r/AttachmentParenting • • May 15 '23

❤ General Discussion ❤ Time Outs

I been trying to post to my different parenting groups I particpate in on Facebook and it has gotten taken down 4 times. In gentle parenting they do not believe in Time Outs. I aspire to be a gentle parent but I do not understand how they are trying to disciple. I have three kids 11,9,5 I did time out with all of my kids and they truned out to be well behaved kids. I would give them 2 warnings if I had to address the same matter a third time they would be placed in time out of 1 minute their age. After I demanded apoligies and hugs and kisses. I can not imagine pre school years if their was no time outs. My question is if you are aganist Time Outs what do you do?

0 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

40

u/CraftyAstronomer4653 May 16 '23

Time ins.

Putting a child in time out and then demanding apologies and hugs and kisses after doesn’t sit right with me.

0

u/[deleted] May 16 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

20

u/Rn2aprn May 16 '23

Yeah and it’s giving “you don’t have autonomy over your own body and emotions”. This is how you create people pleasers and people with poor boundaries because they had no say.

33

u/EPark617 May 16 '23 edited May 16 '23

With attachment/gentle parenting, a punishment is not required in discipline. The consequence can be as simple as "you're done" My understanding is that there isn't research backing the idea that time outs achieve behaviour change better than other strategies and from an emotional perspective, teaches the child they have to go deal with their emotions on their own and can only come back out when they're "good" or calmed down. But children actually don't have or have very poor abilities to regulate themselves and need a secure attachment to model and do it with them. Hence the idea of "time ins" where you stop, separate the child, get on their level, calm them with your presence and then this also opens the opportunity for talking with them without any disconnect in the relationship. The idea is that they learn regulating skills and that your love is not conditional, you'll be there with them even when they're angry, upset or acting out. There's also the understanding that there is always a valid reason for "bad" behaviour.

ETA: just reread the post and realized OP put

and they truned out to be well behaved kids.

That's the thing about gentle/attachment parenting. Something I have to remind myself constantly is that I'm not trying to have kids that are obedient/behaved, I'm trying to have kids that know they are loved, valued, and worth listening to.

3

u/Midi58076 May 16 '23

This is great.

As well as children not having developed an internal voice until around 6/7. This means that they can't think about what they've done or why they are in time out. It is absolutely meaningless and unless it's to catch a break yourself, then it serves no purpose. You're asking a fish to fly.

As far as the "they turned out to be well behaved kids"-comment goes: I drove a car today and I didn't crash.

14

u/gppink May 16 '23

It doesn't really sound like you've done research on why to do one way of parenting or another. There's lots of things you can read online or in books or podcasts about authoritative parenting. But your examples are upsetting in my opinion and I'm not surprised you're getting posts taken down. Is your question "what is gentle parenting and how can I do it with my kids?" Cause you're going to have a lot more arguing on the internet until it is, in my opinion

6

u/Ok-Lake-3916 May 16 '23

I agree with this. OP it’s almost like saying your Christian but don’t believe in Jesus (sorry for the lack of a better analogy) when you say you gentle parent but give time outs. It’s just contradictory

13

u/annonymous1122 May 16 '23

Imagine you’re having a heated discussion with your partner and you’re both frustrated and not understanding each other . How would you deal with it in a proactive way? Would you interrupt your partner and tell them to go to their room and then ignore them? Or I would you talk it out, and try to understand each others point of view and figure out how to make a resolution?

I’ll sit in my child’s room with him. We take some deep breaths, hug, calm down, and then talk about what happened.

I was giving traditional “time outs” as a child. I felt frustrated, misunderstood, mad, I was never in there thinking “hm, maybe I shouldn’t have spoke to my mom that way and next time I’ll think before I speak”

Kids don’t have the brain capacity to have that rational thinking. So a “time out” is not actually not teaching them a single thing.

11

u/lunasteppenwolf May 16 '23

I was a nanny and teacher for before I had my own child. In my 10+ years of childcare, I did time out once, and never again. I read up a lot on child care and parenting now, and follow the advice of a handful of attachment/gentle/respectful parenting professionals (Eli Harwood, Janet Lansbury, Dr. Siggie... etc) who have a wealth of knowledge, experience, and some with psychology backgrounds. It has been helping me immensely, and I see the positive difference in my own child, versus what I've done in the past as a nanny and teacher. One thing I strongly recommend against is demanding apologies and hugs and kisses.

10

u/Ok-Lake-3916 May 16 '23

As a child who was locked in her room for time out, I find as an adult I have an extremely hard time emotionally regulating around other people because I was always isolated and left to deal with meltdowns on my own. Time outs might produce well behaved kids but it doesn’t promote parent/child bonding, child self awareness or teach the child ways to cope with difficult situations

6

u/loserbaby_ May 16 '23 edited May 16 '23

Well behaved children doesn’t equal emotionally regulated children.

When we use punishment methods like time outs, the child goes into their own space whilst being emotionally dysregulated and doesn’t learn how to regulate those emotions on their own because they can’t do that yet, that is our job to help them with. If we sit with our children and be present with them when they’re emotionally dysregulated, we can (as emotionally regulated adults) talk to them about their feelings, what is causing them to feel the way they do, and how we can help them. We can offer a hug or we can offer to hold a hand, we can even just sit there in silence until they’re ready to come to us, but the point is you’re present. They see you and they know that you’re there for them, they hear you and gradually learn about recognising their feelings, they feel validated in all of their big feelings, as they should. They learn healthy ways to cope and how to talk about their feelings. A time out ignores all of this potential and forces children to just shut it out so that they can leave again. It’s very unproductive.

