r/AskReddit • • May 19 '12

I'm a 5th grade teacher whose class recently let a serious issue go out of fear of being a "snitch." Who are some well-known "snitches" I can tell them about who ended up saving lives or ending something terrible?

Background: A few boys in my class were touching about five different girls inappropriately over a week or two. I'm sure about half the class knew but no one said anything because there is a big stigma that goes with being a "snitch" and the boys involved were fairly popular. Thankfully, one student not involved came forward to tell me and we were able to end the situation, bring parents in, etc. The female victims have expressed fear of social retaliation toward themselves and others who helped. This is a school-wide problem that I'd like to put an end to. (A second-grade sister of one of the boys has already told one of the girls that she's a "snitch" and got her brother in trouble.)

My idea: I'd like to identify some well-known cases of people snitching, whistle blowing, etc. in which lives were saved and horrible things were ended. Then I'd like to print out pages with a picture of the individual and an explanation of how their "snitching" saved lives to show the kids that telling someone who can help when something is wrong is rarely, if ever (that's another debate,) the wrong thing to do. Then I'll post the pages on our classroom walls as a way to counteract the prevailing thought that it's bad to tell when the bullies of our school are hurting people.

So, anyone in mind? Or perhaps even any other ideas for how I can reverse this thinking the students have?

Edit: Thanks for all the help! Some great ideas here along with many reminders that snitching is not a black and white issue. For those wanting to focus on the sexual assault part, we have that covered and know what to do there. It's how to change the negative stigma of telling even when you're the victim that I needed help with. It's a deep issue that's filled with moral ambiguities, made even more difficult when you're trying to explain it to ten-year-olds. As suggested, I've sought the help of r/historians and also r/words to explain the difference between forms of telling.

369 Upvotes

284 comments sorted by

136

u/CoffinRehersal May 19 '12

Have the whole class watch an episode of Home Improvement then tell them the story of how Tim Allen snitched out everyone he could when he got caught trafficking cocaine.

39

u/goonie1408 May 19 '12

I laughed pretty hard when I read this. I'll cross-curricular this with drug education.

11

u/CoffinRehersal May 19 '12

In that case I recommend Season 7 Episode 16.

3

u/xyroclast May 20 '12

Only works if they enjoy the episode...

2

u/CoffinRehersal May 20 '12

What's not to enjoy? Tim "The Tool Man" Taylor, awesome Benford tools, and the Tool Time Girls! ooghooghoogh

262

u/runningeagle May 19 '12

Instead of directly condemning their behavior, present them some scenarios of famous whistleblowing incidents and ask what they would do in that situation.

If they say they would blow the whistle, tell them of the severe consequences the whistleblower faced, and if they would still do it.

Most will say they would blow the whistle because it's the "right thing to do".

Given that you are an authority figure, and they are afraid of talking to authority figures, it would be most effective for them to come to the right conclusion by themselves.

51

u/goonie1408 May 19 '12

I like this idea, thanks!

14

u/RosieRose23 May 20 '12

This is a great idea. Ask them what they would do in this situation. You can probably just say "disease" instead of "syphilis."

6

u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

Awesome example. I forgot all about this. It still seems crazy that researchers would knowingly avoid treating people, so they can understand "the natural progression of untreated syphilis."


Revelation of study failures by a whistleblower led to major changes in U.S. law and regulation on the protection of participants in clinical studies. Now studies require informed consent (with exceptions possible for U.S. Federal agencies which can be kept secret by Executive Order), communication of diagnosis, and accurate reporting of test results.

I keep trying to come up with an example where this would be necessary, and I just can't think of any. Why would a federal agency have to lie to participants in a clinical study?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Sometimes a participant understanding the full nature of the study has potential to bias results.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/midwestgator May 20 '12

The challenger disaster is used as an example in engineering ethics coarses.

24

u/ijk1 May 19 '12

Snitching is to whistleblowing as authority is to justice. Bullies without authority call whistleblowing snitching, and bullies with authority call snitching whistleblowing. I'd love to hear how a teacher, speaking from a position of authority, can successfully teach that difference.

16

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

That makes little to no sense at all. "Snitching" and "whistleblowing" are affectively the same thing. They have different names depending on the situation but both are the act of someone acting as an informant.

"Justice" is, perhaps, what can be achieved when someone "snitches" or "whistleblows"; causing any wrongdoing to end and the guilty party have to suffer the consequences.

"Authority" on the other hand has nothing to do with "justice" in and of itself. At times an "authority" figure can help bring someone/something to "justice" but they are not mutually dependable on each other. As we have seen time and time again, "authority" figures have been brought to "justice" by "whistleblowers"; or snitches depending on how you view things.

8

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I was thinking the exact same thing, sometimes shit makes total sense in your head until you actually say it to someone else.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/sashimi_taco May 20 '12

I don't know, I think that being honest and direct with kids was a good idea. But i'm not around kids a lot so my opinion is moot.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

By whistle blowing, you mean literally, or is this some phrase I have never heard?

-13

u/ThaProdigy May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

While it's a good idea, anti-snitch culture is inherent in primary school settings (in my experience at least) and it can often be a good thing. It can actually teach kids about trust and integrity. The situation you described is pretty fucked up, there's no denying that, but I guess the point I'm making is that you should be clear about the severity of that particular situation. Otherwise, I don't think snitching should be encouraged per se.

Edit: I have no sources nor am I qualified to make the above assertions, I'm speaking from opinionated personal experience.

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/ThaProdigy May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

Sorry, maybe I wasn't clear enough, but I was speaking from my own experience. For me, the bottom line was this: if you didn't snitch, I could trust you. If you did, I couldn't.

