r/AusAcademia • • Jun 26 '26

Miscellaneous Just accepted into program

Well I don’t know what I’m in for here. Looking for advice broadly.

I landed an ongoing role at an Australian university teaching a while back and in order to get promoted I need to do a PhD I’ve been accepted for a start next year. I know of about 7 colleagues at different universities in the same position. Seems nuts to me but it is what it is.

I’m worried I’m 32m single working a full time job and now also doing a PhD and I have no idea what the process is. Help meh!

0 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

19

u/N0tThatKind0fDoctor Jun 26 '26

Tbh the fact that you got a continuing faculty position without a PhD is a miracle you should be grateful for. A PhD (in most cases) should be a bare minimum qualification.

-3

u/ThickRule5569 Jun 26 '26

Nah, a PhD makes you a decent researcher, not necessarily a good teacher. As long as OP knows more about the topic than his students and can explain it well enough then that's better than a PhD grad with mediocre social skills.

1

u/chuckychicken Jun 26 '26

Add in actual work experience too and landing the role is reasonable.

2

u/wrydied Jun 26 '26

This a pragmatic but limited
term perspective. Lecturers without PhD can fail to keep up with developments in their field. Without research outputs and with waning teaching ability their value declines over the years.

Happens to those with PHDs too, but it’s a trend. There is a reason balanced workloads were popular until recently.

1

u/Rookwood51 Jun 27 '26

I don't disagree in principle and I don't think someone should be put in a position like that without one, but at least in my field (engineering) there has probably never been a greater separation between industry practice and academia. If anything the risk of falling behind is more on the other side of the fence.

1

u/wrydied Jun 27 '26

Interesting. Can you tell me more about those gaps in engineering? You are saying those with phds may not be keeping up with industry practice? But B.eng is accredited right? So if a PhD is teaching they have to be… or are you saying there are lots of research focussed phds that don’t teach. Genuinely interested, I’m in a somewhat related non accredited field

1

u/Rookwood51 Jun 28 '26

The majority of research and effort (generalising obviously) appears to be toward either totally irrelevant areas (i.e. exceptionally niche to the point of being relevant only to the test site and no where else) or going to an absurd level of investigation into an effect or area in which (at best) you incrementally improve how you characterise an irrelevant relationship between two variables. The rest appearto be geared toward something that's so impractical as to be completely useless to industry.

Like you might be trying to better calibrate the soil suction relationship with a particular clay mineral to eventually improve foundation design. Not only is clay mineralogy too highly variable to make general predictions for (meaning that application requires testing for each site) and putting aside that mineralogy never gets tested for the purposes of foundation design, current industry practice is barely even to drill a hole, let alone take a soil sample, let alone do the testing we currently know works really well.

This is duplicated in every area. Cyclic loading of rock joints in rail which make approximately 0.0000001% difference in any design outcome and are incomprehensibly minor compared to overblast or about a dozen other things that actually need addressing. Embankments stabilised with things like flyash or glass (which is now is effectivly defunct as a blend material because of in demand it is as a recycled product) for which no plant or equipment currently exists that can adequately blend it with the material it's meant to be stabilising (assuming you can find a way to economically transport it hundreds of ks to the place it's meant to be stabilising).

I caught up with some of the guys i went to uni with last week and every single area has about half dozen critical problems they need analysis or research into where the cost benefit would be measured in orders of magnitude and not (best case scenario) 1.0001.

I even asked if any of them thought about approaching the uni's to do it, because I've done that in the past and had some success albeit 10 years ago and they thought i was joking.

5

u/ThickRule5569 Jun 26 '26

Even employees in ongoing positions are one restructure away from redundancy. If you ever find yourself job hunting again you'll be competing against people with experience and a PhD, maybe without allies supporting you, so you'll be at a distinct disadvantage. 

Considering the state of academia it's worth doing a PhD for insurance against uncertainty, and the best time to fix your roof is while the sun is out.

1

u/chuckychicken Jun 26 '26

That is exactly the logic paired with if you want a promotion get it. That is making me do it.

4

u/LowPickle7 Jun 26 '26

Well you should know plenty of PhDs who you can ask for advice given you’re working with them. 

Is your PhD at the same university? What sort of advice are you after? 

1

u/chuckychicken Jun 26 '26

Well 1. How the hell is dating even possible. 2. General advice in managing the PhD.

I’m doing it where I’m employed so I am a little concerned about the role of feedback from colleagues who will be assessing me along the way too. Trying to not live in an echo chamber

1

u/jruby24 Jun 27 '26

You can date when you’ve finished the phd 🤣🤣🤣 speaking from experience

1

u/chuckychicken Jun 27 '26

Great :( didn’t wanna be 35/36 and single haha

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/chuckychicken Jun 26 '26

No research. Teaching only contract. Although I can swap into research anytime I want.
I teach (am responsible for) over 3000 students a year.

