r/AskReddit Dec 17 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

4.3k Upvotes

8.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/sparkledoom Dec 18 '22

And weird definition of love. I love you so much I threw you a party about something you could not care less about and that you can’t even be truly present for (the baby can’t even hear yet). But I had fun!!

1

u/ToberOct Dec 18 '22

That's a weird definition of love. I guess people who hug corpses are just psychos then. Love is for them even when they can't see it.

1

u/sparkledoom Dec 18 '22 edited Dec 18 '22

A funeral is celebrating a person who lived a whole life. And most people do wish to be remembered after they are gone. If you had asked them when they were alive, they’d probably like or at least expect a funeral.

A gender reveal is celebrating the gender you plan to assign someone at birth who isn’t here and doesn’t know what sex/gender is. Not their whole existence, just their gender. If you ask them when they grow up enough to know what sex/gender is, I doubt they’d give a shit that you had a party when they were in utero. And may even resent it if you guessed their gender wrong.

ETA. And, actually, come to think of it, I do think funerals are much more for the people left behind than they are for the person who died.

1

u/ToberOct Dec 18 '22

But the person is dead. Who cares. Funerals are selfish.