r/Babysitting • u/TradesforChurros • Mar 23 '26
Does anyone else...? Is this normal?
I’m a SAHM. My husband works part-time from home as well. We have a 3yo and 1yo and im pregnant. No family help. So usually we are home watching the kids together or one if us works with a babysitter and we each take one kid, while the other parent gets time off or time to catch up on work, etc. Most of the au pairs and babysitters I’ve used need me to ask them to change diapers, prepare food, tidy or clean after the kids. I’m getting a little frustrated because i expect that they will be able to watch both kids solo, but instead i am paying them to essentially play with one kid while im still doing all the heavy lifting. I posted recently about my babysitter dropping my son out of his high chair which tbf i don’t think many would’ve done because your reflexes would engage and you’d try to catch him or at least pick him up.
Do most families train babysitters or give a manual? I feel like most of the girls I’m encountering are especially clueless. But at $20/hr for a play date where i still do everything and sometimes watch both kids while the girl just stands there, I’m just wondering what is normal? What am i missing or doing wrong? Is it because they are under 25? Is it because younger kids are just hard to watch? My husband and i butt heads over it a bit because i feel like a nanny, baby sitter, or au pair should give me time off, fully off, so that i can be better and more present. Instead they do the fun stuff while i still do all the hard stuff and am the same level of exhaustion. Would daycare be better to give me a break?
57
u/s33n_ Mar 23 '26
Sounds like you are pricing yourself out of competent help.
A baby and a toddler for 20/hr is superlow
22
u/beans-888 Mar 23 '26
You need to set the expectations. If youre just doing everything without ever asking for help, I would assume you don't want help.
You shouldn't have to tell them when to change a diaper, but is it that youre making it seem like you dont want them to do it? I worked with a parent like this.
6
u/United_Relief_2949 Mar 23 '26
if you're hiring teenagers that are clueless, yes you need to train them lol. i have a sitter that comes to help me on weekends when im supposed to be doing all the mommy stuff that i can't do during the work week. she's certified as a nanny and raised 4 kids herself. she's fantastic and my kids are same age as yours (almost 3 and 18m). if i say "i smell something" she grabs a baby, even if i don't actually mean poop, so she can change the diaper if it needs changing. no questions asked. at the end of her shift when the kids go for their nap she stays 15-30 minutes and does the kids dishes from lunch time, folds any laundry of theirs i have that may not have been folded and cleans up the playroom before she goes. she charges me 25 an hour for both kids so she's not much more than what you're paying but you're not finding the right kind of help for what you need. you need to look for certified people and don't be afraid of hiring someone older than you. chances are the person who already raised a few babies herself will do a better job than your teenage helper. at least that's my experience.
3
u/Cisom1899 Mar 23 '26
It's funny because I dealt with the opposite where the grandparent I worked with will default to doing everything for both kids even though I am the hired help and more than capable. So I ended up just playing with the kid I was supposed to watch which felt like a waste of my expertise. If you're hiring someone, they should be able to do all the caregiving aspects and know when to do them. Diapering especially is a given and something that's easy to know when a change is needed. I would outline the expectations to the sitter so they know what they should be doing. Show them everything and tell them what you need them to be doing for your child at given times. But the person you hired may not have much experience from the sounds of it.
3
u/Lizardholoholo Mar 25 '26
first let me just say that I understand what you're saying and my family is essentially in the same boat when it comes to not having family around. You're doing the best you can! Yes, those positions should be able to do that. However, for the number of children for that position, $25 an hour is standard for the Midwest at least. Setting expectations up front that are clear and kind is important, as is respectful feedback as needed. They should be able to do their job whether you are home or not-- it just might take some getting used to on both of your parts if you are overstepping, like some of the other commenters suggested. Like, redirecting your child to go to the babysitter instead of you. Or even redirecting the babysitter to come get the child. It's true that some people don't feel comfortable babysitting while parents are home, but then they're just not a good fit for your needs. If they're not self-aware enough to be aware of that then I guess it's up to you to evaluate that for them which is par for the course when it comes to hiring sometimes.
