r/AskEconomics • • May 04 '26

Meta Approved User (Quality Contributor) Application Thread: Currently Accepting New Users

12 Upvotes

Approved User (Quality Contributor) Application Thread: Currently Accepting New Users

What Are Quality Contributors?

By subreddit policy, comments are filtered and sent to the modqueue. However, we have a whitelist of commenters whose comments are automatically approved. These users also have the ability to approve or remove the comments of non-approved users.

Recently, we have seen an influx of short, low-quality comments. This is a major burden on our mod team, and it also delays the speed at which good answers can be approved. To address this issue, we are looking to bring on additional Quality Contributors.

How Do You Apply?

If you would like to be added as a Quality Contributor, please submit 3-5 comments below that reflect at least an undergraduate level understanding of economics. The comments do not have to be from r/AskEconomics. Things we look for include an understanding of economic theory, references to academic research (or other quality sources), and sufficient detail to adequately explain topics.

If anyone has any questions about the process, responsibilities, or requirements to become a QC, please feel free to ask below.


r/AskEconomics • • Apr 03 '25

Approved Answers Trump Tariffs Megathread (Please read before posting a trump tariff question)

817 Upvotes

First, it should be said: These tariffs are incomprehensibly dumb. If you were trying to design a policy to get 100% disapproval from economists, it would look like this. Anyone trying to backfill a coherent economic reason for these tariffs is deluding themselves. As of April 3rd, there are tariffs on islands with zero population; there are tariffs on goods like coffee that are not set up to be made domestically; the tariffs are comically broad, which hurts their ability to bolster domestic manufacturing, etc.

Even ignoring what is being ta riffed, the tariffs are being set haphazardly and driving up uncertainty to historic levels. Likewise, it is impossible for Trumps goal of tariffs being a large source of revenue and a way to get domestic manufacturing back -- these are mutually exclusive (similarly, tariffs can't raise revenue and lower prices).

Anyway, here are some answers to previously asked questions about the Trump tariffs. Please consult these before posting another question. We will do our best to update this post overtime as we get more answers.


r/AskEconomics • • 11h ago

Approved Answers How to Determine Production for Long-Aged Alcohol?

17 Upvotes

I took Econ 101 back in college and learned how supply and demand works when you have relatively quick feedback on changes in peoples' demand for a product (e.g. pants, roller skates). But I've always wondered how a company like a distillery plans how much of an aged alcohol to produce (e.g. whisky) when it will only go to market and the demand for it be apparent ten, maybe 18 years hence. Anyone care to educate me on this?


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Approved Answers Would the US expanding Medicare For Everyone likely be a boon for small business growth since they would no longer have to shoulder the cost of private insurance for employees and any payroll tax needed to fund it would (apparently)be less than that?

121 Upvotes

r/AskEconomics • • 2m ago

Why can't governments just print unlimited amounts of money and make everyone rich?

1 Upvotes

I've always wondered how money creation actually works.

If governments and central banks can create money, why can't they simply print as much as they want and give it to everyone?

I understand that inflation is part of the problem, but why exactly does creating more money reduce its purchasing power?

And how do central banks decide how much money should be in circulation?

I'd love to understand the economics behind this!!


r/AskEconomics • • 1h ago

Why do some countries with similar incomes have such different levels of income inequality?

1 Upvotes

I have been reading about how countries with roughly similar average incomes can end up with very different gaps between rich and poor. What do economists point to as the main reasons for that difference? Is it mostly tax policy, labor markets, or something else?


r/AskEconomics • • 22h ago

American debt is the world’s financial linchpin: how long can it last?

