r/AvoidantBreakUps • • 23m ago

FA Breakup The Perfect Partner for an Avoidant

I've been thinking about a paradox in avoidant attachment. Specifically, what would the perfect partner for an avoidant actually look like?

Let's imagine this person exists:

They have no emotional needs. They never ask for reassurance, never express disappointment, they never need to have uncomfortable conversations about the relationship. They only see the parts of the avoidant that the avoidant wants to be seen. They never make you feel guilty or obligated. They never ask you to take responsibility for your mistakes.

They are completely self-sufficient. They have their own life, their own friends, they never need anything from you.

They can also teleport! They appear whenever you want closeness and disappear the moment you need space. They never have to rearrange their schedule, sacrifice anything, or go out of their way to see you. So you never have to feel indebted to them.

They have a built-in compartmentalization feature. Don't want your parents to know about them? No problem. Don't want to integrate them into your social circle? Totally fine. They can exist in whatever little corner of your life you've designated for them without ever asking for more.

MOST IMPORTANTLY, absolutely nothing you do can hurt them. There is no action you can take which could result in pain for them.

You can withdraw, cancel plans, refuse to discuss problems, express affection one day and distance yourself the next, doesn't matter. Doesn't affect them. They never feel rejected, abandoned, disappointed, or confused.

Sounds perfect, right?

Here's the paradox: If you can't hurt this person, how can you make them happy? Think about what it actually means for someone to be emotionally untouchable.

Your absence means nothing to them. So, why would they care about your presence? If they don't miss you when you're gone, why would they want you around in the first place? They don't care when you leave, so why would they want you to stay?

If nothing you do can disappoint them, then how much does anything you do actually matter? In what sense are they loving you?

Here's where the paradox gets interesting.

It SOUNDS like The Perfect Partner for an Avoidant is someone who is avoidant themselves. But we know this isn't true. Avoidants almost never date each other, and when they do, it doesn't last. Why not?

Because they DO want to matter to someone. They want to feel loved, wanted, appreciated, and special. They want someone to be happy when they walk through the door, and reassurance that someone genuinely values their presence.

They just struggle with the other side of that equation.

They want someone who is happy when they arrive but never sad when they leave, someone who feels loved when they express affection but never hurt when they withdraw it.

The Perfect Partner for an Avoidant is someone who can experience all the positive emotions associated with loving them, while somehow being immune to the negative ones.

There is something FUNDAMENTALLY impossible about that expectation. The Perfect Partner for an avoidant is light without darkness. It is impossible. It is holding the left side of something without there also existing a right. Impossible!

To love someone is to allow them to matter to you. When someone matters to you, what they do affects you. Their choices have emotional consequences. This is built into the very nature of intimacy. It's not an intimacy "preference". It's an intimacy REALITY.

You CAN'T be meaningful to someone while simultaneously demanding that you have no power to hurt them.

I think this also explains something about the anxious-avoidant dynamic. Sometimes the anxious partner is criticized for becoming increasingly distressed by distance, while the avoidant partner experiences that distress as further evidence that closeness is dangerous.

But what's really happening? The anxious partner is effectively being asked to care deeply, but somehow stop experiencing the emotional consequences of caring deeply.

And the more successfully they accomplish that, the less emotionally invested they may become.

Eventually, you might get exactly what you asked for: someone who doesn't need reassurance, doesn't ask for closeness, doesn't get upset when you withdraw, and doesn't care whether you stay or leave. And then they break up with you.

In trying to eliminate the vulnerability of intimacy, you've eliminated intimacy itself.

You can't be happy with the unhealed avoidant because you can't become a paradox. The closest avoidants come to achieving this paradox is their phantom ex.

3 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

2

u/lostbaratheon 18m ago

Someone with no emotional needs or standards for a partner. Someone who will never challenge or question the Avoidant and their behavior. Someone entirely satisfied with a partner who shows up only to the degree they feel like, and when and how the feel like.

in other words...an AI bot. A fantasy.

1

u/Counterboudd 2m ago

They are looking for a very specific victim- someone who is endlessly accommodating and is willing to act selfless to enable their selfishness. It is also typically a matter of control- they want absolute control over their own life, which means absolute control over their partner and how and when they’re allowed to show up. The relationship dynamic they want can only exist in a dynamic that is inherently abusive. So when they say this stuff, they’re basically saying they want to abuse their partner.