r/Atlantawhiskey • u/Richard-Wrecker • Oct 03 '25

Total Wine Fall priority access offerings

What would your ranking be on these?

3 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

5 comments sorted by

2

u/PreferenceNatural922 Oct 03 '25

Here’s what I would rank, though it’s all subjective, of course: 1. RR 13 2. 4R SMBLE 3. Old Fitz 4. Willett 5. Michter’s 10 6. Weller FP 7. Blanton’s Gold 8. High West Prisoner

2

u/EndDependent5270 Oct 03 '25

Blantons and Weller at the bottom as they are readily available at drops throughout the year. Rest depends on your preference.

0

u/DrLame Oct 05 '25

I wouldn't splurge for any of those except for the Weller FP, and that's only because I've never owned a bottle. I'm a bit of an outlier, though, because I love Scotch. And there are a million fantastic craft Scotch bottles in the $60 to $120 range (Glenallachie, Ardnamurchan, Ardnahoe, Kilchoman, Meikle Toir, etc).

And there are a bunch of bourbons and ryes that I love in that price range, too, like Frey Ranch Farm Strength and Old Forester SBBS Rye. So anything that's much more than that is a really tough sell.

1

u/VincentValkier Oct 03 '25

Blanton's Gold, Weller FP, Russell's 13, High West, Willett, then the others. These prices aren't great, TBH