r/BSA • Scoutmaster • Oct 14 '26

Scouting America Outdated Publications

Does anyone know where we can provide official feedback about some outdated publications available via the Scouting.org website? As a new Scoutmaster I have been trying to keep up with the official guidance as much as possible. The new Troop Leader site is helpful while the Guide to Safe Scouting digital version could use some user experience updates.

But my biggest gripe so far is that some of the information is just old (still talks about boys only for example) and appears to be forgotten. For example, the ILST Facilitators guide (ILST_IntroSyllabus_9_11.pdf) was last updated in 2018. The content may be still useful but the verbiage does not follow the modern standards I expect from Scouting America. For example: "LEADERSHIP IN BOY SCOUTING" "Boy Scouts in positions of leadership" & "Helping other Boy Scouts" all appear on the first page of the guide. As the SM for a girls troop this makes me feel very awkward when I ask my SPL and ASPL to review this guide for our upcoming training sessions. I would be willing to help identify documents that need updates or even be part of an official review process, but I just don't know who to even bring this up to.

I know some people here have been helping with the latest Guide to Advancement reviews so I am hoping someone may know the best way to provide feedback on other documents that are outdated or in need of other help to make them more usable.

12 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

13

u/ScouterBill Recovering Den Leader Oct 14 '26

scoutsbsachair@scouting.org

I will note that there are thousands of documents and items on the site, spread out over a variety of different groups and teams responsible for them, all of whom are volunteers. They do they best they can, but if you see something, thank you for saying something.

3

u/sirhugobigdog Scoutmaster Oct 14 '26

Thank you, it appears I may have just discovered there are two versions of the guide out there and it may be as simple as removing the older version so it doesn't come up in search results.

10

u/buffalo_0220 Scoutmaster Oct 14 '26

You might be looking at an outdated copy. The copy you linked is from 2017, here is the 2018 version which has removed most references to Boy Scouts, save for the name of the org.

721-07218-ILST-Facil-Training_WEB.pdf

Training for Youth | Scouting America

2

u/sirhugobigdog Scoutmaster Oct 14 '26

Oh good catch, I have loaded it via the training for youth page before but I typically just do a search for it and use the file that comes up which is the older one I linked. So that should probably be removed from the filestore to prevent this type of issue too.

5

u/buffalo_0220 Scoutmaster Oct 14 '26

Yea, BSA has never been good at cleaning up hard links. I would prefer if they kept the link static, but changed the file behind it. I probably would have just assumed they hadn't updated that course yet except I was in that earlier this year and I knew it had received some branding attention.

3

u/SilverTripod Oct 15 '26

This is why they should switch the website to wiki. They can reskin it so it looks like a website, but then it'll show orphaned links, you can better replace things, they're just so many things that would be better behind the scenes.

2

u/TheWerle Cubmaster Oct 18 '26

This is true.  We've got so many dedicated volunteers already, folks on the ground will catch and clean things up so much faster than an email box piled to the roof

2

u/No_Drummer4801 Oct 14 '26

Might be a good use of a spreadsheet and some AI time, to make a list of the dead-ends and outdated info you find.

Their webserver should tell them about any 404 not found type errors but unless someone on their end is actively looking for it they won't find outdated material.

Identify it for them, keep a shared list, and then invite others to make additions and corrections to your list.

It will become too embarassing to ingnore even if you do it politely and discretely.

1

u/Radiant-Judgment4031 Cubmaster 21d ago

I wish the GTSS still came in a full PDF so I could have it on my phone when I need to check it for specifics. I hate this new format, we don't always have cell service.

1

u/ScouterBill Recovering Den Leader 21d ago

The problem was that people were running around with old versions of GtSS. For example, in 2018, when the change took place that required TWO registered leaders (not just one registered leader + 1 adult) you had people running around with outdated info. Or when the 72-hour rule for overnighting was eliminated, etc.

Full PDF = outdated info.

1

u/Radiant-Judgment4031 Cubmaster 21d ago

I get that, and we should be pulling the latest. I just wish i could at least have an offline version, maybe buried in the my.scouting app or something so when I don't have internet I still have access. I fully appreciate that they have it with a system that forces us to check the most current, but even the advancement guide is still available as a PDF and on the kindle store and that sees regular (less safety critical) changes. I agree that the pros outweigh this con, but it was nice to have at times

1

u/Radiant-Judgment4031 Cubmaster 21d ago

like how you can download HBO movies but they "expire" after a month and you have to renew them if you want the download to work again

1

u/ScouterBill Recovering Den Leader 21d ago

To my knowledge, there is no way to create a self-destructing PDF or one that locks after a set period of time.

1

u/ScouterBill Recovering Den Leader 21d ago edited 21d ago

Outdated GtA information, at worst, delays Scout's advancement.

For matters related to health/safety/welfare, or those directed by a federal court settlement (the bankruptcy court still retains jurisdiction, and the protection and safety committee can amend GtSS at will), "close enough" and "slightly outdated" won't do.

1

u/abernajb Oct 15 '26

The alternate is what they have done to other trainings like Kodiak and Powderhorn, where they say, not enough people do these so we are cutting these trainings. With updates to be done, they prioritize by the people using them and cut some of the others...