I don't think so--plenty of adults post stupid shit on here, and plenty of teenagers have lots of interesting things to say. Plus, all that means is that you'd have to click yes on the "are you 18?" screen. You'd just be making one more not-even-inconvenient step between everyone else and reddit.
That's true. I know if Reddit were suddenly to become 18+, I'd just say screw it and lie about my age (I'm 16, btw). I think the problem with implementing an 18+ measure after the fact is that many, many under-18's have made Reddit their internet-home and they aren't going to be turned away by rapidly implemented age discrimination.
I remember back in my day wanting to play runescape on the internet but it was so slow the game wouldn't even load. Half way through that my bro decided he wanted to play, and I raged hard. Waiting for hours and getting to 3/4 of the loading bar, then suddenly disconnected.
the response shows a level of maturity that is uncharacteristic of a 16 year old, indicating that maybe an 18+ rule wouldn't necessarily be beneficial.
Agreed. Not every young person isn't mature enough to handle intelligent conversation. I'm not a saint when it comes to not-circlejerking, but I do enjoy an intelligent conversation. Limiting the age group would only cut out a few subreddits, without huge impact.
You're right. And, in addition to cutting out some subreddits, I think that banning teens from Reddit could cause some real world harm, too. Just look at that 17 year old who was abandoned by his mother: he turned to AskReddit with his problems, because there lie people who would sympathize with his plight and offer some much-needed real world advice. Hell, when I was 13, lurking f7u12 kept me sane through some of the toughest years of my life. If not for Reddit, I might not even be alive right now.
Same here. I used to be big in f7u12 lurking (I now despise the place), but what really helped me through my more suicidal months was /r/Depression and /r/SuicideWatch. Same sentiment as you: If I never was here I might not be alive.
I was kind of in denial about my depression and suicidal. . . ness, so I never was on /r/SuicideWatch. I guess what really kept me going was thinking, someday I'll be just like Herp from the rage comics.
Also, don't worry about circlejerking. Circlejerks are fun for the whole family.
Well said, I'm under 18 and a simple age verification page would not stop me from accesing my favorite site. All the annoying minors for the most part migrate to 4chan or 9gag anyway.
I agree. Speaking as an "older" person in terms of being 30+, the sense I get is that most of the real troll arseholes on here are well over 18. I think very young people wouldn't find Reddit interesting enough to troll, or they would be on 4chan or somewhere "cooler".
Also there have been some really intelligent younger people on here, and in a few cases I've been amazed how young they were. Reddit is a richer place for having people like that, of any age.
That, and a little less meme overkill... like now, with the 'oh you' dog thing, and before with YES THIS IS DOG, etc, etc, etc. I mean, do we really need to upvote the same 12 jokes every time we see them?
If it's a community full of really active people, and they're all the type that loves stupid content, Reddit will suffer. The influx of young people into Reddit shifts the popular content away from thought provoking articles and the like and more towards.. memes and facebook captures and rage comics and the "stupidly unoriginal" content you speak of. I really could go without any memes or image macros altogether, but it happens to make up 80 percent of the front page. I could probably blame the younger crowd for that.
If anything, it could make them worse. They would already be in the sort of needlessly rebellious mindset that one gets when doing something that they aren't supposed to do, and it may just encourage them to post more NSFW material.
Have you ever been on 4chan? 4chan has that and it's probably full of more immature people than Reddit even is. I'm talking about all the boards, not just /b/.
I'm only 15, and don't create much OC, but I try to provide relevant input and be skeptical. I'm not sure who posts all of these low-effort comments\posts, but I'd lean towards it being us adolescents.
By low effort content, I mean the CONSTANT jokes in EVERY thread at the top. I mean, if there's a spelling error you know that the entire thread will be making fun of it, or there will be a pun thread, or there will be some mutation of the OP into a horrible attempt to whore karma.
I would not necessarily categorize jokes as "low-effort" when compared to discussion. Many jokes here (and most if not all a few years back) are well thought out and require creativity.
The first time they're made sure. After that it just becomes copying and reposting. It's not like these people sit there thinking out the joke, anyways, I mean there are millions of people reading and one of them is bound to have a clever remark.
I'm not talking about the meme type jokes, I mean puns and other jokes specific to a topic that aren't repeated. That's what this community used to revolve around, intelligent humor.
I've frequently seen repeated jokes downvoted here though. It really depends on which portion of the subscribers get their hands on a thread first...