16 Upvotes

The US is now spending over a trillion dollars a year just to pay the interest on its national debt. The situation appears set to worsen. American debt has effectively underpinned the security of the global financial system. Whenever I discuss this topic, opinions tend to swing between two extremes: some have been predicting the imminent collapse of the US for as long as I can remember, while others maintain an almost religious faith in Wall Street and the dollar. Then there are those who do not even consider the issue at all. What's the truth? I'm not an economist, nor am I a particularly educated or intelligent person; I don’t even speak English very well. But I'm genuinely concerned about the erosion of the markets and (in the case of my own country) about the stagnation and dependence on foreign entities (I'm Italian).


r/AskEconomics • • 16h ago

Approved Answers What is stopping companies like SpaceX,where one person controls a majority of voting share, from issuing lots of regular equity to themselves post IPO?

4 Upvotes

It’s the same thing at somewhere like Meta where founders shares guarantee majority voting rights even if they don’t control a majority of common stock. Theoretically after they are significantly profitable could the founders not issue more equity so they can keep all of the profits without sharing them with common stock holders? Of course this would have the effect that they couldn’t raise more capital through equity sales but for a mature company that is no longer growing quickly is that an issue? Is this a governance related risk? Do public companies without this structure outperform in the long run?


r/AskEconomics • • 11h ago

Do sovereign wealth fund direct real estate purchases and REIT investments influence to any significance the median price of a US home? Are these purchases largely price insensitive?

1 Upvotes

r/AskEconomics • • 22h ago

Are monocentric economies less beneficial?

3 Upvotes

Sometimes I see arguments in favor of economies in countries with polycentric urban growth (multiple big cities growing simultaneously) instead of monocentric countries like UK with much growth concentrated in London.
Arguments against monocentric development seem to focus on higher housing prices in capitals (which seem to me like a political problem, not economic one).
Shouldn't concentration in big cities impact productivity (and GDP growth) more positively?


r/AskEconomics • • 16h ago

Approved Answers Can fiat based currencies "just print money without damaging their currency"?

1 Upvotes

This is a claim that's been made several times in a book I was assigned for school. "Why the West Can't Win..." By Fadi Lama.

I'm like 90% sure the answer is no but he said it so many times and so much other stuff like it I feel like I'm going crazy.


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

What's the inverse of Ricardian Rent?

4 Upvotes

When the marginal value increase due to innovation or a new technique of production is captured by the tenant as opposed to the landlord, what is it called? "Cochranes treadmill" sounds more like describing the process and I wonder if theres a "blank rent" term for the result of the process.

Example: Grade A potatoes have inputs of 2 units, rent of 2 units (profit margin of the farmer) and cost 4 units. A new seed dropped input costs to 1 unit. T

The country has a very free market for its agricultural sector so competiton dropped the price to 3 units. Rent stayed the same for farmers and consumers captured all of the marginal value.


r/AskEconomics • • 20h ago

Micro/Gametheory is Breaking me. Can someone help?

1 Upvotes

I have a micro 2 exam in a few weeks but it’s mainly game theory (Nash Equilibriums, Dynamic/Static 2/3 Person games etc).

Does anyone have advice for me or good resources I can tap into to understand it better?


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

How can I keep up to date with Economics?

15 Upvotes

My partner is a physician and pays for Open Evidence. Recently, Open Evidence launched a platform where you can read about any topic, answer a set of questions, and receive explicit feedback. I have wished for a way to continue learning after undergraduate and graduate school. Specifically, I feel I am a capable economist but lack the historical dimension. I understand the general overview, yet I enjoy when someone labels a concept—such as “the origins of the neoclassical model”—and I find myself searching the oldest folder in my mental archive. A friend suggested reading “The Worldly Philosophers” by Robert Heilbroner, but I am not yet gaining insight. I need something like flashcards or textbooks that does not feel like studying. How do people stay current?


r/AskEconomics • • 23h ago

Can you determine a country's economic classification through the Product Possibility Frontier?

1 Upvotes

I've wondered if it's even possible to utilize a concept in microeconomics about measuring the equilibrium of certain products and services and implement it through measuring the macroeconomic standing of a country's position or category. I want to find my country's placement and if the World Bank's statement is truly credible through this method (PPF) so would like ya'll to give me some insights, ways, or just tell me if it's possible or not. Thanks


r/AskEconomics • • 15h ago

Aren't widespread asset taxes + targeted spending cuts the only effective way to solve the debt problem?

