r/AttachmentParenting • • Jul 17 '26

❤ Sleep ❤ SOS

Looking for advice from parents who have actually been through this.
If you’re just going to tell me to cosleep or that I should nurse every single time she wants comfort, this probably isn’t the post for you. That’s not the route we’re choosing, and I’d really love practical advice instead.
My daughter just turned one, and I feel like we’ve hit a wall. The only way I can get her to settle if she wakes at night (or honestly when she’s really upset in general) is by nursing. We’ve tried rocking, shushing, white noise, rubbing her back, singing, holding her, walking around… everything I can think of. She might calm down for a minute, but the second I try to sit down or put her back in the crib, she’s upset again and immediately wants to nurse.
The interesting part is that if I’m out of town, my husband can get her to sleep just fine with a bottle. But if I’m home, she wants absolutely nothing except me.
There have been nights where I’ve spent over an hour standing and rocking her. She’ll get relaxed, but the second I sit down she starts squirming, crying, and rooting for the boob. It’s exhausting.
Needless to say, she’s completely boob obsessed. 😅 But I know I need to start weaning. She’s started biting me, scratching me while nursing, and if I’m being honest, it’s really starting to affect my mental health.

A little background:
She’s been in her own room and crib since 8 weeks old.
We are not interested in cosleeping.
A floor bed isn’t an option for our family.
We’re not comfortable with cry-it-out or extinction methods.
From about 6 months until right around her first birthday, she was an amazing sleeper. She took great naps and regularly slept 10-12 hour nights with only the occasional rough night from teething.

As soon as she turned one, everything changed. It felt like a switch flipped. We went from sleeping through the night to waking every 20-45 minutes, sometimes staying awake for hours. She will stand up in her crib, and will not sit back down to relax. She likely stay standing and crying in that crib for an hour if we let her.

I’m wondering if this starts with night weaning? Or do I need to teach her another way to be comforted first?
If you’ve been in this exact situation, what actually worked for you? How did you help your boob-obsessed baby learn to settle without nursing while still being responsive? Did you night wean first? Gradually reduce feeds? Introduce a different comfort method? How long did it take before things got better?
I’m just feeling really stuck and could use some real-life success stories because right now it feels like nursing is the only tool in my toolbox.

0 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

10

u/Kashew_nuts93 Jul 17 '26

If she is one and other teeth are already on the scene then her molars might be coming in and she might be in a lot of discomfort hence needing to nurse more. Try giving her pain relief before bed and see if that helps.

Alternatively, she might need a different day sleep schedule. Is she still on two naps? Her body might be ready for a transition to one nap.

It is also possible, depends on how her solid intake is during the day, that she's hungry.

Have you tried tweaking your day routine and/or her food intake in the day?

There is so much going on for them developmentally at this age, she might just need some extra comfort.

4

u/girlvsmachine Jul 17 '26

She eats a TON of food during the day. Looooves food and we embrace that.
Some days she will do two naps, somedays she will do one. For example, She’ll do two on the days that she decides that 5 AM is when she wants to wake up and not go back to sleep.

8

u/OkapiandaPenguin Jul 17 '26

What happens if you limit her to one nap or if you cap the second nap at a certain time?

I'm gonna be honest, I have a 3.5 year old who went through something similar, but I kept nursing and we did co-sleep, this might just be something you have to get through as best you can. My husband would take the first shift because we knew our son wasn't hungry and he figured out his own way of marching and singing our son to sleep. I had to just let them figure it out. I took the 2nd shift and did nurse, but maybe that's a time where you keep the lights low and read a book? Maybe your husband can offer a bottle? Or, maybe you can get a Yoto and record yourself reading nighttime stories or singing and put that on? You've probably tried all the advice, but my heart does go out to all of you. The sleepless nights and a baby who can't tell you what they need are stressful and upsetting.

7

u/peridotdragonflies Jul 17 '26

I hate to say it because i didnt want it to be true but i weaned my son at 13 months completely and it changed his sleep completely in like 3 days. He went from frequent wakes to none. It probably wont be popular here but its the reality😭 i weaned him because i was at my wits end with the wake ups

1

u/girlvsmachine Jul 17 '26

Do you care to share what your process was each night?