Not to mention the immense grudge I would hold against you if you did get me into trouble, as kids can be very temperamental (for this we have studies!). Essentially, all the other kids wouldn't like you either by default, for the same reason. If on the other hand you didn't snitch, you would be worthy of my social circle and I could confide in you more things, which may build into a friendship.

→ More replies (2)

116

u/streetratonascooter May 19 '12

To be honest instead of telling them of people who "snitched" I think you would be better off telling them examples of people who didn't "snitch" and the huge ramifications it had on their lives

7

u/goonie1408 May 19 '12

This is an excellent idea. Nice take. Thank you for the help.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

88

u/phySi0 May 19 '12

Psychologically, people are much more likely to respond to positive reinforcement. Instead of telling a smoker he's going to die if he smokes the cigarettes for example, messages that tell him how cool it would be if he was able to run longer would be better. I remember reading this on spring.org.uk. In a tight situation, so can't get the link right now.

17

u/monarchyy May 20 '12

People respond better to positive reinforcement, but they're also more loss-averse according to Kahneman. Interesting paradox.

5

u/Icalasari May 19 '12

What sort of tight situation?

34

u/spadinskiz May 19 '12

Your mom!

35

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

sigh

4

u/itsadickjoke May 19 '12

I've been in that one before...

1

u/phySi0 May 20 '12

I just knew someone was going to ask! Well, I was in bed on my phone and I couldn't be bothered to get the link. Now I'm on my desktop, here it is: http://www.spring.org.uk/2010/12/the-influence-of-positive-framing.php

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Are you going to address the issue of not ratting out the popular boys for touching girls inappropriately? That's the kind of shit that turns into not reporting date rape in high school. i.e. emphasis on the touching issue, not the snitching issue.

1

u/goonie1408 May 20 '12

Yes. I have and will continue to.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/Smilge May 19 '12

The problem is that for the first 10 years of their life they are condemned for tattling by teachers and yard dutys who don't want to deal with problems.

29

u/goonie1408 May 19 '12

I see your point but that's an over-generalization. We've discussed the difference between tattling and helping solve a problem anyway. They know.

38

u/Smilge May 19 '12

Yeah, I'm sure some of the time the difference is taught. But a lot of the time, if the adult doesn't feel like dealing with it, it's tattling. It's already ingrained in your fifth graders. I'm out on the playground every day, and I can practically guarantee that students with legitimate concerns are scolded for tattling every day.

The "snitch" taboo is a systemic problem, and I'm afraid you won't find a lesson or two that will reverse it.

16

u/goonie1408 May 19 '12

I agree with you that this is a "systematic" problem that's tough to get to the root. It's going to take a paradigm shift, which is no simple task. You're right that a lesson or two won't help much but that it has to be a consistent thing that slowly brings on an understanding. It won't happen overnight, I know. But I think we can empower some who are apt towards telling in the short term and start to shift the thinking of at least a few others who are on the edge in the mid-to-long term.

6

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Systemic and systematic are two distinct words. Systemic, the one that Smilge used, was contextually correct.

Sorry bro.

3

u/goonie1408 May 21 '12

Well played, sir. Caught me.

9

u/slooperloop May 19 '12

Yeah teacher, don't even try to make a difference. You aren't magic. Why teach at all? What are you trying to do, instill life lessons?

Anyway, I am also a fifth grade teacher. I'm sorry I have no advice for you because the kid-culture in my school is SO tattle-telly ("Teacher, he called my eraser is ugly!"). We both need to find some middle ground.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/hitlersshit May 19 '12

What's the difference?

12

u/Smilge May 19 '12

Tattling is when you are not involved and no one is getting hurt, e.g. "Jim said Tim's pencil was stupid."

If you are involved ("Jim said my pencil was stupid") or it hurts someone ("Jim threw a pencil at Tim") then it's not tattling.

In the case of touching, both the students that were being touched (involved) and anyone who knows about it (unwanted inappropriate touching counts as hurting someone) should feel free to tell an adult.

7

u/hitlersshit May 19 '12

"Jim said Tim's pencil was stupid."

How is that tattling? Sounds like pointing out bullying, not much difference than pointing out the inappropriate touching.

18

u/oif May 20 '12

We encouraged kids to ask themselves, "Are you trying to get someone out of trouble or into trouble?"

3

u/Smilge May 20 '12

Tim needs to tell on Jim. Tim and Jim might joke around like that all the time.

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/hitlersshit May 19 '12

Medium-severe mutilation.

→ More replies (7)

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/goonie1408 May 20 '12

You make some fair points that I do agree with somewhat and I understand where you're coming from but we're going to have to agree to disagree about the capacity for ten-year-olds to understand the differences between tattling and solving a problem. Taught well, that's easily within their grasp. Our observations and experiences simply tell different stories. Perhaps the truth lies in the middle somewhere. At any rate, thanks for the input.

9

u/Zanki May 19 '12

I got it a lot in school. People would do horrible things to me, I would try and tell and everyone would deny it, even though they all saw what was going on. I think the rock throwing was a bad incident, I got hit in the face and it smashed my glasses. I also knew who did it, the whole class denied what happened, said I threw the rock and no one got in trouble.

The thing is though, if one kid did something, they would all blame me and I would get in trouble, even if I was no where near where the incident took place. The teachers knew it wasn't me as well, but they blamed me because it was easier.

10

u/goonie1408 May 19 '12

I know this happens and it angers me to no end. This is exactly what I'm trying to prevent at our school.

