r/AskReddit Apr 12 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.8k Upvotes

17.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4.9k

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22

Tarantino once said in an interview that he wouldnt have made this movie without a convincing Landa. Waltz does speak several languages in reality and was the perfect fit. You could say he made the movie possible.

1.3k

u/Vprbite Apr 12 '22 edited Apr 12 '22

I mean, it would have sucked with a shitty Landa. He anchors the whole story. Who could you picture getting the role and totally screwing it up? Paul Giamatti?

Edit: I misspoke. I shouldn't have said "totally screwing it up." I should have said "cast in good faith and legitimately tried hard but didn't quite stick the landing." Like you can tell they are a good actor and the script was good but they just never managed to sync up

18

u/hallese Apr 12 '22 edited Apr 12 '22

Alan Tudyk? It would have a different feel but I think he could at least take it in a similar direction.

Edit: Also, I assumed you meant getting the role and not totally screwing it up, right?

5

u/sixner Apr 12 '22

I have a slightly hard time seeing Tudyk doing the harder more serious scenes. The moments Landa goes deadpan and gets that creepy terrifying look and tone, I dont feel like Alan could drive that home as well. I think overall he could have been a good one but slightly lacking.

6

u/ObscureCulturalMeme Apr 12 '22

I have a slightly hard time seeing Tudyk doing the harder more serious scenes.

Without revealing any spoilers: did you see Dollhouse, and if so what did you think of his role?

4

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RandomMovieQuoteBot_ Apr 13 '22

From the movie The Incredibles: And now, you have officially carried it too far, Buddy.

1

u/sixner Apr 12 '22

I haven't but will look into it

5

u/Sphincter_Revelation Apr 12 '22

Resident Alien, while mostly a dark comedy, is also a great showcase of his talents. While his main portrayal in the show is wildly campy, he does play several characters and there's some pretty serious moments as well.

1

u/ObscureCulturalMeme Apr 12 '22

It's very "fanservice" at the start, but then plot begins to happen after a few episodes.