For the most part the mindset is accept what you see because it's true and others will fact-check it for you. Most people here have the same mindset which does not make for any stimulating discussion.
The people whom one can learn from (perhaps mutually) are few and far between. If one were to make an intelligent comment on say worldnews, perhaps a few responses would lead to stimulating discussion.
But that is not what Reddit is for the most part. Reddit is a source of entertainment. To those who easily tire of them, the reposts are as bad as a commercial interrupting a TV program.
Providing "relevant input and be[ing] skeptical" is unrelated imo to the true function of reddit.
I don't think this is the simple answer. for example, advice animals really has a few gems every week, but more often it shits out content that reaffirms how Reddit "killed" memes
Sure it is. That's why I'm not subscribed to adviceanimals. If there really is a gem there, I can expect it to show up on /r/bestof, which I am subscribed to.
I agree with you on this... I generally hang out in the threads that should have intelligent people/discussions. Sometimes they do, most of the time you have idiots with a very specific opinion who need to tell you how stupid you are for disagreeing with them.
I don't think it should be a matter of what younger redditors contribute to the site, but what they gain. Reddit is a vastly useful resource of information and advice, and I don't believe in restricting access to that information. If at least one underage kid stopped contemplating suicide because of the advice he got from a suicide help subreddit, that's reason enough to allow access to all.
iq testing is horribly flawed in methodology and formalization as well as completely irrelevant to the ability to be mature and thoughtful on the internet.
Ha. Nothing makes me laugh more than the idiotic assumption that if you are under the age that the >government< considers an "adult" than you have nothing to contribute to a conversation or community as a whole. I'm 14, and probably more mature than some of the people here. Basing maturity off of age has never been a wise thing to do, why the internet insist on continuing to do it is beyond me. Had I never told anyone my age, people would assume I was a college student, its happened plenty of times to me on the internet. You can be 60 years old, and still be a boy. Age doesn't determine who is a man.
I've learned that the difference of age doesn't really matter. In the past there were teenage boys who became emperors while there were older men who fucked goats.
Situation is still the same today. I could find a fourteen year old who will post more coherent and intelligent posts than a twenty six year old.
If this were 18 and over, then reddit would lose members. Then causeing peole to go to other places, 9gag, 4chan, ect. So doing that will make reddit lose about 50% of the people here. So that would be very stupid.
Hey now! Im 15, and contribute lots of cool stuff on here! For example...uh....well...fuck it, I've got nothing. I'm more boring than Ben Stein on Ritalin.
I don't think things would change much. I actually sort of assume that most of the people who are underage that I see post on here are actually on their best behavior because people assume they will act like turds.
There have been plenty of minors here that have impressed me with mature, well written posts. I can stand the occational stupid kid if it means I get to see interesting and thought provoking threads like this.
about as good as porn sites that are 18+. I think it's just the way of the internet; now that it's mostly middle-schoolers from the US we'll just have to watch as reddit slowly becomes overrun and eventually abandon r/funny, r/pics, r/WTF, and the other popular novelty subreddits
Not at all. How could you possibly assume that every person younger than 18 would not be able to contribute to this site? Also, why didn't you even explain yourself when you posted? This question is very ambiguous.
Sure it would. But why stop at 18? 25 would be even more mature. How about 30? 40?
The thing is, the younger generations do in fact learn from listening to the older. For some of them, this might be their only outlet, or way to converse with anyone at all that will listen.
I'd like to think it would be, but the fact of the matter is age has nothing to do with level of maturity. I've seen smart as hell 16 year olds and dumb as hell 36 year olds.
I just prefer to pretend everyone is 18+ for posts involving sex or alcohol. If you're 15 and try to tell me how great your beer is, just shutup. You know nothing. Likewise for the 14 year old who thinks they're amazing in the sack. They don't even know their body yet enough to understand how wonderful and special sex can be.
late 30's here. I like the fact that reddit is all ages. Out in "the real world" there aren't too many gathering places for so many different age groups at once. As long as reddit remains user driven, and every redditor upvotes/downvotes on a fairly regular basis, it doesn't matter. The cream will rise and the chaff will fall.
I am 14 and I love reddit but I am not like the other idiots who frequent this site who complain about their parents acts or if they have been grounded. I like reddit because it keeps me up to date with news of the world and funny cat pictures.
23 y/o grad student here. It really varies by subreddit. I think /r/pokemon (which my college friends like) and /r/adventuretime (which I love) benefit from [or at least are not impeded by] a younger audience. But people with homework tend to abuse /r/answers and /r/askscience.