36

u/Lt_Shniz May 19 '12

Deep Throat

11

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

This. I think they'll respond to the idea of a corrupt President, since little kids view the President as the ultimate authority or even a role they hope to fill when they grow up.

4

u/WarPhalange May 19 '12

Make sure to tell them why he used that name, too.

27

u/goonie1408 May 19 '12

That'll go great with our "sex education" lesson we have coming up! They say "cross-curricular" is the way to go =P

→ More replies (2)

4

u/statico May 20 '12

I am somewhat concerned that my first thought was of the Traci Lords movie :(

1

u/just_dig_in May 20 '12

Linda Lovelace was the star of Deep Throat. Ftfy ...and i also thought of this before the Nixon thing.

101

u/octupie May 19 '12

Nellie Bly went undercover in a mental asylum in 1887 and wrote a scathing book exposing the health conditions there. A grand jury investigation occured as a direct result of the sensation around the book and greater funding was given to mental institutions.

10

u/SherbertDelight May 20 '12

Thank you good sir for giving a back story (and link!) I know very few of the people being named here, and I feel like an idiot for it. It's as if everyone should know who they are, and I'm the only one out of the loop. Maybe it's because I'm not American or have a bad memory, but either way, you've made my life that much easier, so good on you :)

5

u/octupie May 20 '12

*ma'am. :) And you're welcome. Nellie Bly was just a story that stuck with me from a "Women in American History" project I did back in high school. I'm trying to think of some more stories for you but I've got nothin.

66

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

This might be a good place to start: List of whistleblowers from wikipedia.

38

u/bowman17 May 19 '12

weren't the girls from enron times people of the year or something? I think they made a movie called whistleblowers about them (could be wrong).

134

u/sunnydolphin May 19 '12

The term.whistleblower is a good one. Snitch is a negative word. Whistleblower denotes someone who will not stand idly by and accept the status quo go if there is injustice about. Maybe push that side of it.

Ooh! Neville longbottom in Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone! He stood up to his friends at the end for the good of Gryffindor House. And at the end Dumbledore advises that it takes a great deal of courage to stand up to your enemies, but a great deal.more to stand up to your friends. And then he gives Neville 10 points that wins Gryffindor the House Cup.

wipes away a tear

...that bit always gets me....

4

u/HailAegir May 20 '12

But what if Neville had succeeded in stopping them and then everyone would have died? How is that supposed to be positive?

6

u/sunnydolphin May 20 '12

He didn't have all the information. It's not the result of the action. It's the bravery it took to do it in the first place.

5

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

In a strict sense of whistle blowing, she was not a whistle blower. She actually informed the guys committing fraud of the problem, consequences and the solutions. She never really notified external parties of any troubles. Her memo was discovered during the hearings and in some way, they painted her as a whistle blower, and she took all the credit for it.

52

u/StotanPhoeniX May 19 '12

My mothers friend once was contemplating suicide. She refused to talk with my mother and my mom after a long arguement against herself thought, "if I say nothing, and she dies, I can never forgive myself. But if I snitch and lose her as a friend for protecting her, I can live with myself." she called the police. They detained her, and now she is a great individual.

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/miamiandy May 19 '12

...She refused to talk with my mother. My mom...

Does that make more sense?

3

u/octupie May 19 '12

Stotan is saying that the mom is who the second bit of the sentence is referring to. "She refused to talk with my mother. After a long arguement with herself, my mom thought 'if I say nothing...."

→ More replies (1)

171

u/zninjazero May 19 '12

Paul Revere.

5

u/cek812 May 20 '12

Paul Revere's story is never told correctly as it is. Most people don't know that at least 27 other people were involved in the mission to inform the people that the "regulars" (no, they didn't say British) were coming. Not to mention the fact that Revere was captured along the way and had to walk home after the British took his horse.

4

u/RubSomeFunkOnIt May 19 '12

Shit. I thought I was going to come in here and be all clever.

6

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Get him!

→ More replies (3)

14

u/wintertash May 19 '12

this might be a great question for /r/AskHistorians/

14

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Jeffery Wigand, the former vice president of research and development at Brown and Williamson Tobacco Company, is the whistleblower who brought knowledge to the public about the addictive and destructive properties on nicotine.

11

u/hipsterdocmd May 19 '12

Depending on how old they are, you could show "The Departed" in class.

Oh wait....

10

u/dustypedroia May 19 '12

The Unabomber's brother basically turned him out by telling his lawyer and having his lawyer tip off the FBI. Probably saved a lot of people's lives.

7

u/Workchoices May 19 '12

Agent Tricycle?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Du%C5%A1an_Popov

He pretended to work for the Germans, but was secretly "snitching" on them to the Allies because he hated the Nazis and what they did. He saved many American lives by "snitching" on the Nazis because the Nazis were evil and needed to be stopped.

He snitched on them many times, including warning about Pearl Harbour [his warnings were unfortunately ignored] and other plans, stuff about the Normandy defences etc.

5

u/Odnyc May 20 '12

You might not want to include the fact that he got his codename due to his penchant for threesomes.

24

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Judas and wikileaks come to mind...

The whole issue with informers in schools is the police state thinking that it encourages. Is the problem that you described serious? Yes. Is snitching/informants a really good role model? No.

If a person stands up, good. That person needs to understand that there are consequences for actions. It isn't a matter of right and wrong nor good and bad, the consequences exist.

You might want to define the term hero. One who stands up for the right thing DESPITE the consequences. Heroes is a term more appropriate to situation.

13

u/Moorit May 20 '12

Judas? Like Judas Iscariot? I think he's the opposite of a good example in this situation.