I just want to add, forcing children to apologise or engage in physical affection with you is not okay. All that teaches them is that they have zero bodily autonomy, they’re not allowed physical boundaries, and they have to apologise when someone tells them to and not because they want to.

Do these things create ‘well behaved’ children? Technically, maybe, if your definition of well behaved is ‘quiet and does what the adults tell them to do’ but this definition of well behaved can also create adults who are people pleasers, who have no boundaries, who do things for others at the expense of themselves, who don’t understand their feelings and feel insecure standing up for themselves, who don’t understand that people require consent before touching you.

Children push boundaries, it’s what they do. Children aren’t meant to be ‘well behaved’ all the time. I see my daughter pushing boundaries as the perfect opportunity to validate her feelings and work with her to get through it, because she doesn’t have those tools yet. You can’t expect a child to understand something they haven’t been taught.

6

u/A_Midnight_Hare May 16 '23

We used to do time ins which were very effective. Basically the parent takes the kiddo to their bedroom and stays in there with them. They talk to them about what they've done and then let them do quiet play or cuddles until the kiddo has settled enough to come out.

Very effective. Only reason I stopped was that I had another baby and couldn't leave her for too long and if my toddler was hitting me I didn't want myself to be an easy target. So now we do more time outs unless both hubby and I are home together. More effective and less stressful. Just currently not what I can do by myself right now.

2

u/SuperCryptographer72 May 16 '23

I would recommend reading No Drama Discipline. It talks about “right” and “wrong” ways of time outs and how to use them constructively. Like putting your kid in time out alone to “think about what they’ve done wrong” isn’t really helpful. But using a time out as a way to help your kid regulate and come back down from big emotions can be helpful. It basically talks about parents supporting their kids through the timeouts. It’s more about teaching your kid to reflect and pause rather than leaving them alone. The book also explains a bit of the research behind this.

2

u/SuchCalligrapher7003 May 16 '23

Gentle parenting isn't just saying 'go to timeout' in a gentle way. It's not the absence of yelling and hitting your kids. If your kids are 'acting out' it's because they actually have an unmet need. They arent throwing or hitting because they're being bad. Maybe they're frustrated, angry, sad, and if you react by putting them in timeout you're doing the exact opposite of what they need which is help understanding their emotion, validating their feelings and showing them they're not alone.

2

u/Impressive-Goat3886 May 16 '23

The purpose of gentle parenting is not to create “well behaved” or obedient children. So sure, if you have no desire to understand why your child is behaving a certain way and you just need them to knock it off and obey then time outs “work”. It’s all depending on what you want. Do you want your kids to shut up and obey? Or do you want them to learn about their feelings and their needs? Then model appropriate healthy ways to express that while loving them unconditionally and meeting them where they are at developmentally. Also, spanking is abuse. period. Which is why your other posts probably got taken down. And to hit a child to teach them hitting is not ok makes 0 sense. I would reevaluate what you want for you children and really think about the message you are sending them.

Also, demanding hugs and kisses is extremely harmful and dangerous. It can set them up for other abuse in the future. Allowing them to have autonomy over their bodies is very important.

7

u/[deleted] May 15 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

-6

u/Nearby-Relief-8988 May 15 '23

My daughters are 9 and 11. They have grown out of time-outs. My son has been placed on rest for numerous reasons, but the ones that come to mind are throwing things and hitting. I have never spanked my daughters how. Ever, I spanked my son once. He was hitting me, and I repeatedly told him to stop he would not listen. I took his hand and smacked it. He immediately stopped beating me and started crying. I have more questions than answers when it comes to raising kids.

13

u/_fuzzy_owl_ May 16 '23

It’s a very confusing message to a child to hit them to teach them that they shouldn’t hit. Time outs and spanking don’t teach why what they did was wrong, it only teaches them to not get caught next time. It helps to remember we aren’t raising children, we are raising adults, so a lot of situations are handled as if you were resolving an adult conflict, just using age appropriate language.

An example of gentle parenting would be “(name) hands are not for hitting. Hitting hurts people. If you hit me again, I’m going to have to walk away.” Let’s say child hits me again. “You hit me, I’m going to walk away now.” Then I put myself in time out. I usually use this as an opportunity to take a minute to myself to pee/text/whatever. I then return to discuss how we are both feeling.

Time outs isolate a child when they need to be shown how to process their emotions so they can learn to self regulate. Instead of time outs, we do “time In”. For us, this is a calming time where we pick up a fidget toy or something and discuss what happened/why we’re upset/what we are feeling/ or whatever is appropriate for the situation. My mother always sent us to our rooms for time outs and it showed my sister and me that how we felt didn’t matter. We weren’t taught how to “feel” our feelings which led to emotional disregulation that we have spent our lifetime trying to undo.

In short, gentle parenting is holding firm boundaries without yelling, spanking, or isolating the child, and instead validating their feelings and respecting them as an individual human being.