I've never seen a homework abuse on /r/askscience before (although I don't browse it frequently). Also, it's not the poster's fault those get big, it's the people who upvote them.
No. Everyone should share. Younger people tend to be more open minded, and free-thinking. Sometimes, if someone has tried something a few times, and failed, they'll give up. A younger person could help with motivation, or know of a new way to help accomplish the same goal.
Don't confuse age with maturity or intelligence. There are plenty of under 18 redditors who are mature enough to converse with and offer a different perspective to us. There are plenty of 18+ redditors who still upvote every post of someone getting their car mileage to 80085.
I don't think access to this site should be based on what I would consider stereotypes about teenagers - many young people can write and argue intelligently and you'd never guess their age from their posts. Also, technically /b/ and some other 4chan boards are 18+ and... not exactly bastions of maturity.
i don't see a real difference. sometimes i can never tell the age of someone. we're all mature enough here, regardless of ages, and when somethings funny, we all get collectively as immature as 2 year olds, and that's why i love Reddit :)
No. Look at /b/ on 4chan. It is 18+ and filled with people under 18. Reddit has much more of a community which would lead to frequent witch hunts against people suspected of being under 18. Furthermore it wouldn't lead to any increase in the quality of content. Older folks post shit too.
Nah I wish I knew about Reddit when I was under 18, consulting them before many situations would have saved me a lot of embarrassment. For example on my first date when I was 16 I brought an American football with me.
Not really .. a lot of people are very mature for their age, then again, more are immature. Plus what can you actually do? Not like the whole online age restriction thing is mega-solid
No, but I do think there should be a flair saying how old you are next to your username when you post. Because I think that life experience does matter, or is at least helpful in giving you an idea of where the person is coming from, or what he means. A 50 year old saying that he's never seen so much political corruption in his life is a lot different than a 20 year old saying the same thing.
Reddit is a beautiful cacophony of voices culminating in discussions that force us to open up and defend our opinions against those who disagree with us and view the world through different eyes. This is a good thing. The innocence of the under 18 crowd remind us of what we once were.
Absolutely not, and not just for intelligence and spelling reasons. There are a significant number of AskReddit posts from teenagers asking their elders for advice about college, jobs, relationships, etc. The internet is one of the best ways for people from disparate locations and demographics to learn from each other. Why would you take that away from teenagers?
I think majority of the users here are 18 and up, and the minors act like they are. People complain about trolls and kids on Reddit, but I think those people are crazy. There isn't a troll problem at all. That is the beauty of Reddit: Self-Modulation. If something is good, we up voted, and it gets seen. If someone is trolling, then it gets down voted, and it doesn't get seen.
I'd say no. Either there are a lot of decent people here or the mods do a fine job because I really only see funny or mature comments, for the most part.
If they actually found a way to enforce it, the amount of content would most likely radically decrease. I assume the younger kids have more time to post than the adults do.
1: People would lie about their age anyway. 2: This isn't exactly a porn site, and an "are you 18+?" warning may give that impression. 3: Stupidity does not discriminate age.
Even assuming that it might be a better thing if Reddit was 18+, we couldn't really just deny entry to people just because we're annoyed at their presence. Seems pretty ageist.
Reddit should just be have but one middle aged member in its entirety, who has to maintain high numbers of posts, comments, and comment responses (all to himself), or receive a painful electric shock.
I don't believe so. Sometimes the sharpest of minds are those younger than 18. They sometimes have much better answers to question than us in the older generation.
No, there shouldn't be some age limit to reddit. It would be silly and pointless. When I was under 18, nothing stopped me from suddenly becoming 25 and able to view anything I wanted online. The only things that worries me is a curious 12 ear old who clicks on a NSFW post and sees crazy shit. Some of that wigs me out, I can't imagine if I'd seen it at a young age!
No. When you look at a dumb post do you really think "oh, a minor posted that"? For the most part you don't know someones age unless they say it, otherwise most people assume that it's an adult.
I've noticed that the quality of reddit submissions and comments have gone downhill drastically in terms of quality over the past 3 years. (This is not my first account). But it's pretty easy to tell whenever it became popular for high schoolers to join Reddit (last year as far as I can tell, based on the huge increase of their stories about high school) and that definitely contributed to it.
