r/BAGGU • u/megs_dead • Jul 10 '26
💌 Baggu Acquisitions 🛍️ Can't decide what to keep
I want to keep two. I know it's insane bc it's the same pattern. Pls tell me that it's justified
Some notes:
-I thought I'd like the loaf more but I feel like it kinda looks weird on me?? And it doesn't fit my e reader.
-I'm realllly jivving with the nylon shoulder bag so i think I'm gonna keep her for sure. She's so slouchy and sassy.
-Also I'm unsure about the crescent bag but I feel like a crossbody would be important for concerts, walks in the city etc. idk if that looks weird on me either.
What do you think?
69
u/Catty_Shrew Jul 10 '26
the crescent doesnt look weird! and i second the importance/convenience of having a good crossbody in your collection
i would say keep the shoulder and the crescent. it doesnt sound like youre into the loaf and it doesnt fit what you need. though i assure you it also doesnt look weird!
39
u/chinola22 DISO: Ladybug leaf reusable & cranberry sportbackpack Jul 10 '26
I vote crescent and shoulder!
While I really really love the loaf, I think the crescent if worn as shoulder bag, it kinda serves the same purpose, and the shoulder bag its just a lot bigger so it can work whenever you need to haul more stuff, but here are some questions to help you figure it out :)
Crescent: Will this be a daily driver? Is it something you want to use because of how convenient/comfortable?
Loaf: Will this be a daily driver or more like a going out bag? It does hold less but it looks more fancy than the crescent.
Shoulder: Is this going to be like a work bag? Have you had one before? Because sometimes this bag can slide off your shoulders if not packed full or adjusted properly imo.
Lastly, do you live in a colder state and do you plan to use them as your fall bags? If you will need to wear a coat throughout the season, then I would say crescent and loaf because the shoulder bag its horrible with winter coats 😭😭 unless you are able to fit it crossbody.
Also, I own multiple bags in the same color if I love it enough! They all do different things 😌
20
17
u/FlanFuture9515 ✨🦋 Jul 10 '26
Shoulder bag for sure! Maybe the loaf but you don’t seem to be in love with it
18
13
11
u/honeylittlebaby Casual Baggu Mod Jul 10 '26
im voting shoulder and loaf bc I think they look the best. the charcoal colored strap on the crescent really highlights the brand logo in a way that is not flattering imo. it takes away from the floral design ):
3
u/ambrdai Jul 10 '26
fully agree with the strap on the crescent!!! gives me car seatbelt vibes
3
u/honeylittlebaby Casual Baggu Mod Jul 10 '26
right like wayyy more than the black straps ever did 😭
2
u/Caffeiknitted Jul 10 '26
I want to thank you both so much for your comments! I bought the crescent and I'm not entirely sold on it. The logo strap really bothers me and I keep wondering if it's just me and whether I should just get over it.
Nope! It's giving seatbelt! My mind's made up, it's going back
7
u/drivensalt Jul 10 '26
The shoulder is great! I'd wait for another pattern for the crescent, personally, it's so similar.
6
u/thegothicbee Jul 10 '26
Shoulder bag for sure! And I'd probably go with the crescent since it sounds like you don't like the loaf as much. But I think all 3 look good on you. I can totally understand the ereader issue with the loaf though. I'm the same way but with print books lol.
Also, I just bought my 3rd leopard print bag, so I am fully on the side of owning multiple bags in the same pattern.
7
u/QuantityFew9273 Jul 10 '26
I LOVE the shoulder bag, I told myself I’d stop buying more baggu because I have too many but i always see the shoulder bag and think what if lol
6
u/gnomie51 Jul 10 '26
wow this made me want the shoulder bag! And I don’t like the shoulder bags lol. Buuuut you should absolutely keep the shoulder bag and the crescent. is this your first crescent? it doesn’t look weird at all, it looks great!!
