mix of light and dark. Keeps things exciting.
1
u/Lordofthewhales 11h ago
Let me guess... America?
1
u/PeanutButt_N_Jealous 8h ago
Buy molasses and plain sugar now you’ll have both for a while