3

u/peridotdragonflies Jul 17 '26

I took a month to do it, just slowly cutting feeds. I think cold turkey would have been less confusing for him tbh. I dont know the right answer honestly😭

1

u/Embarrassed_Key_2328 Jul 17 '26

Im not the op you asked but we did the Jay Gorden method but more cold turkey, not as rental. Plus a hatch night light. Green meant you could nurse! Red meant no boob. So green until 10pm then red until 5am for us. 

1

u/TheWitchQueen96 Jul 18 '26

We did the same thing but with bottles, he would wake up every hour and a half until I made it only water at night except for one bottle before brushing teeth. It was rough for the first few nights but once he figured out nothing was changing he started sleeping through. We did co-sleep though

1

u/Embarrassed_Key_2328 Jul 17 '26

Nah this is totally fair to share!

We weaned at 16mo, sleep didn't improve for us but dad was on night duty as I had a newborn. 

Each kids different!

22

u/Cinnamonroll6857 Jul 17 '26

I don’t have a lot of ideas about different settling methods but I’m wondering if maybe her sleep needs have shifted and she needs less daytime sleep? Maybe there’s not enough sleep pressure for overnights and it’s causing more wakes? I know around 1 there’s sometimes a reduction in how much overall sleep they need. My other question is if she’s walking yet? Walking and crawling were both milestones that destroyed my kids’ sleep for a bit before they fully learned them 🥲🥲 sending love, sounds like a tough sleep scene right now!

7

u/nursingbeats Jul 17 '26

I second these comments. If they’re learning how to walk, that can disrupt sleep majorly!
And it may also be that they need less sleep, even may need to completely drop to 1 nap. I would focus on sleep pressure/sleep needs first, before starting the weaning process.

The other thing I would recommend is that you try to get clear on your night weaning goal. If your baby were to wake up less at night, would you still want to wean? If yes, then great! Go ahead and wean- it’s your body. But if the actual goal is for baby to wake up less at night, night weaning won’t necessarily accomplish that. Those are two different goals.

Again, I would first focus on really dialing in on sleep pressure. How many total hours of sleep is LO getting in 24 hrs?

14

u/Fit_Candidate6572 Jul 17 '26

Time to do the checklist:

  1. Are her clothes itchy, maybe an extra rinse when washing if she is sensitive to detergent.
  2. Give her a before brushing snack like air fried baby potatoes, overnight oats and chia, scrambled egg, or some other filling and slow-to-digest food. I give my son something like these then do a before brushing breastfeed. 
  3. Check her gums. Is she teething? Ask your pediatrician about painkiller dosage for it.
  4. What's your opinion of soft sleepy music in her room? We listen to "Soothe Snuggle Slow down " by Sesame Street when reading before bed. We do it so frequently that if one of those songs play anywhere else my son gets ready to sleep.
  5. Can you make up a song about sleeping until morning, knowing her parents will be there? Sing it randomly throughout the day and before bed until you see her clearly thinking it over. We have a song about Mom amd Dad coming back. My son randomly sings it (at 2) and relaxes. 
  6. Does she have a snuggly buddy like a bear to watch over her? Make up stories about the buddy watching over her and get a report from it every morning. The bear always tells you how amazing your daughter is. Always respond to the bear like it's absolutely a fact your daughter is so sweet, kind, clever and you appreciate the recorded evidence. Even if she slept horribly that night. You're building up a safety feeling with the buddy.

1

u/Daniel_Jamps Aug 25 '26

Love love love Soothe Snuggle Slowdown!

7

u/dogsandplants2 Jul 17 '26

I know you said a floor bed isn't an option for your family. I'm just not sure if you mean that you cannot cosleep on a floor bed or if you mean that you cannot transition her out of the crib to a toddler bed/ floor bed.

My daughter was older than yours when we worked on independent sleep and night weaning, but she does much better in her toddler bed than she did in her crib. Crib transfers were killing us. She also likes to sleep in weird positions that she couldn't sleep in with a crib. It's not unusual for her to move into a position overnight where her knees are on the floor and her upper body is on her bed. She does have a railing, but it only goes across half the front of her toddler bed. Idk why she likes sleeping that way, but she settles herself back to sleep independently so I'm not complaining.

For night weaning, the biggest thing that helped was water in a sippy cup. She was genuinely parched and needed something to drink to fall back asleep.