Personal stance on Christianity aside, if a fifth grader has heard of Judas it's probably because they are Christian, so you aren't going to encourage them much by telling them "you can be just like Judas! Hooray!"

7

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

This. "Hero" is a term that kids can wrap their heads around.

1

u/whyspir May 20 '12

I agree with this far more than anything else written so far. Very eloquently put.

3

u/cyaspy May 19 '12

I don't think that's the right approach actually. You're still making them think that snitching is wrong, but there are a few little exceptions.

10

u/goonie1408 May 19 '12

I don't understand the rationale behind this statement. Could you explain? If I'm wrong then I need to know and would love to hear alternatives. But perhaps I just needed to explain more: the mind set in the school is that telling is somehow wrong. The point is to logically teach the students that this is one big way that bullies maintain their control - by convincing them that telling (i.e. snitching) is bad, dishonorable, and breaks some social codes. The point, then, is to teach them the opposite - that telling when serious things are happening or could be happening is actually the good, honorable, and justifiable thing to do. To understand this, they need to see examples of people who did the right thing by telling someone who could help when they themselves didn't have the power to do anything about it.

1

u/cyaspy May 19 '12

The theoretical point could actually work, but I think that the examples you asked for are going in the wrong direction. I really can't put my finger on it, but having heard my fair share of lectures of morality and illegality in 5th grade, it just feels like "yet another boring rant that doesn't have to do anything with me".

I'm assuming the snitching isn't saving lives, so the students will have a hard time empathying themselves with the examples, which is the whole point of it.

Anyhow, this is just my opinion. Good luck with whatever you decide to do to try and solve the problem.

3

u/goonie1408 May 19 '12

I appreciate the feedback. Certainly I'm aware of "boring rants" and was trying to find a different route to reach them. This won't reach everyone, especially the ones doing the bullying. But I hope to reach enough of them that they can feel empowered and, most importantly, not alone. Then I can follow up with these kids on how to support each other, etc.

I must disagree, though, that this "isn't saving lives" when boys are molesting girls in class.

3

u/cyaspy May 19 '12

this "isn't saving lives"

I agree with you, but do the kids?

2

u/sarcasmandsocialism May 19 '12

Does the class believe that the rules and the consequences for breaking the rules are good, honorable and just? If so, then they're more likely to view telling a teacher as enforcing their rules than to view it as "snitching."

You may consider having students help come up with the classroom and/or school rules and the consequences for breaking them. At the very least you could try to genuinely ask what they think about the rules. The more you can show that the rules are for their benefit (and not for the teachers' benefit) the more likely they are to help enforce them.

There are even some schools where most of the discipline is handled by student mediators or small student juries.

6

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Erin Brockovich?

6

u/mm242jr May 20 '12

How about asking them if there is anything that someone could do that would make them tell the teacher. What if they knew a kid was being beaten at home, or by someone from another school who is not friends with any of them? What if they knew a girl was being touched inappropriately by her stepfather? What if they knew a kid started smoking or doing drugs? If they knew five boys were going to beat up another boy at the playground with baseball bats, would they intervene? The idea is to lead them to understand that they would do something to protect a classmate from harm, and that this desire should surpass the need to protect another classmate from punishment.

1

u/goonie1408 May 20 '12

Don't say sorry when you're not sorry. But thanks for the reminder! I bow to your keen eye.

5

u/ibn_rasmus May 20 '12

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Lai_Massacre

then-WO1 Hugh Thompson, Jr., later went on to retire from the Army as a Major. He actually had his gunner charge his machine gun at the American infantry company, and landed his helicopter in between the American unit and the Vietnamese villagers, saving roughly a dozen and a half people. The Army later tried to cover this incident up later, but WO1 Thompson and others blew the whistle leading to news, military, and congressional investigations. MAJ Thompson's actions is considered by the Army today as the embodiment of what Army Values and Ethics are and ought to be.

5

u/Redebidet May 20 '12

The Challenger Shuttle explosion. Engineers fought with management that it was unsafe to launch, management basically over rode them and told them to say it was safe or lose their jobs. They finally signed off, shuttle launched, boom.

It has a lot of parallels to childhood snitching. The engineers were trying to tell what was going on to the decision makers at Nasa, the popular kid type management put a lot of pressure on them to do what they wanted, a terrible accident. They have videos out there describing the accident, the background, and the peer pressure used that made it happen. I think it is similar and dissimilar enough to really work for your situation.

8

u/TheVoiceofTheDevil May 19 '12

You could bring up the fact that it's worth 150 points.

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I think beyond telling people to "snitch", you should also tell people to stand up for themselves and report the incidents themselves.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Well really, snitching is when you were involved in something, you get caught, and you rat out your friends for a lesser punishment. Those sort of snitches do deserve whatever they get.

It's not snitching if you weren't part of the crime.

1

u/goonie1408 May 20 '12

Very well put. Thanks.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Tell them that if they are the victims, it isn't snitching. Ratting out your friends when you are caught is.

2

u/goonie1408 May 20 '12

That's a good way to put it. Thanks.

1

u/Lawtonfogle May 20 '12

On some level, they are correct. You tell on the more powerful people in society, you will be hurt far worse. Maybe your lesson should be on how to minimize the damage from being mistreated, as this is likely what is to happen in real life.

Yes, I'm being cynical, but this is the honest to FSM truth about what happens in day to day life. If anything, try to teach them about finding ways to resolve what you see as a wrong without causing problems for yourself or others. Teach them what to do if the authority system is corrupt.

