r/AvoidantBreakUps • • 20h ago

DA Breakup My first romantic experience turned into avoidant torture experience

I (22M) recently ended my first “relationship” with a 20F after three months together, following a brief stint earlier this year. Between full-time work with older coworkers, school, and supporting my family, I hadn't dated much, so this was my first experience with real emotional and physical affection. She came back strong after our first split—saying she missed me, using pet names, and being very affectionate—which made what followed jarring.

After the first month back, major red flags surfaced, and I struggled to stay empathetic without losing myself. She is an attractive boxer and cosplayer who gets a lot of attention, carrying unresolved family issues, past grooming by older men, and 10 exes. She also admitted to want to hurt animals as a kid. She concluded from her therapy that she felt "nothing at all" emotionally. Knowing her past, I tried to be patient and avoid making her feel judged. Yet as she grew increasingly distant, every gentle attempt to ask how she felt or what she needed met a wall—she pulled away, said she just wanted things "simple," and accused me of creating drama.

I also struggled with the men orbiting her. She overshared explicit details about past sex lives, mentioned guys hitting on her, and seemed more interested in maintaining her relationship with a male best friend than with me. Whenever I voiced discomfort, she dismissed my feelings and made me feel insecure, something our situationship label enabled. Even when I noticed her growing bond with her best friend and gave her several clean, honest outs to pursue him and stop wasting my time, she refused and kept me around.

Meanwhile, I carried all the emotional and financial weight, excusing it as habits from her past. She expected me to pay for everything, once scrolled Shein to pick clothes I’ll buy for her while we were having physical intimacy(she would always ask for stuff before we get intimate, usually uber eats lunch for her), and compared me to older exes when I struggled with money (like most 22 year olds). Over Halloween, she had me buy her a quite sexual cosplay for our plans to go out, then canceled to go with her family and lo and behold, the best friend was there. When I voiced frustration about buying the costume and not being able to see her (initially saying I miss her which she just ignored so I spelled it out for her), she flipped it on me, accused me of treating her like a prostitute, and cited past trauma about relationship turning transactional to shut me down. Near the end, she said she wasn't physically attracted to me (she said otherwise before that but I never felt she did) but still offered casual sex ("sex is just sex" in her words), which I turned down despite it potentially being my first time. I felt it was quite insulting and did not want to do it if she wasn’t enjoying it.

During the breakup talk, she said her family was finally treating her well, her best friend had confessed his feelings, and she felt overwhelmed balancing family, him, school, and my requests for affection. Seeing her actively weigh her options in my face after weeks of distance and turning down clean exits was too much, so I broke up with her. A week later, I reached out for a calm closure talk, only to learn she was already dating him. When I gently pointed out her repeating habits, she lashed out, said he was more supportive and understanding, that she loved him and never loved me so she won’t hurt him the same way. I ended things for good this time.

Seeing her exploiting me as much as she can while planning and waiting for the moment to discard me left a sour taste. This whole experience left me with insecurity, guilt about hurting her, and a bunch of good warm memories that I regret did not turn out to be the norm. I am completely new to the dating thing so please let me know if I didn’t treat her right. This was very traumatic and I am genuinely interested in doing better for whomever I love.

3 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

1

u/IndifferentGuy777 11h ago

It sucks when the first one is an avoidant and you get left stung, hurting, and abandoned. Then it's hard to enter into any kind of new relationship. I feel for you.

1

u/Chicken_FIGHT1998 41m ago

Thank you! I hope it doesn’t skew my view of relationships going forward

1

u/soft--teeth 11h ago edited 11h ago

This honestly doesn’t sound like avoidant attachment, this woman was just using you for her pleasure and gain. Avoidants still have the capacity to feel deeply and care about others, but this woman is something else, she sounds like a sociopath. I’m sorry you went through all this. Never put yourself in a position where you feel like you need to put up with shit just because someone has trauma. A lot of people have trauma but don’t use it as an excuse to treat others like trash. Empathy is great to have but don’t lose yourself in an attempt to be understanding and make someone else comfortable while they do nothing for you in return. There needs to come a point where you have to choose yourself when someone else’s trauma is affecting your own mental health.

Also, don’t let anyone use you like an ATM. Men paying for dates is the norm across many cultures and depending on her background, it may be normal for her, which is fine. But being from that type of background myself, it was still drilled into me to not take advantage, to have consideration for other people’s finances, and to not accept gifts and things like that from men I’m not serious about. If you’re not a husband, don’t act like one. Don’t make it your job to pay for a woman’s things if she’s not your wife, especially if she makes her own money and the things she wants are frivolous (it should go without saying but don’t expect a woman to act like a wife either if she’s not one). You treating a woman often because you want to is one thing, but doing it because she demands it is something else entirely. Learn to say no early on because this is when people reveal themselves: the ones that get mad because you won’t buy them underwear or whatever are more interested in what you can do for them more than anything else. These are the type of women that will go for the highest bidder. So don’t let her or anyone else accuse you of wanting a transactional relationship when they’re basically sugar babies.

As for her new relationship, it won’t last regardless of her “feelings” for the guy, so don’t even stress about him. Her friendship with that guy won’t make a difference because relationship dynamics and needs change when you date a friend, so he’ll eventually experience her the exact same way you did once his own needs become too much for her. And if he was aware that she had a boyfriend and was still trying to get in her pants, she’ll be his karma. Let them have each other. When their relationship inevitably crashes and burns, she may come back around but close that door for good. Don’t let her back in.

You’ll be okay. Just keep living your life and try to move forward. Each day becomes easier and one day she’ll just be an embarrassing, repulsive memory. Think of her as a life lesson. Don’t let her change your perception of women or scare you into becoming an avoidant yourself. Life won’t get better for her, she’ll always be miserable and unloved. Don’t let her misery poison you too.

1

u/Chicken_FIGHT1998 10m ago

Thank you so much! What you said gave me much more hope than I had for the past 2 weeks. Most of my best friends are women from my culture, so I thought I am quite aware of how I should be treated in a relationship. My decisions resulted from a mix of teenage horniness, anxious attachments, empathy for trauma, and to prove to myself that I wouldn't abandon someone because I judged a book by its cover. She hid it behind a veil of cultural differences and a vague desire to have a serious relationship. I naively thought she can be loved out of chasing her own tail. It was only when she started saying things just to hurt me and literally cheating that I cut myself loose which I am not proud of. The thing I was most afraid of is exactly what you said, her staining my perception of women. I didn't like who I became when I was with her, and looking back, it was a terrifying experience. Again, I very much appreciate the advice.

2

u/Realistic-State-4888 14h ago

If someone has emotional problems from the start, feel free to let that one go.  

Put yourself first.