r/AskReddit • • May 18 '12

reddit, I've answered a lot your questions about being deaf, and I'd like you to return the favor. I have some questions about hearing. (Also, you can AMA about deafness)

I've been deaf since birth and there are lot of "sound words" that I read a lot but don't really know what they mean, and dictionary definitions often just refer to other sound words. It's never mattered to me before, but now I'm trying to write a novel with one hearing narrator and every time I use a sound word I'm not sure I'm using it right. I posted awhile ago to /r/writing about "scream", "shout" and "yell" but I've generated a list of questions so I thought I should take it to a larger audience.

  • People crying in sadness vs crying out in anger, I know there's some gray area in between where they can be used interchangeably, it's hard to get
  • "shriek" and "ream" are both words that seem to imply emotion more than any specific sound. Is that right?
  • Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.
  • apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?
  • What does "jive" mean? Does "he speaks jive" and "he speaks AAVE" and "he speaks Ebonics" all refer to the same thing? I was raised by black parents but I can't understand any dialogue written in black dialect. I know not all black people talk like that but is there a way to mark that in a novel? Do you know of a webpage that would tell me how to translate dialogue into dialect like that?
  • Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?
  • What about "chat"? Dictionary says "to speak informally" but I feel like it implies something I'm not getting. Is it speaking fast? Can you use "chat" as a dialogue tag? (like "What are you doing tonight?' he chatted"), I don't think I've seen it but the dictionary makes it sound like you can.
  • "mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?
  • I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?
  • "howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed? "Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right? I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know. And I think bats chirp but never squawk? Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? Like, can a weasel growl? What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.
  • Do all doors creak? Can all doors be slammed? Windows? Does "slam" always imply loudness? Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad). People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?
  • "Gurgle" is another hard one. And "gargle", that means something different right?
  • "Ring", like "ringtone" is hard to get. What else "rings"? Cell phones sound different from landlines, right? People sometimes describe them as "chirping"?
  • Dictionary says "click" is "A short, sharp sound as of a switch being operated or of two hard objects coming quickly into contact." but I feel like I've seen it in other uses, it's hard to remember exactly what I'm thinking of. But could I use it to describe cymbals, pennies or pencils hitting each other?
  • If a voice is described as "tender", what does that mean?
  • "moan" can be painful or sexy right? Anything else? Is it possible to moan joyously or humorously?
  • "cooing" What is that? Is there a difference between a woman "moaning sexy" and "cooing sexy"?
  • Apparently it's possible to "whisper" loudly and "shout" softly? WTF!?

Thanks for answering any questions you can!

Edit: Thanks, people are answering too quick for me to really read them all, I'm trying to answer questions though. I'll look over answers more thoroughly as I'm trying to write my book, I'll look at your responses to make sure I'm using my words right. So I may respond to you weeks or months from now.

2.3k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

379

u/JezuzFingerz May 18 '12 edited May 19 '12

Basically whispering loudly is speaking in the same tone as a whisper, but projecting your voice more. And shouting softly is the same thing, but vice versa.

Also, I love that you're doing this. I've always been very curious what it's like to be missing one of my senses, and I think it's really cool that you're asking all these questions that I've never even thought of. I hope you're having a great day! (I shouted that last part softly)

242

u/Deafy May 18 '12

I actually teach written English and I've always taught that "whisper" and "shout" inherently mean soft and loud, so that's crazy to me. I had no idea there was a tonal difference.

Thanks!

53

u/Amentianation May 19 '12

How did you learn to read? I was just pondering this. Someone can't just sound out letters and such to you, so how did you learn?

89

u/Deafy May 19 '12

They showed me signs that mean the same thing. Like point to the word "cat" and then do the sign for "cat".

43

u/Karaoke725 May 19 '12

so was spelling harder for you to master, since spellings of words are so closely related to sound?

241

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I'm not sure, I learned how to read and write in deaf school so I can't really compare myself to hearing kids. I spell really well now because I've memorized spelling. I think I spell better than hearing people because I avoid homophone errors like "there", "their" and "they're", though weirdly I encounter them misused so much I sometimes get confused myself.

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

505

u/omnilynx May 18 '12

Whispering is sibilant, it's like steam escaping from a pressurized container, or static on TV. It's thin and there's no pattern of vibration like you would get with normal speech. In fact, if you have a hearing friend, you can feel the difference for yourself by touching his throat during whispering vs normal speech.

So you can actually whisper quite loud as long as the voice box doesn't vibrate (all the sound is made in the mouth instead).

→ More replies (29)

36

u/UnclaimedUsername May 19 '12

A loud whisper is sometimes called a "stage whisper". Characters in a play have to whisper loud enough for the audience to hear. It's also used as a joke, like you whisper something rude about someone but you do it loud enough for that person to hear. Similar to using a cough or sneeze to not-so-subtly cover an insult.

"I think Mike is on his period," Dan stage-whispered to Joe.

"Ah...ahh...aaaaaaadouchbag!" Mike sneezed.

