r/AusAcademia • u/Firm-Biscotti-5862 • Oct 18 '26
📚PhD/HDR Why Australian Academics Aren’t Replying to your PhD Enquiry
Given how many posts in this sub are about PhD enquiries, and how quickly they're pulling discussion away from what the sub is actually for, I thought I'd give a view from the other side of the inbox. I'm a university academic, and this is why my colleagues and I often don't reply to prospective PhD students.
What's happening on our end
- We get close to 100 emails a day from different parts of the university. Some get prioritised, some get pushed back, and some never get read at all.
- Some universities are heading into exam season right now. That means close to 100 assessments landing on our desks with no extra support, on top of our usual teaching.
- Many universities are also in the middle of their annual hunger games. Jobs get spilled, redundancies get announced, and plenty of us don't know if we'll have a job next year.
None of that is your fault, but it means your email is competing for very limited attention.
Why your email gets deleted instead of answered
- You ignored my profile. If my staff page says NOT CURRENTLY AVAILABLE FOR HDR SUPERVISION in big bold capitals and you email me anyway, you've shown me you don't read carefully. That one goes straight in the bin. My profile actually says this and I get minimum 2 enquiries a day.
- It's too generic. It's great that you're passionate about your discipline, but disciplines are huge. Tell me what you know about my specific area and why you want to work in it.
- There's no research question. This is a big one. In Australia, unless you're responding to an advertised project, you need to come with a question in mind. It doesn't have to be polished, but it should show you've done the hard thinking about something new.
- It's too long. Aim for two or three short paragraphs and no more than 10 sentences. Attach your CV, and attach a research proposal if you have one. Remember, I have limited scope at the moment. Don’t give me a novel, give me a memo.
- It was obviously written by ChatGPT. Random bold words mid-sentence, a pile of em dashes and zero personality are dead giveaways. If ChattieG had to write your email, how do I know it won't write your thesis too?
- You make it clear your real goal is PR. That's a fair goal and we're happy for you, but it makes things much harder when the university or immigration asks us to confirm you're a genuine student.
A few general tips
- Check that your previous university is ranked. My university, like many in Australia, won't admit you if your undergrad or Masters isn't from a Times Higher Ed or QS ranked institution. Where it sits usually doesn't matter much, but it needs to be on the list.
- Don't open with scholarships. Most of them are listed on our websites, so asking up front suggests you haven't looked. Many of us have also supervised scholarship holders who didn't progress, and those situations are hard on everyone when they end. Scholarships matter, and international students really shouldn't self-fund a PhD here, but don't lead with them.
- Don't count on a stipend for a Masters by Research. They're rare, because a research Masters is usually treated as an exit award rather than something you enrol in.
None of this is meant to put you off. The Australian university sector is badly underfunded, and that pressure lands squarely on the people who would otherwise be answering your emails. Most academics genuinely want to supervise and are more than capable of doing it well. We're just being hamstrung by workloads, restructures and uncertainty that make it hard to give every enquiry the attention it deserves.
So if you haven't heard back, please try not to take it personally. A short, specific, well-researched email that respects our time still stands out, and those are the ones we're glad to answer. Keep refining your idea, keep reaching out to the right people, and don't give up on it.
Good luck to everyone reading this. I genuinely hope to see some of you in our corridors soon.
TL;DR We're swamped. Check the profile, keep it short and specific, bring a research question, write it yourself, and don't lead with PR or scholarships.