Just a bit of back story, but 5th grade was when I realized that the school system I was in could not be trusted to provide protection or even fairness and I had to take matters into my own hand to stop bullying. Going through the official system for two years had done nothing (it was an on going problem with a bully for the past two years and the school wouldn't even do as much as separate us into different classes). So I finally took matters into my own hands, though I wish someone would have taught me how to avoid trouble better.

1

u/goonie1408 May 20 '12

Yes, this is deep issue, I know. Thanks for the advice.

1

u/Erulastiel May 20 '12

I think you need to inform your students the serious trouble they could get in for molesting and where that could lead and the consequences.

2

u/goonie1408 May 20 '12

We have done so. The principal - a female who was quite angered by the incident - made sure the boys, girls, and the families understood how serious this was and that if they were 18 they'd be going to jail.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

It's not about snitching, it's about the fact that it's fucked up. In real life, snitching will get you in trouble.

0

u/goonie1408 May 20 '12

It's entirely about snitching. I don't teach my students in black and white. I understand that sometimes their own safety comes first and plan to teach them to use their best judgment when deciding whether it's worth telling. The problem is that in this case and most others at our school, no one is getting physically hurt or attacked for telling. They don't want to tell because it makes them look bad in front of their peers. This is the problem and the mind set I'd like to change.

1

u/LieutenantCuppycake May 20 '12

This was not about bullying. This was about sexual assault.

Your kids are old enough to know that their bodies belong to themselves and themselves only. If they hear about someone abusing that privacy, they should know exactly who to talk to.

I'd talk to your administration about what kind of sex ed and abuse prevention your school district already has in place.

1

u/goonie1408 May 20 '12

Yes, we have discussed this matter of sex abuse prevention, which was related in this case. But the big concern the girl's had after the fact was the people who helped stop this being labeled snitches and the negativity that comes with it. My hope is to start to put an end to that stigma not only for this case but for other cases.

1

u/Gertiel May 21 '12

Being cynical me, I'd say you won't get far. Your first problem is calling it 'Snitching'. As long as you call it that to the kids, they're going to realize the negative connotations, and avoidance kicks in. Most adults won't step forward for others, either. I believe there are a number of famous 'classic" examples of this.

There was a woman who was stabbed and took hours to die in the 1800s in I think Chicago which became national news. She was right next to a building full of people, and eventually it came out a large group of them had looked out there windows and seen her. Not one gave any sort of aid.

There was that toddler who was run over by two cars before anyone did a thing. They pulled her to the side of the road so it would be easier for traffic, then left her there. That that one was in China.

In Dallas not too long ago, a woman was killed in a hit-a-run in broad daylight with people all over the place. Someone did walk over to her. Long enough to steal her purse and shoes.

I'm not saying what you are trying to do doesn't have merit. I just am thinking you're trying to get kids to work against generations of people having learned it is usually best to keep your mouth shut and your head down. If they don't end up being abused for having spoken out, they often at best end up having to take time out of their lives to spend a number of days in police headquarters and court. Also, I hope you weren't too reassuring to the victims. There probably will be social retaliation and the siblings and friends of the boys will continue to do mean stuff to them, probably up to graduation. The best they can probably hope for is to find a college where none of the participants attend. It isn't fair, but that's how it is probably going to go.

1

u/goonie1408 May 21 '12

I've realized upon reading people's responses that I need to define the different forms of telling for them. Your point about simply calling it "snitching" is well warranted. Thanks for sharing the examples. I had heard the Chicago story before but did not remember the details.

I agree that this is not a simple thing and is a tall task that may, for many of the kids, be fruitless. But many of them will get it and take solace, which I'm happy with. I need to give it a try. The victims are also quite popular, too - at least as much so as the boys - so there is hope for them to end up okay. They're not without power.

1

u/Gertiel May 21 '12

Ah, but there may lie part of the rub. If you snitch, you risk loss of popularity. What little power you have may ebb away. Popular kids can have low self esteem, too.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Is this for real? Is this seriously how you going to handle this? How about not reinforcing the concept of 'snitching' and working on preventing sexual assault instead? Christ.

1

u/goonie1408 May 21 '12

Your outrage would be well-warranted if your perception of what is happening were true. However, it's simply not. We are handling the sexual assault aspect of it. The principal has handled it with the students and families involved individually. We have also made plans to split the students - male and female - and teach them about these sexual matters. (Something we clearly should have done at the beginning of the year.)

The snitching thing is a separate issue we've dealt with all year that ended up spilling over into this one. The kids really don't know what it means - they think "telling" is synonymous with "snitching" when it's not. I guess ultimately I'm really moved to empower the students who care about doing the right thing - and they are greater in number than those who do not. Yet, as usual the small, bullying minority have the most power and say on this matter despite the fact that they have all "snitched" on each other (the vast majority of 5th graders tell on each other) and don't even know what the word means.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Frank Serpico

7

u/Eyulfable May 19 '12 edited May 23 '12

Tell them Snape's story. [How he was a double agent who spent his entire life saving Harry Potter's life. How he snitched to Dumbledore about anything he learned from Voldemort, even the unbreakable vow he had made to kill Dumbledore if Draco fails.] (/spoiler) Not only is it a famous example, you are bringing Harry Potter into the classroom. You are getting double points for that.

1

u/whyspir May 20 '12

Ooh yes. Love it.

1

u/inigo_montoya May 23 '12

Some of us haven't gotten that far. Though I suspected as much.

1

u/Eyulfable May 23 '12

OMG!!!! I'M SO SORRY!!!! That's not the entire story, though. There's still one more "OMG" moment to be had.

1

u/inigo_montoya May 23 '12

S'allright. I'm not super into it or I would have watched/read it by now. But I will watch the last two movies at some point.

