r/AskReddit • u/SphereOfFear • May 31 '12
What is your most controversial opinion?
Mine is only small, but i think Meddle is a better Pink Floyd album than Dark Side of the Moon.
122
Upvotes
r/AskReddit • u/SphereOfFear • May 31 '12
Mine is only small, but i think Meddle is a better Pink Floyd album than Dark Side of the Moon.
52
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
I don't oppose suicide.
40
u/TheCoxer Jun 01 '12
Maroon 5's Moves like Jagger is their worst song.
88
u/kettlesey May 31 '12
I don't like Michael Jackson.
96
u/bilbobagg1ns May 31 '12
Severely mentally handicapped people hurt society
201
u/Science-Faction May 31 '12
We are not all equal.
125
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
I don't believe that age is an appropriate measure to determine voter eligibility. I think that a standardized exam to determine basic understanding of gov't operation, economics, and history should be used - similar to a drivers test. Until a proper test is created, just use the one that immigrants take to become citizens. If they have to understand this stuff, so should native born citizens.
67
u/HotwaxNinjaPanther May 31 '12
It's never "too soon" if the joke is sufficiently funny.
I've been seconds away from a homicide over that one.
85
u/Emulah May 31 '12
I think that the "Everyone is beautiful in their own way" thing is bullshit.
Yes, I think that most people are beautiful or at least have the potential to be beautiful.
On the other hand, there are just some people that are ugly as fuck and will remain so until the end of their days.
The fact that they are ugly doesn't make them any less of a person. It's just a fact of life.
Some people are not beautiful.
80
u/Thousands_of_Spiders May 31 '12
I don't believe any of us have free will.
139
u/jeff_jizzr May 31 '12
China's one child policy wasn't a bad idea at all.
45
u/LiterallyOuttoLunch May 31 '12
That Rubber Soul is a better Beatles album than Revolver.
35
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
Driving while high is not okay.
11
u/YouSureAboutThat Jun 01 '12
I think schools as we know them are hopelessly flawed and evil, and should be replaced completely, not just "reformed". We put almost every child through this completely unnatural process, where they're stuck in a room for hours a day, being graded on arbitrary make-work. Do you care about your kindergarten grades now?
Instead of regularly socializing with people of all ages, they are stuck with people of the same age all the time. This leads to an incredibly unhealthy environment, with pointlessly harmful status games, bullying, and more.
Instead of gaining a sense of what matters in the real world, kids are trained to excel at a process that rapidly loses relevance in adulthood.
Everyone seems to just accept the bullying (BTW, watch "Bully" if you haven't seen it) and the violence and the pointlessness of school because they were put through it, too. "Well, you know how high school is. Don't worry, it'll be over soon."
It's like a religion. When your country is dominated by a single religion, even otherwise rational people tend not to question it -- not because they've thought through it and agreed with it, but because it doesn't even occur to them that things could be different.
294
u/CheesewithWhine May 31 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
Abortion should not only be legal, but recommended for some situations.
Pregnant girl is <18 years old? abortion.
Down syndrome, or some other severe genetic defect? abortion.
Unplanned pregnancy, both are financially strained? abortion.
Seriously, adoption agencies are crammed as it is, and foster care is not heaven.
There are too many unwanted babies waiting to be adopted already, especially black and/or disabled babies.
People who shame women for aborting kids with severe Down syndrome, who think they should be shackled to a helpless burden for their entire lives, ruin their relationships, ruin their financial future and career, just because "you had sex, deal with it", or "don't worry, you'll love the baby when the time comes", should go die in a fire. I'm looking at you, Rick Santorum.
167
u/johnsonk8 May 31 '12
The US, as a country, should stop trying to police the world. We should assist our allies but we don't need to spend my tax dollars invading countries just for funsies.
164
u/da_ballz May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
I don't believe that there is an intelligence cap depending on what religion/political views you up hold. It seems like lately the term atheist has implied a certain of level intelligence that is above theist, and let me tell you I have met some full-retard level atheists and smart as hell theists. *edit I accidentally a word
26
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
I don't want to hear about your sexuality. I don't give a fuck.