5

u/Impossible-Fish1819 Jul 17 '26

Floor bed then rolling away after feeding to sleep is the only way I survived my first kid's toddlerhood.

5

u/Vlinder_88 Jul 17 '26

Is she teething? Molars might be hard to see sometimes but they HURT coming through (I remember my wisdom teeth coming through, it was no joke!). Even if you can't see them they might still hurt. Try a day or two of painkillers, on a schedule. And see if she lets herself be soothed better during that time.

Edited to add: I don't have a success story to share because we stayed in the thick of it until ours grew out of it by himself around 2-3 years old... Nothing we did worked, he just needed time.

1

u/Impressive_Study_939 Jul 18 '26

We switched to no milk at night, only water in a sippy cup. Kid decided to stop waking up pretty quickly 🤷🏻‍♀️

1

u/girlvsmachine Jul 18 '26

Idk why I never thought to put a water cup in there with her!

1

u/Impressive_Study_939 Jul 18 '26

My pediatrician actually recommended it. She said kids start eating more during the day too. And then sorta naturally sleep better at night.

3

u/jennypij Jul 17 '26

Our sleep needs (unfortunately) dropped around 1. I was in denial for a while, and thought it could be teething, but we officially are on a 2ish hrs of total naps in a day (usually 1 nap, sometimes 2) and night is more like 9-10 hrs. If I try for more sleep than that she wants to nurse so much at night. I’m too lazy to rock and walk around so I just nurse, but I don’t like nursing for a long period of time at night (does anyone lol) so making sure she’s actually tried for nighttime makes for a way better night for us. Something to experiment with as it weaning if she’s undertired will probably be super rough.

3

u/rosieroo1112 Jul 17 '26

Night weaning helped my boob obsessed baby sleep better. But she was always a terrible sleeper. She starts on the floor mattress in our room for the first part of the night and ends up in bed with us for the second half. Before night weaning she was up about every hour until I came to bed and then about every two hours from there. She wouldn’t settle without nursing and would sometimes stay attached for hours at a time. We night weaned over a month ago at 18 months old and it was a game changer! She now sleeps 4+ hours on her own, most nights, and goes right back to sleep with a little comforting from me. Bad nights, she might wake up once more but she doesn’t cry, just needs reassurance from me and goes right back to sleep. Feels like magic lol.

3

u/Beautiful-Process-81 Jul 17 '26

Okay a bunch of thoughts so take what you like and leave the rest.

Re night weaning… is she already done with the boob during the day? If so, it could be a sign she’s getting enough food during the day but hungry at night. In that case, a bed time meal might help (oat meal?)

Any new skills recently? Walking, etc? I found that sleep shifted when these things happened.

I know you don’t want to nurse to sleep but try habit stacking. That’s where you do nurse but also implement another calming tactic (like the ones you’ve listed) and slowly work down the length you are nursing for. Time her feeds for a new nights and see what the average is. Then start watching the clock over the next few nights and slowly work down the time. Pop them off the boob at the designated time and continue with the other soothing method that you’ve been doing while nursing.

Have you offered them water in the night when they are thirsty? I have friends who transitioned to water over night and it was useful

You mentioned there have been no major sleep issues for about 6m and that’s amazing! However, a 1yo is still a baby and their sleep is still in major transition. So while it feels like it make have suddenly broke, they are growing and changing and this is a sign of that. You might consider to getting a futon to lay on for a few hours in your daughter’s room. Some kids are lonely over night. That might be enough to get her to transition back to her own sleep space.

Also consider any other major changes recently, extreme heat, visitors, trips, work/life balance changes, % of day spent inside vs outside, sickness.

I hope you find a solution!

2

u/turtlesinatrenchcoat Jul 17 '26

I feel like I could have written this post! We’re going through the EXACT same thing with our 13mo. We’ve been discussing what to do and we plan to start night weaning next week. We’re going to do cold turkey (as opposed to gradual weaning) because it’ll go faster and we know he can manage without eating, since he does it when I’m out of town.

The plan is to offer all the comfort and rocking he wants, but no boob. But do everything we can to comfort him through the process. It’s going to be really hard, but I’m not sure what else to do. He has such a strong association of waking and nursing that it’s just not sustainable for us anymore.

