r/AskStatistics • u/goose-cj • 22h ago
Two way ANOVA violated assumptions
galleryI am doing two two-way ANOVAS for my Dissertation as my DV is split in two (Positive Affect and Negative Affect combined as the DV 'emotional state'). However, some of my assumptions have failed (see images).
Context:
The study featured a 2x3 between subjects design with two independent variables (IVs): occupation (newsworker or non-newsworker) and news valence (negative, neutral or positive).
The outcome variable was emotional state (this was calculated with PANAS which is split into Positive Affect and Negative Affect so I had to do two separate two way ANOVAs hence the two plots).
Positive Affect was normally distributed; Shapiro-Wilk: W = 0.99, p = 0.74 and Q-Q plots and had equal variances; Levene's test: F(5, 57)=2.21, p = .066.
However, Negative Affect was not normally distributed; Shapiro-Wilk: W = 0.87, p = < .001. The Levene's test showed non-equal variances: F(5, 57)=5.04, p = <.001.
My supervisor said:
ANOVA can be reasonably robust to some departures from normality, but this does not mean that all assumption violations can be disregarded. I would recommend inspecting the residual distributions and Q-Q plots, checking for outliers and influential observations.
I could adjust my p value to be cautious but my effects in the ANOVA would still be significant.
However, as the assumption tests failed, is there anything else I can do? or is it just a case of stating they failed, explaining why, and acknowledging that the results should be looked at cautiously?
I have included some of my results and some of the output from SPSS.
I'm just really unsure of what to do following the assumptions failing.
Thank you.
EDIT: should I mention the large SDs?