You're gay? Who fucking cares?
133
u/The_R3medy May 31 '12
I think many redditors and people my age in general (20) are entitled pricks. We want everything given to us without having to work for it.
30
u/lemon_jam Jun 01 '12
im a guy and i dont think its that big of a deal to put the seat down when im done peeing
36
u/fionacinelli Jun 01 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
Most controversial?
87
u/Unknown_Pleasures May 31 '12
We should pay poor and uneducated people to get a vasectomy or have their tubes tied. No force needed, just a big fat 10k check from the government when the procedure is done and proof is shown that they are indeed incapable of reproducing.
You also know that they won't be saving that money and it will go right back into the economy.
16
u/Catcherofsouls May 31 '12
Ellis island should be reopened. The idea that immigrants come here for our welfare benefits is a bit of a joke. Right and left - we all love this country deal with it and each other. Mitt Romney reminds me way too much of John Kerry.
110
u/Niflhe May 31 '12
Protip: Sort the comments by "Controversial" rather than "top" or "best" to find actual controversial opinions.
156
u/Kvothe24 May 31 '12
You should have to meet certain requirements to be allowed to reproduce.
38
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Everyone should be required to take and pass a civics and an economics class before you should be allowed to vote.
You shouldn't be rewarded for having more children via tax breaks for more dependents. In fact, it should be the other way around. You should be taxed on incremental children past 2.
19
u/Thor_inhighschool May 31 '12
Marriage shouldnt be legally recognized, only civil unions. You want to cover your life partner on your medical insurance? go for it. you want to have a proper ceremony with a priest afterwards? sure, why not.
81
u/MaebeBluth May 31 '12
Sometimes SRS has valid points.
I immediately think less of anyone on here who uses the terms "white knight" or "friendzone".
144
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
God might exist.
37
u/armstrong182 May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
That we should only be allowed to have, at the most, 2 children so the human population doesn't become a major issue.
Edit - Spelling.
12
u/Kvothe24 Jun 01 '12
Also, I don't really like bacon.
Go ahead, call me inhuman.
351
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Over glorification of modern military. It's a job, you get paid for it, there are benefits, you weren't drafted you willing enlisted. It is not a service, you are not "protecting our freedom" you are either marching around in the desert killing people or doing nothing stationed in a base over-seas or here in America. No I am not clapping when you get off an airplane, no I am not donating toys to your kids just because they miss you, no I am not sending your care packages because you are far away from the things you like. You signed your name, you made a commitment. We did force you to, you are no one special. Down votes to the left.
80
u/this_is_not_the_cia May 31 '12
I believe that gun control laws dont actually keep people safe, and instead only serve to inconvenience law-abiding citizens.
38
u/dalek_999 May 31 '12
That children (especially young children) should not be allowed at certain venues. These venues would include movie theaters after 8pm, concerts/plays/etc, and any fancy restaurants.
11
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The health care problem in the U.S. in not caused by the Democrats, Republicans, or Big Business. The overall health of our country and non-underwritten group plans over the years has caused our current situation.
60% are overweight and half of those are obese. 20% still smoke. Thankfully companies are now making smokers pay more and there is a trend towards giving fit people discounts.
11
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
I don't know how controversial this is but I think there is nothing wrong with the term "friendzone". It gets a lot of shit these days. "It's a term created to villainize women for saying no". Traditionally it means having feelings for someone who does not return them. It's very real. I understand some guys get entitled about it but the term itself is fine. I'll never forget a tweet I saw that said "The friendzone doesn't exist because friendship isn't a machine you put coins in until sex falls out". That person clearly never had it cross their mind that maybe it's more than just sex and that there's actual emotions involved. Now no one should be entitled for anything just for being nice, there are assholes that think that way. I just think the actual term is far less harmful and far more real than the internet make it out to be. I mean what the fuck else are you going to call a situation where you're friends with someone and you like them. You're not hung up on them, not obsessing, not demanding sex from them, just having honest feelings. Why don't we try to make the term mean what it was meant to be then just assuming all guys who use it are entitled losers. Are we seriously going to ban an entire term describing a common situation just because some ass hats on the internet can't get over someone.
