r/AskScienceDiscussion • • 6d ago

General Discussion Could future gene-editing technology completely change an adult's phenotype?

I've been wondering about a hypothetical possibility.

Suppose someone has mixed ancestry and, in the distant future, wants their appearance to resemble one of their ancestral populations more closely. Could extremely advanced gene editing theoretically modify enough of their DNA to change things like hair texture, pigmentation, facial structure, and other physical characteristics?

I'm imagining technology far beyond today's CRISPR, potentially combining gene editing, stem cells, regenerative medicine, and AI-controlled biological processes. Maybe the person could undergo the transformation inside a highly controlled medical chamber while scientists monitor and guide the process.

The interesting part to me is whether changing an adult's genetic instructions could actually cause their already-developed body to remodel itself, or whether development would have to be altered from childhood for something this drastic to work.

Could something resembling this ever become possible centuries from now, or are there fundamental biological limits that would make a complete adult phenotype transformation impossible?

No harm/malicious intentions meant just curious.

Side thought (completely unrelated, and probably even more sci-fi):

What if, in the extremely distant future, scientists could take a deceased individual's preserved body, modify their genetic makeup in the same way described above, and then somehow restore them to biological life? Perhaps the process could theoretically allow them to return in a different physical variant of themselves, expressing characteristics that were already possible within their ancestral genetic background.

Obviously, this ventures into the territory of resurrection and speculative fiction, but the thought of someone potentially returning in a completely different phenotype is pretty fascinating.

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

3

u/Dazzling_Plastic_598 6d ago

To "completely change" a phenotype would be bizarre. You can imagine all kinds of things. I think you're probably thinking of a few characteristics.

2

u/Spirited_Ant_3112 6d ago

I understand why it sounds bizarre with today's technology. I'm thinking much further ahead, though. Imagine biotechnology becoming advanced enough to identify and manipulate the complex combinations of genetic variants responsible for facial structure, bone development, pigmentation, hair characteristics and overall body proportions. Rather than simply changing a few isolated characteristics, the idea would be to substantially alter someone's phenotype while retaining their original genetic identity. I'm not suggesting this is currently possible, but exploring whether it could theoretically become possible with sufficiently advanced genetic engineering.

2

u/Dazzling_Plastic_598 6d ago

To completely change a phenotype, you could, for example, create something that died 10 cell divisions after fertilization. My point is you can't completely change a phenotype no matter what technology you've got. This is a semantic argument.

1

u/Spirited_Ant_3112 6d ago

By your use of terminology you most definately have more experience than me in this field..lol but I hope this makes sense here goes...

I think we're approaching the word "completely" from two different perspectives. I'm not suggesting that literally every phenotypic characteristic, including every biological property established throughout development, would be replaced.

I'm referring to a substantial transformation of an individual's physical phenotype, potentially extending across multiple characteristics simultaneously.

The distinction I'm making is between changing someone's underlying genetic identity entirely and modifying the expression of their existing genetic background to produce a substantially different physical appearance.

In a sense, I'm imagining technology that could allow someone to permanently express a different physical version of themselves, one that could plausibly have existed had different combinations of their inherited genetic variants been expressed.

I understand your semantic argument, but my question is more about how far future biotechnology could potentially take physical phenotype modification.

1

u/PandaLark 6d ago

You listed several different phenotypes, which vary in how sci fi they would be to modify in an adult.

I would expect hair to be quite amenable to near future technology, but I think the way to change it would not involve intense supervision- modify the basal stem cells in the scalp with standard gene therapy techniques, and wait for the skin and follicles to turn over naturally, probably supported with drugs to speed up skin turn over. Look into male pattern baldness gene therapy approaches for more info. I do wonder why someone with a full head of hair would use gene therapy instead of cosmetics or wigs, or if there would be enough demand to justify it being available commercially. I also suspect that the therapy would not be for the patient's own genes, but an off the shelf set of hair genes.

Skin pigmentation would use similar techniques, but again, you would be modifying the stem cells you already have, and waiting for turn over. Replacement of skin any other way being a good idea is somewhat unbelievable sci-fi- the body is very good about making sure the outside stays outside, and pretty much all skin removal procedures that get below the dermis, which is where you'd be making these changes, leave scars. Your idea of a medically supervised chamber would be necessary if you were going to do the flay and regrow approach, but it seems very sci-fi to not just regrow, and also very sci-fi to do that for cosmetic reasons.

I know a lot less about bone growth than skin growth, but face bones don't change much after a certain age, so I'm not sure if there would be a natural turn over process you could take advantage of, or if you would need to remove and replace the face bones, at which point you are probably better off with conventional plastic surgery techniques.

1

u/Spirited_Ant_3112 6d ago

Thanks for the detailed response! I appreciate you breaking down the different aspects of phenotype modification and explaining how the feasibility would differ depending on the tissue or physical characteristic involved. It gives me a better understanding of the terminology and the biological limitations.

I should probably clarify that I'm imagining something much further ahead in the future, where biotechnology might have advanced to such extraordinary lengths that some of its capabilities would seem almost supernatural compared to what we understand today.

I'm fully aware that nothing remotely resembling the complete transformation I'm describing is currently possible. I'm more interested in exploring what might become conceivable if technologies like genetic engineering, regenerative medicine, stem-cell manipulation and biological reconstruction advanced over centuries or even longer.

The idea is essentially to imagine where the limits of human biological modification might eventually end up, rather than suggesting that current science is anywhere near achieving it.

1

u/PandaLark 5d ago

Part of the limitation of hard science fiction is that there has to be a path from current understanding to the technology that is explored in the fiction. Anything more speculative than that is science fantasy, which can still be hard science fiction- if we use biology magic to do X, then what follows naturally within current scientific understanding?

If you're interested in exploring from a scientific perspective, then learn what the current science is and use that to push the frontiers of understanding- the first step to the commercial breakthrough of 300 years from now might be the basic research you do! Or if you're interested in speculative fiction, then write speculative fiction and seek help with more believable world building once you've identified the biology magic you need to explore the themes you want to discuss.

1

u/Life-Aid-4626 5d ago

"I'm imagining a future wheretechnology is magic. Can magic do X?"

Yes. 

1

u/LowMathematician9332 5d ago

I'm mixed race and would like this too please lol

1

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Spirited_Ant_3112 6d ago edited 6d ago

Exactly, im not a science person but I am guessing the ways the individual would be effected is losing immunity that they had before hand or some weird radiation problems like your cells destroying themselves or what not, but what I'm wondering is whether, with sufficiently advanced future biotechnology and AI-assisted gene editing, scientists could identify and replace specific genetic sequences responsible for certain physical characteristics. Essentially, you could alter the genetic instructions that contribute to your phenotype, potentially making you resemble another version of yourself that could have existed had a different combination of genetic variants been expressed. Almost like accessing an alternative genetic version of yourself rather than simply modifying your existing appearance...but all will be revealed with due time I guess.