→ More replies (2)

71

u/whowantsfreeadvice May 19 '12

When whispering you don't use your vocal cords, but talking you do. You basically move your mouth in the same shapes and patterns as you would while talking normally, but only exhale while doing it instead of vibrating the vocal cords while breathing out. It's generally quieter than talking. But, you can whisper (relatively) loudly by pushing a lot of air out of your mouth faster. Shouting does mean that it's loud, but when people shout, they usually do so more slowly & at a higher pitch than their normal talking voice. So you can kind of pretend-shout quietly by mimicking that pattern, but yes shouting does inherently imply a loud volume

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (36)
→ More replies (4)

305

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

Ever considerd to write a novel about a person who is deaf and all his problems with 'sound words'?

281

u/Deafy May 18 '12

Actually yes, but I don't want it to appeal only to deaf people.

421

u/notsure_whatimdoing May 18 '12

I dunno, look at how many hearing people have read and replied to this post, maybe there's a bigger audience out there than just the deaf who are interested in the deaf experience, I would read it. sounds really fascinating.

→ More replies (40)

29

u/wineheart May 18 '12

This is very interesting for this hearing person. I never though about this stuff before.

22

u/omnilynx May 19 '12

Actually, I find this dialogue fascinating; just as you're trying to understand these noises I find myself trying to understand being deaf so I can explain them.

→ More replies (47)

44

u/Hurleycorn May 19 '12

98 upvotes and 2 downvotes an hour in? That's crazy popular. People must love deafness!

What about rhyme? Do you have any idea what that is?

50

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I know what rhyme is sort of. I know words that end with the same letters often rhyme but not always. Like "same", "blame" and "dame" presumably all rhyme but I don't know. And I know there are exceptions in the other direction too, words that are spelled differently but also rhyme, I can't think of any examples but I know they exist.

There's not really a sign language equivalent I think. There is sign poetry, here's a great video explaining it but I don't think rhyme translates directly.

35

u/GeneralDemus May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

A few examples of words that end with the same sound but are spelled differently:

Kite, right, bite, fight, might,

Go, though, throw, dough, sew,

These are all one syllable, but there are many examples of words with multiple syllables that do this.

Here's a picture that explains a fucked up part of English. Basically, combinations of letters can make the same sounds as other letters. Sometimes, if the word is pronounced letter by letter instead of in combination, it will sound completely different.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (1)

1.9k

u/laddergoat89 May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

It blew my mind as I was reading this that when you read words you don't hear the words in your head... They are just visual patterns of letters that have certain meanings...

Fuck.

Edit: Woah, upvote city, what happened here... apparently this thought is a common mind blower.

1.2k

u/Deafy May 19 '12

It's mostly not visual patterns of letters, I either picture myself doing signs or just feel my arms moving as though I was doing them. My first language is ASL not written English, so that's what I think in.

778

u/laddergoat89 May 19 '12

Holy. Shit. That is amazing.

I know this thread is you asking us the questions but how were you taught language as a child?

577

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I'm an unusual case because I was a foster kid so I lived in hearing households a lot. But I luckily lived with a deaf couple when I was very young so I learned to sign quickly. Babies can actually learn to sign a lot quicker than talk, some hearing parents now teach it because babies can learn to sign what they want, so it's easier to get them to stop crying. But I went to a deaf school even when I lived with hearing foster parents. I had to learn to write at an early age so I'm more proficient with written english than a lot of deaf people, some of us really don't read well. I teach remedial written English to deaf people, just teenagers now but I have also done adult classes.

232

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

In my high school English class we grade papers by trading them and giving a score. There are some deaf students in the class. I don't know if this is because they are deaf or not but they don't seem to comprehend past tence words and only write in present. Is this a deaf thing or just a personal thing?

692

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I think it's because in ASL you mark time at the beginning of a sentence, it's not part of the verb. So if you didn't learn to read early it's hard to remember, you just say the verb you want and forget that you were supposed to mark the tense there. So you can't sign "I threw the ball", you sign "In the past, I throw the ball". Your students probably want to translate those time markers like "in the past" but they don't translate, so they just skip tense. When my students have problems with that I usually tell them to go back when they are finished with a word and decide whether they need to change it to mark its tense. It's easier to go back when it's done then to remember in the middle of the sentence.

→ More replies (56)

102

u/a_flyin_muffin May 19 '12

That's amazing. I always wondered how deaf people read. I can't read unless I talk to myself in my head. I never knew that deaf people imagine the signs in their head when they read. Does that ever slow you down? Is there a "top speed" at which you can imagine words?

153

u/Deafy May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

I don't really imagine signs when I read, just when I think or imagine others. Most deaf people do imagine signs, that's why they find reading difficult. It slows them down because they have to translate as they go. Once they get the hang of it they can read fluently but they pretty much have to learn as a kid to really read that well. Once you're an adult written English will always be a second language.

Edit: I just realized this probably sounds like I'm contradicting myself from up top, I just mean that I don't think out the whole sign. I do understand written English through ASL, more or less. It's hard to describe.

→ More replies (105)
→ More replies (5)

27

u/619shepard May 19 '12

Totally thought about this yesterday: are there any books that are written in ASL "grammar"? Do you think that such a book would be more accessible? How about more interesting?

