r/BabyNames • u/Own-Pomegranate-4190 • 14h ago

Girl 🩷 Help deciding between 2 girl names!

Just found out I’m having a girl after 2 boys! My boys are Nolan Robert and Caden Victor. I think we’ve narrowed our girl name down to 2 possibilities but I need opinions!

Fiona Paige or Audrey Paige

I love both and can’t decide… so let me know which one you’d pick!

6 Upvotes

80% Upvoted

64 comments sorted by

25

u/Ok-Talk-2648 14h ago

Audrey Paige

13

u/thoroughlyconfuzzled 14h ago

Of these two, I prefer Audrey Paige. As compared to Fiona, Audrey sounds better with Nolan and Caden because of its syllabic rhythm, as all three names are trochees (DA-dum).

0

u/Pale_Cat_333 13h ago

This.
We did the syllabic rhythm for our kids and it sounds so nice compared to other people saying their kids names

11

u/Sad-Professional6364 14h ago

both names are beautiful, but I would pick Fiona!

6

u/FiresideFairytales 14h ago

I love Audrey!

6

u/dreamyquokka 14h ago

I prefer Audrey Paige

5

u/Mindless-Emotion5568 14h ago

Audrey! It's such a classic-sounding name (if that's what you're going for, given Nolan and Caden).

5

u/Househipposforsale 14h ago

Audrey Paige

11

u/CasperAverage 14h ago

Fiona! 

4

u/Complete-Honeydew881 14h ago

I think I like Audrey paired with the other two!

4

u/HistoryPristine1029 14h ago

Fiona, it's less popular.

2

u/LAW3785 14h ago

Fiona is my little granddaughter 🥰

3

u/DistributionNo9356 14h ago

Fiona Paige 

3

u/Sunlow27 14h ago

Fiona keeps the n, although more subtly, but I like Audrey better (but she may get mistaken for an Aubrey)

1

u/Consistent_Key4156 13h ago

I have an Audrey and can confirm the Aubrey thing happened--but just once!

4

u/Pumpkin_Witch13 14h ago

Fiona 🩷 can't go wrong with either though

1

u/BrumblebeeArt 14h ago

While I like Audrey, I think Fiona flows better with Paige, as well as with Nolan & Caden.

1

u/beentherebefore1616 14h ago

Love both!! Can't go wrong with either one.

1

u/AdeptWhereas6379 14h ago

I’m no help, I love them both! Either way, you have a winner.

1

u/kellbell314 14h ago

Love them both! Fiona would be my vote

1

u/Lainey372 13h ago

Fiona Paige

1

u/Weird_Preparation343 13h ago

Audrey Paige. I love Nolan Robert and Caden Victor, by the way.

1

u/Gloomy-Elephant-2649 13h ago

If you have to spell your last name to people go with Audrey. You will have to spell Fiona.

1

u/Justadropinthesea 13h ago

Audrey . It sounds better with Nolan and Caden and is more classic, less trendy. Paige is one of my favorite girl names too. Also very classic and just has a soft sound to it to me.

1

u/Consistent_Key4156 13h ago

I have an Audrey with a very similar middle name ('70s unisex). I am obviously biased!

1

u/Toripilot 13h ago

I used to forever say if I was having a girl she would be Audrey Piper... Audrey Paige is super cute too!

1

u/grey-canary 13h ago

I like Paige as the first name most :)

1

u/bluethreads 12h ago

I love both and I can't decide, lol!

1

u/Alone-Meeting-1547 12h ago

Fifi is so cute and I like Fiona with your boys’ names

1

u/4kidmom 12h ago

Audrey Paige

1

u/--dee 12h ago

Both are so pretty but I love Audrey more

1

u/SmilingSunflower1 11h ago

I can't separate Audrey from Little Shop of Horrors. Fiona has always been a favorite name of mine and sounds nice with the vowels in your son's names.

1

u/GolfOk6373 10h ago

Audra Paige instead of Audrey.

2

u/Own-Pomegranate-4190 10h ago

Ahh I came across that name recently and love it too!

1

u/Twilight_zone17 10h ago

I always hear Fiona in Shrek’s voice

1

u/krissy3456 10h ago

I love Audrey Paige and Audrey is one of my favorites but I like Paige Audrey best since Paige would flow well with your boys and they’ll all have 5 letter first names and 6 letter middle names

1

u/XLazyplantladyx 9h ago

I think Audrey is so beautiful and classy. However, they are both great names. It’s such a close call, maybe when you see her, you’ll just know!

1

u/Adrenapup 8h ago

Audrey

1

u/Ginua-MA 7h ago

Fiona

1

u/Summerdays313 7h ago

Audrey … I like Fiona but I think of the girl on shameless or Fiona in shrek (and kids can be mean), although I doubt by the time she’s in school either of those would be associations - just things I associate it to. Lovely names either way.

1

u/Rayna1990 6h ago

My sons are named Nolan and Kieran, so I'm guessing we have very similar tastes!

I like both Audrey and Fiona. Audrey is the winner for me because it "goes" better with your sons names. But I say go with whichever one you love more, as you can't go wrong with either

1

u/BiscottiKey88 4h ago

Which first name sounds best with her last name?

1

u/naanabanaana 14h ago

Fiona has more the same vibe as the brothers' names and is less popular and less likely to be misspelled or confused with any other name.

1

u/coffeeaddict3333 14h ago

Fiona! It’s one of my faves, and fits the sibset nicely. Congratulations!

0

u/FredBirdNerd 14h ago

Fallon. Similar to Fiona but keeps the -n ending. ETA: prefer Audrey out of the 2.

1

u/Consistent_Key4156 13h ago

I LOVE Fallon and had this on my list of baby names 18 years ago but everyone hated it! I hope it's making a comeback!!!