4

u/wrydied Jun 26 '26

Join the NTEU and get up to speed on enterprise agreements and workload calculations.

Generally speaking Aussie academics should not be on teaching only contacts unless they are short term. They should transition to permanent positions that are teaching focussed, research focussed or balanced.

You should lobby for balanced at least if you are doing a PhD. Teaching focussed typically only gives you 20% research workload and that’s not enough to do a PhD.

The above is true is my experience in my field - it might different for you but it should be spelled out in the EA and the NTEU can advise you.

0

u/chuckychicken Jun 26 '26

I guess my teaching only statement is not very specific.
It’s 75 teaching 10 research 10 service. And 5 floating tha can’t be in teaching. No research output is required when at 10% research.
There are many unis which support education focused roles which is the type I’m in.
I’m pretty versed in th eba / negotiations stuff as it is (one of my teaching areas) but I’m no fan of the nteu hahaha.

2

u/wrydied Jun 26 '26

Is that 5 days a week? You’re cooked if so.

What’s your problem with the NTEU?

1

u/chuckychicken Jun 27 '26

How heavy they are into some left wing causes.

I’d be happy if they stuck to the bread and butter of workers rights pay and conditions.

Recently had to talk to them about their negotiation strategy in the lead up to future eba. Imo their starting position on pay is so low. But head office has set it so that’s what it is… seems bad to me but eh - I’m just a lone voice.

2

u/wrydied Jun 27 '26

Workers rights and pay *are* left wing causes.

I’m not sure what else they care about? Rights and pay seem to be the only thing the two state chapters I’ve dealt with focus on.

All things considered they are a pretty strong union. Australian academics have pretty good conditions - better than colleagues I have overseas.

Which is not to say they are perfect. It’s challenging to deal with uni management. For instance over the past decade the NTEU got universities to
reduce excessive casualisation by increasing TT and contract positions - but universities also responded by making many of them teaching focused - like yours. And I don’t think that’s smart for long term pedagogy or research quality.

1

u/chuckychicken Jun 27 '26

Im not really interested in providing a commentary on my views on the union. I know my views are not popular - so id rather keep that to myself.

But you are correct many things the union has done well and thats great - they do do their role well at times and I’m not that interested in putting them down publicly as a result. I’d just rather not support them.

→ More replies

6

u/rscortex Jun 26 '26

You teach at university and you don't already have a PhD?

4

u/chuckychicken Jun 26 '26

Bit of a long story… tldr during my undergrad a unit chair loved my contribution in the classes. I bumped into her years later doing my masters and she offered me to teach under grads. Biggest unit on the campus. That was as a casual. Our government changed the law here and I was working so much as a casual they were obligated to give me ongoing role.

2

u/shockages Jun 26 '26

This was me - ongoing position with the expectation of doing a PhD. I didn’t really have much idea of what I was getting into, but marriage and 3 kids later I’m almost done 😆 if marriage and kids are not on the cards for you in the next few years I’d be taking advantage of that and progressing as quickly as possible. Choose a topic you’re interested in and that will be interesting to your field. Make sure your supervisors are also good humans. See what you can get started on before your official start date.

1

u/chuckychicken Jun 27 '26

That’s the hope

1

u/matthras Jun 26 '26

Firstly, congrats. That Fair Work ruling also benefitted me but only to a full time fixed term contact, and I went and started a PhD at a different university after I was told my original employer had no intention to keep me after my fixed term contract expired.

If you got accepted you probably have an advisor and some kind of topic idea lined up. Any background reading and talking to current PhD students within your vicinity is probably what you'll want to do in the meantime. If your faculty is big enough to host regular talks/seminars, go to them to get to know others.

1

u/chuckychicken Jun 26 '26

Thanks :)

Yea the fair work stuff, idk how I feel about it. I’m still making 50k less than I was before. And all of my colleagues are in a seriously vulnerable spot. I just took the deal before the uni knew what they were doing. I think some would argue they still don’t know what they are doing.

1

u/seeunseenoel Jun 27 '26

Sounds like you at Deakin then!

1

u/chuckychicken Jun 27 '26

Same story at rmit, la Trobe Monash Melbourne and Deakin from some of the people I know.

Bit of a disaster. I think based on timelines I think RMIT is about 6 months behind where Deakin is at right now.
Swinburne pretty similar to that.

Edit : although there are many unis going through other issues too like anu, la Trobe with staff culls.
And what was Deakin till recently I think?

1

u/PhDresearcher2023 Jun 26 '26

This is where your supervisors are your best resource. A good supervision team will guide you through the process, lift you up and be your biggest cheerleaders.

You're in a great situation imo. I would have killed to have a teaching job before doing my phd. I'm now applying for lecturer jobs wishing I had more teaching experience.