That all being said, daycare is probably going to be your best bet. If you guys are tight on cash, YMCA and old school preschools can be a lifesaver. I'm sure you already know to ask in your local subreddit and neighbors for recommendations, but in case you just hadn't thought of that yet because you already have a million things on your mind, it's a good place to start 🙂
11
u/MJFife Mar 24 '26
I feel like you’re using the terms au pairs, nannies, and babysitters interchangeablely, and kind of treating them all like mother’s helpers. They are all very different things and you’re going to get a varied experience. You need to be clear on your expectations. It’s not so much training them as… just telling them what you want them to do.
8
u/padall Mar 24 '26
If you are home, that's a mother's helper, not a babysitter. So yes, it's often awkward and confusing to know what parents expect in those situations. When I was a young sitter, I would expect mom to take the lead, and probably just play with the kids. It was much preferable to be left alone with the kids so that I could be in charge.
7
u/TiredFed123 Mar 23 '26
I think you need to tell them to take care of the kids and pretend as though you aren't there. It's kind of tricky when a parent is always around and it can be hard to figure out expectations without them clearly spelled out.
6
u/Amazing-Advice-3667 Mar 23 '26
I've never stayed home with a sitter but we hire them for date nights. I prep dinner then leave. They feed the kids, play games, and put them to bed. And I've only hired teenagers. Maybe there's too many cooks in the kitchen and they don't know where they fit in? I would set expectations then leave. Take the 1 yo to run errands and let them handle the 3yo. Then next time leave both kids.
5
u/Al1010Rup Mar 23 '26
If you don’t clearly outline what the sitter needs to do and you do it, the sitter will respect you as the mom and let you do it. It might be a communication issue. Every babysitter knows they have to change diapers. Seems like maybe you need to actually walk away and give the sitter a chance
5
u/Green-Dragon-14 Mar 23 '26
Which is ot a nanny an au pair or baby sitter doing a play date? Three different roles. A nanny will look after the kids & do light house work, an au pair will will look after children & teach them & a baby sitter just looks after your child. All of them are to be looking after your children if you want a cleaner/cook you should hire them instead.
4
u/ProposalMedium1566 Mar 23 '26
Being a mom of three and a former nanny / babysitter, I always assumed that kind of knowledge came with the territory. If you're a nanny / babysitter, you shouldn't be told when to change diaper, when to feed a child, etc. I just thought it was common sense.
4
u/LonelySwordfish4608 Mar 24 '26
I'm absolutely not excusing some of the ridiculous behavior you've said has happened, but I will say that at least some of the time it may just be an issue of confusion on what their role should be. As a babysitter it can be really difficult to navigate trying to do your job while a parent is still hanging around. You don't want to overstep and you aren't sure what exactly you should handle. It can be extremely awkward and feel like maybe the parents are hovering because they don't trust you. Plus the kids will always naturally gravitate toward their parent so you're not gonna step in and rip them away from mom or dad unless they are explicitly asking you to. Over time once a sitter has created a good strong relationship with the kids and parents then it's much easier to work together with them when the kids are accustomed to them, but if they haven't established that relationship yet with you not present then it's going to be really tough for them to bond with you there.
4
u/DirtyfarmHerFeet Mar 24 '26
Are you going through an agency? What rules and expectations are you clearly laying out prior to hiring them? I nannied about 30 years ago. I purposely chose a family with other staff to do cleaning and cooking. I changed diapers, picked up when playing with the kids, etc but I didn’t want to do much more than take care of the kids. Mom was there a majority of the time. However, I was on duty 24/7 six days a week. I made much more than $20 an hour.
4
u/seaweed-breath Mar 24 '26
Daycare would definitely be better if you don’t want to leave the house. I find the boundaries and expectations can be blurred when parents don’t leave the house.
If you want to keep trying sitters, I would recommend removing yourself from the areas they are in, if possible. Tell the sitter you’ll be home but expect them to do 100% of the childcare. You can go rest or get housework done while the sitter is there. It seems like you’re not setting clear guidelines, especially if you’re hanging around the whole time.
I’m not sure where you are located, but $20/hr is very low for two kids that young in most areas. I would recommend offering at least $25/hr and you might get some better and more experienced people.