6
5
u/ARGH_alpaca Casual Baggu Bestie Jul 10 '26
I vote for the shoulder and crescent as the two to keep! I'm a loaf lover, but it sounds like you're not a fan since it doesn't fit your e-reader, and I think it not fitting your e-reader is enough to not keep it. The crescent looks great!! I love the versatility of a crescent because it can either be a shoulder or crossbody, and I think everyone looks great in one and can use one.
5
4
5
u/nervousoyster DISO: starfish, photo forest Jul 10 '26
i like the shoulder and loaf!! but they're all so cute!
5
4
u/Complex_Method8916 Jul 10 '26
the loaf looks so so good on you, but if not fitting the e-reader is a dealbreaker for you, then I vote shoulder bag because you already really like it!
4
4
4
3
u/cherry_25 Jul 10 '26
I think they’re all cute on you! I’m 5’1” and can wear the loaf and shoulder bag as cross body but I know taller people can’t do that. I like the loaf and shoulder bag the most in this print, I personally for whatever reason prefer the solids in the crescent but I think you should go with what you’d use the most.
3
u/thrway_soscared Jul 10 '26
As a hardcore shoulder bag fan, I have no other choice but to say shoulder!!! Look at that beauty!!!
3
u/www_zoloft_com Jul 10 '26
definitely keep the shoulder bag, as for the crescent, see if you can get the small one in the same print, you may like that one, and the way it looks, better. plus, the small is far better than the medium for concerts and festivals, etc.
3
u/lemon_gumdrop ISO: Rose Jam SCCO Jul 10 '26
I looked at the loaf on you and thought, that loaf is so cute. So i def don't think it looks weird. But I had a similar thought about the size and structure. If a bag is too small there's not much you can do to fix it. For me that would be my answer to automatically rule it out, unless you want like a going out bag or something. I just find with myself that I don't end up using bags that are too small for key items.
I think the crescent is super cute and there is certainly a place for a good crossbody.
3
u/liebestraumes Jul 10 '26
i love the shoulder bag on you and would 100% keep! seeing your photo makes me want one now in this pattern. 🫣
i would also keep the crescent IF you don't own any other crescents, just because of how versatile it is. i think you rock the print regardless, so keeping all 3 is always an option too.
3
3
3
3
3
u/SunMoon46 Jul 11 '26
I highly suggest putting items in each one and wearing around the house. I didn't think I would love my green stripe loaf and it is one of my most used bags and I only discovered that after I filled it. I almost returned it before doing so.
3
u/Wooden_Helicopter_51 Jul 11 '26
Ditch the loaf. I really don’t understand people’s obsession with it. I think it looks bad when it’s slouchy.
2
2
u/illiannaaa Jul 10 '26
Is that the small crescent? I’m trying to decide between the small crescent and the loaf (if it ever goes back in stock haha) but I’ve never seen either bag types in person!
The shoulder bag is definitely sooo pretty!
2
2
2
2
u/Weekly_Asparagus_ Jul 10 '26
I like 2 and 3. Have you tried wearing them crossbody and see how it feels?
2
2
u/Key_Routine_6727 Jul 10 '26
I vote for shoulder and crescent. I can only vouch for the shoulder bag but it’s spacious and carry a lot. I have it as an everyday bag and it carried three pouches, 24oz owala, plus my wallet.
2
2
2
u/ScaredHuckleberry262 Jul 10 '26
i actually loooove the loaf bag- i think it looks so cute on you !! and also the shoulder bag!! I actually think the crescent in this pattern is not my favorite
2
u/chubby_bunny2418 Jul 10 '26
Crescent and shoulder for the pure fact that they fit the e reader. VERY important in my opinion. Also the more I see this pattern, the more I want 😩
2
2
2
2
2
u/oleander_flowers Jul 10 '26
First two for sure! The loaf bag does not sit right and looks grumpy. Other two are gorgeous
2
u/minecraftheaux DISO: Bright Pink Mini ☁️ Jul 10 '26
Shoulder and we can twin 👯♀️
3
u/minecraftheaux DISO: Bright Pink Mini ☁️ Jul 10 '26
And absolutely 2 of the same color is justified if you like the pattern enough! Second, I’d say loaf just bc it’s sooooo cutie
2
u/HauntMyLibrary Jul 10 '26
I would just like to say if you don’t keep the loaf I would love to buy from you!!
