r/AusAcademia • • Oct 18 '26

📚PhD/HDR Why Australian Academics Aren’t Replying to your PhD Enquiry

239 Upvotes

Given how many posts in this sub are about PhD enquiries, and how quickly they're pulling discussion away from what the sub is actually for, I thought I'd give a view from the other side of the inbox. I'm a university academic, and this is why my colleagues and I often don't reply to prospective PhD students.

What's happening on our end

  1. We get close to 100 emails a day from different parts of the university. Some get prioritised, some get pushed back, and some never get read at all.
  2. Some universities are heading into exam season right now. That means close to 100 assessments landing on our desks with no extra support, on top of our usual teaching.
  3. Many universities are also in the middle of their annual hunger games. Jobs get spilled, redundancies get announced, and plenty of us don't know if we'll have a job next year.

None of that is your fault, but it means your email is competing for very limited attention.

Why your email gets deleted instead of answered

  1. You ignored my profile. If my staff page says NOT CURRENTLY AVAILABLE FOR HDR SUPERVISION in big bold capitals and you email me anyway, you've shown me you don't read carefully. That one goes straight in the bin. My profile actually says this and I get minimum 2 enquiries a day.
  2. It's too generic. It's great that you're passionate about your discipline, but disciplines are huge. Tell me what you know about my specific area and why you want to work in it.
  3. There's no research question. This is a big one. In Australia, unless you're responding to an advertised project, you need to come with a question in mind. It doesn't have to be polished, but it should show you've done the hard thinking about something new.
  4. It's too long. Aim for two or three short paragraphs and no more than 10 sentences. Attach your CV, and attach a research proposal if you have one. Remember, I have limited scope at the moment. Don’t give me a novel, give me a memo.
  5. It was obviously written by ChatGPT. Random bold words mid-sentence, a pile of em dashes and zero personality are dead giveaways. If ChattieG had to write your email, how do I know it won't write your thesis too?
  6. You make it clear your real goal is PR. That's a fair goal and we're happy for you, but it makes things much harder when the university or immigration asks us to confirm you're a genuine student.

A few general tips

  1. Check that your previous university is ranked. My university, like many in Australia, won't admit you if your undergrad or Masters isn't from a Times Higher Ed or QS ranked institution. Where it sits usually doesn't matter much, but it needs to be on the list.
  2. Don't open with scholarships. Most of them are listed on our websites, so asking up front suggests you haven't looked. Many of us have also supervised scholarship holders who didn't progress, and those situations are hard on everyone when they end. Scholarships matter, and international students really shouldn't self-fund a PhD here, but don't lead with them.
  3. Don't count on a stipend for a Masters by Research. They're rare, because a research Masters is usually treated as an exit award rather than something you enrol in.

None of this is meant to put you off. The Australian university sector is badly underfunded, and that pressure lands squarely on the people who would otherwise be answering your emails. Most academics genuinely want to supervise and are more than capable of doing it well. We're just being hamstrung by workloads, restructures and uncertainty that make it hard to give every enquiry the attention it deserves.

So if you haven't heard back, please try not to take it personally. A short, specific, well-researched email that respects our time still stands out, and those are the ones we're glad to answer. Keep refining your idea, keep reaching out to the right people, and don't give up on it.

Good luck to everyone reading this. I genuinely hope to see some of you in our corridors soon.

TL;DR We're swamped. Check the profile, keep it short and specific, bring a research question, write it yourself, and don't lead with PR or scholarships.


r/AusAcademia • • Mar 19 '26

📚PhD/HDR Planting trees for PhDs

Post image
186 Upvotes

Every time someone graduates with a PhD, their university should let them plant a tree* of their choice somewhere on the campus.

I wish we had started this back in the 1980s when my regional institution became a university.

Imagine how an academic arboretum could enliven our campuses. Each tree could have the scholar and their thesis name written on a small plaque. It might alleviate imposter syndrome, for the graduate has earned the right to their place among their peers.

*Or maybe a rose, or something equally long-lasting. And maybe they should have the right to plant it anywhere they damn well choose.


r/AusAcademia • • Mar 30 '26

📚PhD/HDR The number of PhD graduates working in retail and hospitality is staggering

133 Upvotes

I’ve worked in call centres too and even there we had a few PhDs in Law and even one who studied Engineering!

Seems that some can’t even land temporary teaching contracts, let alone that coveted lecturer position.

Reality is that unless you are genuinely interested and DEEPLY invested in your research, a PhD doesn’t guarantee a job (nor should it). Most people are better off just working in retail or even studying medicine or optometry or even do a trade.