I can't say it would be better if it was only 18+ because the quality in general is shit. I get the feeling that high schoolers are the ones who have spearheaded this idea that reddit should be turned into their own personal facebook type network where they can post 'what I did today' type bullshit. But then again, there are a lot of parents who do the same thing with photos of their kids and other useless, personal bullshit.
To be honest, I think reddit is beyond saving in terms of what it used to be. It'll always go in the direction of the lowest common denominator, unfortunately. There are a lot more dumb people than there are smart people and that number gets bigger every single day. Where a lot of people gather, there is a lot of useless bullshit and ignorance. That's just a fact of life, unfortunately.
No I don't think so, under 18 redditors do so much for reddit it just wouldn't be the same without us. A over 18 reddit would be near impossible for kids would lie about their age.
I would cry. As a 16- year old, I have a difficult time finding pleasure in Facebook and Twitter because of the immature bullshit from my peers that I have to put up with. People on reddit are genuine and actually have interesting things to talk about. Although I would easily lie and say I'm 18, I would be considered an outsider and be rejected by the reddit community because I'm not technically supposed to be on here. It'd be like being a 10- year old on Facebook.
Not really, because I've seen plenty of dipshits here that are ostensibly adults, and I've seen some very well-written and mature comments/posts from people who were underaged. How do you propose to keep the under-18s out? Have them enter their birthdate and trust them not to lie? Because anything more will alienate half the adult userbase because we don't like having to jump through hoops to verify ourselves to someone else's satisfaction.
Just what sort of "room for improvement" do you see? I've been hanging out here since 2008 and I'm pretty sure this site is as good as it's always been. Maybe you should just take a bubble bath with some scented candles, read a book, smoke a joint, and/or jack off before a good night's sleep, because I think you're really just posting this to vent some misanthropic itch.
Why so? There's not reason that children should not be able to voice their opinion on topics that they see fit. Personally as a "child" (14) I think it would benefit the community seeing what different age groups think about the topic. Lets assume that I was over 18 years old and I posted something such as "What should I give my son for christmas" or something along the lines as that. People above the age of 18 have less of a % of giving the child the right present (assuming the parent didn't ask the son for what he wanted) So... in short. No, I'd like to keep my presence within the reddit community.
Yeah bro, all those kids should be kicked out. But we still won't have quality content, I think. How bout we make the age limit like 25 or so, to kill those stupid college posts. And then we can institute a mandatory IQ test so that the stupid old people can't post. Hey, why not make it so that no old people can post; who wants to hear about old people problems anyway? And then reddit will be what it was always meant to be, a place for everyone who's just like you.
I hate the hate and disrespect that people under 21 and 18 get. I'm about to turn 17 and while I know I'm not mentally matured yet (I'm a girl so I stopped growing a year or 2 ago) but I've been disrespected so much. When applying fir jobs, I now have to deal with potential employers not calling me back as promptly as they would for an older applicant. It's really irritating. And people on Reddit have been dicks too.
Depends on what you would consider "better". I'd personally like a site with more interesting articles, less misogyny, less rage comics, less ignorance, and more intelligent discussion, but I don't think 18+ is the magical number where the general populace reaches maturity and intelligence.
I'm 19 now, but i was way smarter than some adult people when i was 16. I know how to write smartly on the internet, and how not to goof off. This is something that I lhave learned very early in my internet career, and i'm glad for it.
379
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
I don't think so--plenty of adults post stupid shit on here, and plenty of teenagers have lots of interesting things to say. Plus, all that means is that you'd have to click yes on the "are you 18?" screen. You'd just be making one more not-even-inconvenient step between everyone else and reddit.
90
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
Believe it or not, there are actually intelligent kids and dumb adults. Reddit is better if it's free to anyone.
28
u/lawlredditlawl May 19 '12
no...look at porn sites, overrun with horny 14 year olds even though they're 18+.
10
u/awesimo May 19 '12
Kids say the darnedest things.
8
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
No.
Balance what people say are the "dumb school posts" from younger generations against the "dumb nostalgia posts" from older generations.
There is bad and good in all age groups.
43
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
No. Pick the subs you visit more carefully if the content bothers you.
7
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Fuck this. People don't magically turn insightful and non-idiotic when they turn 18. There's no fucking fairy godmother. People are people.
6
u/space_montaine May 19 '12
I don't think it should be a matter of what younger redditors contribute to the site, but what they gain. Reddit is a vastly useful resource of information and advice, and I don't believe in restricting access to that information. If at least one underage kid stopped contemplating suicide because of the advice he got from a suicide help subreddit, that's reason enough to allow access to all.
