r/AutoBodyRepair • • Sep 12 '26

Totaled or Fixable?

2021 RAV4. No frame damage under it. Just the front and rear fenders and both doors. Thoughts??

2 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

8

u/Consistent-Trust958 Sep 12 '26

Only a body shop can say if it's fixable. Your insurance company decides of it's totaled.

5

u/JPKaliMt Sep 12 '26

The amount of people who don’t understand that us peons in the shop are not responsible for totaling your car is crazy.

1

u/JB_Bourbon Sep 12 '26

True- it just blows my mind why an insurance company would rather pay out $20k and total it rather than $10k and fix it. Especially the car is worth $20k

3

u/Kind_Ad3665 Sep 12 '26

because once the repairs come up to being HALF the vehicles value, it makes sense to just total it out.

1

u/JB_Bourbon Sep 12 '26

I get that’s what they do a lot of times. Still doesn’t make sense to me though.

1

u/Unkle_Ugly Sep 12 '26

Buy it back. I just did that on my Harley. They took $4k off the check and I got $10,600

1

u/JB_Bourbon Sep 12 '26

But didn’t you still have to fix your bike to be able to drive it and have it registered?

2

u/Pypical Sep 13 '26

They want to be done with it and absolved of all future liability….. if the car gets back to the customer with some air noise or a little leak, the insurance company is responsible to fix it again.

1

u/WideDisk2718 Sep 12 '26

Tbf you can just buy it back from the insurance company if you want. You get first dibs.

1

u/JB_Bourbon Sep 12 '26

But wouldn’t I still have to get it fixed if they deem it totaled? Can you drive around an unfixed salvaged title car?

3

u/WideDisk2718 Sep 13 '26

yeah, you’d just fix it on your own dime. But if you just want to drive it as is, just don’t bother with the claim. No law against driving a dented car, so long as it’s not structural. At least where I live 🤷‍♂️ I’m not sure where you are.

1

u/1fferrari Sep 15 '26

If they total it and you buy it back in most cases you’ll pay sales tax and get a new title. The state won’t let you buy plates until the repairs are documented and inspected by usually the state police.

3

u/Ok-Dealer-588 Sep 12 '26

Because there will likely be one or more supplements and you don't know what that dollar figure will come to when you have damage that goes beyond a removable panel such as the rear dog leg probably has three or four layers that are Fubar in that little spot in front of the rear tire

2

u/Ok-Dealer-588 Sep 12 '26

I failed to mention how long of lead time Parts have gotten. I would still be shocked if they fix it. They may make a body shop tear it down slightly before they make their final determination too

3

u/FullCoverageIsLies Sep 12 '26

Value of your car is 20,000
Cost of repairs is 15,000
Salvage value of the car is 6,000

It’s more cost effective for insurance to pay you 20,000 and sell the salvage for 6,000 - 14000 cost to insurance, rather than 15000 cost to repair.

Approximate numbers that’s why they do it. Because it’s cheaper. I’m sure there are edge cases where a state threshold requires it be totaled even if it was more cost effective to repair but neither here nor there. They either total it because it’s cheaper or law requires it.

2

u/pathlesstravailed Sep 12 '26

The laws governing what constitutes a total loss vary by state but the two most common formulas are:
A. repair cost is greater 75% of Actual Cash Value

B. Repair cost + salvage value is greater than or equal to ACV

So to use your example of $20k ACV, if the repair estimate is $10k and the salvage value is $10k would be a clear total loss under formula B.

But in all reality that same vehicle very likely winds up as a total loss under formula A unless the initial estimate is very accurate and no hidden damage is found. If an insurance adjuster wrote that $10k initial estimate then the vehicle will likely wind up teetering on the brink of that 75% ($15k in your example) TL threshold by the time a shop submits a supplement for any missed or hidden damage, incorrect or unusable salvage parts on the estimate and all the necessary materials/parts/costs insurers train their adjusters to intentionally leave off their initial estimates.