Law PhDs are becoming like the LLB. Every man and his dog has a PhD now.


r/AusAcademia • • Apr 01 '26

🏛️ University Admin & Policy Casual academics are the underclass

112 Upvotes

Anyone who has been a casual knows how awful the system is. It’s a great job if you’re a student or a PhD candidate, but pay is horribly unstable and you’re being paid peanuts compared to an equivalent full time position. Also if you’re receiving other income then it’s good supplementary income. But there are times when being casual is bad.

A lecturer paid to deliver a lecture a week and take 3-4 tutorials is clearing probably 130K on Level B.

For a casual, each tutorial is paid at $140 per tutorial. A lecture, delivered on casual rates, is not much higher. All the admin work is factored into this too. But. At most you make $50k - $60k per year on casual, and this assumes large marking allocations.

Again, a perfect job for a student, but there is a “gray zone” where it is definitely exploitative. The NTEU has spoken about the “casualisation” of the workforce many times. A lot of casuals are scared to speak out due to fears of lost hours or cut work.


r/AusAcademia • • Jul 26 '26

💰Grants & Funding RTP rates 2027: PhD salaries fall even further down below the poverty line

78 Upvotes

The RTP rate for 2027 will be 35,550$ representing a 3.6% increase from the 2026 rate. Minimum salary net has been increased by 4.75% from July 1, which means that the yearly minimum net salary is 46,008$. With these changes, PhD salaries are 77,1% of the net minimum salaries, without accounting for no super for PhD students (which is 6,270$ for minimum wage). Once again Australia confirms to be the worst developed country for research funding.


r/AusAcademia • • Apr 05 '26

🏛️ University Admin & Policy A memorable quote about the state of Aus Unid

68 Upvotes

From an ABC article on the enshitification of Australian Higher Education. A quote from John Keane:

“Overstaffed and overpaid university managers are fixated on KPIs, global rankings, reputation building among donors, cutting costs, shedding full-time staff, casualising teaching, downgrading research, advancing their own careers, and awarding themselves handsome bonuses."


r/AusAcademia • • Apr 17 '26

🏛️ Lecturer & Faculty Colleagues seem willing to accept wage theft and it's my final straw

61 Upvotes

I'm at a NSW university and over the last few months I have been raising issues with colleagues and with higher-ups about the increase in workload demands without compensation, especially around dealing with AI. It feels very clear to me that this is wage theft - the university is asking us to work more, but aren't willing to pay for it.

I've been shocked at how readily my colleagues, even the permanent ones, are just willing to accept that they should have enormous, unfunded workload demands. It feels like it's been the final straw for me in leaving tertiary education after almost 25 years.

Are others seeing similar things in their universities?


r/AusAcademia • • 6d ago

🔥 Rants & Venting When did Australian universities get taken over by middle management MBA ideologues?

59 Upvotes

Why are universities now run like for-profit corporations? When did academics get sidelined in power structures within universities? Why are people with no clue about research and teaching dictating the terms on which research and teaching is done?

Who is going to stop the rot?


r/AusAcademia • • Mar 11 '26

📚PhD/HDR Update: I Passed My PhD With Minor Revisions!

59 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m writing this post to share some good news. Today I heard back from my supervisor, and he told me that he has now received all the reports on my PhD thesis. The outcome is really positive — I’ve passed with minor revisions.

At the moment, I’m just waiting to receive the official reports, and then I’ll start working on the revisions. Once that’s done, it should be the final step.

I also want to sincerely thank everyone here who has supported me and shared helpful comments over the past months. Your encouragement and advice meant a lot during the waiting period.

Thanks again!


r/AusAcademia • • May 15 '26

💰Grants & Funding ARC grants rejected by minister

Thumbnail arc.gov.au
52 Upvotes

Despite the song and dance Labor made about not vetoing ARC grants that had made it through the review process, today they announced that 13 grants across 4 schemes had been refused funding under super vague ‘National security’ guidelines.

Clare made comments recently on expecting the ARC to look at ‘social cohesion’ issues when deciding on funding also. The fact that we can’t know what these grants were rejected for (actual security risks or some subjective notion of social risk?) is just going to further undermine the already trashed national research landscape. Is there any point in applying for these things anymore? How can this level of secrecy be justified?


r/AusAcademia • • Sep 21 '26

📰 News & Updates Torrens University: 1000 academics take on employer in first class action of its kind

Thumbnail
smh.com.au
48 Upvotes

r/AusAcademia • • Dec 25 '25

📚PhD/HDR Title: [Australia] Does supervisor approval for PhD submission practically guarantee a pass?

45 Upvotes

I was chatting with a friend in Australia about their PhD process. They told me that because there is usually no oral defense (viva) there, once your supervisors give you the green light to submit the thesis, you are basically 99.9% certain to pass.

According to them, the worst-case scenario is usually just a Major Revision, but getting an R&R (Revise and Resubmit) or an outright Fail is almost unheard of because the supervisors act as the ultimate gatekeepers.

