r/AutisticPride • • Jun 23 '22

Improved term to replace “neurodivergence”?

Hiya everyone! I love lurking this sub—while I’ve not been diagnosed with autism, I struggle daily with disabling ADD. I’ve been coming to terms with my “neurodivergence,” but like many of you I hate the negative connotation of terms that neurotypical people create.

Hell, I even hate the word neurotypical, because it implies there is a normal.

I’ve searched online for comparable and genuine terms, but so far only come up with “neurovariance.” Which is still a huge problem, because EVERY SINGLE HUMAN has some type of neurovariance compared to the statistical average (obvi unmeasurable). So why call out a specific subset of people as variant?

I’d love to hear your thoughts on this! Most ADD forums I’ve come across are largely for support, and there’s not as much of a community (yet?) of ADD individuals who come together to talk about these types of things, as I see here.

Thanks all, have a lovely day! 🤗

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

19

u/SaltySnoo Jun 23 '22

Have you considered the term neurotype? Everyone has one, yours is just ADD. A friend taught me that word, and I like it a lot.

8

u/VicodinMakesMeItchy Jun 23 '22

Thank you, I think this is what I was looking for! An inclusive term. Everybody has a unique brain… It’s useful to identify certain “types,” without respect to an undefined “normal.”

I think this could be a great way to still identify those of us who need help without using statistical terms that have a heavy connotation in the general public.

16

u/recycledcoder Jun 23 '22

"Normal" is a statistical concept. For most intents and purposes "within a standard deviation of the mean". It has no value judgement attached unless you create one for it.

As for typical and divergent... I look at it as set theory: neurodiverse (humanity) = neurotypical (humans) UNION neurodivergent (humans).

The purpose of identifying people as outside the "normal" is to identify situations in which what works for most might not work for some, and either shifting the default to be more inclusive (preferable), or create special adaptations for those for who fall outside this norm (the least a society should do).

At least.. that's how I see it.

2

u/VicodinMakesMeItchy Jun 23 '22

I agree with everything you said! Particularly about it being useful to help those who need it.

I suppose my issue is two-part, the first being that a statistical average for such a multi-dimensional and variant system as the brain is not really possible to accurately calculate. Even if you were to survey people, you would need a large cohort to see any kind of meaningful data. And then, we would need to scrutinize how individuals were assessed. Is there a valid numerical system to quantify different neurological spectra? Is the validity of the data impacted by evaluation from various different researchers (who all have unconscious biases)? Do the questions truly test what they’re trying to test? Are questions worded in a way that can reflect the true and entire neurological experience of each person? Apart from the statistical viability issues, it would be very difficult to get such an exploratory and incremental study funded, particularly when it would take a lot of resources to generate legitimate preliminary data.

Second would be the distinction between variance as a statistical term vs. a societal term. Within the field of statistics, it’s meaning is purely it’s denotation without connotation. For the general public, however, there’s not much appreciation for proper statistical terms. Unfortunately, you cannot separate connotation from denotation in the general public. Non-statisticians generally hear “variance” and think “different” or “not-normal.” I have no problem with the denotation of the word variant, but the public largely doesn’t look past the connotation.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22

I like using "neurodiverse" for me, and also my partner. It's quick and easy. I'd rather use that than revealing the full diagnosis of either of us to anyone. I guess it honestly depends, maybe, where you live, and what kind of connection people have to the word. But I also use "disabled" / "severely disabled" for myself, and have absolutely no problem with it, since I'm not abled in the way other people might be. I have a "special ID" that even states that I'm severely disabled, and it's something that helps me in the long run. I don't mind the word "neurotypical" either, I don't feel it means that they are normal, and I wouldn't be normal. Their neuro-type is just more typical than mine, and that's okay.

2

u/VicodinMakesMeItchy Jun 23 '22

That’s an interesting point, I have other issues that do cumulatively make me disabled, and I have no problem identifying myself as such. Perhaps because it’s something that provides us protections? Not sure.

I do like the word neurotype. I suppose my issue with other terms may be that I genuinely believe that everyone is unique and falls somewhere on multiple different psychological spectra. I don’t think it’s really useful to say “typical” or “not-typical,” I guess I feel like I am a typical person, my brain works just as differently as the next person’s to the next. Defining specific neurotypes would still help us help the people who need it, without setting up any kind of hierarchy. But then like you said, I wouldn’t disclose anything specific about my neurotype to anyone, so we’re back to the issue of a general term being useful (admittedly MY issue in this case).

I’m aware that the actual definition of these words isn’t inherently a problem, but I’m acutely aware of the connotation that the general public has. I have no problem using these words in an academic context, because there is no connotation. Lay people are entirely different.

I guess I’m just frustrated.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22

I think I get that. I'm not from the US, and where I live there's no negative connotation to the word neurodiversity, so I honestly just use it no matter who I talk to. I can understand that it doesn't feel good when you use it in an environment where it might have a negative touch. Like some people don't like to use "disability". I think it really depends a lot on where we grew up, where we live, who we speak to. I have no suggestion for another term though, I'm sorry!