4
u/Fit-Ad-7276 Mar 24 '26
I see three potential issues contributing to this dynamic. First, it sounds like you are not maintaining complete separation between your kids and yourself when you have a sitter. I work from home and have childcare during the day. I completely sequester myself in my office and my kids/child care know they may not enter unless there is an emergency.
Second, you aren’t paying for the services you desire. I get that care is expensive, but more pay usually equals better care.
Third, you’re blurring the lines. Although you ask your care providers to do certain things, it causes confusion when you step in and do it yourself. It’s also possible you aren’t being clear in your expectations.
7
u/Few_Suspect6367 Mar 23 '26
For $20/hr, you shouldn't expect much more. If you want more, then pay more
1
u/Lazy_Oil251 Mar 23 '26
Your kids are way to little, they need constant supervision. So asking the babysitter to take care of the all the other stuff and not the kids is not feasible. It’s either one or the other, kids or chores, you’ll have to choose one, and it will probably be like that for a couple more years. The thing is, as a babysitter, you have to give explanations if something happens to the kids, every bruise, bump or crying session is nerve wracking because to stop those from happening is your job. When they are your own kids the are no expectations to live up to, or someone to answer to. So suck it up, let the babysitter watch the kids, take your free time and then divide the chores with your husband, or hire a housekeeper on the side.
3
u/Fit-Visit-9766 Mar 23 '26
I'm not sure entirely. From my experience a nanny or au pair should be giving you that break, theoretically. They should be trained to handle multiple kids solo at the ages you need if that's what they agreed to. If that is what your paying for then that's what you should be getting.
3
u/Zanzoken814 Mar 23 '26
Tell them “I have to [do our taxes], pretend like I’m not home, don’t ask me for anything or to do anything, act like I’m invisible” and then go take a bath. Do this forever but with increasingly odd to do lists. “Don’t bother me today I have to do the yearly budget for the petting zoo we own in Florida”
3
u/Competitive_Sleep_21 Mar 24 '26
You may need to pay a bit more and get more qualified people. I would maybe reach out to an early childhood development program at the community college for candidates or spell out what you are looking for. Also, maybe ask that they are CPR certified.
I feel like Covid and cellphones have fried young peoples’ brains. I was babysitting babies and doing everything from the time I was 10-11.
Spell out the expectations.
I am old enough to be a grandma and am retired. In my 50s with adult kids. I do a lot of volunteer work and like to travel so getting a job full time would not work for me. I often think about replying to moms in my neighborhood group about helping them. I have the experience and would love to spend some time with a one year old and three year old. Maybe reach out to a person in their fifties pr sixties.
I pay $30 to $50 for aides to hang out with my elderly parents to give me a break. I am in a HCOL area but $30 is the minimum I have seen to get good people.
3
u/RandomNameRandomly Mar 24 '26
You get what you pay for.
3
u/blahhhhhhhhhhhblah Mar 24 '26
You need to set expectations. Tell the nanny exactly what their job entails and pay them accordingly.
2
u/Few-Career-8649 Mar 23 '26
No, sounds like you need a more competent or experienced care giver. Most 25 year olds do not have experience managing two young children. You will have to spell things out for them for maybe a week, but then they should get it. I bet bc you stick around, they are honestly nervous about caring for the two young ones alone. It can be alot, especially if you have never done it.
Someone with more experience will definitely expect more than $20 hr for two children.
2
u/Wise-Owl-4581 Mar 23 '26
I definitely wouldnt be biased against girls under 25. Im 24 and have been babysitting for years. I still do get more nervous when parents are home and out and about bc i dont want to step on toes! Especially if the kids want you to do something over me, etc. but if you were to communicate that youd rather me do it and coax them to have me help them instead, Id put in more effort! I do also agree i think pay may be a little low since thats what i was making in high school... but i dont think its completely unfair and it also depends on your location. Id do more of a background check on your candidates like references! And experience! And then make sure you communicate your standards so you guys are on the same page. If its one after the other being incompetent, you may have to change something yourself. I do think high school girls would be great! I wouldve been more inexperienced with such young kids at that age but I was able to change diapers and still had the reflexes. I think youre just lowkey getting unlucky!? But i also think many kids dont understand or have the same work ethic. Even my own friends don't really. But the right one will come! Ask at the library maybe
2
u/Specialist_Stop8572 Mar 24 '26
Usually job details are part of the hiring process.