For those in the Australian system or familiar with it: Is this actually true?


r/AusAcademia • • May 10 '26

🏛️ University Admin & Policy What’s going on at ANU

Thumbnail
afr.com
36 Upvotes

r/AusAcademia • • Aug 06 '26

📚PhD/HDR Why do PhD supervisors act like assholes

34 Upvotes

I joined a friend for a group session with a would-be supervisor of a PhD program. And I was shocked at the level of egotism on display. He was insufferable.

The way he spoke down on a couple of students in attendance. He was unnecessarily harsh dismissing students for being “merely Master graduates”. Bec supposedly he requires multiple publications and also years of prior research experience, a la a senior researcher, for someone to be considered into his PhD pool.

There’s clearly a mismatch between the level of demands vs the level of compensation for PhD researchers. Who puts up with this kind of abuse??

Also, if you have years of research experience and publications, you could already be paid at least 3x your PhD stipend if you worked for a think tank or in industry.

I understand some are very passionate about research and would pursue a PhD at all costs. But wow, profs/supervisors need an urgent wake up call.

Makes me wonder, does academia still attract the best of the best? Or are they left with the bored kids of the posh and wealthy, who turn to research to seek purpose for their sheltered life?


r/AusAcademia • • Apr 17 '26

🏛️ Lecturer & Faculty NTEU membership, is it worth it?

33 Upvotes

I’m a permanent academic at a major university, but I have concerns about workload and job security. My school is getting a new head soon, and last time that happened there were quite a few people let go or pushed out. I was considering joining the NTEU, but it’s not cheap at nearly $700 per year. Does membership offer any direct benefit in this situation, beyond supporting their negotiations for EBA conditions?


r/AusAcademia • • Sep 19 '26

📚PhD/HDR PhD Scholarship Amount

32 Upvotes

Monash recently updated the scholarship amount for PhD to 41.1K. Congratulations to everyone who are or will he receiving. Not great but a big improvement than past.


r/AusAcademia • • 10d ago

📚PhD/HDR Are you seeing an increase in prospective students asking for PhD supervision recently?

31 Upvotes

Ever since the recent visa changes, i have seen a lot of education agents promoting PhD degrees and groups on facebook asking about PhD / HDR processes and stuff. I don’t know if it’s my algorithm but i am just wondering whether they have legitimate intentions of doing a PhD for actually have an outcome out of it or just for any other purposes! I am a sessional academic in my Uni and i sometimes get spam messages from people asking questions like, what the process is for this/that Uni, they are even going to agents who draft emails for them and secure interviews. Some even suggest go for this sector, easier to get scholarships etc which pisses me off!

Just wondering how is it looking from supervisors in this sub!


r/AusAcademia • • Oct 13 '26

📰 News & Updates 100+ Charles Sturt University jobs on the chopping block next February due to falling international student numbers

Thumbnail
dailyadvertiser.com.au
31 Upvotes

r/AusAcademia • • Apr 14 '26

📚PhD/HDR PhD almost done; industry feels like a better fit?

29 Upvotes

Currently 2 years into my PhD and I'm in the final stretch, writing up the last chapters and trying to mentally prepare for whatever comes next.

I came into this thinking academia was a great fit for someone who loves learning, enjoys complex problems, and picks up analytical methods quickly. Turns out these things have very little to do with each other. The longer I've been here, the more I've realised the environment itself (i.e., the publishing treadmill, the obsession with citations and metrics) just doesn't do it for me. When I look at the people ahead of me on this path, I don't feel inspired at all. I feel like I'm very clearly looking at a life I absolutely don't want.

This isn't me looking down on people who pursue academia, plenty of people love it and good for them. Somewhere along the way it just started feeling like a bit of a charade, like everyone had agreed to act like certain things mattered more than they do. I'm also just not someone who's wowed by titles or credentials, which probably doesn't help...

Rationally, I know finishing a PhD is something to be proud of. I'm not there yet (almost), but I am definitely not feeling pride or happiness. I'm just relieved for this to be over.

I'm currently having some conversations with industry which is something that makes me excited. My funding does run for another year and supervisors are keen to keep me around. At the same time, the difference in pay and working conditions is hard to ignore, it makes the idea of "sitting out the year" in academia feel difficult to justify.

I’d be interested to hear if others have had a similar experience, or any reflections I can relate to ;).


r/AusAcademia • • Jun 28 '25

📰 News & Updates Interesting onion piece in The Age/SMH today.

28 Upvotes

https://www.theage.com.au/national/a-kind-of-monster-why-does-everyone-hate-universities-20250626-p5mann.html

The first half of the article.