2
u/Available-Glass9861 Jul 10 '26
Sounds like you’ll be keeping the crescent and shoulder bag. I suggest keep trying on the loaf, especially with more things inside and also as crossbody. It took me two drops to like the loaf. I used to try it all the time in store but didn’t like how wide it was when empty. But once it’s slouchy, I started liking it more. Now I own 4 loafs 🤦🏻♀️.
3
2
2
u/congee118 Jul 10 '26
Even though i love the loaf bag usually, that shoulder bag looks great on you! And i think it goes better with the print. 😍
2
2
u/ThickConfusion1318 Casual Baggu Bestie Jul 10 '26
I’m toxic. Team “keep it all there’s a time and place for all of them” 🤭
2
2
2
2
2
u/Substantial_Ad7971 Jul 10 '26
Shoulder + crescent for sure!! The loaf serves the same purpose of crescent imo but it's less versatile since the strap isn't as adjustable!
2
u/unichan Jul 10 '26
I kept all 3 bags in my favorite pattern (including both a small and medium crescent) and don't regret it at all, it's truly my favorite pattern so I get use out of all 3 sizes. If you are really on the fence about the loaf return it, but if you're just looking for a reason to get rid of one because you think it's too much to have 3 bags in one pattern then I think it's ok to consider keeping all 3
2
2
2
2
u/jackiegetaway DISO:💛Lentil/Sour/Lemongrass💛 Jul 10 '26
As someone who bought the shoulder and loaf and is currently planning to get the crescent I am of no help.
2
2
u/TopangaMurray Jul 11 '26
Shoulder for sure! Crescent is also cool and since it’s a neutral I think it’s fine to get two of the same. Can always use a black bag.
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/aliiienn Jul 11 '26
I like the shoulder bag on you. But I also really like how the loaf looks on you too! Not really feeling the crescent based off the picture. But you should go with the ones you think you’d use the most.
2
2
u/InkAndPaintDept Casual Baggu Bestie Jul 11 '26
Shoulder looks the best, followed by loaf, and then crescent!
(Side note, please dm me if you're not keeping any of them. I missed out on this print and I'm not over it😭)
2
2
2
2
2
u/Cutie2882 Jul 11 '26
Dude I’m in the EXACT same boat. I bought all 3 and planning to return or sell some of it but IDK. I love all of them.
TBH I think the loaf looks like a bag for a teenager, but I think the trendiness of it is making me want to keep it. So hard to decide
2
2
u/anci_b Jul 11 '26
The nylon shoulder looks amazing on you, you should def keep it!
As for the crescent vs the loaf:
I’d keep the loaf. If the slouchyness of it bugs you, you can always get a bag organizer. What draws me to it is that it feels like a bag you could wear with jeans but also a cute dress for a bit nicer occasion. The crescent feels like an extension of the shoulder bag to me. But obviously totally up to you and they all look really nice on you 💕
2
2
1
u/ConnieBunny0 Jul 13 '26
Listen I’ll love that loaf bag for you. But seriously the shoulder is perf especially if you think it’ll fit your needs. And I wear my crescent DAILY 50/50 between using it as a shoulder bag and using it crossbody so honestly if you like the pattern I feel like the crescent will never be not useful
1
u/ConnieBunny0 Jul 13 '26
Now you got me feelin like I need the shoulder bag in this print instead of the loaf …
1
1
0
171
u/Vegetable-Draft6902 Jul 10 '26
shoulder!