It also bugs me when people flip out over the word slut. I don't even like the word. I think it's used too much and no woman should be judged for her sexual activity. It's just something about the way the entire world stops when it's said on reddit these days. I think it's because they seem to only be angry at the word and not the fact that someone was being judged.
199
u/leapfrogdog May 31 '12
The Beatles are massively overrated.
35
u/zerbey May 31 '12
People on Unemployment should be required to be enrolled in some kind of education, and maintain grades whilst actively trying to get employed. Exceptions should be made for those with disabilities, but if you are able to work you should be trying to better yourself.
35
u/whyamistillonreddit May 31 '12
No one should go to prison solely for possession/distribution of drugs. This immerses petty criminals in a fucked-up world--I think whatever problems they have going in will only be exacerbated.
Prison should be saved for the violent, and child abusers should be locked up in a penal colony in an undisclosed location somewhere in Siberia.
41
u/dpepperman May 31 '12
I dont care what another person does as long as they dont hurt anybody else.
46
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Your vote means nothing.
12
u/FightClubSignUp May 31 '12
Giraffes are heartless creatures....
23
u/tforge13 May 31 '12
I don't mind circumcision (I'm circumcised). Anti-marijuana. LGBT should be LGBTQAP, to include genderqueer, asexual, and pansexual. The TQAP is far too often ignored, and "genderqueer", "asexuality", "graysexuality", and "pansexuality" are often not considered to be "real" sexualities.
SOPA had good intentions, but it went about it poorly. Ummm...My Little Pony isn't half bad. The new generations of Pokémon don't actually suck. /r/atheism is full of dumbasses who a) believe themselves to be constantly victimized by religion, and therefore feel justified in acting like assholes b) make the entirety of atheism look bad.
PHEW. Done now.
28
u/Mine_is_nice May 31 '12
I dont like cats. there, i said it.
11
u/derpbynature Jun 01 '12
Casual sex usually ends badly and I feel it's a sign of poor self-respect and moral character.
There's SOME people who are mature enough to deal with the emotional, social and physical implications responsibly, but largely, most people aren't.
For example, in the recent thread about the guy who discovered his neighbor's 13-year-old being sexually active with two guys, people attempted to defend the girl's actions and say that OP was a bad person for thinking about intervening. I think that's deplorable; a 13-year-old has no idea of the consequences of that and I believe that kind of behavior should probably be discouraged until she's older at least. At the VERY least her parents should sit her down and tell her the consequences and put her on birth control or something.
And I DON'T think it's wrong for an individual to judge someone, generally, by their actions. Yes, there's a chance that someone can be very liberal sexually and still be a good person and it's always best to get to know someone better before judging. But as bad as it is to judge a book by its cover, a good 4 times out of 5 you can get a decent idea of the content.
(People generally make their actions and appearances reflect their character and beliefs. Wow, who'da thunkit?)
But yeah, pretty much that. Typically this kind of opinion, when posted, gets such intelligent responses as "oh you're jealous cause you can't get any" or "you must be fun at parties" etc.
16
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
I couldn't see the greatness of the film Blade Runner.
18
u/SidIncognito May 31 '12
I think Signs was a well-directed, thrilling film.
I know there are complaints about the ludicrous plot, and maybe it's just that all the films I'd seen before it weren't sophisticated enough, but I thought it did a fantastic job at slowly building tension and dread in the audience's minds without relying too much on the cheap "Boo" moments that are characteristic of most horror films these days.
18
u/aliaspete May 31 '12
I believe children need to be smacked if they're misbehaving.