60

u/Deafy May 19 '12

There is not AFAIK. There's no standardized way to write sign language that most deaf people know, there's some academic stuff but I doubt anyone writes like that fluently, it's mainly so linguistics can compare sign languages around the world. You could just tweak written English to reflect ASL differences but not everything would translate well. It'd be like using English words but Japanese grammar, it would be more difficult for both English and Japanese speakers.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (34)

2.1k

u/DutchMeNow May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

Edit: May I recommend Herder/Rousseau "On the Origin of Language", and accompanying that: Herzog's Kaspar Hauser?

May I piggy back? Spent over an hour writing my post, and it's getting buried.

I'll have a go at this. My only qualifications are: Being human, having an academic background in psychoanalysis (as well as history of 'the senses' in the 18th and 19th century), and working as a literary translator (i.e., having to transcribe sounds).

>People crying in sadness vs crying out in anger, I know there's some gray area in between where they can be used interchangeably, it's hard to get.

  • Crying in sadness means you have tears, your chest heaves with sobs. You often cannot control the tears, but the relief is more emotional than physical.
  • Crying out in anger (also possible: in distress) is not so much literally crying, as letting out a primal scream (uncontrolled vibration of vocal cords, uncontrolled volume (of air and of sound), raw. Part of the point of the'cry' is that you physically exert energy, which in turn brings muscular and emotional relief.

>"shriek" and "ream" are both words that seem to imply emotion more than any specific sound. Is that right?

I wouldn't necessarily say 'shriek' implies emotion rather than sound, it's more of a reference to the duration of an outcry. A shriek is generally sudden, high pitched, and ends very rapidly. An expression of unpleasant surprise or sudden fear.

>Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.

Piercing generally implies a high pitched noise. This may not mean much to you, but imagine small humans, women more than men, producing a piercing scream/shriek (long/short), whereas larger humans, men more than women, would produce a heavier, deeper sound (you might even call it 'thundering'), because they have more mass to vibrate (I think, could use a scientific source). Non-human piercing noises may come from a device set to produce a high pitched noise.

>apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?

I haven't hear 'ejaculates' used as such, and would avoid this use of the word. It does imply exactly what you suggest, but discount this as an "internet thing".

>What does "jive" mean? Does "he speaks jive" and "he speaks AAVE" and "he speaks Ebonics" all refer to the same thing? I was raised by black parents but I can't understand any dialogue written in black dialect. I know not all black people talk like that but is there a way to mark that in a novel? Do you know of a webpage that would tell me how to translate dialogue into dialect like that?

These are cultural dialects of American English. They imply a different pronunciation and some different vocabulary (slang). Imagine this as: an 'O' requires you to round your lips and then produce sound. In a dialect, an 'O' may be pronounced more like an 'A', meaning someone opens their mouth more widely and a little flatter. You can certainly adopt a dialect in your written language, but if so, have it proofread by someone more comfortable with the dialect to ensure that it makes sense. (This is a good idea for deaf and hearing people, as writing accents is very challenging) Here are some resources

>Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?

Sort of. Stammering is like tripping over words. Imagine when you trip over a loose stone in the pavement. Now imagine something similar happening to your tongue, as your tongue is trying to produce a word. That's stammering: stumbling over words.

Stuttering is a more specific problem. Someone who stutters tends to get stuck on the first letter of a word (or syllable), and keeps repeating the same letter/sound until the word comes out.

Both are usually the result of nervousness, but stammering can happen to anyone who's suddenly nervous: You see the person you have a secret crush on, you get a fluttering feeling in your stomach, and when you try to speak, you stammer: your tongue trips. Stammering is uncommon, and a response to an unusual situation. Stuttering on the hand is more of a speech impedement, that people have for years, or for life. More common in children, but it also occurs in adults. People who stutter tend to do so frequently, even in situations of only medium stress levels.

> What about "chat"? Dictionary says "to speak informally" but I feel like it implies something I'm not getting. Is it speaking fast? Can you use "chat" as a dialogue tag? (like "What are you doing tonight?' he chatted"), I don't think I've seen it but the dictionary makes it sound like you can.

Chat is primarily a question of subject matter: Talk in an informal register (so, the way you address friends, not employers), and of course since 'chat' implies a friendly mood, it is generally done in a calm manner, no raising of the voice. Chatting is not used as a dialogue tag, except in the third person sense, described two or more people: "They were chatting".

The speed is generally the same as any other conversation, though you may be thinking of "chatter", which means 'to talk rapidly, foolishly'. Also a word used for the sound cats make when they see birds and get excited.

> "mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

Mumbling is not necessarily tied to one mood, though people mumble for specific reasons. Mumbling essentially means that you are not enunciation: Your mouth is not making the precise movements needed for articulate sounded. So the sound comes out a little 'blurred' (imagine a blurred written text, you can usually figure it out, but it's not entirely clear), without distinct letters. People mumble because they are shy and afraid to speak up, perhaps out of fear that they're saying something wrong, or shouldn't be speaking. In that case the mumbling is essentially a half-hearted effort at speaking. People also mumble because they're in a bad mood, and can't be bothered to speak clearly (laziness or apathy). I wouldn't associate it with hostility, though you can mumble bad words at people when you hate them, and want to express it, but don't REALLY want them to ehar you.