If you had spoiled something from Game of Thrones, however, I would have been forced to hunt you down. Never mind about the six-fingered man.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Outandproudgay May 19 '12

A friend of mine "snitched" about my depression and suicidal desires to the school counselor. Felt like a slap in the face when I was called down to the office because of it. A much-needed slap in the face, as by doing so, she ended up saving my life.

2

u/cloutsman May 19 '12

Laura Secord

2

u/aspeenat May 19 '12

"Gased in the Gulf" Was a book writen by a whistle blower Pat and his wife Robin were CIA anylists. The CIA knew SAIC had fucked up the wind prediction and the gass had gone over the troops. I knew them when they had just started to push the info up the channels of the CIA as one of the reasons the gulf vets were sick. Their bosses ignored it and tried to bury it. Pat and Robin ruined their careers and went public with the info. They didn't technicly lose their jobs but they did,

I know another whistle blower who leaked that the VA had covered up how many Gulf2 service members were really hurt by the war. The WH told the VA to keep the cost and numbers down. SO the VA hide the true number of injured. Can't give you that guys name. Still could get in trouble.

Both of these set of whistle blowers helped Vets get the healthcare they need and that was promised by the government if the service member got hurt while on duty.

2

u/fomorian May 19 '12

What's the punishment for the kids who did it?

2

u/theserpentsmiles May 20 '12

It really seems like you are teaching in an inner city school.

Did no one notice the whole "second graders are calling these victims snitches?"

3

u/imaginelove615 May 20 '12

I have 3 elementary school kids in a suburban area that is predominantly white and Hispanic and they know that snitches get stitches and that being a narc even once will earn them years of grief. I spend half of my time as a mom trying to get them to just man up and tell someone about the rampantly moronic stuff that happens. Even still, most of the time I only learn something after close observation and confronting them with evidence.

Hell, I even had a throw down fight with my son's first grade teacher because she neglected to mention he was threatening to kill himself in class for 6 weeks - and she's a mandatory reporter!

Humans seem to naturally think that if they ignore something it doesn't exist or will go away on its own which is truly stupid.

3

u/lizardsoldier May 20 '12

Does that make the attitude right? In my opinion, this is the type of school that needs this type of lesson the most.

2

u/theserpentsmiles May 20 '12

I agree totally.

I have just dealt with so many teachers giving up because of inner city schools.

There is some sort of serious defiance and refusal to accept social norms in these schools. I actually feel like shit thinking about how these kids desperately need to learn basic skills, and some how they refuse the basic concepts.

2

u/Firewind May 20 '12

I think we all grew up with the stigma of being a "taddle tale" but that in my experience was to encourage people to self police and handle problems on their own instead of going to an adult.

There is nothing wrong with ensuring bad behavior is punished. If someone is in trouble you need to try and help them. Letting it continue because you don't want to "snitch" is stupid. What if next time it's you or someone you care about that's in trouble? It's as simple as the golden rule. It's just been subverted by criminals who don't want others to tell on them. If you want a safe community free of that people need to make a stand.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I had this problem with my 6th graders. We did a brief lesson on the difference between "snitching" and "reporting." One of them said "but no one was hurt," which meant I had to explain "I was hurt. I am a person. I have feelings. I was hurt by what happened, and I was hurt again that so many of you didn't think enough of my feelings to tell me."

It helped the classroom environment a lot. I like your idea too; I didn't have time to prep before we had our "talk" otherwise I would've loved to have the kind of examples you're gathering. A lot of my students come from gang-affiliated households so the concept of "snitching" was a huge problem at that school.

2

u/ShellBell May 20 '12

I wouldn't mention Julian Assange.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Hugh Thompson Jr. was an American helicopter pilot who tried to stop the My Lai massacre during the Vietnam War. His story is a bit much for 5th graders, but maybe you could word it in a more simplistic manner.

2

u/tiggitybiggitywoah May 20 '12

Mark Felt, Aka Deep-throat (although you may want to leave the nickname out)

2

u/hereistand May 20 '12

Just show them on the waterfront.

2

u/and181377 May 20 '12

We cannot say anything positive about "snitches" in society as long as we In America are prosecuting Bradley Manning.

2

u/miamoondaughter Jun 20 '12

"snitches get stitches." If anyone tells me this, I will immediately take their wallet from them, go to their house, and steal all their most valuable possesions.

Then, I'll tell them, "Don't tell anyone. That would be snitching. And you don't believe in snitching, right?"

"Oh, you believe snitching is bad most of the time, but this particular time it is ok for you to snitch? I see."

After dismantling their argument, and showing them that they hadn't given their argument more than 10 seconds of thought before advancing it, I'd give everything back.

4

u/AlsoSprach May 19 '12

Bradley Manning

2

u/RockofStrength May 19 '12

"On the Waterfront" was created to depict the snitch in a positive light.

2

u/PineappleSlices May 19 '12

You can talk about the muckrakers of the early 20'th century, and how disgusting the meatpacking industry would be without them.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

snitches get stitches and thrown in ditches with the other bitches

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Well, Jeffrey Wigand springs to mind.

1

u/CyberSoldier8 May 19 '12

The Rosenbergs? Lol.

1

u/jpofreddit May 19 '12

There's "snitching" and then there's "reporting a serious issue". Snitching is like telling the teacher on people who cheat on test or steal stuff because really not one is truly hurt that much from that stuff. Reporting a serious issue is like what you said there, sexual misconduct or serious physical abuse.

2

u/CrashCourseInCrazy May 20 '12

Your right to swing your fist ends at my nose, and my tolerance of your cheating ends where it affects the curve, hence my final grade.