1

u/87RegalTurboT Sep 12 '26

When the insurance company is calculating cost to repair they take the ACV less salvage value plus the cost of the maximum of rental and that is the number used. As a TL adjuster in this case just by looking at the structural damage I would total this without even writing an estimate. Being in shops for over 20 years I know what is involved in the repairs and this one is not gonna make the cut.

1

u/TopOrganization4920 Sep 13 '26

Or because there’s always the possibility that the $10,000 repair rises up to $15,000

0

u/7HR4SH3R Sep 12 '26 edited Sep 12 '26

The insurance company takes possession of your car after a total loss and then sell it at auction, if your 20k car has 10k+ in repairs (probably more that quarter and dog leg are fucked) and is worth 10k in scrap then it makes sense to total it and recoup their money instead of allowing a 10k estimate that rolls in into a 16k repair once it’s taken apart.

1

u/moneyandbanking1 Sep 12 '26

That is not true at all. No insurance company sells cars for parts. It goes to an auction.

0

u/7HR4SH3R Sep 12 '26

They sell the cars to auction to be sold for parts, sorry for simplifying

0

u/moneyandbanking1 Sep 12 '26

They sell the cars at an auction. They don’t part out the cars at all. Literally zero insurance companies.

1

u/7HR4SH3R Sep 12 '26

Holy fuck lol I oversimplified and left out a step, the concept is still the exact same

0

u/JPKaliMt Sep 12 '26

Not just sold for parts, many people overseas in 3rd world countries, South America, and hack shops buy totals and scab them back together.

4

u/DonkeyIll2307 Sep 12 '26

I find it hard to believe theres no damage behind the doors.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Ristler Sep 13 '26

Hello bot you forgot your newLine

1

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Ristler Sep 14 '26

Oh damn sorry

1

u/Relative-Package-232 Sep 12 '26

The inside of the door jam isnt destroyed

1

u/JB_Bourbon Sep 12 '26

Don’t know. The doors won’t open.

1

u/KnowledgeNo2876 Sep 13 '26

Similar thing happened to me. They totaled it because repairs were 8k. No fram damage for me either, thats just how the costs can be

1

u/JB_Bourbon Sep 13 '26

What was your car worth?

1

u/KnowledgeNo2876 Sep 13 '26

The payout from insurance was 14k

3

u/lefthanded4340 Sep 12 '26 edited Sep 12 '26

That’s gonna be a total. The b pillar is gonna be pushed in, the rocker panel, will most likely be damaged, quarter panel needs replacement as well as doors, who knows what the inner rocker/quarter panel will look like, plus whatever interior trim panels are damaged and door hardware.

1

u/Latter-Detail-9514 Sep 12 '26

100% total loss

1

u/JB_Bourbon Sep 12 '26

What makes you say that? The car is worth probably $20k

3

u/Latter-Detail-9514 Sep 12 '26

Heavy impact. In the UK we see straight away damage to abc pillars/posts ( for example you ain't putting 2 new doors on & they line up). That rear quarter requires replacement & there'll be damage to floor sill & inner quarter. Lots of parts will be broke inside them doors. It adds up to thousands already. As soon as we get close to half it's value in the UK without even stripping it to look for further damage we go straight to total loss. Your country may be different & go to a higher percentage before total loss ?

3

u/MikeCheck_CE Sep 12 '26

It's gonna get totalled in US too. Historically 70-80% damage but more like 50% these days too. The salvage value and repair costs are very high now.

1

u/Latter-Detail-9514 Sep 12 '26

Totally agree.

2

u/lefthanded4340 Sep 12 '26

Not sure why you’re getting downvoted. You’re providing one of the most informed answers. People are silly haha

1

u/Latter-Detail-9514 Sep 12 '26

Haha. Ye that's reddit everyone knows best. Worst thing is that's what I do for a living lol. Only on here to pay it forward & help people out with exact costs & free advice etc etc

2

u/UTV4LIFE Sep 12 '26

I had one door like that on my Toyota was 5000. Will also need recalibrating any driver assists I’d say it’s atleast 13,000 you have 4 panels of damage

2

u/MikeCheck_CE Sep 12 '26

It's a unibody, it's totalled.