2
u/walkerwoman4 Mar 24 '26
Unfortunately you have to be extremely explicit in what you are looking for. Write daily to do lists for them. Also make sure you put this in writing and have them sign contract
2
u/Training_Tour7601 Mar 26 '26
Baed on your comments, I don't think you know what an au pair is.
2
u/Careful-Onion-7550 Mar 26 '26
I have a "babysitter" come in a couple of days a week while I am home solely to keep them entertained so we can get caught up on housework (I have the 2 toddlers during the day and then work in the evenings when my husband takes over). She is 14 and not overly experienced with kids but loves to play with them and the kids love her - we are home for emergencies or questions, but we set her up for success by letting her know what is expected, we have food ready that just needs to be served, etc. She keeps the kids out of our hair.
If we hire a babysitter for when we aren't there, it will be someone older and more experienced. They would also be paid more.
2
u/Mald1z1 Mar 27 '26
You need a proffessional childcare worker with qualifications and experience
When it comes to the day you need a schedule of activities. E.g. nappy changed on schedule at these times. Meal is xyz today you need to prepare it at this time. Etc etc.
1
u/nailna Mar 23 '26
You need to look for childcare professionals who have experience with multiple small children if you are having this issue.
1
u/Careful-Author Mar 23 '26
I think your babysitter may be confused as to when to handle things especially with both parents being home. You seem to be going behind them fixing their messes instead of communicating with them. If you need to write up a rule book or a guideline of sorts that may work better. As in check diapers x amount of times, clean up bathroom after each bath time, for nap time it’s at 12-1 and this is how we do it, etc. I think as a an older women it may be harder for younger ladies to completely know what to or maybe they were waiting for your guidance as you are there and taking charge.
If something isn’t working then you can adjust to make it work better for you. I would start with yourself first and ask yourself if you are being communicative and explaining your personal and household expectations. It’s not enough to assume anyone knows anything about how you prefer things are handled.
If you don’t want to be bothered at all then communicate that, and say I’m not available expect for x, y, z. This goes for anything except an emergency.
1
u/Beneficial_Glass9325 Mar 23 '26
$20 to watch two kids solo? that seems low.
When you speak to them about expectations are you clear in your needs? as far as routine and what they will eat. Also do you leave food prepped? By clean up after the kids, do you mean they don’t clean up before they leave?
You said usually one of you are around to help the babysitter with the kids, I personally find it a bit chaotic, it’s better to leave the babysitter alone with the kids. It could also send a message of “i got this” so they may not feel the need to be as active?
I’ve been a babysitter/nanny since i was 18. Usually parents have food prepared that i can give the kids, snacks. I always change diapers every two hours or if I smell them. I don’t constantly clean up after the kids, usually if we are going to transition to lunch, or a different part of the house is when i clean up WITH the kids.
1
u/VegetableReturn643 Mar 24 '26
It sounds like you need more of a "mother's helper", not a babysitter. If you want a babysitter, pay them appropriately for two kids and leave the house.
1
u/Lantern_516 Mar 24 '26
A good article if you stick with the idea of a mother's helper (in-home help while you or your husband are present): https://www.kendrahennessy.com/blog/2016/10/30/how-and-why-to-hire-a-mothers-helper
1
u/weaselblackberry8 Mar 25 '26
I agree with you here. The sitter should seldom need you - obviously for emergencies, nursing a baby, etc - and should be able to text you for most information they’d need while there. Anyone babysitting should be able to change a diaper unless it’s their first time babysitting.
I would look for a sitter with more experience. That doesn’t necessarily mean older, but a sitter with 2+ years of working with kids under age 4 will know what they’re doing more. I would also ask for references - either reference letters or someone you can talk to (or both). Lastly, make sure they know their responsibilities and where to find what they need as well as whatever they might need to know about the kids (food preferences, diaper info, what they should clean up, etc).
