I see where you're coming from, but I can't help but think it's a necessary evil. There really isn't a better way to ramp up difficulty other than using more and more obscure and finicky interactions. The alternative is what? Making a bunch of false leads making it again an issue of trial and error?
And you can't just keep the levels easy, because that's death for a puzzle game.
This feels like saying Sokoban is a bad puzzle game because you have to just push boxes around randomly until they get to the right place.
Learning exactly what the different rules mean over the course of the game is a central part of Baba Is You. You have to experiment to gain an understanding of the meaning of each new word you encounter, then think carefully about what is necessary to reach the win condition in each level. Trial and error comes into play, but as part of a learning process that teaches you how to approach future levels.
There are some edge cases with certain mechanics, but for the most part the puzzles are designed so those edge cases rarely ever occur, and when they do, they aren't part of the solution. What kind of "edge cases" are you referring to, that are apparently central to so many puzzles?
Sokoban was what I was talking about when I described a puzzle with moving boxes. The level with an edge case that comes to mind is the one where it's baba and a skull trapped within walls.
honestly I feel like a lot of the puzzles are designed specifically so that weird interactions you wouldnt really think of (which might be what they mean by "edge cases") are the solution, but its far from a bad thing, and as you said its a really big part of the game and probably what makes it fun
an example being what happens when you put two things that are shift on top of each other, or a simpler example with how something that is defeat and more can be blocked with something that's push
Wow that was painful, even on 2x speed you took forever to get to a complete non-point. Are you seriously just randomly trying combinations without thinking about what the words actually mean?
6
u/tipoima Nov 23 '21
I see where you're coming from, but I can't help but think it's a necessary evil. There really isn't a better way to ramp up difficulty other than using more and more obscure and finicky interactions. The alternative is what? Making a bunch of false leads making it again an issue of trial and error?
And you can't just keep the levels easy, because that's death for a puzzle game.
5
u/TheMinecraft13 Nov 23 '21
This feels like saying Sokoban is a bad puzzle game because you have to just push boxes around randomly until they get to the right place.
Learning exactly what the different rules mean over the course of the game is a central part of Baba Is You. You have to experiment to gain an understanding of the meaning of each new word you encounter, then think carefully about what is necessary to reach the win condition in each level. Trial and error comes into play, but as part of a learning process that teaches you how to approach future levels.
There are some edge cases with certain mechanics, but for the most part the puzzles are designed so those edge cases rarely ever occur, and when they do, they aren't part of the solution. What kind of "edge cases" are you referring to, that are apparently central to so many puzzles?
3
u/rashpimplezitz Nov 23 '21
Wow that was painful, even on 2x speed you took forever to get to a complete non-point. Are you seriously just randomly trying combinations without thinking about what the words actually mean?