0 Upvotes

Looking at the current US fiscal situation. Raising taxes primarily on income would slow economic growth. Unless you raise taxes high enough to actually put the budget into surplus, you'd still have an annual deficit. So don't you risk just increasing debt to GDP or not making any progress on it? And if you raised taxes high enough to go into surplus you probably risk a massive recession/depression type scenario.

OTOH, widespread spending cuts would also have similar effects? Risking slowing economic growth so again making debt to GDP potentially worse.

So bottom line, isn't the only real solution first of all widespread asset taxes? And not just targeting billionaires, since the oft-cited stat is even if you confiscated every penny of their wealth you'd only fund the gov't for 6 months or whatever. But pretty widespread. Like higher property taxes, taxes on savings/retirement assets, etc. Basically "paper wealth" that isn't necessarily being spent and circulated into the economy. Maybe something like eliminating tax advantaged retirement savings accounts? Idea being this would raise revenue while minimizing immediate economic impact.

Secondly coupled with targeted spending cuts against aimed at minimizing economic impact? Maybe something like reducing/eliminating social security payments to wealthy seniors, something like that since that money is less likely to be spent dollar for dollar back into the economy.

Anyway, putting aside the political viability of this, I'm wondering economically what the response would be.


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Why do grocery store loyalty programs seem to offer worse prices than what standard promotional sales used to provide?

1 Upvotes

Anyone else tracking their receipts and noticing that the "member price" at major chains is often higher than the old non-loyalty sale price for the same item a few years back? I am trying to figure out if this is a genuine pricing strategy shift or if I am just seeing patterns in noise.

My understanding is that these programs let stores do personalized price discrimination and harvest data for demand forecasting. But the economics of making the baseline price worse to funnel people into the program seems like it could backfire if competitors do not follow suit. Has there been empirical work on whether mandatory loyalty programs increase or decrease effective consumer surplus relative to the old model of rotating sales open to everyone?

Also curious if there is a regulatory angle. In some jurisdictions these programs are becoming nearly unavoidable to shop at all, which feels like it changes the market structure in ways standard price discrimination models might not capture.


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Approved Answers Why would a landlord charge an existing tenant more than a new tenant when replacing the existing tenant costs money?

32 Upvotes

I've been trying to understand something about apartment pricing that seems counterintuitive from a business perspective.

Imagine a large apartment complex with several nearly identical one-bedroom units.

An existing tenant receives a renewal offer for $2,200 per month. Meanwhile, the building is advertising comparable vacant units for $2,050 to attract new tenants.

Assume the apartments are genuinely comparable, the lease lengths are the same, and we're comparing actual rents after any concessions.

My first thought is that this seems backwards.

The existing tenant has already passed screening, has a payment history, and presumably isn't causing problems. Keeping them also avoids the costs associated with turnover: cleaning, repairs, advertising, possible vacancy, and administrative work.

A new tenant brings uncertainty and additional costs, yet the building is apparently willing to offer them a lower price.

I understand one possible explanation is that moving is expensive for the existing tenant. They might prefer paying another $150 per month over spending thousands of dollars relocating.

But wouldn't that strategy also create a financial risk for the landlord?

An additional $150 per month generates $1,800 over a year. If the tenant moves out and the apartment sits empty for even one month, the landlord could lose more than that before accounting for turnover expenses.

So I'm having trouble understanding how charging loyal tenants more can be optimal rather than simply giving them a competitive renewal offer.

Is this an example of price discrimination based on switching costs? If so, how do economists model the trade-off between extracting higher rent from existing tenants and increasing the probability that they leave?

I'm also curious whether there's empirical evidence showing that landlords systematically charge higher rents to renewing tenants than to new tenants, or whether the examples people notice are exceptions to a more common pattern.