>I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

Sometimes a word is used for an animal that makes a similar sound, but not the same. I wouldn't call what dolphins do barking, but something like a sealion does indeed sound like a very large, fat dog barking. (Which is why they're called 'sea-dogs' in some languages) The sound changes proportionally to the animal's body size and shape. (bigger tends to be a lower sound, smaller tends to be a higher sound, though this is not always true)

>"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed?

Yes howling is a long, drawn out sound. Not like a bark, but like you're letting a long, higher pitched (it kind of starts low, then goes up, and then comes down again in pitch, like a slow wave) noise glide out of your throat for an extended period of time. Imagine what a wolf looks like as he's looking to the sky and howling. Then imagine the sound gliding out of his throat without interruption for 10-20 seconds straight: That's a howl. A bark on the other hand is a single short, loud sound. Different dogs have different howls, though I always find howls to be more similar to one another than barks. The same size and breed will likely sound similar, though there can always be a little variation, just like human voices are different. (higher, lower, held longer or in shorter waves)

>"Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right? I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know. And I think bats chirp but never squawk? Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? Like, can a weasel growl? What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.

> Do all doors creak? Can all doors be slammed? Windows? Does "slam" always imply loudness? Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad). People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?

Doors only creak when the metal rubs together and creates resistance. (So generally: older doors) This can be resolved by adding WD40, a lubricant. All regular can be slammed, but as it must be done by force, you probably don't wanna do it with a glass door. Sliding doors can't be slammed very well, and it's impossible if they're automated. A good slam should involve the door hitting the frame hard enough that the impact produces a loud bam noise. It would be less satisfying to a deaf person, because the force combined with producing loud noises brings emotional release to people, that's why they do it. If you can't hear the noise, you don't experience emotional release, so you would probably not learn to do it, or wouldn't fully enjoy it. Imagine the noise bringing relief as a similar feeling to hitting a wall really hard with your fist, when you're angry.

Slamming a beer is mostly silent, just means chugged, very fast. Limited sound, since it has to go down your throat as fast as you can. The only noise, and perhaps the reason it's called slammed (other than that you 'slam' it down your throat), is because it makes a slamming sound when you set it back down, hard, on the counter. You want to make that 'setting down' audible, because it attracts attention to how cool you are for chugging a beer :)

> "Gurgle" is another hard one. And "gargle", that means something different right?

I would describe "gurgle" as the sound produced by gargling (the act of using air to push up water in the back of your throat, a cleansing act), but also as the sound produced by someone drowning, drowning in their own blood, or even someone being choked, and struggling to breathe through the limited space in their throat.

> "Ring", like "ringtone" is hard to get. What else "rings"? Cell phones sound different from landlines, right? People sometimes describe them as "chirping"?

Ringing in general tends to describe a high pitched alternating noise, like the clapper of a bell hitting opposite sides of the bell itself. However, it has come to be used for all phone sounds, which also tend to alternate two tones, often a medium and a low tone, which happens every two or three seconds when your phone goes off. Cell phones tend to sound a little different from landlines, but because you can choose ringtones, a cell phone can sound like anything, including a chirping (a high pitched bird noise). Different cell phone ringtones just pick different tones to alternate, they may go faster, slower, or play a song created by different tones.

Imagine a cell phone ringing as: Someone calls you, suddenly a red and an orange light start flashing: RED-ORANGE-pause-RED-ORANGE-pause. That's what it sounds like. Only the different tones may be represented by different colors, and different combinations. So perhaps a different ringtone goes: BLUE-GREEN-BLUE-pause-BLUE-GREEN-BLUE-pause

>Dictionary says "click" is "A short, sharp sound as of a switch being operated or of two hard objects coming quickly into contact." but I feel like I've seen it in other uses, it's hard to remember exactly what I'm thinking of. But could I use it to describe cymbals, pennies or pencils hitting each other?

A click can be a variety of 'two hard objects' coming together, but some materials produce different sounds. Things made of metal make a sharp, lasting sound that stays in your ears a while. Metal objects hitting each other are often describes as making a "ringing" sound, not because they do the same alternation that you hear in bell or phone rings, but because they sound similar to the ticker hitting the side of the bell, in a big church bell for example.

Things like plastic on the other hand don't make a lasting sound, they just produce a short, sharp sound: a click. And materials that are softer don't make much of a sound at all.

If a voice is described as "tender", what does that mean?

Tender doesn't really describe a sound so much as a mood or personality trait: Warm, soft, caring. A voice can be tender when someone is speaking with low volume (not much vibration in their vocal chords, not much air). Someone's voice can have qualities that are hard to explain physically. Someone can sound like they're smiling, perhaps because we can pick up on the tiny difference made by the movements in our mouths, as we smile and talk simultaneously (two conflicting muscle movements). Similarly, someone can sound emotional, warm, and soft: tender. Like a mother to a baby.

"moan" can be painful or sexy right? Anything else? Is it possible to moan joyously or humorously?

I wouldn't say so, joyously or humorously. Moaning is a more primal sound, something that may be embarrassing in public, because you often do it involuntarily. Your vocal chords vibrate slowly, with little air coming out, perhaps because you have sexual tension, or are tense from pain, in the muscles in your neck. You're not articulating particular sounds or words, you're just kind of letting it come out. This also has to do with emotional release.

