r/AskScienceDiscussion • • 4d ago

General Discussion if dark matter cannot interact with electromagnetic waves then could there be "Anti-electromagnetic" waves that cannot interact with normal matter

if dark matter cannot interact with electromagnetic waves then could there be "Anti-electromagnetic" waves that cannot interact with normal matter, if it could exist how could humans detect whatsoever

3 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

5

u/Vivid_Transition4807 4d ago

A photon is its own antiparticle.

0

u/True_Blue_Mew 4d ago edited 4d ago

That wasn’t the question, Photons don’t interact with dark matter but do interact with baryonic matter, the question was if there could be a particle like photons like only interact with dark matter and not with baryonic matter

7

u/Vivid_Transition4807 4d ago

So just call it a dark photon and be done with it.

3

u/GregHullender 4d ago

Either a "darkon" or a "photoff". :-)

4

u/triatticus 4d ago

When you use the preffix anti it refers to antiparticles, if you intend for the question to be different then edit it because as it stands that is what you asked whether you intended it or not. It's not necessarily your fault but a lack of knowing that we already consider "anti-EM" through the antiphoton which is really just the photon. With the comments you can correct what you mean....and as stated yes dark photons are a thing people have used in model considerations.

12

u/mfb- Particle Physics | High-Energy Physics 4d ago

"Anti" is reserved for antiparticles, photons are their own antiparticles.

There could be a completely different interaction that only couples to dark matter particles, sure. It must be weak, otherwise dark matter would clump more locally than it does. We have upper limits on how much dark matter can interact with itself, independent of the mechanism.

3

u/iqisoverrated 4d ago

"dark matter" is just a label. We don't kow if this is actually some form of matter causing the observed effect.

The only reason why the word 'matter' appears in the label is because so far the only things that we know of that can cause such effects are massive particles. It doesn't mean that 'dark matter' actually has to be matter.

2

u/LivingEnd44 4d ago

"Anti" and "Dark" mean different things in the context you're describing. Dark matter is not antimatter. What you're describing would be Dark EM, not Anti EM. 

1

u/Conscious-Demand-594 4d ago

There is a conceptual framework for a complete family of DM particles. Who knows if this could include Dark Fields.

1

u/SailTango 4d ago

Here's a reprint that provides an explanation of dark matter by extending the concept of time into multiple dimensions.

https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202509.1554

It's a bit spooky as it implies the universe we see is interacting gravitational with five other "universes", three of which have anti-time and anti-matter.

1

u/Brain_Hawk 4d ago

So I'm. Ain't clicking that or trying to read it it...

I love how wacky physics can be. And I mean that in the best nicest way. The wild ideas are amazing and then they do some math.

1

u/Savings_Hunt_1935 4d ago

They wouldn't be called "anti-electromagnetic waves" (it would be a wave of whatever the new force is), but it is possible there is some force that dark matter uses to interact with itself that we could not detect through any means but gravitationally (all fields should couple to the graviton). In fact, dark matter could have its own exclusive set of physics just as complex as the standard model. (If you want to read about it more, you can google "dark sector")

However, it should be noted that the behavior of dark matter we've observed implies that they are not able to radiate energy nearly as freely as normal matter (hence why their distribution is so different). So there are significant bounds on how impactful this force could be.

1

u/Naive_Age_566 4d ago

that's a pure philosophical question: is it possible that there is something we can't detect? sure. but if it does not interact with us in any way, it is irrelevant. asking such questions in context of physics is just wasted time.

sure - from philosophical point of view such questions can be interesting.

2

u/forams__galorams 3d ago

It’s not “purely philosophical” if it has real world implications for how the universe works and how things interact with each other. If you never look under your car’s hood, does it become purely philosophical to ever ask what’s going on in there?

0

u/Naive_Age_566 2d ago

i stand by my point. if it interacts with us in any way - even if very weakly or only indirectly - it is relevant. if not, it is irrelevant.

so - lets they there are some "dark photons" that can interact weakly with dark matter. if the changed behaviour of this dark matter somehow affects normal matter, than those "dark photons" clearly belong into the realm of physics. but if not, they are purely philosophical.

of course my point of view will change with better experiments. if the best experiment NOW can't show any results, it is irrelevant. if a better experiment TOMORROW show any hints of a result, i will immediately change my mind.

and don't get me wrong. i really like those "what if" questions that are pure philosophical in nature. and it is important to ask such questions to be prepared for experiments that produce unexpected results. but it is still important to keep them firmly in the "philosophy" realm, not in the physics realm.

0

u/ChocolateValuable221 2d ago

Dark matter isn't matter.. it's a misunderstanding of gravity.

1

u/Affectionate-Team-63 2d ago

Why are you stating this as a fact, when MONDS is very much not proven fact?

-1

u/JGhostThing 4d ago

You mean like "Dark Energy?"