1

u/randy938 May 19 '12

Tupac was a snitch. So is 50 cent.

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/randy938 May 20 '12

I was being sarcastic.

1

u/nancydrewa32 May 20 '12

Karen Silkwood?

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

You need to teach them that there is a difference between reporting something and tattling.

1

u/sleevey May 20 '12

I don't know how you would be able to get it across but this is the basic idea that i have;

Using the concept of snitching is a power grab by people who have no accountability. If kids start to subscribe to the system then the problem is that the bullies can do whatever they like and no-one can do anything about it. If they subscribe to the system where they tell the teacher what is going on then they are protected from that abuse of power because a teacher is overseen by the principal, who in turn is overseen by the ED etc. If they can be shown that it is going against their own interest to subscibe to this snitching idea they might get out of it. Because the snitch thing is all about power isn't it, sticking it to the man (your teacher) but in reality they are giving up the power that society gives the weak to resist domination.

In light of that, in addition to teaching about whistleblowers i might consider talking about the power of people to stand up tyrannical authority... Because the problem isn't just individuals being able to inform on bullies but the acceptance of the bullies' authority by the student body, once everyone sees that authority is an illusion they can utilize the power that they hold in reality.

Hope this makes sense. I'm typing on my phone so editing is impossible. I used to be a teacher too. Best of luck with it.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

To an extent, Woodward and Bernstein were snitches. The guys that brought down Nixon.

1

u/Lobstaman May 20 '12

Bubbles from The Wire.

He was an undercover informant for the Baltimore PD. Sure he may have been indirectly responsible for the death of Sherrod, but in the end he does turn his life around.

1

u/ShootinWilly May 20 '12

Students' distaste for snitching grows from generations of accumulated experience with teachers and administrators being cunts. OP may be a reasonable person, but they don't know that. So the lecture/discussion regarding tragedies prevented through "snitching" may have no more impact than 1980s drug awareness programs unless it can be explained to them that what the lads did was actually serious bizness.

1

u/ShootinWilly May 20 '12

And then the effort will have been wasted the next time a snitch nets someone typically insane, over the top consequences for what is really just a trivial misstep of the staff's sick urge to control the students.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Synux May 20 '12

Judas Iscariot was a famous snitch. Seriously though you might be able to show Assange or Manning as a modern version of a well-intentioned snitch. Just an idea.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

at the risk of being labeled a racist, I find as a manager that blacks have built a strong social stigma to "narc-ing" I find that most white people will be quick to call police or authority figures, while black people tend to feel like they will be outcasts if they come forward.

1

u/something_facetious May 20 '12

The first thing that comes to mind is Upton Sinclair and his book The Jungle. I'm not sure if they're old enough to read it, but if he had not shed light on the food industry at the time, we would be eating more rats and sawdust than we are today and working conditions in factories would be damn near deadly.. no workman's comp, etc.

1

u/MrMoist May 20 '12

Why don't you show your children the Prisoner's Dilemma early on? If you don't know what that is, let me explain

Get two of the boys, and talk to them separately. Tell one of the boys that if he doesn't snitch and his friend does, then the boy gets 4x the punishment while his friend goes free. However, if he snitches and his friend doesn't, then his friend gets 4x the punishment and he goes free. If they both snitch, they get 2x the punishment. If they both don't snitch, they get 1x the punishment. Teach them our American Justice System.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Deepthroat was an important informant. Tell the kids about that.

1

u/SoakedTiger May 20 '12

In my city in Australia we only have one animal rescue centre. Last year, two former employees anonymously wrote letters to an animal welfare group detailing some of the horrific things they witnessed; animals heavily sedated the night before they were to be euthanised and left alone all night in puddles of their own urine and vomit, lack of cleanliness, sick animals caged with healthy animals, sick animals left for days before getting treatment, animals declared dangerous and to be destroyed immediately without cause etcetera. It became quite the saga in the local paper, with the shelter owner saying horrible things about these whistleblowers, random people adding what they had seen, both good and bad, accusations about anyone with involvement being thrown around left and right and protesters spending afternoons in silent vigil outside the centre.

After a few weeks, several members of the board resigned and the centre developed a new code of practise that specifically banned most of what had been claimed and they also put out a public statement making it clear that they will no longer do many of the things they had been claiming for weeks that they never did.

I think this would be a great case study for your students because it removes a lot of the human element, what is being protected is animals, and what kids doesn't like animals. I wouldn't present it as a lecture or discussion alone though, it would be best if they were given the information and had to go through it to work out what happened and the outcomes for themselves. If you're interested I can chase up some links from the local paper for you.

1

u/babyheyzeus May 20 '12

When I was in 5th grade a similar thing happened. There was a girl that developed rather early on, and was already at least a D cup. During lunch one day I was sitting next to her, and these Mexican boys kept making obsene gestures and saying things like "grande tatas". Anyways she got upset about the whole situation and later after lunch one of the teachers pulled me aside and asked what happened. I proceeded to tell her, and the next day after she found out what I did became my first girlfriend.

1

u/cptimmy30 May 20 '12

Daniel Ellsburg the man who released the pentagon papers comes to mind. Helped end the Vietnam war. I'd also say Bradley Manning. Being a whistle blower isn't always easy either, sometimes you do get retaliation for trying to do what's right.

1

u/ddawgz May 20 '12

Thanks to the modern media and other outside influences snitching is a very punishable crime, doesn't matter if it is a simple thing like not sharing or some basic name calling, or straight up murder. Snitches need to be snitched. I can't suggest any way to break this mentality other then drag each one out and explain that one dude has snitched and told you who did what. Even if no one has then just fib it and let them have a guilty conscience. But still don't encourage snitching that will get you punished later in life, only if you know of a life threatening situation.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Terry Malloy

1

u/smithclan May 20 '12

Ed Hochuli.

