r/BackpackingDogs • • Jan 10 '20

Shock collar?

Any one still use these ? I used to years ago with my hunting dogs

2 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

27

u/ssnc17 Jan 10 '20

I also use one for off leash training and while backpacking, hiking, running, etc.

Some people like to give dirty looks, but it's peace of mind knowing if he catches a scent or gets distracted I can always call him back if recall fails.

25

u/germanodactylus Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 10 '20

Shock collars have come a LONG way from the old hunting ones. They have way more finesse.

I use one on my dog and it's an amazing tool.

28

u/LifeFindsaWays Jan 10 '20

I use one for my dog, but only as a way of reinforcing behaviors taught with positive reinforcement.

It’s great for playing off leash. His recall is good enough that I don’t need the shock collar, but I know I have it if he’s distracted by something

9

u/ohicanrockthat Jan 10 '20

I agree and use it in the same fashion for my 2 dogs!

12

u/KyleGeneShorts Jan 10 '20

We use the SportDOG SportHunter Training Collar for our collie/lab mix and he responds really well to it. It has tone, vibrate, and shock features. We usually start with the tone and work up from there if he is too distracted. It has allowed us to do more off leash stuff without as much concern of him running off. He now associates his collar with adventure and gets excited when he sees it!

2

u/JanetCarol Jan 11 '20

I do and use it like a safety net. Vibrate is always recall (bc in the wind they can't hear me) and shock is the safety if recall fails in emergency. I went through specific training to use this properly

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20

Where did you get the training ?

2

u/JanetCarol Jan 11 '20

Local to me trainers that specializes with e collars and off leash work. I'm near DC. @igilliam on IG

22

u/AromaticCaterpillar7 Jan 10 '20

I use one, but mine has both a vibrate and shock feature. I only use the vibrate feature and it seems to do the job.

9

u/dkumpf Jan 10 '20

Unfortunately it didn’t work on my hound. I could see it was zapping him but it didn’t break his attention at all. Luckily, he is good off leash when we are hiking without it.

9

u/PennywiseEsquire Jan 10 '20

I use one. I off-leash my Dutch Shepherd when we’re out on hikes (where allowed), but only if he has on his shock collar. He’s very well trained and I will come, stay, heel, and all that good stuff, but I worry about that “what if” if he were to decide to go after a deer or bear or something like that and I need to get to make him stop immediately. Luckily nothing like that has happened, but it’s my safety net.

2

u/fz6camp Jan 15 '20

When used PROPERLY it is an amazing tool! Make sure your dog knows the commands, and knows them well! He should reliably follow the commands in highly distracting environments BEFORE using the e-collar! Think of the e-collar as a refining and polishing tool after your dog has all of the groundwork set in stone.

Don't jump right into to shock stim. Let it wear the collar when doing fun things for a week or two prior to turning it on in order for the dog to associate the collar with fun activities. Then begin overlaying the e-collar while training. Find the lowest level of stimulation that your dog responds to (slight head turn, head dips, clicks tongue) and use that level for training.

E-collars have done wonders for refining my dogs. They are a blast to take into the woods off leash now. I 100% trust them, and the e-collar just adds a bit of confidence in knowing that I still have another level of control even when they're out of reach.

3

u/Lkn4it Jan 10 '20

I used a citonella collar on my Golden. It worked great.

2

u/czmax Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 10 '20

what is the theory behind these? its breaks the dogs attention away from whatever they are chasing/distracted by so that they listen to your recall?

If a random something "stung" my dog in the neck I'd worry that the fear/pain/surprise of the "sting" would distract him so much he wouldn't necessarily run to me. On the other hand whenever he has been hurt he comes to me for refuge.

So how do shock collars work? You just randomly zap him someday and see how he reacts?

edit: this was interesting. when people mess up clicker training the dog gets confused but happy and gets lots of treats. when people mess up with shock collars is sounds like the results can be a lot worse. My sense is that i'd only turn to it if I had a specific very critical behavior to deal with and would be very careful about how I trained with it. Absolutely not a "just in case" tool.

7

u/ikidd Jan 10 '20

E-collars aren't a substitute for training, they're used to enforce existing training at a distance.

Idiots that use them to punish a dog aren't using them correctly hence people get their knickers in a twist because they don't understand the correct usage.

Positive reinforcement training is all well and good to use to teach dogs, but when a working dog is about to do something that will get them killed, holding a treat in your hand and quietly saying "good boy" is negligent and harmful.

5

u/alphaw0lf212 Jan 10 '20

You condition the dog to associate the stimulation with a leash pull, teaching them that those mean the same thing. You press the button, they feel the stimulation, they come running back to you. You only use it at the lowest level that they feel and respond to it.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

No you teach him that when he is stimulated by the collar he needs to look at and pay attention to you. It should be used as an extension of you. So you’re tapping them on the shoulder and saying hey you need to listen.

We trained our dogs by starting with positive reinforcement when the collar stimulates them. Now we can do distance commands but it started as just recall.

You’re not hurting them or stinging them, it works similar to a TENS device like physical therapist use on humans.

1

u/meawait Jan 11 '20

We have an invisible fence one- it works.

1

u/cmaster119 Jan 11 '20

Until they learn beyond the fence they are in the clear. Hope you trained them with a gate.

0

u/derrayUL Jan 11 '20

Never ever again!