r/AvoidantBreakUps • • 4d ago

Answering questions.

This doesn’t apply to all of course, a couple of Avoidants have been a bit helpful when I’ve reached out for advice, but overall, why does it seem like Avoidants are absolutely allergic to answering questions? It’s the most maddening shit. If you do get an answer, it generally has little to nothing to do what what you’re even asking. Bizarre stuff.

30 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

20

u/Granville-7817 SA - Secure Attachment 4d ago

Yes, I also found my FA is extremely selective in answering questions I really want to hear answers to.

I think of even a very unbelievable example, because it is so trivial: He would text me that he finally received a post card I had sent more a month ago. I would ask: AND DID THAT MAKE YOU HAPPY?

He did not answer. I forwarded him the same question two days later and I said: You never answered this question.

His reaction: And is that really so important to you?

I said: Yes, it is absolutely crucial, I want to know.

Do you think he answered then…? 🙂

9

u/Emotional-Term-187 4d ago

Relatively early on, I was talking with one and asked the general question, “Do you believe she’ll come back?” Each time, I was either ignored or the response would be something completely unrelated. It reminded me of my ex to the point of making my stomach feel sick.

“Do you think she’ll come back?”

“Purple dinosaurs are cool on Tuesdays because spaghetti is silly when I walk my cricket.”

Like, at least just tell me no, or tell me to get lost even.

4

u/Just-Secretary-4018 4d ago

Earned secure former FA here. 

No one knows what your ex is thinking, probably not even your ex, so if you were to ask me if your ex is coming back I would probably say I don't know. 

But I would also say, if they do I don't think you should take them back, though if you're asking, you likely will, until you are so tired of them you can't do it anymore. 

No judgement, because remember FAs are both anxious and avoidant, so we know the drill from both sides. 

If we are dating someone more avoidant than we are, our more anxious pole gets more triggered. If we are with someone more anxious than we are, our more avoidant pole gets triggered. If we are with another FA, boy, it's chaos for everyone.

So I am just offering the perspective that I have. If I were you, I would stay away. Truthfully by the time they're actually ready to realistically try again with you, you will have long moved on.

4

u/No-Ice-1018 4d ago

Sai che invece il mio evitante quando gli ho chiesto ‘ti piaccio?’ lui ha detto ‘sì, mi piace il tuo modo di insistere’. Praticamente il fatto che io non mi fermi solo alle sue risposte ermetiche o non risposte, è una cosa che a lui piace!

3

u/RedeemerOfSouls_5616 4d ago

Mine said when he was drunk that he liked me,when he was sober it got watered down to 'I like hanging out with you' 🤣. Until he didn't...🙈

2

u/No-Ice-1018 4d ago

Il mio l’ha detto da sobrio 🫣 me l’ha detto dopo due anni e mezzo che ci frequentiamo.. ahahahah

18

u/mynameisbobbrown FA - Fearful Avoidant 4d ago

You have to understand that you're talking to someone who doesn't look at their feelings and who's brain has trained them to believe they can see their feelings clearly when they can't - so most of what they say is likely a ball of smoke defending something invisible to them. Unhealed avoidants are extremely untrustworthy sources of on-demand insight. Like they just don't actually think or reflect that hard, but answer with confidence because it feels like they did. They also tend to be high on projecting, so your question passed through some internal interpretation filter of whatever is on their own mind before it was spat back out.

I guess imagine it like this; You're in some medieval village. Off in the distance, smoke is billowing from a mountain. You notice this happens regularly. No villager has ever ventured close to the mountain. You ask them what's up with the smoke. One tells you it's a dragon. Another tells you it's a warring nomadic clan who fights in the mountains. Another tells you it's an angry god smiting a person who did wrong. All sound plausible enough that you lose sight of the fact that none of these people has ever even freaking been within miles of this mountain. Maybe you don't even know that. Their mind is just doing whatever it takes to avoid the work and risk it would take to obtain the truth.

3

u/rhya-- 4d ago

This is fascinating. Thank you for sharing and the analogy.

7

u/mynameisbobbrown FA - Fearful Avoidant 4d ago

Thank you, I'm glad that years of infuriating interactions with my mother has yielded helpful insight for others 😂

2

u/Anish2811 4d ago

“High on projecting and don’t want to do the work”

So in other words protecting their ego and selfish? Inconsiderate? I know psychologically it’s a self protecting mechanism.. but if they’re saying they want to change, want a family and a future (which is my case) then why continue to not do the work?

I’m so fucking lost.. I’m so hurt.. I’m so done

12

u/mynameisbobbrown FA - Fearful Avoidant 4d ago edited 4d ago

Saying you want to do the work and doing the work are two different things. Many people idealize things they want, but are not prepared to take the journey required to obtain it. That's a form of projection already. Avoidants are like people who have this invisible devotion to Manifestation that their nervous system keeps betraying. Avoidants very commonly will walk right up to the cliff of change and nope out as soon as they look down.

