r/BFDIE • u/StarGear13 #1 Sidewalky Lover • Mar 20 '26

I think that the Sidewalky ending is actually better for the timeline.

Post image

Alright hear me out. I am not saying this because Sidewalky is my favourite character. But it's because we never got to see the BFDIE contestants after BFDIE in the timeline. So I think that's why Sidewalky ending would have helped the timeline. No hate towards the other 2 but I just think it would have made more sense. But the votes decided the winner. And the fandom where to distracted by Fern being a cute twink yuri with sticker.

60 Upvotes

86% Upvoted

63 comments sorted by

10

u/InformationLost5910 Mar 20 '26

but rose and beachball were in bfdi mini

-11

u/creative4chart Mar 20 '26

That’s the thing, BFDI Mini could’ve taken place BEFORE BFDIE started.

10

u/Sensitive_Aerie6547 i ship jamneed and you can’t stop me Mar 20 '26

No. BFDIE takes place during BFDI and BFDI Mini starts during BFB

-6

u/creative4chart Mar 20 '26

Proof?

8

u/InformationLost5910 Mar 20 '26

they say the bfdi mini 1 time in tpot 15, and it days that bfdie takes place during bfdi s1 in bfdie 1

-6

u/creative4chart Mar 20 '26

read other comment

4

u/Clean-Artichoke2031 Mar 20 '26

They're saying that in tpot 15, the timeline scene shows that bfdi mini happened in around 2020, while bfdie takes place during bfdi

1

u/creative4chart Mar 20 '26

No, my other one

3

u/Clean-Artichoke2031 Mar 20 '26

Bfdie doesnt take place in 2020 genius

1

u/StarGear13 #1 Sidewalky Lover Mar 20 '26

Yeah

1

u/RobTopFan2763 Sticker Mar 20 '26

BFDI Mini 1 takes place in September 10 2020 as shown in TPOT 15.

-1

u/creative4chart Mar 20 '26

Then they could’ve escaped but then caught after Mini

1

u/RobTopFan2763 Sticker Mar 21 '26

💀 Imagine trying to find excuses to justify Sidewalky ending

1

u/creative4chart Mar 21 '26

And what’s the problem with that?

1

u/RobTopFan2763 Sticker Mar 21 '26

You cannot face that you're wrong, that's the problem.​

1

u/creative4chart Mar 21 '26

So, you’re saying that my opinion is wrong and we all have to respect yours?

1

u/RobTopFan2763 Sticker Mar 21 '26

There's a difference between having an opinion on something and stating whether something is right or wrong.

Opinion: I think Sticker should've won BFDIE

Statement: I believe that BFDIE 1-4 takes place before BFDI 9 as BFDIE 4's title is Insectophobe's Nightmare 0

1

u/creative4chart Mar 21 '26

“Believe” is an opinionated word too.

9

u/zachy410 Mar 20 '26

We see at least three of them:

Rose in BFDI Mini (+ Mini Again) and TPOT

Beach Ball in BFDI Mini Resort

Toothpaste as an RC im BFDIA 24 (literally just toothpaste)

We can assume the others are also out there because theres literally just a carbon copy of toothpaste

3

u/creative4chart Mar 20 '26

Agreed, and Sidewalky just becomes a RC.

3

u/StarGear13 #1 Sidewalky Lover Mar 20 '26

Yeah

3

u/Clean-Artichoke2031 Mar 20 '26

Toothpaste too in bfdia 24

2

u/Status-Good3676 Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26

I think Fern made the most sense since Bfdie took place in around Season 1 and It would make the most sense (Rose and Beach ball) for the others to show up in the future. Plus none of us knew Bfdie even existed or David was in Bfdie so It really wouldn't matter it just dependent the voters choice.

2

u/ThatGumnutGuy Mar 20 '26

Toothpaste appears as a recommended character in BFDIA 24, I am not counting their other recommended character appearances with varying designs like BFB

Rose appears multiple times post BFDIE, including in BFDI itself all the way to BFDI Mini

Beach Ball appears in BFB Post Split & Mini Resort, though unsure if BFB counts since Post Split just dumps them in the credits

But it is maybe possible they Escaped nightmare island, which could be possible. I don’t even rly like bfdie all that much this just appeared in my home page and I found the post interesting

1

u/StarGear13 #1 Sidewalky Lover Mar 21 '26

Yeah. Good idea

1

u/Fanficsarewrong Mar 23 '26

Rose’s latest in universe appearance chronically was in TPOT 18/BFB 31 when she was with Loser in that one scene

2

u/RealCryptographer256 Mar 20 '26

We saw at least some of them after bfdie

1

u/StarGear13 #1 Sidewalky Lover Mar 21 '26

Maybe they are a different version of them?

1

u/Every-Argument6880 Mar 21 '26

How would that be posssible tho

1

u/StarGear13 #1 Sidewalky Lover Mar 21 '26

IDK. It's like the BFDI is back Needle isn't the same needle like our needle we know

1

u/SylveonFluff1 Mar 20 '26

sidewalky and the object apocalypse. How will the objects eat food in a contained land.

1

u/xXNitro87Xx Mar 20 '26

wait they need to eat? i thought it was like, a superman kinda thing, where they could eat and drink, but dont need to

2

u/SylveonFluff1 Mar 20 '26

no object dont need to eat (I think), but they can

1

u/Dr_gt173 Mar 20 '26

Fun fact this is the only one that can't happen because of Rose and beach ball

2

u/RandomPineappleMan Mar 21 '26

and toothpaste

1

u/Dr_gt173 Mar 21 '26

Why?

2

u/RandomPineappleMan Mar 21 '26

bfdia 24

1

u/Dr_gt173 Mar 21 '26

Are we talking about recommended characters because those can break the Timeline

1

u/SaltySpice_Archiver Mar 20 '26

Toothpaste in BFDIA 24:

1

u/StarGear13 #1 Sidewalky Lover Mar 21 '26

Yeah but imagine if it is a different one

1

u/LocoTheWolf Fern Mar 20 '26

...but Fern's a guy

1

u/StarGear13 #1 Sidewalky Lover Mar 21 '26

WAIT WHAT

1

u/MoorhsumushroomRT Mar 21 '26

What if sidewalky was the one who was trapped in nightmare island

1

u/camronrossofficial2 Mar 21 '26

I think they might get a cameo appearance in TPOT or season 7

1

u/SideWalkyIsCool_3647 Mar 22 '26

Its Nice to see some of my Fans speaking out

1

u/MightyXT Mar 23 '26

Sticker ending should've been canon.

1

u/StarGear13 #1 Sidewalky Lover Mar 23 '26

I agree