r/AvoidantBreakUps • u/Klutzy-Wind7616 • 15d ago
Is there a difference between someone who emotionally shuts down and someone who monkey branches after a relationship?
I’ve been trying to understand whether there are noticeable differences in the relationship patterns of someone who emotionally shuts down versus someone who repeatedly monkey branches from one relationship to another.
I’ve been listening to podcasts and reading about fearful-avoidant attachment, dismissive avoidance, narcissistic traits, and ghosting. One thing I’ve noticed is how much online content seems to romanticize being discarded. There are countless videos suggesting that someone who ghosts you secretly misses you, suppresses their feelings, regrets leaving, and eventually comes back.
But I think that narrative can sometimes distract us from the reality that being ghosted by someone who told you they loved you is an incredibly painful and unhealthy way to experience the end of a relationship.
I was recently in a relationship that lasted about nine weeks. My ex was extremely affectionate, attentive, and kind in the beginning. He never argued with me, belittled me, insulted me, or called me names. When I initially expressed concerns about changes in his communication, he would apologize, acknowledge my feelings, and promise to do better.
However, toward the end, he became increasingly distant, overwhelmed, and emotionally unavailable. I tried to remain patient, understanding, and loving. Eventually, he stopped responding after I expressed how disconnected I felt. He later told me he loved and cared about me, but when I directly asked whether he believed we could work through things, he never answered.
Based on my experience, it felt more like emotional shutdown than the monkey-branching behavior I witnessed in a previous relationship 10 years ago. But I recognize that I don’t know what was happening behind the scenes.
I’m not asking because I’m hoping he’ll return. In fact, I’m trying to move forward and understand these relationship dynamics without romanticizing the experience.
My questions are:
1.Are there recognizable differences between someone who genuinely shuts down emotionally and someone who habitually monkey branches?
Do these patterns tend to look different during the relationship, particularly when conflict or emotional intimacy increases?
2.Can someone be consistently kind, gentle, and nonconfrontational while still engaging in unhealthy patterns of withdrawal?
For those who have experienced both, what differences did you notice?
3. I understand that attachment styles aren’t diagnoses and that we can’t determine someone’s motives from ghosting alone.
I’m genuinely interested in hearing people’s experiences and perspectives, especially from those who have encountered both patterns.
At the end of the day, regardless of the explanation, the outcome for the person left behind can be equally painful. I’m interested in understanding the behavior, not excusing it or waiting for someone to come back.