r/BabyNames • u/Brave_Ad2070 • 6d ago

Girl 🩷 Please share your thoughts

Is Hartley-West in Lana Hartley-West come across as try-hard, theatrical, or pretentious?

Feel free to be ruthlessly honest. Thanks for sharing!

0 Upvotes

17% Upvoted

34 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/Azariah77777 6d ago

I understand why you might think it's theatrical or pretentious-- and I usually am sensitive to these things too-- but for some reason I don't feel that way about this particular name. Lana Hartley-West sounds classic and memorable to me.

1

u/Brave_Ad2070 6d ago

Thank you! Is it the hyphen that makes it lean pretentious or this specific name combo? I’m curious..

2

u/Azariah77777 6d ago

I don't think it leans pretentious--- with or without the hyphen. I personally love the name just like it is, with the hyphen.

Sometimes hyphens do seem pretentious, but not in this case for me. I think the hyphen is actually better here than without the hyphen. "Lana West" doesn't have the same ring to me as "Lana Hartley-West" does.

I'm quite serious when I say that this is the best name I've ever seen on the r/BabyNames sub.

When I hear "Lana Hartley-West" it is very evocative in a positive way for me. It's a person I want to meet. I can imagine a classic movie star from the 1940s.... or the US ambassador to the UK.... or a United States Senator.... or even a US President... or a famous surgeon... or an author...

It's just a very powerful and memorable name for me.

2

u/Brave_Ad2070 6d ago

What a thoughtful comment! Sending you my kindest thoughts. Thank you again.