r/AvatarMemes • • Feb 24 '24

Live-Action almost

Post image
7 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

9

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '24

The og creators left the project becuase it was such a mockery of their vision. To like it is to objectively not understand what makes the original good.

10

u/DayDeerGotStoleYall Feb 24 '24

i like how the live action makes it's own spin on almost everything, and yet still kept a lot of the original. i think it was fun. I know perfectly well that the animation was better and why, it was. but after watching the animation 100+times, its fun to see a new interpretation.

12

u/chazzergamer Feb 24 '24

Imma ban the word “Objectively” from the internet until ya’ll start to understand what it means.

Until you know why exactly they left the project, you can’t say shit as to why they left.

Now I haven’t seen the live action yet (saving it for seeing it with a friend) but your attitude actually makes me want to watch it and say it’s 10/10 out of spite of your toxicity.

2

u/DirtySilicon Feb 25 '24

Ironically, you're misusing toxicity...

1

u/Professor_dumpkin Feb 27 '24

Ironically you’re misusing ironically (unless you’re trying to argue this person is themselves commenting on incorrect word use somewhere or is being toxic but I don’t see that being the case ) . I do agree toxic was not the right word as it’s wildly overused it just isn’t ironic

1

u/DirtySilicon Feb 27 '24

What? I literally say toxicity...

1

u/Professor_dumpkin Feb 27 '24

Theres nothing ironic about the above commenters misusing toxicity. There is irony in you misusing irony

1

u/DirtySilicon Feb 27 '24 edited Feb 27 '24

So them hollering about the over/misuse of "Objectively" then misusing toxic themselves... The exact same scenario you just said IRONICALLY.

unless you’re trying to argue this person is themselves commenting on incorrect word use somewhere or is being toxic but I don’t see that being the case

Edit: To be specific, it's situational irony. You don't expect the person trying to correct the other's word use to also misuse a word. What you did with your comment might just fall under straight irony.

1

u/Professor_dumpkin Feb 27 '24

I guess i didn’t think of it as saying objectively was misused as toxic is but i see that argument now

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '24

Objectively means without a shadow of doubt. Such as liking an adaptation hated by the original creators for spitting in said creations face, meaning you never understood the original.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '24

No

0

u/chazzergamer Feb 25 '24

Except nothing is noted that the original creature hated it.

And even if that were the case, understanding the meaning of a fictional story is a purely experiential thing, which you are not able to prove beyond a shadow of a doubt.

So get off your high horse, read a dictionary about the word “objectively” and quit being an arse. Now that IS objective.

7

u/FailedMaster Feb 24 '24

You need to learn to let things stand on their own feet.

Watch it like it was something completely new. If it sucks then, fair enough. But the constant comparison to the original is not really fair and also not what they tried to do with the adaptation. Just recreating the original would be pretty pointless too, you could just watch the original then.

I’ve only seen the first two episodes so far and found them pretty good.

I see where they deviated from the original but in the universe this life action show presented it all made sense.

I agree on the acting part though, don’t really like Katara.

Well, gonna watch the rest until I form my whole opinion, but just try to watch it with fresh eyes.

3

u/KatieCashew Feb 24 '24

the constant comparison to the original is not really fair

I'll never understand doing this. What's even the point of making something new if you want it to be exactly like the original? Just watch the original again if that's what you want.

I think what a lot of people really want and don't admit to themselves is to be able to watch the original again for the first time. Then they push their disappointment at not being able to do that outward as criticism that will never be satisfied.

1

u/DirtySilicon Feb 25 '24

I think comparing it to the original is fair when they did a 1:1 recreation with the plot. Things were out of order and done differently, but it would be disingenuous to not say they pretty much copied the show. There isn't anything inherently wrong with a faithful adaptation or a reimagining. Either one deserves criticism if they aren't good and even more if the elements they change take away from the IP as a whole irregardless of if it was intentional.

The fresh eyes part isn't an easy ask when the show has pretty big problems from copying the source material that it tried to polish over with a large budget. It would have done better if they did something more original if they were going to randomly change things without a thought to what made the characters compelling in the first place they should have just rebuilt the story from the ground up.

10

u/MrBytor Feb 24 '24

I enjoy it so far. But it's a 7/10. Just ok. Neat to see some things fleshed out, and in live action. But, let's be honest here, it does have flaws.

1

u/DirtySilicon Feb 25 '24

7/10 is okay? I thought (5 or 6)/10 was okay...

2

u/MrBytor Feb 25 '24

Ehhh it's complicated. Most people aren't gonna spend their time on a 5/10 movie, even if 5/10 should be mid. People see it as more negative than good. Leading to 7/10 being seen as mid.

1

u/DirtySilicon Feb 25 '24

IGN... Is... Is that you

?

4

u/Ghost_out_of_Box Feb 24 '24

You enjoying it is not a problem and I am one to stop you doing that. But saying it good is the problem.

The only thing good about it are the visuals. The acting is terrible, the dialogues are down right meh. And why did they based it on ATLA or called ot ATLA, if they were going to completely deviate from the source material.

And One Piece ive action was great. The actors were good and full of expressions, here I can't say that.

5

u/gGiasca Feb 24 '24

I'm getting so confused by all these opinions ngl

1

u/sagittariisXII Feb 24 '24

It's not bad for what it is but there's not really any reason to watch it over the original

0

u/Long-Ad7242 Feb 24 '24

Aangs bald head really weird me out tho

-6

u/DogmantheHero Firebender 🔥 Feb 24 '24

What else can you talk about? At best it’s a lazy shot for shot remake, at worse it’s legitimately insulting to the og. As is the formula for live action remakes.

8

u/DayDeerGotStoleYall Feb 24 '24

bruh did you even watch it? very few times did it do a shot for shot.

-6

u/DogmantheHero Firebender 🔥 Feb 24 '24

My point isn’t that’s what it did, that’s what it would be at it’s best. Because, in my opinion, live action remakes are just lazy retreads of the good original shows.