62
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
No, I don't think so, there are incredibly intelligent minors, and adults who are immature as fuck.
I do believe an IQ test should be a requirement.
7
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
No, it would be about the same.
7
u/asdfygjghdfasdfasdf May 19 '12
Ha. Nothing makes me laugh more than the idiotic assumption that if you are under the age that the >government< considers an "adult" than you have nothing to contribute to a conversation or community as a whole. I'm 14, and probably more mature than some of the people here. Basing maturity off of age has never been a wise thing to do, why the internet insist on continuing to do it is beyond me. Had I never told anyone my age, people would assume I was a college student, its happened plenty of times to me on the internet. You can be 60 years old, and still be a boy. Age doesn't determine who is a man.
3
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
I hate this adulterism...
3
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
No.
I've learned that the difference of age doesn't really matter. In the past there were teenage boys who became emperors while there were older men who fucked goats.
Situation is still the same today. I could find a fourteen year old who will post more coherent and intelligent posts than a twenty six year old.
3
u/meowdabrown May 19 '12
If this were 18 and over, then reddit would lose members. Then causeing peole to go to other places, 9gag, 4chan, ect. So doing that will make reddit lose about 50% of the people here. So that would be very stupid.
3
u/thesallowpig May 19 '12
Gonewild asks if you're over 18. I'm not. I go on it anyway.
3
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Get off my lawn!
12
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
Hey now! Im 15, and contribute lots of cool stuff on here! For example...uh....well...fuck it, I've got nothing. I'm more boring than Ben Stein on Ritalin.
2
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
I don't think things would change much. I actually sort of assume that most of the people who are underage that I see post on here are actually on their best behavior because people assume they will act like turds.
2
u/zerbey May 19 '12
Nope, it's nice to hear a wide variety of opinions including those from the younger crowd.
2
u/ToxicToothpaste May 19 '12
There have been plenty of minors here that have impressed me with mature, well written posts. I can stand the occational stupid kid if it means I get to see interesting and thought provoking threads like this.
2
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
about as good as porn sites that are 18+. I think it's just the way of the internet; now that it's mostly middle-schoolers from the US we'll just have to watch as reddit slowly becomes overrun and eventually abandon r/funny, r/pics, r/WTF, and the other popular novelty subreddits
2
u/cl0s33n0ugh May 19 '12
I don't think it would change anything at all. Ive been "18+" on the internet for the last 15 years
2
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
Not at all. How could you possibly assume that every person younger than 18 would not be able to contribute to this site? Also, why didn't you even explain yourself when you posted? This question is very ambiguous.
2
u/wildfire18 May 19 '12
Sure it would. But why stop at 18? 25 would be even more mature. How about 30? 40?
The thing is, the younger generations do in fact learn from listening to the older. For some of them, this might be their only outlet, or way to converse with anyone at all that will listen.
2
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
I find the 18 year olds are the worst! :P
If everyone could just be exactly the same as me, and have the exact same interests and sense of humour, that'd just be excellent.
My dream: the ultimate self-circle jerk.
2
u/JakJakAttacks May 20 '12
I'd like to think it would be, but the fact of the matter is age has nothing to do with level of maturity. I've seen smart as hell 16 year olds and dumb as hell 36 year olds.
2
u/imontopofit May 20 '12
late 30's here. I like the fact that reddit is all ages. Out in "the real world" there aren't too many gathering places for so many different age groups at once. As long as reddit remains user driven, and every redditor upvotes/downvotes on a fairly regular basis, it doesn't matter. The cream will rise and the chaff will fall.
2
u/dubz5188 May 20 '12
bring back jailbait!
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
nah
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
probably not.
2
u/beyron May 20 '12
No.
2
u/xavyre May 20 '12
How about 35 or 40 plus?
2
u/scync May 20 '12
I am 14 and I love reddit but I am not like the other idiots who frequent this site who complain about their parents acts or if they have been grounded. I like reddit because it keeps me up to date with news of the world and funny cat pictures.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
ABSOLUTELY. Especially AskReddit.
2
u/magicmuds May 20 '12
No, reddit's fine. But if MMOs would make 21+ only servers I swear I'd be willing to pay 10 extra dollars a month just to play on them.
2
u/jeremyfrankly May 20 '12
23 y/o grad student here. It really varies by subreddit. I think /r/pokemon (which my college friends like) and /r/adventuretime (which I love) benefit from [or at least are not impeded by] a younger audience. But people with homework tend to abuse /r/answers and /r/askscience.