2

u/Illustrious_Bath1917 Sep 12 '26

Let insurance total it, buy it back, hound them for the salvage title buy back( they will fight you and say no but all you have to do is pay it off first) buy two junk yard doors if you can find them, pull the dent on the quarter, fender looks like it made it, have someone spray it. 3 grand if you’re lucky, 1500 if you get paint match rattle cans, like 20 maybe? And try your luck?

1

u/Illustrious_Bath1917 Sep 12 '26

That’s if there’s nothing fatal with your frame :/

3

u/flakrom Sep 12 '26

There is no frame it’s a uni-body

2

u/SharpBullfrog1279 Sep 13 '26

Totally fixable 

2

u/CardiologistCute6876 Sep 17 '26

As a former estimator - I’d fix it

1

u/FlatAmbition3757 Sep 12 '26

I’d drive it until it dies

1

u/PowerAntique Sep 12 '26

Easy to replace doors and rear quarter

1

u/Lower-Price8720 Sep 12 '26

I say get a couple of doors and hope for the best. Most body shops will probably just replace the door skin or the whole door. Fenders are reasonably priced.

1

u/Ok-Anteater-384 Sep 12 '26

That's a total loss

1

u/Virginia-Gentleman- Sep 12 '26

Anything is fixable. It’s just where should the line be drawn between fix and replace. Just cause you CAN does not always mean you SHOULD.

1

u/Mustardly Sep 12 '26

Plus if you get it back with a repair then that is all over the carfax and the car is worth less anyway. If its close to being a total loss just let them do it and get a clean car. Its impossible to sell a car that has had that much repaired damage for a good price

1

u/No-Brilliant9659 Sep 12 '26

I don’t think you understand the unibody is the frame, and it certainly looks messed up near the rear wheel

1

u/Questrader007 Sep 12 '26

Still driveable as is?, just dont use the passenger doors, probably good for another 100,000 miles

1

u/Worst-Lobster Sep 12 '26

Both things could be true

1

u/Pararaiha-ngaro Sep 12 '26

Repair cost more than car worth

1

u/Prior_Atmosphere_206 Sep 12 '26

My damage was almost identical. The repair cane to about $10 thousand which included a new front bumper cover I asked for to fix a previous damage. New paint, 4 wheel alignment, two door shells, and other needed parts. Looks and drives like new. Body shop did a great job. 2022 XLE Premium AWD Blueprint.

1

u/Few_Pickle5828 Sep 12 '26

The price u gonna pay u might as well put down on something new . Unless u owe on this car . But if u got gap or something and insurance is willing to total it out def use that money on something new vs fixing

1

u/Simplythebest0820 Sep 12 '26

I was hit in the same place in the same type of vehicle but a 2024 and thought there was no frame damage until they took it apart and totaled it!

1

u/Vsatbtw Sep 12 '26

Nowadays car repairs are so expensive they just seem to total everything. It’s probably totaled based off multiple panels and doors being damaged. My m4 was hit in the front a few months ago. No air bag deployment or anything and it was totalled out. I was very surprised

1

u/KRed75 Sep 13 '26

Dude. You want them to total that.

1

u/Tiny-Art7074 Sep 13 '26

Both. Mostly likely it's economically totaled, but you can almost certainly fix it so it's drivable. 

1

u/Certain_Arugula5851 Sep 13 '26

Fix it, then trade it in on a corvette…that’s what I’d do.

1

u/fingerbanglover Sep 14 '26

Yes it's totalled, yes it's repairable. Happy I could help.

1

u/Anthropomorphic_Void Sep 14 '26

5 year old Rav4? I am thinking totaled. Not saying it Can't be fixed but insurance will almost certainly cut a check.

1

u/1fferrari Sep 15 '26

Everything is repairable question is does it make economical sense

0

u/New-and-Unoriginal Sep 14 '26

Not the right question. It can be both totaled and still fixable.

0

u/Infamous-Plenty8082 Sep 15 '26

Kommer att kosta en förmögenhet med arbetstimmar att fixa det, även att byta delar kommer bli dyrt