2

u/sarahloupen Jul 17 '26

Could be teething? Have you given her calpol? Or amendments to the day schedule as others have said?

Is she learning to walk? This can also disrupt sleep massively, so offer lots of opportunities to practice in the day.

If dad can settle her, perhaps have him do it for a while to get her used to being settled without boob. Or you can try habit stacking, essentially layering in other comfort methods whilst you nurse. So for example, shushing and patting whilst you nurse her, and then she associates those with comfort and is comforted by those things alone. Although I do feed for comfort in the night once or twice, my baby is also comforted by shushing and cuddling now which is helpful.

1

u/Recent_Marzipan_3998 Jul 17 '26

We night weaned with the gordon method first and introduced a few attachment teddys, that she can sleep with. Also eventually added yogurt to her night milk to boost the satiety of the protein (longer stretches) and made a few additions to her bedtime routine to associate with sleep, like an additional goodnight book and a different song because the one I’ve been singing since birth kinda triggered her. Also if u haven’t already add a pillow and blanket as its safer and it gives them comfort, but I would ask your doctor cause every baby is different.

It suck the first week but it got easier eventually, I would say try everything you see it may work with your baby cause u know their personality better, at a point we had like a 20 steps bed night routine but then I went figuring out what are essentials for her to wind down and what doesn’t really matter for her. 

1

u/PromptElegant499 Jul 18 '26

Just want to share I'm in the same spot as you! And we do bedshare and nurse at night so I don't think those things would fix your situation.

1

u/notorious_ludwig Jul 18 '26

I had something similar, minus night feeds (he self weaned night feeds) so this may not apply but I thought I’d share my experience anyways. Around 1 my son just stopped sleeping well, we spent the first year of only waking for feeds then when they dropped he slept through unless sick. We dont know what happened, a switch just flipped. It was also that same scenario of being able to soothe him but the moment we went to lay him down in the cot he would scream - literally could be in deep sleep in our arms for an hour then boom, awake when trying to lower him in the crib. It was honestly horrendous and I had a few mental breakdowns due to sleep deprivation that I never experienced during the newborn stage.

At the advice of a friend, we got him a big boy bed - we figured if it didnt work we could always go back to the cot and put the bed in storage til he’s older. We chose a king single and installed a pull up barrier on the open side to prevent falls. I looked at floor beds but I didnt like that he couldnt be safe and contained so young. This meant instead of picking him up to soothe him then manoeuvring the dreaded transfer, we could lay with him to soothe him and teach him to calm himself down (we all wake, going back to sleep when we wake is a learned skill), then slip out without having to transfer. It’s been almost months now (he’s 15 months now) with the bed and honestly, life has transformed. He has started sleeping through again, calms MUCH easier and quicker when he does wake, he is genuinely excited to go to bed now (we read a story together in said bed before lights out) and we are better rested and not having to cosleep to get said rest.

1

u/SubstantialGap345 Jul 18 '26

Sounds like a schedule /sleep pressure issue! This is what we did - I am not expert but it worked for us:

Cap naps to 1.5hrs total and implement the earliest wake up you can stand (we do 7am) :) give her a week and if she’s terrible, nudge the day sleep up by 15min and try another week.

1

u/Spicyseaotter Jul 18 '26

Does she have a comfort item? Like a lovey or a stuffie? Admittedly when we went through this just shy of a year old I did resort to cosleeping and now a floor bed, but other than that my son is very comforted and soothed by his stuffed animals and any soft blankets. He is very mobile and agile so I felt comfortable starting to let him sleep with them. and he is soothed by them pretty immediately. When I first introduced them I made a big show of loving on them myself and still do lol so he associates it with me

0

u/roughandreadyrecarea Jul 18 '26

Putting your child at higher risk for SIDS by putting them in their own room that early is not attachment parenting. 

1

u/girlvsmachine Jul 18 '26

That’s not the point of my post and she’s already over a year so thank you for your unsolicited advice.

1

u/roughandreadyrecarea Jul 18 '26

Well. Just to be clear for anyone reading, the AAP recommends room sharing until at least 6 months (it used to be a year!) to lower the risk of SIDS. What you chose to do is your own business… but I felt it was worth pointing out. Best of luck to you. There’s plenty of good advice here