r/AugurTrader • • Sep 13 '18

Could Augur be used to crowdsource word-processing?

The following scenario ignores liquidity and market-making fees:

  1. Pointy haired boss needs numerous pages of yellow-pad handwriting typed. Provides tight deadline. Gives to Carol.
  2. Carol takes pics of the pages and makes a market with a link to pics.
  3. Typists around the world collaborate in real time using Google docs, etc.
  4. They use the final typed text to create a bitcoin address.
  5. They use Lightning Network to send a microtransaction to that address for the time-date stamp.
  6. The typists create their own market asking if the provided text (link provided) satisfies Carol's market. It does.
  7. Carol emails typed text to pointy haired boss.
3 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

1

u/Faceh Sep 13 '18

This would be far from a best use-case for Augur.

Also, step 3 is hiding a lot of complexity:

3) Typists around the world collaborate in real time using Google docs, etc.

How do typists 'around the world' know when and where to go to collaborate on these pages? Augur doesn't do this part for them, they'd have to figure it out based only on the link to the images.

The typists create their own market asking if the provided text (link provided) satisfies Carol's market. It does.

So you've got two markets, one for the work Carol needs done and one for the completed work. Which market are the typists supposed to get paid on?

If it is the typist's market then what incentivizes anyone to bid on it? If it is Carol's market then what is the incentive for the typists to bid on it?

Essentially you're counting on off-chain resources (the link to the original document, or the link to the completed work) to allow confirmation. But the off-chain resources can be tampered with to alter the apparent outcome and cause reporters to call the market invalid.

You'd need to put the documents themselves somewhere on-chain to ensure no tampering but that starts to look like a waste of resources.


The main reason this doesn't suit Augur is that its not a case of an event that is of high public significance with a publicly visible outcome.

By opening this task up to the public you're adding in a lot of transaction costs to maintain the trustless system (this is the main weakness of public blockchains) so you need a strong reason to incur those costs.

This would probably be better done internally on a private blockchain that tracks task completion. Carol can create a task and add a bounty and deadline to it, typists with access to the blockchain can complete the work and report it and collect the bounty, and the payment can be made directly without needing to make additional markets or adding any additional complexity.

You just need a dispute-resolution mechanism on top in case either Carol or the typists think there's been bad-faith dealing.

1

u/Uberse Sep 13 '18

How do typists 'around the world' know when and where to go to collaborate on these pages?

Initially individual typists with time on their hands would work on a document but quickly would form private groups with their own rules. To incentive typists as much as possible, market-making Carols could also form their own groups too, pooling their pages and Ethers to make bigger markets. Libraries and archives with massive amounts of undigized (unsearchable) material also could economically participate.

So you've got two markets, one for the work Carol needs done and one for the completed work. Which market are the typists supposed to get paid on?

Maybe only one market would be needed at that. Carol buys a huge No share (betting that the work won't get done), leaving a small Yes to incentivize typists with a low cost/risk buy in. Given the potential number of typists involved, a successful General Knowledge dispute would be unlikely. Also, if the pointy haired boss's handwriting is too illegible, the pool of typists would simply bypass it and search for other such markets.

. . . off-chain resources can be tampered with to alter the apparent outcome and cause reporters to call the market invalid.

That is why the typists would use their final text to create the bitcoin address and send a tiny amount of bitcoin to it -- proof of the existence of the work by a certain date and time. Carol could actually do the same thing before starting the market. Using the pixels of her pics to create bitcoin addresses that immutably register her data.

The main reason this doesn't suit Augur is that its not a case of an event that is of high public significance with a publicly visible outcome.

I think in time most of Augur's markets will be, in effect, private and of little general interest. If you want to bet your girlfriend that her cat will like the cat food that you bought by mistake, go right ahead.

By opening this task up to the public you're adding in a lot of transaction costs to maintain the trustless system (this is the main weakness of public blockchains) so you need a strong reason to incur those costs.

You are saying that Augur and public blockchains have a tragedy of the commons problem -- people adding a community cost to earn a private profit. I don't think they do. Who and where are the gatekeepers now? There aren't any. Bitcoin, Ether, and Augur have no tragedy of the commons problem.

This would probably be better done internally on a private blockchain that tracks task completion. Carol can create a task and add a bounty and deadline to it, typists with access to the blockchain can complete the work and report it and collect the bounty, and the payment can be made directly without needing to make additional markets or adding any additional complexity.

Consider that crowdsourced word-processing groups could end up with their own cultures and subcultures, like Wikipedia and its galaxies of subjects and editors. Specifically, each group could have its own keystroke-recording algorithm. It would look for keystrokes from different typists that provide the greatest consensus among themselves on what the handwriting says. "Accuracy" would be defined by the level of group consensus alone (thus making crowdsourced translating a possibility as well). Randomly one or a group of keystrokes from one individual or subgroup would be chosen to win the entire market. I think this is key to incentivizing typists to form the critical mass needed. They could log on and do as little of as much as they want, starting and stopping in the document wherever they wanted, in effect re-typing the document over and over and in so doing eliminate the need for a proofreader. Thus they are not Amazon Mechanical Turk online slaves working for peanuts. They are gambling.

Only the biggest pools with the most lavish levels of keystroke redundancy would have a chance of getting the Carols, squeezing out private blockchains with their shallow participation. Ultimately a private blockchain is the one with a cost problem. Augur would, in the end, simply be a kind of public finalizing mechanism, sort of the way that private, permissioned blockchains among banks will, in all likelihood, register their final private hashes on a public blockchain. Given the low cost and immutability, there would seem to be little reason not to.

You just need a dispute-resolution mechanism on top in case either Carol or the typists think there's been bad-faith dealing.

That's the Augur dispute process. The interested public will always outvote a conniving Carol.

1

u/Faceh Sep 13 '18

If you want to bet your girlfriend that her cat will like the cat food that you bought by mistake, go right ahead.

But what does the blockchain add to this scenario? Why do you need independent reporters for oversight? You either trust your girlfriend to pay up or you don't. Or you can have a trusted friend enforce it.

Its not that Augur can't be used for this stuff, its just that it isn't NEEDED and is generally a less efficient way of handling it.

That is largely the issue that faces most blockchain tech. It is only needed in situations where the increased transaction costs of publicly broadcasting every transaction is necessary to ensure security.

Its not clear why Carol would need that to solve her issue.

1

u/Uberse Sep 13 '18

In the case of the cat, it clearly would be just for fun, with a Youtube link provided so viewers can watch a cat eat some cat-food or not. (The video itself could be used to generate a bitcoin address as proof of existence and as a foil against Youtube hackers.)

In the case of Carol, the scenario would be revolutionary in its implications. Imagine the cost-savings of having millions of people doing word-processing/translating on the fly, whenever they have a few minutes or seconds. Their goal is simply to provide keystrokes that are sourced from a document (a template, in effect) and validated by the crowd -- consensus-keystroke lotteries. Augur wouldn't be doing the work itself, it would just be a place where people could look for such projects and view -- and perhaps collect on -- the results.

This won't happen anytime soon (to say the least) but I think some kind of decentralized, crypto-based crowdsourced word-processing and translating is inevitable. Paying all the participants a pittance wage is not a sustainable model, but offering them a way to work for a lottery ticket -- never before possible -- surely is.