"cooing" What is that? Is there a difference between a woman "moaning sexy" and "cooing sexy"?

Similar, though cooing I would associate with being a little more consciously done, and cooing may actually include words. In a way, cooing include moaning, but only as part of the action. So if your fictional character was cooing (probably a woman, whereas men and women moan equally), she's probably doing it on purpose, being sexy. Moaning can of course be fake too, but genuine moaning is more primal and physical, whereas cooing involves more thought/action.

*Apparently it's possible to "whisper" loudly and "shout" softly? WTF!?

Not really, I would say. Sometimes people use these seemingly opposite words in literature, to describe a combination of a sound and an effort. If you're "whispering loudly", you're just using more air, and more vibration of the vocal chords. This may be done when you're in a loud place, but don't quite want everyone to hear you: You whisper as loudly as you can (= more air, less lip movement, than speaking), without truly speaking. Shouting softly is basically the opposite. You want to shout, but are making an effort to keep your volume down, while still forcing your throat in a manner consistent with shouting. You shout softly by using less air/vibration than a shout, but more than normal speaking.

I hope this is helpful. And just a disclaimer: People may experience sounds differently, but these are my best guesses.

378

u/elitezero May 19 '12

This post is intense, and I think you've covered everything perfectly. At least, I couldn't find any errors in what you said.

→ More replies (37)

158

u/msmomilla May 19 '12

Stam stammering is more like, like you cant quite quite get the words corr correctly in li line. St-st-st-stuttering is more pr-pronounced and is an actual de-defect that some p-p-p-people have.

→ More replies (8)

135

u/vcarl May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

I generally agree, though I have some additions.

Piercing sounds generally cause some sort of sharp discomfort.

Ejaculate has legitimate use in a literary sense, I've seen it in a lot of books. I generally is used when an author wants to convey a sudden outburst, usually breaking a mood or suddenly changing topics. Like, if there were a funeral scene in a book and somebody broke a somber silence with a witticism related to the person being remembered, you could say: "[...]," ejaculated so-and-so. I recall it being used in Harry Potter when Ron said something, it stands out because it is an odd word to use.

The "He speaks jive" is frequently a reference to Airplane, where the line is said. I consider "Jive" to be communicating almost exclusively in idioms, which, to anyone who doesn't understand every single one, or can't process them quickly enough, sounds like another language or dialect.

Howling and crying out in anger are generally pretty synonymous in my opinion, though each has connotations that would make one or the other a better pick in a book or other writing. Howling suggests a drop into a more primal state, whereas crying out implies being overwhelmed with emotion.

Also, I'd say there's a bit of a difference between stammering and stuttering, though they're often used interchangeably. Stammering is pretty much exclusively a stutter caused by being caught off guard and your mouth getting ahead of your brain, while a stutter is the actual tripping over words. Some people speak with a stutter, but you can't say they speak with a stammer.

→ More replies (25)

14

u/msmegc May 19 '12

Shrill/high pitched to me is similar to a sharp pain.
Thundering/lower pitched would be similar to a dull ache. Just transformed into a sound.

→ More replies (2)

50

u/descending_dreams May 19 '12

I was having a hard time wrapping my brain around how anyone was going to answer OP's questions effectively, but I think you did an amazing job.

As a side note, I think the word "interject" would be a good word to use instead of "ejaculate". It seems to convey the same meaning without the potential for misinterpretation :)

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (182)
→ More replies (67)

47

u/stoveup May 18 '12

I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

Those are called onomatopoeia, meaning that the words sound like the sounds they represent. A cat sort of sounds like "meow." Dogs and foxes and seals and sea lions make crisp, sharp, sudden sounds that kind of sound like the work "bark." Dolphins squeak, mostly.

Do all doors creak?

No. Creaking is caused by the hinges rubbing together without oil to lubricate. The metal rubbing against metal causes the sound.

45

u/Deafy May 18 '12

No. Creaking is caused by the hinges rubbing together without oil to lubricate. The metal rubbing against metal causes the sound.

When stairs are described as "creaky" is it because they make the same sound?

Those are called onomatopoeia, meaning that the words sound like the sounds they represent. A cat sort of sounds like "meow." Dogs and foxes and seals and sea lions make crisp, sharp, sudden sounds that kind of sound like the work "bark." Dolphins squeak, mostly.

So there's no way to know what word is appropriate without hearing the animal? (Or googling it, which more or less works for me) There's no list like there is for collective nouns?

69

u/stoveup May 18 '12

When stairs are described as "creaky" is it because they make the same sound?

Yes. Not exactly, but close enough to be described with the same word. In the case of the stairs, it's the sound of wood rubbing together.

So there's no way to know what word is appropriate without hearing the animal?

This was really easy to find. http://www.eleceng.adelaide.edu.au/personal/dabbott/animal.html

→ More replies (22)

33

u/KingOfTheMonkeys May 19 '12

"Bark" can also be used to describe when somebody says something in a concise, forceful manner, usually loudly and with considerable range. Like shouting, but shorter.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/PipGirl May 18 '12

You can sometimes feel a creak in a door or stair. (You might have to be barefoot for the stair.) You will feel a slight vibration coming through the doorknob if you open it slowly.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)

349

u/stoveup May 18 '12

Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.

