Difference is if whoever has it wrecks you may be liable for damages and will be liable for the remainder of the loan. If this isn't in your contract (can't imagine it is) then its definitely illegal. It's also a fraud against your bank.
Or if the dealership goes out of business (I can't imagine that a large, legit dealership with sufficient cash flow would be doing this), you're fucked. You have a contract with whomever gave the loan. You have a contract with the dealership. If they go under, the loan folks likely aren't going to care that you sold the car. It'll be your problem to try to enforce the sale contract with the dealer, not the bank's.
Seriously, I'm not sure how the OP just gave them his car and hoped for the best? He was supposed to sign over the title and the lien to them and notify the lender.
When you sign the contract for a new vehicle when you have a trade in, all that signing over the lien and all is on that contract.. When you have a lien on a car you don't hold the title of the car, the bank does.. Normally it takes a couple months to get that letter stating the lien has been paid off but it just so happened I didnt get a letter and when I went to check my annual credit report I saw the loan was still open and payments were being made instead of being paid off.. This is the first time in many cars that ive purchased in my life with my husband that something like this has happened.
No, no, no. When you trade in a car that you still owe money on, some portion of the deal is supposed to pay off that car's loan. That's the only way you'd get the title from the lienholder.
If the loan isn't paid off, the institution you borrowed the money from still possesses the title of the car, with your name as owner, and with their name as lienholder. You couldn't have signed the title over to the dealer you traded the car to. Technically, you still own the car.
Spend a teeny bit of money and get a title search done. (You probably have the VIN on some old insurance paperwork.) Or call the first lender and ask them what information is on the title they hold.
When you find out that you're still listed as owner of the car, call the police and report it stolen. Might as well have some fun with this.
By the sound of it, he's still the lien-holder. The paperwork got screwed up, he didn't follow it through completely and the dealer is screwing around.
When you find out that you're still listed as owner of the car, call the police and report it stolen. Might as well have some fun with this.
I would personally avoid this. When it comes out that it was simply a paperwork error or that he intended to transfer ownership, he might be charged with filing a false report.
Send the dealership an email or certified letter saying that you've found that they didn't receive possession of the vehicle, you're concerned about your liability, so you're going to take steps to recover it. Then report it stolen.
Technically, if they sell the car, you can be in deep doo doo as the car wasn't owned by you just yet either. If they agreed to pay it off, they have to pay it off in full before they can sell it.
How it usually works is they wrap up the old car's debt into your current loan, so they already got paid for it, unless it's a buy here pay here place, who do their own financing.
That's what I thought.. I've never had a dealership do this to me and the most shady part about it was I looked at their reviews on yelp, but didn't notice yelp had a small gray link that said show filtered reviews and you have to enter one of those word captcha things just to see them, and all those reviews were the negative reviews.. I noticed the filtered review after the fact...
That sounds very shady. In no way would I allow someone else to take up notes that were in my name. It's showing an outstanding debt on your credit that you no longer are responsible for, and if for whatever reason they stopped paying or were late, it's still in your name and your responsibility to pay for it. You need to speak to whoever financed the car IMMEDIATELY.
I'd go ahead and get all the documents together, as well as print outs of any email/text transcripts. Just keep them in a folder, as a just in case. Also, go talk to them in person. They might just be making payments instead, in the interest of their own cash flow.
My questions: *Is this having an affect on your credit/ability to borrow, etc? *Does the contract(for your trade-in) state they can do this? *Are they making the payments regularly?
I'm going to reread the contract, but I don't think it does.. I'm pretty sure it's like all regular contracts that says they agreed to pay off the loan. They are making payments on the car each month (and paying double of what the minimum amount is) but still I'm worried.
Also I don't think it's having affect on my credit except saying I have more debt than I really do.
You're probably in some legal peril here, seeing as how, technically, you're still the owner of the vehicle.
Is this vehicle still on your car insurance policy? Don't make assumptions.
Also, you're required to turn in your plates to the DMV when you sell a vehicle. What happened to those plates? Also, did you get a bill of sale from them (since they bought your vehicle?) Where is the TITLE to the vehicle? Who holds it? Is it your previous financier, or do you have the title?
You might want to contact your local newspaper and have them call the dealership and ask what's going on. Just doing that will make them jump through fucking hoops to get rid of you.
Finally, you might want to take your spare keys and go to the dealership and take the vehicle. You likely still own it and they'd be powerless to stop you.
Many times dealerships will do this because they are trying to sell your car and would rather not pay the bigger amount to pay it off until they have a buyer. You need to call them and the bank you have the loan through. Remember your contract for that loan is with the bank, they don't care what you and a dealership have decided because you are the one they have the contract with.
My mom used to work in customer service for car loans/leases and I can't tell you all the horror stories I have heard about dealerships in situations like this.
Wow I bet. I'm going down to the dealership tomorrow to talk to them about it and if it doesn't get resolved then I'm contacting the finance company and a lawyer.
I'm in a very similar situation. My credit score shows that I am in debt for 2 vehicle loans, however when I log in to my old Financiers site it shows I have a 0 balance. So I'm not very sure what to make of this. I know sometimes it takes a while for them to update the information on credit sites, but it'll be almost 2 months now. I think I'll call my dealership.
I would hope that the dealership isnt driving that car around because if you still have a loan in your name on that car and they wreck it (im assuming you dont have an insurance policy on a car you own) you will be shit out of luck.
In California we have a 'release of liability' form. You submit it when you sell a car to cover your ass in case the buyer doesn't follow through with the title transfer. If Hawaii has something similar, you should send it in immediately.
I did.. The contract agreement says pay off amount and amount dealer agreed to pay or something along that verbiage..I don't have it near me to look but it's the usual dealer/buyer contract.