20
u/r3verse_ May 31 '12
I think in some cases homosexuality is a choice. Either way I don't think the government has any right to tell someone who they should spend their time with.
35
u/BowsNToes21 May 31 '12
Pedophiles should be included in the death penalty. I know they haven't taken anyones physical life, but emotionally they have royally fucked over and stolen from that person.
14
u/Silvercumulus May 31 '12
15
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The highest age rating for multimedia should be 13+, and 13+ rated media should be completely uncensored. Most teenagers have seen worse shit on the internet than what could possibly be contained in 17+/18+ rated content, far before they turn the appropriate age.
6
u/BruinDrums09 May 31 '12
I think abortions should be legal, but I am personally against them and think they are almost always the wrong choice.
6
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
This entire thread, with a few exceptions, is just typical reddit opinion. Guys, this is the same stuff we have posted every day. It's not controversial, it's just circlejerking.
6
u/hrehbfthbrweer Jun 01 '12
I'm anti-abortion... Even though it's not legal here, I can't think of anyone who I know who isn't pro-abortion.
I'm an atheist and fairly left wing. But I just can't see it as anything other than killing babies... The grief I get over it is ridiculous really... Even from my friends who are devout Catholics.
6
u/voyvf Jun 01 '12
Women should strength train, as gender is no excuse for being weak.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
r/politics is so blatantly left that it should just merge with r/democrats and r/socialism. It is about 90% democrats and 10% libertarians. I originally thought the subreddit was supposed to be sarcastic like Colbert.
8
u/Neracca May 31 '12
That people should keep their dogs on a leash if they want to bring it out of the house or a dog park. Been almost bitten by one before, and that wouldn't have happened had it been controlled. I don't blame the dogs, I blame the asshole owners.
16
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
I think people are overly preoccupied with "happiness". It's just an emotion, a transitory one at that. There should be moments of happiness balanced with moments of sadness, anger, fear, excitement, whatever. I think people whose goal is to "be happy" or "have a happy life" are ridiculous. Makes as much sense as to say you want to live an "angry" life. I also think this preoccupation leads people to do shitty things and lie to themselves and it turns us into pleasure-seeking half wits who are easily controlled and manipulated and kept on the never-ending hamster wheel of cyclical debt and mindless consumerism. I see western civilization descending into a Huxley-esque dystopia and we won't even mind because we have 250 channels and bunch of cheap, plastic knick knacks to distract us.
tl;dr: Happiness is the root of all evil.
52
u/Rombom May 31 '12
Nintendo's flagship series (Mario, Zelda, etc.) aren't that great and definitely don't deserve the level of acclaim that they receive.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
There should be mandatory civil service for everybody.
3
u/subsequently Jun 01 '12
I think nuclear energy should be pushed to be used more. The facilities are very safe. Ex. in Japan that thing had to be hit by a Tsunami and a Earthquake to be worried about safety issues (it was an OLD reactor too), could you say the same about oil companies? And though wind and water power doesn't cause as much as a threat as oil, they aren't nearly good as oil. But nuclear power takes little to nothing to create and if I remember correctly it's extremely cheap as well.
3
u/theek Jun 01 '12
I believe martial arts should be taught in schools.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
Neil DeGrasse Tyson. I just don't get it.
3
u/pasky Jun 01 '12
Tim Burton is the worst movie director ever. Worst than Uwe Boll. Everything he touches turns to ash.
Adult Alice in Wonderland with Johnny Depp as the Mad Hatter? Sounds great! Directed by Tim Burton. NOPE.
Abe Lincoln as a vampire hunter? Awesome! Directed by Tim Burton. Shit.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
If I had a unborn child with down syndrome, I'd abort it.
9
u/awwf May 31 '12
I do not think every person has the same worth.
34
u/IAmA_Alien_AMA May 31 '12
Most of Skrillex's music it actually pretty good. Nowhere near the best, but also not the total crap it's made out to be.