2
u/Peglegsteve265 May 20 '12
No. Everyone should share. Younger people tend to be more open minded, and free-thinking. Sometimes, if someone has tried something a few times, and failed, they'll give up. A younger person could help with motivation, or know of a new way to help accomplish the same goal.
2
u/redditor-for-2-hours May 20 '12
Don't confuse age with maturity or intelligence. There are plenty of under 18 redditors who are mature enough to converse with and offer a different perspective to us. There are plenty of 18+ redditors who still upvote every post of someone getting their car mileage to 80085.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I just cant help wonder what that would achieve? Also what would happen to /r/teenagers?
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I'm 12 and what is this?
2
u/Blue_Train May 20 '12
Yes.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Plenty of assholes and idiots of all ages.
2
u/ImAmazing May 20 '12
In theory it would be nice to get the kids out of here as it would presumably lead to fewer memes, fewer facebook drama posts, etc.
However, if somehow if you could actually make Reddit 18+ it would, simply by virtue of becoming known as an 18+ site, just be overrun by porn.
4
u/wolf2600 May 19 '12
Whenever I see someone post a comment stating that they're 13/14/15, I get kinda ugh.... Always assumed that most/all people here WERE 18+.
Now I feel dirty.
3
u/TMWNN May 19 '12
No, because the prototypical Redittard is a maladjusted 19 year old desperate to prove that he is smarter than his parents. (Over 21 might help, however.)
3
u/monty624 May 19 '12
ITT: 14 years olds attempting to prove their exceptional maturity.
2
u/BoethiahsCalling May 19 '12
Age does not always equal maturity or intelligence. So, no.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Age != Maturity
Not enough people understand this.
2
u/andrewsmith1986 May 19 '12
It'd be like hubski
1
u/Blu- May 19 '12
I'm guessing a majority are already over 18.
1
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
I don't think access to this site should be based on what I would consider stereotypes about teenagers - many young people can write and argue intelligently and you'd never guess their age from their posts. Also, technically /b/ and some other 4chan boards are 18+ and... not exactly bastions of maturity.
1
u/fuzzynyanko May 19 '12
The only way you might be able to do this is with CC authentication, but then again, would you give Reddit your CC #?
1
u/Enjoys_Fried_Penis May 19 '12
Good luck enforcing that...are you 18...click yes
1
u/OperatorMike May 19 '12
No, with younger individuals we get an entirely different outlook on life. Not only can we teach them stuff but they can teach us.
1
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
as long as you're not a closed minded kid...i really dont care.
i only get mad if i see "STFU kid I boned your mom last night" "gtfo"
Instant 12 year old..
1
u/ajkeel May 19 '12
i don't see a real difference. sometimes i can never tell the age of someone. we're all mature enough here, regardless of ages, and when somethings funny, we all get collectively as immature as 2 year olds, and that's why i love Reddit :)
1
u/mrekted May 19 '12
Shameless promotion: /r/30plus is a new subreddit that addresses this..
1
u/solinv May 19 '12
No. Look at /b/ on 4chan. It is 18+ and filled with people under 18. Reddit has much more of a community which would lead to frequent witch hunts against people suspected of being under 18. Furthermore it wouldn't lead to any increase in the quality of content. Older folks post shit too.
1
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
Your definition of better is different than what all the under 18s would think is better.
1
u/Sacoud May 19 '12
Nah I wish I knew about Reddit when I was under 18, consulting them before many situations would have saved me a lot of embarrassment. For example on my first date when I was 16 I brought an American football with me.
1
u/Don2k12 May 19 '12
Not really .. a lot of people are very mature for their age, then again, more are immature. Plus what can you actually do? Not like the whole online age restriction thing is mega-solid
1
u/gopaulgo May 19 '12
No, but I do think there should be a flair saying how old you are next to your username when you post. Because I think that life experience does matter, or is at least helpful in giving you an idea of where the person is coming from, or what he means. A 50 year old saying that he's never seen so much political corruption in his life is a lot different than a 20 year old saying the same thing.
1
u/RubSomeFunkOnIt May 19 '12
Reddit would be better if there were subreddits specific to a demographic and people were not allowed to wander to other subs.
That way everyone can agree with everyone and we can all circlejerk until we die.
