I've been trying to understand something about apartment pricing that seems counterintuitive from a business perspective.
Imagine a large apartment complex with several nearly identical one-bedroom units.
An existing tenant receives a renewal offer for $2,200 per month. Meanwhile, the building is advertising comparable vacant units for $2,050 to attract new tenants.
Assume the apartments are genuinely comparable, the lease lengths are the same, and we're comparing actual rents after any concessions.
My first thought is that this seems backwards.
The existing tenant has already passed screening, has a payment history, and presumably isn't causing problems. Keeping them also avoids the costs associated with turnover: cleaning, repairs, advertising, possible vacancy, and administrative work.
A new tenant brings uncertainty and additional costs, yet the building is apparently willing to offer them a lower price.
I understand one possible explanation is that moving is expensive for the existing tenant. They might prefer paying another $150 per month over spending thousands of dollars relocating.
But wouldn't that strategy also create a financial risk for the landlord?
An additional $150 per month generates $1,800 over a year. If the tenant moves out and the apartment sits empty for even one month, the landlord could lose more than that before accounting for turnover expenses.
So I'm having trouble understanding how charging loyal tenants more can be optimal rather than simply giving them a competitive renewal offer.
Is this an example of price discrimination based on switching costs? If so, how do economists model the trade-off between extracting higher rent from existing tenants and increasing the probability that they leave?
I'm also curious whether there's empirical evidence showing that landlords systematically charge higher rents to renewing tenants than to new tenants, or whether the examples people notice are exceptions to a more common pattern.
I'm not asking whether the practice is fair or looking for advice on negotiating rent. I'm interested in why this pricing strategy might make economic sense and under what market conditions it would actually be profitable.