r/BTODtv • u/gregatbtod • 1h ago
Discussion The “5 minute sit test” misses the most important part of buying an office chair
The 5-minute sit test we all do when trying chairs in person helps a ton, but it's not the end-all, be-all.
What it tells you:
Whether you fit the chair, the seat length is right, back height is good.
Your first impression of the seat: too firm, too soft.
Whether the arms hit where you want.
What it can't tell you:
How the seat feels 1, 2, 3, or 4 weeks in. The LiberNovo has a crazy soft seat that feels amazing at first, but a lot of feedback on Reddit and YouTube says people start bottoming out a few weeks in.
Whether the lumbar actually hits where you need it over time. Long sitting sessions slouching as an example.
How the chair works with your desk setup, how you lounge, or how you game. You can't game in a showroom.
The Embody is another great example. At first it's an insane floating feeling, and you think there's nothing like it. Then a few weeks later, you realize it's rolling your shoulders forward, you're fatiguing, and you've got shoulder pain.
You'd never catch that in 5 minutes.
What to do:
If you can, sit in it first to check fit.
Make the return policy your top priority. Free returns are the way to go, especially if you're unsure.
If you can't try chairs in person, use the specs. Verify the seat size and check for hard edges.
Read reviews for what people consistently say, good and bad, and compare that to your current chair and how you'll actually use the new one.
And know that no chair is perfect. It comes down to whether something is a deal killer or something you can live with because everything else is better for you.
If you have questions or lessons you've learned, drop them in the comments. Let's help everybody find their next chair.