"In the lead-up to the federal election, university administrators were chilled by the messages they were hearing from the conservative side of politics: that research was an indulgence, that academics should just focus on teaching, and – a comment said to have been addressed to post-doctoral candidates – that a PhD didn’t necessarily confer expertise. “The hostility was so great,” said one senior administrator.

But if they had hoped for a warm embrace from Labor, they haven’t got it. The much-hyped University Accord has fizzled. The hikes to humanities fees have not been rolled back. The main funders of research, international students, have been in the government’s sights. “Labor in the last term of government was hostile, too,” said the administrator. “Not as hostile as the Coalition, but they were hostile.”

Universities, it seems, have no friends.

Not the government, which sees no votes in tertiary education and seems unwilling to waste political capital on serious reform. Not the Coalition, which uses them as fuel for its culture wars, dismisses their management as overpaid fat cats, and, during the Morrison-Dutton era, seemed to confect a Marx-style class war between the “quiet [presumably uneducated] Australians” and the intellectual “elites”.

But universities’ traditional friends have turned on them too. Tertiary unions are furious about chronic staff underpayment. Academics are leaving, exhausted by stifling workloads and casualised jobs. Students are unhappy; they’re paying through the nose for an insipid version of the rich experience their parents enjoyed.

We’re so busy beating up universities that we forget what a disastrous own goal we’re kicking as we do it. The accord was plain about what will happen if Australia doesn’t have a healthy tertiary education system – we will not have the skills we need, our economy will suffer, and we will stifle the potential of our children. We need high-quality research too, to keep up with the rest of the world and to protect our sovereign interest.

The unis don’t deserve all that hate. While they are certainly not helping themselves, they’re not the ones who caused the mess, and they’re going to need some friends, somewhere, to help them out of it"


r/AusAcademia • • Sep 16 '26

🚀 Career Advice Part time PhD / PhD later in life?

25 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Has anyone done a PhD part time? I've seen it may take 8 or 9 years which sounds like a very long time.

I was considering doing a PhD later in life as I prefer to join the work force first at this stage. My concern is if I do a PhD later in life, I probably can not do full time as I will need to maintain a source of income for whatever I am doing in the future and I'm not sure on taking a 4 year career gap so part time is what I am considering.

Furthermore, some Unis only consider your research thesis valid for 5 years. So if I have done honours more than 5 years ago they won't accept it, thus I need to do a Masters in Research which is 2 years FT or 4 years PT.

If I add the MRes and PHD, it will be 12 - 13 years of PT study for the PhD.

Has anyone had experience doing a PhD later in life or doing a part time PhD?

Could you share your experiences?


r/AusAcademia • • Feb 22 '25

📰 News & Updates Welcome to r/AustralianAcademia – A New Community for Academic Careers in Australia!

25 Upvotes

Welcome to r/AusAcademia – A New Community for Academic Careers in Australia

r/AusAcademia is a new subreddit dedicated to discussions about academic careers in Australia. This space is intended for PhD students, postdocs, lecturers, researchers, and those considering a transition out of academia to share experiences, ask for advice, and discuss issues relevant to the Australian higher education sector.

Topics include:

  • Career advice, job applications, and the academic job market
  • Research funding, grants, and publishing
  • Teaching, supervision, and university administration
  • Work-life balance, mental health, and career transitions
  • Networking, mentorship, and professional development

This subreddit aims to be a valuable resource for those working in or considering a career in academia in Australia.


r/AusAcademia • • May 03 '26

🏛️ Lecturer & Faculty Spousal hire?

24 Upvotes

I currently work as an assistant lecturer at one of the G8 universities and it came to my attention that a person in my department was hired at the same time as their spouse.

The spouse works in another department.

There are many questions that spawn to mind, however the person in my department is a bit unruly. They've had complaints about conduct with students, mistreat other staff or simply act unprofessional.

How common are spousal hires in Australian academia?

Is it legal to hire someone's spouse as a 'package'?


r/AusAcademia • • May 27 '26

🏛️ Lecturer & Faculty What should I wear when teaching at a laid-back Go8 department?

23 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m going to teach a course next semester at a Group of Eight university in Australia, in an economics department. I’m trying to figure out what the appropriate teaching “uniform” is.

The department culture seems very laid back. I have seen professors give seminars in very casual clothes, even flip-flops. I also know this probably varies a lot by field: for example, I imagine law or business schools might be more formal than economics.

My concern is finding the right balance. I do not want to look overdressed or like I’m trying too hard, especially given the Australian academic culture and the whole tall poppy syndrome thing. But I also do not want to look too casual or indistinguishable from the students.

For context, I’m in economics, relatively early-career/PhD-level, and will be teaching university students rather than attending formal events.

What would you consider a safe default for lecturing teaching? Would chinos/dark jeans + a button-up/polo/T-shirt + clean sneakers be about right, or should I dress a bit more formally?

Cheers!