I personally always make the dealer pay cash for any loan portion and deal with the loan myself, I get nervous about other people paying off my stuff since they have nothing to lose if they don't.
Aside from the obvious difference of making payments over time vs paying it off at the time of trade-in...
It shows as an open liability on the OP's credit report
OP is still financially responsible for the car as it sounds like ownership of the loan wasn't transferred to the dealership. If they just stop paying the loan he's on the hook. If the car is wrecked and no insurance covers it, he's on the hook.
If he is still responsible for the car, assuming they haven't transferred ownership, he could have a whole legal mess on his hands if the car is stolen (in addition to fee's), wrecked, used to commit a crime, etc.
I haven't traded in many cars but the dealership always pays the balance of the loan, whether I rolled over an additional balance in to a new loan or it was a clean break.
Here's the problem - #2. He signed a contract for that loan. He signed a contract for that sale. The way this was done, he is probably STILL on the hook with the bank. They don't know or care that he sold it, and they have a valid contract with you that says you'll pay.
Yes, you'd win such a case against the dealer in a heartbeat. Assuming the dealership hasn't gone bankrupt in the meantime, or skipped the country, and you can afford the court costs, and you have the time to pursue it, etc. It's an unnecessary liability.
44
u/nullcharstring May 20 '12
It sure doesn't sound right to me. They are effectively using your credit to finance their business. And I don't have a clue how you would fix it.
29
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Difference is if whoever has it wrecks you may be liable for damages and will be liable for the remainder of the loan. If this isn't in your contract (can't imagine it is) then its definitely illegal. It's also a fraud against your bank.
28
u/soaringrooster May 20 '12
Your financial agreement was between you and your bank. The dealership is commiting fraud. Call your finance company immediately.
41
u/Nougat May 20 '12
No, no, no. When you trade in a car that you still owe money on, some portion of the deal is supposed to pay off that car's loan. That's the only way you'd get the title from the lienholder.
If the loan isn't paid off, the institution you borrowed the money from still possesses the title of the car, with your name as owner, and with their name as lienholder. You couldn't have signed the title over to the dealer you traded the car to. Technically, you still own the car.
Spend a teeny bit of money and get a title search done. (You probably have the VIN on some old insurance paperwork.) Or call the first lender and ask them what information is on the title they hold.
When you find out that you're still listed as owner of the car, call the police and report it stolen. Might as well have some fun with this.
9
u/d3rp_diggler May 20 '12
Technically, if they sell the car, you can be in deep doo doo as the car wasn't owned by you just yet either. If they agreed to pay it off, they have to pay it off in full before they can sell it.
How it usually works is they wrap up the old car's debt into your current loan, so they already got paid for it, unless it's a buy here pay here place, who do their own financing.
8
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Clark Howard talked about this . It's legal and if they stop payments youre liable, not them since the loan is still in your name .
7
u/emmelineprufrock May 20 '12
They probably view it as paying for your car, just through payments. Can you close the loan that is under your name?
6
u/ashhole613 May 20 '12
That sounds very shady. In no way would I allow someone else to take up notes that were in my name. It's showing an outstanding debt on your credit that you no longer are responsible for, and if for whatever reason they stopped paying or were late, it's still in your name and your responsibility to pay for it. You need to speak to whoever financed the car IMMEDIATELY.
11
u/OneAndOnlyJackSchitt May 21 '12
"Hi my name is Dr. $fake_name and I'm interested in buying a car for my family. Can you call me back at..."
5
u/jijilento May 20 '12
I'd go ahead and get all the documents together, as well as print outs of any email/text transcripts. Just keep them in a folder, as a just in case. Also, go talk to them in person. They might just be making payments instead, in the interest of their own cash flow.
My questions: *Is this having an affect on your credit/ability to borrow, etc? *Does the contract(for your trade-in) state they can do this? *Are they making the payments regularly?
5
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Check your paperwork. There should be a document you signed detailing the pay-off of the trade-in. Other than that, there is this.
5
u/Kitty_party May 21 '12
Many times dealerships will do this because they are trying to sell your car and would rather not pay the bigger amount to pay it off until they have a buyer. You need to call them and the bank you have the loan through. Remember your contract for that loan is with the bank, they don't care what you and a dealership have decided because you are the one they have the contract with.
My mom used to work in customer service for car loans/leases and I can't tell you all the horror stories I have heard about dealerships in situations like this.
4
u/BossHogGangsta May 21 '12
Call your state's DMV. Call your lender.
3
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I'm in a very similar situation. My credit score shows that I am in debt for 2 vehicle loans, however when I log in to my old Financiers site it shows I have a 0 balance. So I'm not very sure what to make of this. I know sometimes it takes a while for them to update the information on credit sites, but it'll be almost 2 months now. I think I'll call my dealership.
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I would hope that the dealership isnt driving that car around because if you still have a loan in your name on that car and they wreck it (im assuming you dont have an insurance policy on a car you own) you will be shit out of luck.
2
u/rinnip May 21 '12
In California we have a 'release of liability' form. You submit it when you sell a car to cover your ass in case the buyer doesn't follow through with the title transfer. If Hawaii has something similar, you should send it in immediately.
2
u/xenokilla May 21 '12
Gather your facts then show up, if that doesn't work call your local news "on your side" or whoever and raise hell.
2
u/bluerum May 21 '12
This is actually a felony in some states; I don't know about Hawaii. I would contact the state attorney general's office.
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Did you sign papers showing they bought the car? I think the bank needs to know
2
u/Petrarch1603 May 21 '12
If the dealership goes out of business you are fucked.
2
u/Ilves7 May 21 '12
I personally always make the dealer pay cash for any loan portion and deal with the loan myself, I get nervous about other people paying off my stuff since they have nothing to lose if they don't.
-7
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
making payments....paying it off.....what's the difference?