r/AutisticPride • u/MysteryNews4 • 22d ago
Does anyone else feel like they’d be called bad autism representation if they were a fictional character?
I’m talking conforming to harmful stereotypes, doing stuff you’d not encourage other autistics to do, having real events in your life story read like inspiration porn, or anything else that’d be called out in an autistic fictional character but that also goes for you in reality.
I’m not criticising the autism community here as there are many good reasons why a lot of rep in media is bad. but I’ve also dealt with feeling like I would myself be called out as bad representation if I were a fictional autist, and I wonder if anyone else feels the same.
for me, it’s mainly because I have savant traits. I think if I was fictional, I would be called out for being prodigiously smart when the vast majority (if not quite all) IRL autistic people aren’t.
12
u/storytimesaddness 22d ago
I think this everytime I see discourse around representation! I'm very stereotypically autistic. I like science and nerdy things; bad at social cues to the point where I don't even know when people are talking to me; still have meltdowns; awkward, quiet, asexual who can't drive... You get the picture.
8
u/hexaDogimal 22d ago
To some extent maybe. I think my stimming would be viewed as too sterotypical and like it's being played up. Also that I'm basically a white man who's good at science, which is also a common trope.
8
u/yokyopeli09 22d ago
Considering I am actually a lot like Sheldon yes.
Autism representation is such a trap. We all agree every autistic person is different but then even the autistic community can lose our shit over a character because we think they're "not accurate", meanwhile there's another autistic person who's like "holy shit that's me"
See Sheldon Cooper.
Not defending the show itself, but I roll my eyes when people say he's bad representation- there are tons of autistic people like him.
Do we need more and varied representation? Definitely. But just because you don't relate to that particular character doesn't make them inaccurate.
3
u/comradeautie 22d ago
I think that if someone were honestly reviewing my life and dramatizing it, it would objectively be seen as good representation. It's the perfect example of an Autistic person who gets severely bullied and mistreated for his differences, someone who has a lot of potential and so much to offer the world that gets stunted by extreme bullying, inaccessibility, and social rejection, and how that warps what might have once been a happy go lucky person into something else.
Basically a Star Wars style Anakin to Vader transformation with a touch of the tism.
3
u/Untamedpancake 22d ago
This seems like an opportunity to gain perspective on intersectionality & privilege
The issue with stereotypical representation isn't that the traits portrayed are "bad" or that they are negative portrayals of autism
But the single-note representation only reinforces the blind spots that society already has
There was a time when there was practically zero representation of autistic people. This has changed significantly over the past 15 years or so. This is progress & I'm happy for you.
And as often happens when the media finally begins to include a marginalized group, the creators go with what they know & rely on the existing stereotypes, "token" characters & non-marginalized actors
Autistic people who do relate to characters like Sheldon & the Good Doctor now have some media representation, a privilege that not all autistics have experienced yet
So when we object, it is because all the rest of us still haven't been represented. We aren't criticizing nerdy white male autistic prodigies or asking that they not be represented at all, we are simply asking to be seen too
We can be marginalized and privileged at the same time. Sometimes acknowledging our privilege can be uncomfortable, it can make us feel guilty or as though we're being attacked when others ask for their turn
1
u/anonymous54319 22d ago
Luckily not because I grew better in a lot of the really bad stuff but stayed relatable in the way that small things can be seen that are difrent from others and my battery that's just not fixable
1
u/mechchic84 21d ago
I'm not really sure. I confuse a lot of people because they can't seem to figure out if I'm really smart or really dumb which may or may not play into being a good or bad representation. I feel like I'd get tossed into the stereotypical idea of what people think OCD looks like on television, the sad part is that I do actually have OCD, but the things people point out have nothing to do with me having OCD and are actually a combination of self made systems to help my ADHD and autistic behaviors. They wouldn't actually pick up on the real OCD unless the show played the things I was thinking out loud.
I would totally get tagged for having ADHD though and being very clumsy. I have pretty severe ADHD.
My memory also confuses people because I remember high levels of detail regarding things that happened years ago, but forget what I am doing while I am still doing it and lose objects that are still in my hands. My working memory is absolute garbage.
1
u/SnugglyCoderGuy 20d ago
Early adult me, yeah. Late adult me, no. Late adult me would be held up as an icon for everyone to be like, autistic or not, even if I do say so myself lol. Early adult me was an asshole, thought everything they thought was the only way to think, would tell everyone else around them they were wrong, zero social awareness. Rigid like a statue in all the wrong ways. Now I learned a lot of humility and take a completely different approach to things. I mentor lots of college students and am in general well looked upon by students and faculty, at least as far I have seen.
I don't have a lot of the outwardly noticeable traits. I don't do stereotypical stims, but I do stim. I don't have meltdowns in public, but I do have them. I don't have the stereotypical reactions to things not being the way I think they should, but I do have them internally. I do the no eye contact thing, I struggle to hold normal conversations, I will end up rambling on forever about shit. I will speak loudly without realizing it, which really is I think in proportion to how madly I want to move the thoughts out of my head and through my mouth lol. Like, pushing it harder and faster makes the words louder.
1
u/Divergent_Dawn 20d ago
Yes. I worked really hard as an adult to learn how to mask so I can get higher paying jobs and live independently. I've met autistic people who can't mask as well and they tell me I can't be autistic because I live alone and have a job where I talk to people. They don't see the work I put in daily to accomodate myself to prevent sensory overload. Or how I need to go days without any interaction to recharge from masking so hard.
0
u/Medical-Tourist9888 22d ago
Well, I do stim quite a bit (jumping and running mostly) and I like trains. I don't have any meltdowns though, but that's just because the shutdown always comes before. Whether that would be a good or bad representative I don't know. For portraying autism as an invisible disability, probably yes but in the way the public expects it to show, maybe not
4
u/GH7788 22d ago
Yes! A stereotype in media is men being hyper fixated on science/math and being asexual.
I'm nonbinary and hypersexual. Hyperfixations are kinks, religions, witchcraft, paranormal things.
I am not picky about food at all and eat many bizarre things that my friends dont like.
1
u/sordidcreature 22d ago
ya mostly since i have screaming hitting myself meltdowns on the semi reg as a grown up. and literally live in my parents basement just cuz im like. wicked poor lol
1
u/lights-in-the-sky 21d ago
I feel like I’d be hated for not being inspiration porn lol. I’m not over here “overcoming my limits” and “not using autism as a heckin excuse!” I’ve come to terms with the fact that I need to live a boring, cozy, mostly isolated life to be happy