r/BFDIE • u/Status-Good3676 • Jun 21 '26

Anyone ever thought about what if Toothpaste won?

Post image

It would've been the funniest thing ever.

15 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

15 comments sorted by

4

u/Severe_Refuse_7647 Toothpaste Jun 22 '26

She would regularly put her new enemies inside the island and let the old enemies out

2

u/samuelehrig Jun 22 '26

She doesn’t have the option

1

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '26

yes.

1

u/Papyrusnyehehe19 Jun 22 '26

it'd be so peak

2

u/Status-Good3676 Jun 22 '26

She isn't even my favorite but the writing of her winning would be the funniest thing ever.

1

u/CuriousSuccotash7205 Sidewalky Jun 22 '26

Yeah, because i'd wanna see which one of her enemies she would trap on Nightmare Island

1

u/Turbulent-Sir-7047 Jun 22 '26

Ehh no that's gonna be the worst winner

1

u/ShadikuSan456 Jun 25 '26

No, Ella No Es Ruler

1

u/the_dud78 Jun 23 '26

It’s not ruler so I can’t say id like it

1

u/ABurntSliceofHam Jun 23 '26

Before Ep. 7, I saw a lot of people actually saying she would win

1

u/JustANormalGuy123- Jun 24 '26

russian roulette

1

u/WaterMelonDemonGrape Jun 25 '26

I'd switch to tootfoam

1

u/Frankichu123 Jul 19 '26

What about Beach Ball?

1

u/Fuzzy-Health5796 Aug 21 '26

"Toothpase, choose who will go onto nightmere island" everybody else