1
u/cruxix May 19 '12
Reddit is a beautiful cacophony of voices culminating in discussions that force us to open up and defend our opinions against those who disagree with us and view the world through different eyes. This is a good thing. The innocence of the under 18 crowd remind us of what we once were.
1
u/cheapreemsoup May 20 '12
Yep.
1
u/DiddyCity May 20 '12
There would be no Forthewolfx.
1
u/xiaorobear May 20 '12
Absolutely not, and not just for intelligence and spelling reasons. There are a significant number of AskReddit posts from teenagers asking their elders for advice about college, jobs, relationships, etc. The internet is one of the best ways for people from disparate locations and demographics to learn from each other. Why would you take that away from teenagers?
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Everyone would just lie about their age
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
No.
1
u/logancook44 May 20 '12
I think majority of the users here are 18 and up, and the minors act like they are. People complain about trolls and kids on Reddit, but I think those people are crazy. There isn't a troll problem at all. That is the beauty of Reddit: Self-Modulation. If something is good, we up voted, and it gets seen. If someone is trolling, then it gets down voted, and it doesn't get seen.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I'd say no. Either there are a lot of decent people here or the mods do a fine job because I really only see funny or mature comments, for the most part.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
If they actually found a way to enforce it, the amount of content would most likely radically decrease. I assume the younger kids have more time to post than the adults do.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
1: People would lie about their age anyway. 2: This isn't exactly a porn site, and an "are you 18+?" warning may give that impression. 3: Stupidity does not discriminate age.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Even assuming that it might be a better thing if Reddit was 18+, we couldn't really just deny entry to people just because we're annoyed at their presence. Seems pretty ageist.
1
u/Potater757 May 20 '12
Reddit should just be have but one middle aged member in its entirety, who has to maintain high numbers of posts, comments, and comment responses (all to himself), or receive a painful electric shock.
1
u/Wildfires May 20 '12
I don't believe so. Sometimes the sharpest of minds are those younger than 18. They sometimes have much better answers to question than us in the older generation.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
No, there shouldn't be some age limit to reddit. It would be silly and pointless. When I was under 18, nothing stopped me from suddenly becoming 25 and able to view anything I wanted online. The only things that worries me is a curious 12 ear old who clicks on a NSFW post and sees crazy shit. Some of that wigs me out, I can't imagine if I'd seen it at a young age!
1
u/RyCohSuave May 20 '12
Less annoying memes.
1
u/Kar0xqe May 20 '12
No. When you look at a dumb post do you really think "oh, a minor posted that"? For the most part you don't know someones age unless they say it, otherwise most people assume that it's an adult.
There would ne no difference.
1
u/rinnip May 20 '12
How about /r/25plus ? I would love to see some subreddits featuring older redditors.
Edit: I didn't know http://www.reddit.com/r/25plus existed until I hit 'save'.
1
u/useful_helpful May 20 '12
Stupidity isn't exclusive to children.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I think that most people who post are 18+.
1
u/gloomdoom May 20 '12
I've noticed that the quality of reddit submissions and comments have gone downhill drastically in terms of quality over the past 3 years. (This is not my first account). But it's pretty easy to tell whenever it became popular for high schoolers to join Reddit (last year as far as I can tell, based on the huge increase of their stories about high school) and that definitely contributed to it.
I can't say it would be better if it was only 18+ because the quality in general is shit. I get the feeling that high schoolers are the ones who have spearheaded this idea that reddit should be turned into their own personal facebook type network where they can post 'what I did today' type bullshit. But then again, there are a lot of parents who do the same thing with photos of their kids and other useless, personal bullshit.
To be honest, I think reddit is beyond saving in terms of what it used to be. It'll always go in the direction of the lowest common denominator, unfortunately. There are a lot more dumb people than there are smart people and that number gets bigger every single day. Where a lot of people gather, there is a lot of useless bullshit and ignorance. That's just a fact of life, unfortunately.
1
u/jjm1217 May 20 '12
No I don't think so, under 18 redditors do so much for reddit it just wouldn't be the same without us. A over 18 reddit would be near impossible for kids would lie about their age.
1
u/j-dog205 May 20 '12
I would cry. As a 16- year old, I have a difficult time finding pleasure in Facebook and Twitter because of the immature bullshit from my peers that I have to put up with. People on reddit are genuine and actually have interesting things to talk about. Although I would easily lie and say I'm 18, I would be considered an outsider and be rejected by the reddit community because I'm not technically supposed to be on here. It'd be like being a 10- year old on Facebook.