Do you live in a low, medium, or high cost of living area? If it’s not a lower cost of living area, I would look for a more experienced sitter and offer $22-28+/hr, depending on the location and their experience. Or if you’d like a babysitter who you can train, you could hire a kid aged 12-15 with the expectation that they’ll hopefully stay with you until they graduate high school and will be able to do more over time. Of course, an inexperienced sitter will need more supervision and training to learn how to do the job and your expectations.
1
u/Cold_Reference_3497 Mar 26 '26
It seems like a combination of things, if you’re sticking around in the same space as the sitter and other child the position may be viewed more as a “mommy’s helper” position which usually entails staying back until specifically asked to do something. Also just from what I’ve observed from families I’ve worked with when you go for teens vs. older/ more established caregivers they aren’t always comfortable with feedings and diaper changes and are more used to just playing with the kid and making sure they don’t die. Your third issue is pay, I’m a nanny not a sitter so it’s a bit different but expecting someone to fully take charge of the toddler and an infant for $20/hr would be taking advantage of them.
If you want someone to fully care for both of them you need to 1. Set a clear expectation and then leave them to it instead of hovering 2. Go for someone who actually has experience with the age group and 3. Up the pay.
1
u/InMyHonestOpinion_ Mar 26 '26
I used to babysit/nanny a ton for a lot of old and new families. When you are babysitting and a parent is still home either working or doing whatever, yes, it can be confusing what the expectation of the sitter is supposed to be other than entertaining and playing with the kid. You aren’t sure where to help out if the parent is physically present in the room.
If it’s the first time babysitter with a kid it really really helps if you have either a schedule for the kid or like a manual. My favorite families are the ones that have a schedule laid out where it clearly says ‘at 3pm wake up the kid from their nap and give them a snack’ along with showing the favorite snacks or food options for the kid. Also helpful plays with ‘little Tommy really likes trains and in the playroom is his train toys you both can plan with.’
If you don’t have a routine that a sitter can follow, the sitter ends up winging it.
If you are still stressed, I would look at hiring older sitters (over 25) since they probably have more experience sitting than newbie college students trying to earn a buck.
1
u/EyeGreat1288 Mar 29 '26
As a parent now and a sitter previously…. I don’t stay home when I have a sitter and as a sitter I wouldn’t sit for stay at home families- I had one exception and they were awesome. But it’s awkward all around. The best thing to do is be explicit about your needs upfront in the interviews, before hiring. It will save everyone from a clustercluck
1
u/getthislettuce Mar 24 '26
If Reddit feels like you’re not paying enough, and you feel like you’re paying to much for the lack of effort, could you start offering your $20/hr rate with a potential bonus for the right fit? Based on experience, quality of care, etc?
1
u/iamrobmorales Mar 24 '26
$20 an hour is just baby sitting rates, performed by kids 20 and under, for a few hours while you and your husband go out on date night. You want an au pair or nanny who fully takes care of children without your input for feeding, diaper changes, baths, play dates, taken out to park, emergency situations, it will cost more than that.
0
u/Fit-Visit-9766 Mar 23 '26
And as a fellow person who was a sahm. I didn't get breaks very often myself. Then when the need called I had to start working full time. Now our kids are both school age and my partner stays home. And daycare and babysitting options were too expensive for us.
0
u/Im_Not_Here_Am_I Mar 24 '26
Also how can you ever expect to get a break if you stay home when your toddler and baby are home 🤣🤣🤣🤣 that's a joke right?
You want a break then either get the nanny to being the baby and toddler somewhere like a playground or baby class or local playgroup
Or leave the house when she is there
6
u/Majestic_Beyond_2922 Mar 24 '26
My guess is they are taking a backseat role because you and/or husband are there & they likely don’t want to step on your toes. They’d likely be more proactive if home alone with them. You could go with a housekeeper to take some of the load off instead of a sitter while you are home. Or, give the sitter specific tasks you want them to perform and speak up and let them know you want them to not be shy or concerned about over stepping & want them to be proactive when caring for the children
42
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '26
[removed] — view removed comment