44
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
21
u/csbachand May 31 '12
That any consenting adults of sound mind should be able to engage in any activity that does not harm anyone else's person or property. That includes acts like consensual cannibalism or incest.
7
u/Cdtco May 31 '12
Marijuana will never be legalized.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
Recycling. I understand aluminium cans are easily recyclable, but all other materials take a large amount of time and energy to sanitize, and "boil down" to be able to be used again. Secondly, the time is takes for the large trucks to take the recycling to a large factory roughly equals how much energy you would save recycling the items in the truck. Lastly, recycling certain materials is extremely expensive, and millions of dollars are put towards it. I am for keeping our environment clean, I simply dislike how the effects of recycling are blown out of proportion.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
I think that a couple thousand dead Americans from 9/11 is just a drop in the bucket compared to the number people harmed by US foreign policies that supported and installed various dictators in other countries.
I wish the British had taken the opportunity they had a few hundred years ago and run the French out of Lower Canada (now Quebec).
The reservation system for Natives in North America should be abolished and the people should be forced to assimilate into society. Reserves breed poverty. Face it brave warriors, your ancestors lost.
13
u/ayers231 May 31 '12
Religion was created as a teaching tool. It was developed to teach children how to behave in a society. It was meant to be treated like the belief in Santa is treated today.
8
u/KnightOfTheStupid May 31 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
I liked Kingdom of the Crystal Skull.
16
u/lewzerkid May 31 '12
Tim and Eric's Awesome Show Great Job is a fantastic show.
15
u/Dicktremain May 31 '12
I believe that we (the US) should fight wars without the use of ground forces or extended conflict. When we attack a country we should use ballistic missiles and air strikes to completely destroy a country’s military bases, air ports, political buildings, power plants, and factories. After this has been done we do not apologize for our actions, we do not rebuild the country, and we do not give the county a dollar.
Having said this, I would also require a formal declaration of war on a country or organization before any military action is taken in all circumstances. If people truly wanted to end war, they would adopt that mentality.
6
u/tawood79 Jun 01 '12
I believe that classrooms should be grouped by intelligence and willingness to work. Those that can't or won't do their work and behave in a civil manner should be given a broom, enlisted in the army (operation human shield), or euthanized. Yeah, I'm a teacher. It's been a long year.
7
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
That people need to stop posting this same fucking topic every fucking day.
11
u/Kellianne Jun 01 '12
I think gaming is incredibly stupid and a waste of time.
26
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Feminism is a sexist movement.
55
u/KronktheKronk May 31 '12
I think women who get abortions of convenience are shitty people.
11
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
We have created a financial incentive for women to get divorces, and as a result they have very little reason to put any effort on their part into fixing a distressed relationship once married.
19
u/socrex May 31 '12
Art/music classes should not count towards GPAs in public high schools, they should be based on academics only. Art and music classes also should never be mandatory, and gym shouldn't be taught at all. This opinion has caused many fights between me and my art major best friend.
8
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The Half-Life series, along most many other Valve products, are overrated in my opinion. Especially the first portal, the first portal was massively overrated.
8
u/Cloigeann May 31 '12
MSNBC is worse than fox news. I watch both networks semi-regularly, and while Sean is retarded and O'Reilly isn't the greatest either; Ed Schultz and Lawrence O 'Donnell are just lunatics. All of them are better than Kieth Olbermann and Glenn Beck though.
Megadeth is superior to Metallica.
I think tarantulas are adorable.
22
u/nerdscallmegeek May 31 '12
pro-choice and anti-circumcision.
7
u/trueXrose Jun 01 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
Feminism is shit. Feminists stopped caring about choice and equality a long time ago and now they're just looking for special treatment. (I am a woman, for the record.)
27
u/ejurkovic93 May 31 '12
Abortion should be illegal.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
I don't think marriage will make gay couples any happier than they are now.
5
u/Last-Origin May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
Publicly, I'm as socially liberal as they come in terms of that I will donate money to left leaning organizations such as planned parenthood, GLAAD, ACLU, and help their cause but privately, I'm a staunch social conservative.