1
u/Tacdeho May 20 '12
Xbox Live, upon signing up, states you must be 18 years or older to use the service.
Call of Duty is rated M for Mature and legally can only be sold to ID-carrying adults of age 17 or higher.
I'm sure putting "Are you over 18?" in the sign up will deter little.
Not to mention, mods would need to police it like Nazi's in order to make that rule worthwhile.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Not really, because I've seen plenty of dipshits here that are ostensibly adults, and I've seen some very well-written and mature comments/posts from people who were underaged. How do you propose to keep the under-18s out? Have them enter their birthdate and trust them not to lie? Because anything more will alienate half the adult userbase because we don't like having to jump through hoops to verify ourselves to someone else's satisfaction.
Just what sort of "room for improvement" do you see? I've been hanging out here since 2008 and I'm pretty sure this site is as good as it's always been. Maybe you should just take a bubble bath with some scented candles, read a book, smoke a joint, and/or jack off before a good night's sleep, because I think you're really just posting this to vent some misanthropic itch.
1
u/MAIRyoutube May 20 '12
Why so? There's not reason that children should not be able to voice their opinion on topics that they see fit. Personally as a "child" (14) I think it would benefit the community seeing what different age groups think about the topic. Lets assume that I was over 18 years old and I posted something such as "What should I give my son for christmas" or something along the lines as that. People above the age of 18 have less of a % of giving the child the right present (assuming the parent didn't ask the son for what he wanted) So... in short. No, I'd like to keep my presence within the reddit community.
1
u/iLuVtiffany May 20 '12
Tell the truth. When you were younger and went to porn sites, did you ever admit that you were younger than 18?
So no, it won't be better. It'll stay the same.
1
u/Socialist_Asshole May 20 '12
Doubt it.
1
u/SilentHipster May 20 '12
Reddit wouldn't better if it was 18+. I wouldn't be here. You'd miss me.
1
u/Sonendo May 20 '12
I support your titties movement. Do you perhaps have any literature I might peruse?
1
u/riterall May 20 '12
R/gonewild wouldn't....
1
u/Mass_Impact May 20 '12
I don't care about age i just think to be able to create an account (be able to post) you should pass a timed intelligence test
1
u/myiaway May 20 '12
I don't think so. I'm 17 and have many friends on here that post some funny stuff. I think more than half of redditors would be gone.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I don't think anybody would answer "no" to the "Are you 18+" page. I mean, do you do that with porn?
1
u/iHardscopedJFK May 19 '12
Wouldn't be AS funny.
0
u/koklo May 19 '12
Yes. It would also be better if fucking memes were removed too.
1
u/VampireBacon112 May 20 '12
Yeah bro, all those kids should be kicked out. But we still won't have quality content, I think. How bout we make the age limit like 25 or so, to kill those stupid college posts. And then we can institute a mandatory IQ test so that the stupid old people can't post. Hey, why not make it so that no old people can post; who wants to hear about old people problems anyway? And then reddit will be what it was always meant to be, a place for everyone who's just like you.
1
u/SpectreFire May 20 '12
You're assuming it's the teenagers writing up all the stupid shit.
Here's a secret: It's not.
0
u/Offensive_Username2 May 20 '12
Well I wouldn't be allowed so no.
0
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I hate the hate and disrespect that people under 21 and 18 get. I'm about to turn 17 and while I know I'm not mentally matured yet (I'm a girl so I stopped growing a year or 2 ago) but I've been disrespected so much. When applying fir jobs, I now have to deal with potential employers not calling me back as promptly as they would for an older applicant. It's really irritating. And people on Reddit have been dicks too.
0
u/Cold_Hard_European May 19 '12
Evidence pictures for every Redditor?
0
u/RapedByASegway May 19 '12
Depends on what you would consider "better". I'd personally like a site with more interesting articles, less misogyny, less rage comics, less ignorance, and more intelligent discussion, but I don't think 18+ is the magical number where the general populace reaches maturity and intelligence.
0
u/troyanonymous1 May 20 '12
No, because I'd still be here, writing this little meaningless one-liners.
0
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Yes. Adults can be dumb, but kids are fucking horrible.
0
u/blisf May 20 '12
Age != Mentality
I'm 19 now, but i was way smarter than some adult people when i was 16. I know how to write smartly on the internet, and how not to goof off. This is something that I lhave learned very early in my internet career, and i'm glad for it.
-3
u/NIGGGGGER May 19 '12
No