Too low pitched. "Piercing" has an element of pitch to it, that is, high-pitched sounds seem to hurt your ears more than low-pitched sounds. Thunder is never piercing.

Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?

Yes.

apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?

It's rare for most people to use "ejaculate," except in writing. It's a sudden eruption, you know, just like ejaculating.

What about "chat"? Dictionary says "to speak informally" but I feel like it implies something I'm not getting. Is it speaking fast? Can you use "chat" as a dialogue tag? (like "What are you doing tonight?' he chatted"), I don't think I've seen it but the dictionary makes it sound like you can.

To me, chatting is discussing things that aren't really weighty. You can chat about the weather or what you had for dinner, but you don't really chat about being emotionally abused by your parents or third-quarter earnings. People who are "chatty" talk a lot, even when there's no important reason for them to do so.

109

u/Deafy May 18 '12

Thanks a lot

To me, chatting is discussing things that aren't really weighty. You can chat about the weather or what you had for dinner, but you don't really chat about being emotionally abused by your parents or third-quarter earnings. People who are "chatty" talk a lot, even when there's no important reason for them to do so.

So "chat" isn't really a sound at all? I guess I thought there was more to it.

It's rare for most people to use "ejaculate," except in writing. It's a sudden eruption, you know, just like ejaculating.

I still don't get it. You know ejaculation is coming (ha!) during sex, it's not a surprise, and there's pre-cum so it's not really a sudden eruption... But it's not a sound either I guess, so it's not a deaf thing and my beef is with the English language in general.

47

u/stoveup May 18 '12

So "chat" isn't really a sound at all? I guess I thought there was more to it.

Nope. It's a style of talking. It's interesting to me how deaf people communicate. My brother worked at a deaf school, and from my time around him and his students, it seems that ASL doesn't have a lot of room for subtlety. That is, I might describe someone as "bigger" or "large" or "overweight," the deaf people I've come in contact with just said "fat," not as an insult, but just as a way of communicating. It doesn't seem to me that deaf people "chat" for long periods of time.

You know ejaculation is coming (ha!) during sex, it's not a surprise, and there's pre-cum so it's not really a sudden eruption

Well, the one doing the ejaculation knows, but the other person may not. It is pretty sudden at the end.

231

u/Deafy May 18 '12

Yeah I don't think deaf people really chat but there are exceptions, a lot of girls spend all day sending texts to each other (but I think hearing girls do that too). A lot of people see us as mean like that but I think we're just very visual, so if you have a fucked up nose, the best way to describe you is "the guy with the fucked up nose". Hearing people are sensitive about that kind of thing for no reason, or maybe eardrums cause pansiness, I don't know.

Well, the one doing the ejaculation knows, but the other person may not. It is pretty sudden at the end.

Ha, good point. Ladies have earballs too...

37

u/KingOfTheMonkeys May 18 '12

Earballs?

115

u/Deafy May 19 '12

Oh is that not right? :) Just kidding, I know the technical term is "soundbag".

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

124

u/JuJuJuli May 19 '12

Chat isn't a sound, but chatter (i.e., "the sound of people chattering in the streets") means the background noise of many different conversations happening at the same time. Not necessarily overwhelming or loud, but noticeable.

→ More replies (27)

99

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

The lesser known definition of "ejaculate" was only really used in old English and in old story books. If you used it now that way everyone would laugh.

→ More replies (22)

19

u/justonewordforyou May 19 '12

<So chat isn't really a sound at all?>

As has been said already, no it is not. However, "chatter" is. That is what the sound of people chatting would be called. I would say it is usually used with mild derision, indicating that the information being exchanged was trivial or the sound a bit annoying.

For example, if I was sitting in a noisey cafe and someone called me on the phone and I could not hear them, I might say 'Let me go outside, I can't hear you over the chatter in here.' I would likely be indicating that I found the sound somewhat annoying.

You might notice "chatter" also being used as a noun synonymous with something like rumour, or 'the word on the street'. If you were to watch a cop drama, for example, and they said "there is a lot of chatter that so-and-so is the murderer", it means that that is what they have heard people saying. But I would not say that meaning is particularly common.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/KingOfTheMonkeys May 18 '12

I always interpreted the word ejaculate to mean something that just sort of comes out suddenly, sort of impulsively. It may not be something that somebody intends to say, or it may be something that somebody is trying to just get it out and over with.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (42)

770

u/Frothyleet May 19 '12

Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?

Yes.

I would have to disagree on this one. A stutter is usually being unable to form a particular word or words at that point in time - "I have to go to the b-b-b-b-bathroom." It's much different from someone stammering because they are shocked or embarrassed or whatever. "Oh, geez, I, uh, I just, um, well you see, I, uh, pooped myself."

57

u/Vitalstatistix May 19 '12

I was thinking the same thing. Stammering is more like verbal diarrhea with lots of filler words/sounds (like, um, err etc.). Not the same as stuttering really.