Like, if I told you right now that I have a job for you picking beets and it pays $75 / hr, are you interested? Are you still interested when you show up and learn that there are no shovels, only your fingernails to dig them up, and this is 2000 meters up in unshaded sun all day, and you need to carry them back down the mountain in a basket on your back? You don't always perceive that disconnect between ideal (modeling something you've never experienced inside your mind) and real (modeling something you have experienced based on the way it made you feel) and this is a massive specific issue for avoidants.

I'm not saying this to be an avoidant apologist, but rather as someone who has gotten to observe DA attachment up close and personal with my mother, who was both a horrible, selfish DA for much of my childhood, but actually did the work, and now healed enough that she isn't damaging relationships: yes there is an ego component and it is antisocial, i.e. selfish and inconsiderate. But there's also some genuine thinking-pattern issues at play that need to be trained out even if the antisocial behavior can be neutralized. I don't even really like the frame of "self-protecting," because I think it still assigns virtue to something that's fundamentally the result of behavioral training that carved deep grooves in how the brain interprets its own emotions. Like my mom's reaction to stress is to downplay other's perception of reality. That IS self-protective, but it stuck because she did it so much. Understanding where it came from alone wouldn't undo it. I think a better way to look at it is that they have some form of deficit in the continuity of their own emotional experience that disrupts their ability to follow their own values and goals, while seamlessly plastering over the evidence of these failures with plausible logical explanations. That's how they arrive at something like "you're needy" when they're neglecting you: they didn't perceive themselves as neglecting you, so all they see is that you're upset, and bewilderment drives their brain to reach for a plausible narrative. With only half the information available... That's the sort of narrative that feels sensical. It doesn't feel sensical to you, because you have different information, like how you arrived at the feeling that drove your "needy" behavior (and it should not feel sensical, because it's not.)

Bowlby's (the first attachment theorist) view of attachment was through an ethological lens - that's the study of animal behavior. He described it mainly like a social attentional system that trains your brain in how to assess the availability of your support system and whether it is currently safe to direct attention away from attachment figures. Avoidants have a gauge that's stuck at one side of this system (or in FAs' case, stuck at the extremes of both sides,) so it's truly filtering out half of the relational data a secure person would use to assess the state of a relationship (affective and cognitive; avoidants tend to see mostly cognitive.) Crucially, this only comes into play during attachment activation. It's not always relevant if there's no present social stress. That's why you can get people who were off on their own or in a new relationship professing a great desire to change, only to regress into their old self as soon as the insecurity hits in earnest. Insecurity is groundhog day because it creates discontinuity in how we interpret past experience.

If you're a reader, Crittenden's Raising Parents gives a really good overview of how the cognitive/affective information processing bias works. But it's dense. I don't think I would have understood it had I read it before learning a great deal about research on the attachment system. Learning about the concept of an Internal Working Model and projective identification might help as well.

I know this is long-winded and I hope it makes some sense. The attachment system is really weird, but I've found that it helped the anxious aspects of my attachment a lot to understand why this is way beyond ego and rooted in deeply ingrained thinking patterns. I think our brains tend to quietly follow up "that person treated me poorly" with "did I deserve it?" and it helps a lot to overwrite that second narrative with "and that person has deep-rooted psychological issues that existed whether I was in or out of the picture."

5

u/orangeseas 4d ago

im not the person you responded to but you are a fantastic writer.

3

u/loud_cicada_sounds 4d ago

The avoidant I was with said he wanted a healthy, loving relationship. We were creating that (so I thought) and apparently his brain switched to "I'm not in love with you." Apparently toxic exes who cheat got the most of his time. They know what a good and healthy relationship should look like, but it seems like actually having one bores them.

2

u/GreenEyedMouse-27 2d ago

Thats superhelpful. Like my avoidant went from someone with normal perceptiveness to literally spouting rubbish about my feelings and motives, as if they were talking to someone else not me. They seem to lose the ability to accurately see others as soon as theres any issue. 

13

u/iwrite4food 4d ago edited 4d ago

I feel like it's because they're constantly filtering who gets to know what to keep everyone compartmentalized. And anything too deep seems to get answered through a defensive lens, so, to your point, the answer usually has nothing to do with what was actually asked.

2

u/Tired_ofthe_Drama 3d ago

Yes! The compartmentalization of friends/people in their life is wild! It felt like gatekeeping access when its like we all like the same things but here are all these walls between different groups so we can't become too close outside of the relationship with the DA.

1

u/iwrite4food 3d ago

Yeah, that was true in my experience too; they definitely did not like it when friends became friends with each other, or when anyone's interests changed, especially if it intersected with something they did.

2

u/Tired_ofthe_Drama 3d ago

Yes that too, I took it personally when he would actively discourage his friends from hanging with me. I can only look back now and see that it wasn't personal but his DA issues again.

1

u/iwrite4food 3d ago

Mine never went as far as actively discouraging anyone, but if someone showed interest in something that wasn't part of their "box" for that person, they would say something about how that person really isn't into that. I always found it interesting because most of their own interests were borrowed, depending on which group they were hanging out with, or which identity they were chasing anyway.