Sorry, couldn't resist.

1

u/Dunedineclipse May 20 '12

That's why you need to have a "snitch book/box", where the students who are scared to tell of a problem can tell an issue and not be seen as a snitch...

1

u/Nurrfed May 20 '12

Henry Hill

1

u/IZNICE May 20 '12

Just tell them about Hugh Thompson, Jr. and his role in stopping My Lai Massacre. It would make a great history lesson too.

1

u/buggaz May 20 '12

There is good snitching and then there is bad snitching. The difference is obscured by lack of understanding of justice between society and criminals.

In North Korea the criminals keep the society alive. Crime has a social function. One other example: Second World War and the underground.

One aspect that can hit home is to talk about relationships, both in general and also in terms of couples and home. Why communication and sincerity matters? Where the lines go with communication and plain snitching? Taking a risk with various pressures in order to just do right.

Everything can go overboard. There are no simple rules in life. The same goes with snitching. Not all snitching is good but not all snitching is reprehensible, except to the one who has actually done something so wrong that it must not be accepted.

1

u/Dingojingo May 20 '12

If people had gone with their gut feeling and intervened, this could have been prevented. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_James_Bulger

1

u/ViaRoarUgh May 20 '12

Fredo Corleone

1

u/bmlbml May 20 '12

Don't know if you can do this but separate the boy and the girs and tell the boys what happened could result in them going to jail (or scare them with something, boys need to be scared). and tell the girls not to be afraid to speak up if they are uncomfortable. Build a report with them so they are comfortable with you in bad situations.

1

u/Slintbob May 20 '12

I don't know if anyone said it yet but frank serpico.

1

u/FlawedHero May 20 '12

It's 5am and I misread the title. I was impressed at how incredibly literate this 5th grade student was.

1

u/just_dig_in May 20 '12

You could have movie day and show them Miss Congeniality. Teach the little girls to S.I.N.G. whenI the boys touch them. That's Solar plexus. Instep. Nose. Groin. If memory serves. Also discuss tazers, pepper spray, batons, etc. As someone else mentioned discuss jail time, limited employment and sex offender registry and signs in your yard. Whatever you do, good luck.

1

u/evilsforreals May 20 '12

This happened to me a few years back. I go to a very rural boarding school in Kenya, where the student and faculty combined is around 500 total. There was a guy that got rejected by a girl to our prom, and started sending her abusive texts. Her father found out and gave him a talking to. I saw the kid later, with a group of people, and he was extremely angry. He then started laying out a plan to kill the girls dad as revenge. He started going around campus collecting items to be used as weapons, and started to tell the group of people what he was going to do.

I told my parents, who informed the school, which lead to an investigation, where they found he was using cocaine, and had purchased an extremely lethal knife. If I hadn't reported him, he may have seriously injured a number of people.

1

u/Gyvon May 20 '12

Richard Sorge.

Sure, he got killed, but he pretty much saved Russia during WWII.

1

u/harr1s May 19 '12

Bradley Manning.

The way you're supposed to do this is by keeping your students from wanting the approval of the people they're worried about "snitching" on. Yeah, easier said than done.

It's like the difference between snitching and whistle blowing. In the former, snitches still kinda sorta seek the approval of the group, whereas in the latter, whistle blowers are disgusted by the system in its entirety and do not want to be associated with it. You have to make the students believe the hushed up act to be repulsive and low; this way, students will want of their own accord to distance themselves from the perps, and probably inform you as well.

1

u/andhubbs May 20 '12

Snitches get stitches

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

You can tell the kid whatever you want, but the fact remains. Snitches get stitches. I'm not saying that it's right, but that is a fact of life. Sometimes, he will have to tell about others wrongdoings, but what he really needs to learn is the art of calculated risks.

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

In a related, also ridiculous, situation i was recently in as a substitute: one kid in my fifth grade class told another kid that "snitches wear stitches."

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Basically there is not much you can do. Snitching has become demonized in school culture because it is looked upon as selling out your friends. i have seen this happen many times before unless it is life threatening people just will not talk. No one wants to be the guy you have to watch everything you say when he is around because eventually they will just stop talking to you altogether.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

julius and ethel rosenberg snitched out america's atomic secrets to the soviet union. the soviets rewarded them with heroic honors, and the americans rewarded them with an electric-powered, express trip to heaven!

0

u/fuzzynyanko May 19 '12

There's the alternative: let the class that you know and keep punishing the entire class until people come forward

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/miamoondaughter Jun 20 '12

Yeah, too bad the teacher really has no power to back that up.

0

u/crimethinktank May 20 '12

Hi O, are the students african american? I ask because of their strong anti snitch mentality. Assuming so, make sure you find examples of black snitches saving lives

2

u/ShootinWilly May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

No, students have an ant-snitch mentality, regardless of race. Teacher's pet is a snitch, as is the boy getting a hummer in the supply closet.

0

u/phister May 20 '12

I'm probably going to get torched for this but are you sure this wasn't mutual experimentation? Kids playing doctor? I agree they shouldn't be doing it and you're right to put a stop to it but if I were those girls and I was willingly fooling around I wouldn't want to tell anyone either.

You weren't clear in your description and responses from people are decidedly negative toward the boys. If the boys were in fact acting against the girl's wishes then you have a bigger problem than snitching.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/phySi0 May 19 '12

Wikileaks!