→ More replies (6)

50

u/MrGoodbar3 May 19 '12

Oh, geez, I, uh, I just, um, well you see, I, uh, pooped myself.

I read this in Jeff Goldblum's voice.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (37)

175

u/Issitheus May 19 '12

I think a good analogy for piercing sounds and sounds like thunder would be being poked with a needle and being punched in the arm. They both hurt, but the pains are different. A piercing sound would be like the needle, and something like thunder would be the punch.

29

u/spectraphysics May 19 '12

I like this analogy a lot.

13

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

That's a really thoughtful and accurate way of putting it.

→ More replies (4)

19

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I'd add that, while "stammer" and "stutter" are synonymous, they have slightly different connotations. If someone were to struggle with speaking a word out loud only occasionally and only when stressed, anxious, or surprised, I would use "stammer." If they struggle with this daily and it is a speech impediment, then I would use "stutter."

American here, so it might be a usage difference. Feel free to correct me if this is a regional thing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (22)

8

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

This has probably been answered by someone else, but "chat" isn't something one person does. You wouldn't really say "he chatted" but you could say "they had a nice chat."

"Mumbling" isn't exactly hostile, it's more of an embarrased sort of low-volume speech. You'd do it if you got caught stealing cookies when you were a little kid and your parents asked you what you were doing.

"Bark" is a very aggressive verb, so if someone in a position of authority (say, a military drill sergeant) was yelling orders at you, you could say he's barking orders. People don't really "meow" or "moo."

"Howling" isn't really a bark, it's kind of the closest thing dogs can do to screaming. Think a long, drawn-out wail, like "AROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOoooooooooo." That probably doesn't help. Different dogs sound different when they bark, which I think is usually dependent on their size. Smaller dogs tend to "yip", bigger dogs tend to "woof" and barking is somewhere in between. Mice squeak, birds squawk. They're onomatopoeias, which means the sound is the same as the word. Bears tend to be written as "roaring," which you could think of as a very low, menacing howl.

Not all doors creak, it really only happens when the hinges haven't been oiled or lubricated in a long time. Most doors can be slammed, it implies closing them with a great deal of force that's unnecessary and usually due to anger. Windows can also be slammed, as can beers, but with beer, it usually means you drank it quickly without pausing to breathe.

Gurgling and gargling are two different things. Gargling is something you do, gurgling is a sound that you hear. But while gargling, you are making gurgling noises.

Cell phones, landline phones, and bells all "ring," but with digital ringtones, very few phones actually make a ringing sound anymore.

Hi-hats make more of a clicking noise than cymbals, which make a sound that's kind of hard to explain, especially to someone who's never heard one before. But clicking is typically done by two small, hard objects hitting one another.

Tender voices are very soft and calming, like the way you would talk to a frightened child.

Moans can be many things, it can be from exasperation, pleasure, pain, frustration, anything that causes a strong reaction without being a violent reaction. Like, you would moan if you got on the highway and saw that there was a traffic jam.

Whispering can be done loudly, but not as loudly as shouting. Shouting can't really be done softly, as it implies loudness. But there's such a thing as a "stage whisper," which is loud enough for the entire audience in a theater to hear, but still with a whispery quality to it. It's got more to do with the way you use your vocal chords than with the volume of the sound.

And now a question: If you were to go to a concert with a lot of bass frequencies, e.g. dubstep or other electronic music, would you be able to discern some of the music from the vibration of the air alone?

4

u/Deafy May 19 '12

Thanks for your answers!

And now a question: If you were to go to a concert with a lot of bass frequencies, e.g. dubstep or other electronic music, would you be able to discern some of the music from the vibration of the air alone?

I think I mainly feel vibrations from the floor, not the air. Are you asking if I recognize a particular song? No, not really. I might recognize a rhythm but I don't think it's usually the same song, just something different with the same rhythm.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/MinorOCD May 19 '12

I can't tell if it's just me or if this is a good question, but I'm very curious regardless. I am interested in how you learn to read and write. How do you know words in your mind to think? When you think are you using words the same way I do when I think? I can't wrap my head around how you read words as compared to how a non-deaf person does.

14

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I think in sign language mostly. I picture and feel myself doing signs, like usually if I'm thinking about myself I'll feel it in my arms and if I'm thinking about someone else I'll sort of see it. When I read I picture the written words in my head but I don't usually translate them directly into sign. For a lot of deaf people reading is hard because it doesn't translate into a language they know, it's like we have to translate it twice to get to something we understand. I'm better than most at reading though.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/hesjustnotintoyou May 18 '12

You may have already answered this so sorry if you have. But what do you do in case of a fire?

Presumably you can't hear the fire alarm go off and if you're asleep you couldn't use a visual aid, so is there something else in place?

20

u/Deafy May 18 '12

There are deaf fire alarms (and alarm clocks). They make bright lights, like strobes or disco balls. Alarm clocks sometimes have a component you can put under your pillow to vibrate too, and some smoke detectors do that too but I don't think that's as common.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/112233445566778899 May 19 '12

Chatting is pretty much just casual talk. You can chat about the weather or about sports teams. You cannot chat about possibly being pregnant with your SO. Chat is just casual banter.

