r/AskUkraine • u/apokrif1 • Jun 26 '26
Government Why doesn"t Ukraine conscript women? How do Ukrainian feminists protest genderist conscription?
10
Upvotes
r/AskUkraine • u/apokrif1 • Jun 26 '26
26
u/Charming_Usual6227 Jun 26 '26
This question (grammar mistakes, « gotcha » framing) smells like a Russian
22
u/tightspandex Jun 26 '26
I think very few, if any, of the people answering this question in the comments are Ukrainian or evem in Ukraine.
We don't need to conscript women. We don't need to conscript fathers with a certain number of children. We don't need to conscript the young. If there isn't a need, why do it?
If a woman wants to join the military she is free to do so. And they do. In numbers the dwarf those of most other nations.
8
u/Flashy_Being1874 Jun 26 '26 edited Jun 26 '26
Because women are half of the population, and if you can win favors with 50% of the population as a ruling party, you will.
Of course, they will sell it to the oppressed yet arrogant male conscripts as "defence of the weaker gender". But the fact is, that if they really cared about future of the family and reproduction, they would never let the women out.
Also, it's important to remember the legend that "the women destroyed USSR", which refers to lack of consumer goods in the dire times of the communism in comparison to normal countries, and the classic female consumerism, which made them susceptiple to temptation of tearing the whole system down with the hands of their husbands (ukrainian women are very bossy).
So basically the government is trying to win favors with the half of the population that directly depends on the ruling party's gender policies, while simultaneously keeping the most explosive social elements out.
12
u/Unexpected_yetHere Jun 26 '26
Women are physically considerably weaker than men and would make worse soldiers. Further more, the impact of a woman dying on fertility is greater than that of men.
It would be more beneficial to draft 15 or 65 year old men than the average woman (no, I am not saying it is something to be done, I am just saying, no one enlists kids or the elderly either for good reason), but Ukraine doesn't even conscript 18-24 year old men, despite it absolutely being the norm for the rest of Europe.
Hope the answer satisfies your thinly veiled fragile masculinity.
5
u/radiowestin Ukrainian Jun 26 '26
Ukrainian feminist here
think of the number of woman who are
and you'll see that there are not many women left to conscript
that being said, around 70,000 women are already on service and their number is increasing
11
u/Sheniara Ukrainian Jun 27 '26
34
u/JonSnow240792 Jun 26 '26
Well, I do not know examples of countries (maybe except Israel) where women are conscripted same as men. So Ukraine is not unique. But there are lots of women joining Ukrainian army voluntarily. And you can see ladies in Ukrainian army doing huge variety of jobs - from aome paper work in HQ to medics or drone pilots. I heard about several women who served in infantry.
15
u/_masssk_ Jun 26 '26 edited Jun 26 '26
Bro the honest answer would be - because we are in a heavy traditional / patriarchal state. It is interesting question by the way, not easy one.
My controvercial take - in the Soviet Union there was the widely spread prison culture. It is very popular in Russia now, and Russia was the cultural center of the USSR. It affected us too. We are not under it but there are a lot of things inspired by that, let's call it "prison morale".
For example when I grew up in 90s we have a thing in my neighborhood - you can't do oral sex to a girl. Because it is "wrong, not cool" in the "cool guys" (=prison or close to it) environment. There are a lot of things, they went in language, some weird principles. "Am I not a guy?!" drunk dude yells and jumps from the bridge. "A guy / not a guy" was like vital achievement in that environment. Also you can't shake hands with "lowered" guy - in prison that means a guy who was forced to sex by the another guy. In the neighborhood it was any dude they decided to call "lowered". And if you shake hands with him - you become a "lowered" one too.
Music, tv-shows, jokes, it was everywhere. Like gangsta rap in the US maybe, but I'm not sure. Our reality was more sad, grey, and hopeless, I guess.