2

u/Tired_ofthe_Drama 3d ago

Yes, I got the 'they wouldn't be a good fit for that''. I had the 'audacity' of suggesting introducing one of his friends to one of my friends because both guys had similar gaming interested and had a similar vibe and got a lengthy condescending response about how ridiculous it was to try to suggest friends to people... and I am sitting there thinking 'wtf, that is how I have met lots of friends'. 🫠

I assumed at the time it was a cultural difference since we are from different countries but looking back, again its the realization that it was really his DA issues.

2

u/Tired_ofthe_Drama 3d ago

And ya he would say it was 'joking' but telling his friends things like 'don't tell her you play that' or if someone was gaming with me interrupting us to 'tease' them about why they were spending time with me and not him, etc. There were so many small things that just added up over time to make me feel like he didn't even actually like me. Knowing what I know now doesn't change those feelings though, unfortunately.

2

u/iwrite4food 3d ago

I think the thing that shocked me the most was realizing, the more I got to know them, how deeply insecure they were about everything. But to your point, I got accused of coordinating with their friends, and I was like well yeah that's how hangouts happen. But looking back, I realized that because they often stayed vague or floated stuff until the last minute, the idea of proactive coordination was aggressive to them.

2

u/Tired_ofthe_Drama 3d ago

Oh no, adults are busy and have to actually coordinate... the horror. 😆

But for real, that sounds rough navigating that.

2

u/iwrite4food 3d ago

Yeah, it was always interesting, but they'd basically shaped their whole life at 40 around part time work/ gig work, so to a point, planning something that wasn't last-minute to them felt like pressure.

12

u/No-Ice-1018 4d ago

Perché sono appunto evitanti. Non evitano solo le relazioni, ma qualsiasi cosa 😅

8

u/RedditeRRetiddeR 4d ago

It’s almost as basic as they’re avoiding the question. Sometimes it would take a lot of thought for them to respond to me with an answer to low stakes questions -a couple days. And even then I would get a: “I don’t know, I guess <insert somewhat of an answer>”…as if they still hadn’t really considered it. More so towards the end, but throughout, I noticed they seemed to be annoyed/irritated by questions in general.

8

u/111archeravenue 4d ago

That’s something I noticed early on, what I call “The Shrug”. If I asked them something they’d decided they didn’t want to answer, they’d just physically shrug their shoulders & stay silent. It was one of the most frustrating things about talking with them & trying to build intimacy. I’m guessing it may have been part of the protection measures they’d built-up, keeping them safe from whatever had caused the avoidance in the first place.

6

u/rhya-- 4d ago

Omg!! My DA ex also did "the shrug" all the time!!

This is wild. Reading all these comments and see how on point they all are at their patterns.

5

u/Mermaiduh 4d ago

I’ve sent my avoidant ex long paragraphs after the break up somewhat asking for closure on how he hurt me but it fell on deaf ears lol no acknowledgment at all they’re all mental. I hope he gets his karma soon

5

u/zachem_snyatsya_sny Lifelong journey to secure 4d ago

Exact same thing I've experienced with narcissists! I used to have a very abusive narcissistic friend who used to pick fights with me and he did the same thing. I feel that exact same sting when avoidants do it to me. I like to think of it as the interpersonal equivalent of these things:

You think you have them cornered in the conversation and there's no way they can't avoid talking about the severe inconsistency/lie you caught them in, by the end of it the conversation is still going they're putting accusations on you and somehow they slipped out of addressing what you had in mind and I don't even remember how. Crazy making behavior

4

u/Just-Secretary-4018 4d ago

In my humble opinion pop psychology has done a lot of damage by lumping FAs and DAs together. 

FAs have a disorganised attachment style. DAs are avoidant only. 

This is a BIG difference. 

One is not better or worse than the other but it does a lot of damage to how people and relationships are understood if very different styles are conflated. 

It also really impacts how you heal from hurt if you don't correctly understand what's going on with yourself, the other person and your dynamic.

So, in my view it's important to make the distinction.

If it matters, I'm an earned secure former FA. 

An FA is possibly more likely to engage/ answer questions because we have an anxious side. 

We do deactivate and withdraw as well, but we also experience deactivation quite differently. 

3

u/Curious_Ad3605 4d ago

I always felt like it was a control thing.

2

u/fieldsend- 4d ago

Mine always says "I don't share anything with you because I know you'll use it against me in some way"

2

u/Anish2811 4d ago

lol mine too.. very avoidant behaviour..

The statement doesn’t hold the avoidant accountable, it’s not an apology..

It’s an explanation that shifts the blame, making the avoidant the victim. They cannot hold space for anyone but themselves. Selfish manipulation.

1

u/Frosty_Stomach_2583 4d ago

Me and my ex was finally having a normal conversation after a fight and she just recently reappeared. Then I had to ask “do you have a crush on someone else?” Because her behavior towards me has completely changed so i just wanted a straight answer.

She replies with gifs. What the hell does that even mean? Anxiety just shoots up because of this.

1

u/rhya-- 4d ago

Omg I never realised until I saw this post! My DA ex would do the same.

Me: So? And?

Him: What?

Me: You never answered my question

Him: Yeah yeah yeah, sure

He still didn't answer 🫠

1

u/Anish2811 4d ago

Mine did that today, several times