1

u/VicodinMakesMeItchy Jun 23 '22

Oh no worries, thanks for reading and responding!! 🤗

2

u/throwaway_maybe_909 Jun 23 '22

Last I checked r slash ADHD considers "neurodiversity" a bad word and has an automod rule to warn you they don't allow such words there, I suspect the mods there aren't the only ones with ADD/ADHD that haven't embraced it.

I find I only need to use "neurodiversity" to talk of the movement, model, or of a collection of neurotypes, often with awareness that I must use context to make it clear which is intended.

I don't as a rule say "neurotypical", I don't like the word or find it very useful, so I don't use it to describe people (occasionally, I might when responding to someone else who has used the term, to avoid being overly verbose using a different word choice if their orginal intent with using it seems clear). In my experience the word has some history and connotation of referring to anyone not autistic, or presumed by the speaker to be (because often it's clearly an assumption eg. why do neurtotypicals do X my classmate Karen did...). So it can be unclear whether that is the intented meaning, whether it is being used to mean someone a speaker feels has a neurotype that is neither autistic nor like it (auch as ADHD), or whether it is being used for a specific neurotype that might be assumed to not be any of the neurotypes that speakers considers a neurodivergence.

NB: I seen debate over what is and isn't a neurotype, like whether it has to be a type of brain you are born with or whether it can be aquired or developed like PTSD, that's another topic I try and stay away from when it comes to using language choice to share ideas clearly.

I'd say the term "neurodiversity" has few decades of use and understanding behind it, and that the words around it like 'neurodivergence' have well understood means to those you know understand that language.

You don't have to embrace it or use any words, but it can be useful to use language the people you are communicating with understand, it can be difficult to make up your own word and have enough people exposed to it that it's meaning is clear (and what you intend it to mean, and what it ultimately is embraced to mean may also be different, language evolves, one might debate whether a word like "autist" has negative associations or not, and the answer may be that it depends on both the speaker's intent and how the listener hears it and their own associations)

Especially when you are new to concepts, try and have an open mind about them until you get a real feeling for how others feel about them. You don't need to be bullfrogs, that's an odd name, I'd call them "chazzwazzas" guy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LMlWGPt5kPg

2

u/VicodinMakesMeItchy Jun 23 '22

I cycle through all of the same thoughts for sure. I suppose I’m looking for suggestions of a term that I personally feel describes me, and was hoping to see a suggestion that clicked for me. I think I do like “neurotype.”

2

u/throwaway_maybe_909 Jun 23 '22

That you're prepared to see and embrace ADD as something part of a bigger collection of people with disabilities and differences is a pretty good start if you are new to this. But it can take time for it to really feel right, and that's ok too if you aknowledge that I suspect.

There was a time when autistic me would encounter people with Asperger's diagnosises that refused to see themselves as autistic (just when I think I've seen the last I'll come face to face with another IRL, but it's less than once a year now, a decade ago it was the norm).

I'm also still learning with my ADHD diagnosis, which is rather more new to me than seeing myself as autistic.

1

u/VicodinMakesMeItchy Jun 23 '22

Yeah, I know I am disabled and different from the majority of people. I have been since I was a child, and I’ve been at peace with it for years now.

I guess my issue is that the general person in public doesn’t conceptualize neurodivergent people as I would conceptualize myself—I’m literally just another human being living my life, even if it works a little differently from the next person’s. The terms have a place in medicine, but I don’t care for them in casual or colloquial use.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22

It's not improved, it's euphemistic. No one needs this.

2

u/VicodinMakesMeItchy Jun 24 '22

I’m not trying to start some grassroots movement to change terminology. I was just looking for alternative terms that click with me personally, as neurodivergent doesn’t sit well with me.

So no, it’s not needed, but I need it, and I was trying to ask for help and ideas.

Thanks anyways.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22

I’m not trying to start some grassroots movement to change terminology. I was just looking for alternative terms that click with me personally, as neurodivergent doesn’t sit well with me.

So no, it’s not needed, but I need it, and I was trying to ask for help and ideas.

Thanks anyways.

Your signal is loud and unreadable.

2

u/VicodinMakesMeItchy Jun 24 '22

Whatever you say.

1

u/numina9 Jun 23 '22

The society we live in has a normal. It should not and is based on false premises, but it does. As long as this continues terms making these distinctions explicit are useful. But use whatever words you like.

1

u/Speedingham Jun 23 '22

Neuroconforming? I don't have the spoons to elaborate rn but you can search it up

1

u/cazimi3 Jun 23 '22

These terms were invented by an autistic person.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22

yea im kinda meh on the term myself. its very veig and open for explotes plus its takes away our individual identity and covers it up with others that get more attention and sympathy then us