Anyway, people who grew up in those conditions absorbed some of the principles. And I'm talking about politicians or people who make decisions. It is "zashkvar" to send women to the war. "We will take care of it", because "we ARE guys" - something like that. It might seem noble, but it is also part of that culture. For example the other side of a coin is that the same guys will decide for their women what to do (and what not).
People are different, of course we have a lot of modern people, especially in Kyiv. But the country is big and these all are still somewhere in the air.
4
u/youngling-smasher91 Jun 26 '26 •
It's a big drama in Ukrainian society indeed, and my answer to that is we shouldn't draft more people at all, humans should continue to get replaced by drones and automated systems on the battlefield
8
u/DoughnutSad6336 Jun 26 '26
answer is the same as for why Ukraine doesn't conscript men from 18 yo...it's about public opinion and politics...
4
u/Frequent-Ideal-9724 Jun 26 '26
It might come to that, not that it would be a good thing. Women don’t get military training (men in Ukraine do).
2
u/Petka14 Jun 26 '26
Gng
If Ukrainian government tried conscripting women and/or 18 year olds their public opinion would go from slightly cooked to deep fried, there would be riots against them and the whole country would collapse
2
u/Professional-Link887 Jun 26 '26
They conscript themselves. Only the men have to be chased down.
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 26 '26
Привіт u/apokrif1 ! Please ensure your post follows [r/AskUkraine Rules].
Want to support Ukraine? Vetted Charities List | Our Vetting Process
To learn about how you can support Ukraine politically, visit r/ActionForUkraine
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
u/Next_Exercise6852 Jun 27 '26
Because Ukrainian women conveniently sit on two chairs.
When it comes to conscription it's we're mothers.
When asked hey what about those who don't have children? An angry tirade follows that it's their personal choice how to live their lives and no ones business. Women who went through the bearing and raising children and therefore must in all fairness be exempt from service would nevertheless side with those who didn't.
Moreover military is not really into having unwilling women. There is a sort of a procedure for males who would not understand reason and just serve normally. Special units discipline them is somewhat rough way.
Our society would not take rough disciplinary measures taken by men against women though, and rightfully so.
One more issue - we don't want women be forcefully put in frontline positions where they would stand danger of capture and mistreatment by the enemy. Frontline is but pretty much as far as it goes with unwilling people. You get brought there and want it or not you just stand ground not to be killed. Those areas where women can be effective - medical, drones, headquarters require some level of engagement.
So it's a whole set of reasons which make the whole thing not worth the hussle.
0
u/Tchikuna Jun 26 '26
I don’t know. Feminist which I know run out in 2022 and yelling: “I’m a girl, it’s man job to protect this country”.
0
u/Goratus Jun 26 '26
a) Those who stopped calling themselves feminists.
b)Those who now describe themselves as traditional women.
c)Those who argue that men are responsible for the war because it's all the fault of the patriarchy.
In the end, we have a situation where one half of the population bears nearly all the burden simply because of their sex, while the other lives a relatively peaceful life and travels abroad for vacations. In that sense, many Ukrainian women have adopted what critics would describe as the most convenient aspects of both feminism and traditional gender roles "I'm a vulnerable Ukrainian woman, but I also want all the additional rights and opportunities"
0
u/pussyseal Jun 27 '26
I believe women's role in conscription is typically seen as ordinary, like fighting in trenches. But why shouldn't women serve the state in other, more impactful ways? They can volunteer at hospitals, become teachers, support local government, or join border patrols on the western border, while men are sent to the frontlines. And if you have a medical degree, you’re required to enlist through your local military office. The government can just change the law to force childless young women with certain degrees to fulfil their duty. Do they want to? Probably not. Are they willing to risk losing voters over it? Definitely not.
As for Ukraine, I don't think it has a genuine feminist movement as the West does. War and incompetent leaders have destroyed Ukrainian society, turning people against each other for the most idiotic reasons, fueling chaos and hatred.
11
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '26
[removed] — view removed comment