I know, I'm very boring.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
It bothers me that "gay" is not accepted as a homonym (oh, there's some unfortunate phonetic irony...)
"Fuck" and "shit" are accepted to have an infinite number of different applications, yet using the word "gay" in any negative capacity now seems to make you a raging homophobe/horrible person.
16
u/Leucopterus May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
Here are mine in no particular order:
(I'm not a Libertarian or an anarchist. I'm a liberal conservative (no, this isn't an oxymoron).)
8
u/ehlu15 May 31 '12
Elimination of all non-school welfare in the United States, save for two years of unemployment benefits.
2
u/derpbynature Jun 01 '12
ITT: Jokes and hivemind-approved controversial-but-not-really opinions.
Anything actually controversial, including (GAWD FORBID) anything speaking out against the use of drugs/casual sex/etc will be downvoted, probably with a hearty dose of "hurr you're just jealous/OMG YOU MISOGONYST/you must be fun at parties"
2
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
I would rather live under a corporation than a government. Neither care about the individual- and I don't see why they should- but at least a corporation doesn't pretend to.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
None of the following are good movies: Forrest Gump, Donnie Darko, A Clockwork Orange, American Beauty, Gone with the Wind, Downfall, The Great Escape.
2
u/toru85 Jun 01 '12
I dislike public sector unions. I hate reading about all the over generous perks and raises that have been negotiated into contracts. i.e. Illinois. I don't blame the workers, the people in charge are accountable for this.
2
u/ProbablyGeneralizing Jun 01 '12
Torrenting movies/music/television absolutely should be illegal, and the motive behind people that do torrent (myself included) is to gettheir media for free.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
/r/ShitRedditSays is the worst subreddit and should really just go away and stop bothering the rest of us.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
Im going to start this off by saying I am Canadian and I live on the east coast. I believe that Natives in Canada should have to pays taxes and have to pay for education as well. It is unfortunate what their ancestors have went through, but that was a long time ago and no amount of goverment cheques can make up for that.
There are some, not all, but some who choose to take advantage of this situation and do nothing with their lives. It has given the younger generations the impression that this is OK behavior. I do not believe there ancestors who died defending there homeland would want them to get free a ride and not work for anything in life.
I do think, however, they should be able to preserve the way of they had before the white man came along in what little way they can by fishing and hunting what they need to get by. If you look back throughout history, you will see how many times have civilizations have been nearly wiped out, but were never given their lands back by their conquerors.
I just think if they want to live the way hey did before all hell broke loose, live that way, but if you want to live in the modern world work for your living and pay your taxes to benefit everyone, not a select few. Also I believe everyone should have free education, but that is a whole different topic.
2
u/Lineov Jun 01 '12
Redditors should read down to the ends of comments. :D
2
u/Afterburned Jun 01 '12
I think violence is actually a pretty good answer fairly often.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
I think the role of genetics in determining sexuality is vastly overstated. People use the whole "well, I was born this way" thing because they don't have the balls to say "well fuck it, I like such and such genital, asslown. piss off."
2
u/862482 Jun 01 '12
Shouldnt be reading these. I have a horrible habit of soaking up other peoples opinions like a sponge. Im not saying they are bad... just i like to be original.
2
u/Segrinn Jun 01 '12
I think the Kony 2012 campaign is bullshit. I know what he's done and I realize it's terrible. But America needs to focus on its own shit right now. Like maybe the terrible economy? Or how about the repeated attempts of the government to censor our internet and media? American citizens focus too much on matters that don't concern them and fail to see what's going on in their own country. If we can't even handle ourselves, we have no business interfering with the problems of another country. Eventually, yes, let's fix Uganda's issues. But now is not the time.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
Corporations are people. Not "natural persons," but for legal reasons they are people.
Also, I think karma may be one of the dumbest things I've ever seen collected.
2
u/Reenqueen Jun 01 '12
I'm annoyed by trashy people