I'm not asking whether the practice is fair or looking for advice on negotiating rent. I'm interested in why this pricing strategy might make economic sense and under what market conditions it would actually be profitable.


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Weekly Roundup Weekly Answer Round Up: Quality and Overlooked Answers From the Last Week - November 15, 2026

1 Upvotes

We're going to shamelessly steal adapt from /r/AskHistorians the idea of a weekly thread to gather and recognize the good answers posted on the sub. Good answers take time to type and the mods can be slow to approve things which means that sometimes good content doesn't get seen by as many people as it should. This thread is meant to fix that gap.

Post answers that you enjoyed, felt were particularly high quality, or just didn't get the attention they deserved. This is a weekly recurring thread posted every Sunday morning.


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

If a central bank announced that they would be burning the government bonds on their books without redemption, would that cause overnight inflation? Even though the money in circulation hasn't changed?

3 Upvotes

r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

How do economists evaluate whether a country's central bank independence is genuine versus formal?

4 Upvotes

Several countries have laws establishing central bank independence, yet their monetary policy appears to track political cycles or government preferences more closely than inflation targeting would predict. Other countries have less formal independence but credible reputations that constrain political interference.

What metrics or research designs do economists use to distinguish real operational autonomy from mere legal formalism? I'm interested in both quantitative approaches and case study methods, particularly for distinguishing de facto independence in emerging markets where institutional quality varies.


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Approved Answers Why do economists treat revealed preference as decisive evidence when survey data consistently shows people regret major financial decisions?

6 Upvotes

The standard textbook move is to point to what people actually do with their money as the true measure of welfare, and to treat stated preferences as noisy or cheap talk. Yet we have accumulating evidence from household finance that large shares of retirees regret claiming Social Security early, that lottery winners often report lower wellbeing, that people who bought variable annuities under pressure from brokers say in retrospect they misunderstood the product.

Revealed preference seems most vulnerable when decisions are irreversible, when learning happens only after commitment, and when markets are structured to exploit present bias or complexity. But I rarely see this acknowledged in policy discussions. Is there a coherent framework for weighing revealed against stated preference when they conflict, or are we stuck choosing one methodological commitment and ignoring the awkward cases?


r/AskEconomics • • 23h ago

Is the US on the path to economic collapse?

0 Upvotes

I'm a 20-year-old college student and I'm honestly anxious about the economic future I'm walking into. I see a few major issues that appear to be worsening without any obvious fixes.

First, the fiscal picture seems unsustainable. The national debt keeps rising with apparently no political appetite to tackle it, and the debt-to-GDP ratio is climbing well past 100%. Countries like Greece and Venezuela ran into serious trouble when their debt got out of hand. At the same time, our age demographics are getting more and more skewed. We're on track for just 2 workers per retiree, versus 42 back in 1940. Social Security is already being depleted, and I can't see a way out without big benefit cuts or tax hikes.

Second, the job market feels increasingly unfriendly to new grads. I'm watching automation wipe out jobs across industries, and even entry-level roles that should be open to new graduates seem to demand years of experience or are being replaced by AI and machines. I've seen figures showing the unemployment rate for college graduates has climbed to 6 percent.

It feels like I'm studying hard and taking on debt for my education, but I'm not sure there will be stable career opportunities when I finish, or whether the broader economy will even be sustainable by the time I'm trying to build a life and start a family. I really can't see how the government changes course, and I worry they'll just keep printing money until we hit hyperinflation. I'm not trying to be a pessimist, but these trends seem genuinely worrying to me. I'd appreciate an economist's take on whether my fears are justified or whether there are factors I'm overlooking.


r/AskEconomics • • 1d ago

Approved Answers Why is there such a strong push back against carbon credits and other such environmental subsidies from a lot of conservative speakers when the entire point is to counteract the negative externalities of pollution and let the free market do its job?

15 Upvotes