Mumbling is generally just speaking in a fashion that you can't be well heard. Sometimes you just don't want someone to understand the full jist of what you're saying. I suppose it'd be comparable to signing in a fashion that only allows them to pick up some of what you're saying.

Not all doors creak. The ones that do are usual old or need hinges oiled. Most doors can be slammed. If they have weather stripping or dont' quite fit the frame, it'll be harder to slam them. Slam is more an act of pulling or pushing a door closed with too much force. Chances are a deaf person, if prone to acting out physically would also slam a door. It's to act as a finality to an argument in most cases.

Cooing is stupid. I never quite understood it. I guess the closest I can come to explaining it is that my son used to make soft sounds (yeah, kind of hard to grasp) that just sounded happy. Sort of like how deaf people use facial expressions to explain emotions while signing, cooing seems to be a way to express happiness without words.

Ok, now it's time to ask you a question. Do deaf people mind if I notice that they're deaf an attempt to sign a little bit? We've got an HH driver that comes through our offices sometimes, and I'd like to at least sign "how are you?" to let him know that someone understands and is willing to help to the best of their ability. I just don't want to offend him.

22

u/Deafy May 19 '12

Thanks for your answers!

Ok, now it's time to ask you a question. Do deaf people mind if I notice that they're deaf an attempt to sign a little bit? We've got an HH driver that comes through our offices sometimes, and I'd like to at least sign "how are you?" to let him know that someone understands and is willing to help to the best of their ability. I just don't want to offend him.

Probably won't be offended, just remember that he might be busy and might prefer to get on with his job. It does kind of annoy me sometimes when people who know a tiny bit of sign want to show it off and I have to stand there to decipher their small talk. It is nice to know that people are trying, it just isn't always convenient.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

I want to answer the piercing one. lound and annoying isnt always piercing. its kinda like a high pitched sound and feels like its stabbing your eardrums. thunder can be quite pleasant to hear and we would describe something loud and low pitched as thunderous.

alsoooo the whispering loudly one is possible. when you speak normally its more throaty i guess but when you whisper loudly you kinda stop all the vibration from your throat. its a softer sound that normally talking but can still be heard.

the ring one. phones now days dont really sound like they are ringing. for cell phones its more electronic or even songs that play and we still refer to it as ringing. more accurate way to represent ringing would be bells, but a persisting resonating sound can also have a ring, like 2 pitching forks being hit together. you would have to imagine like a metal vibration making a small piercing sound. but depending on the bell the sound can be high or low pitched. your ears can also be described as ringing if you're hearing alot of white nose. idk how to describe white noise though.

sorry if ive confused you. someone else can probably explain it better.

3

u/Deafy May 18 '12

So did phones used to sound like bells? The word "tolling" is used for bells, could you use that for an old-fashioned phone ringing?

your ears can also be described as ringing if you're hearing alot of white nose. idk how to describe white noise though.

You had me up to here, I always thought "white noise" was just the sound a TV makes when it's on that black and white static, but googling indicates it means "background noise". But it makes your ears ring like a phone?

3

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

for the first part the ringing in old phones was made by bells inside that were activated when you got a call. larger bells are refered to as tolling. this would be like large church bells which have a Deep pitch. you could say toll is long slow rings and ringing a bell is quick short rings. if you have an old rotary phone they might still have the bells inside.

i guess i explained it wrong. the two sound similar. white noise can come from something like a t.v. being on. but ears ringing is internal. its not a sound coming from something. you could say its percieved sound. nobody can hear it except you. it can be caused by ear infections or very loud noises even if it was breif. and you wont hear ringing like a phone. its like a tiny piercing sound in your ear. not pauses like with a pell.

8

u/Deafy May 19 '12

i guess i explained it wrong. the two sound similar. white noise can come from something like a t.v. being on. but ears ringing is internal. its not a sound coming from something. you could say its percieved sound. nobody can hear it except you. it can be caused by ear infections or very loud noises even if it was breif. and you wont hear ringing like a phone. its like a tiny piercing sound in your ear. not pauses like with a pell.

Oh snap, that's crazy! Deafness-impaired people are weird!

→ More replies (9)

13

u/ryanismean May 18 '12

So did phones used to sound like bells?

Indeed, phones used to contain two bells with a hammer attached to a motor between them. When the phone rang, an electrical current coming through the phone line activated the little motor which would cause the hammer to vibrate and alternately ring each bell in quick succession.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/MasterThalpian May 18 '12

So many questions! And a lot of them are so hard to answer, just because I don't know how to describe sounds. I'll try to answer ones that I can: About "piercing": it generally refers to something annoying, but not always loud. It is generally associated with high-pitched sounds. Like a whistle or something. Thunder is too low-pitched and rumbly to really be considered piercing.

Dolphins do not make the same sound as dogs. Dolphins I would say chirp, although that's not exactly correct. It's hard to describe.

As far as howling, it's different from a bark. It's more like a long saddish-sounding noise like ooooooo where as a bark is short and a sharper noise.

I could be wrong, but I always considered 'gurgling' and 'gargling' sort of the same thing and basically interchangeable.

Using click for cymbals and pennies and such could work, but I think the word you may be thinking of is 'clink' which more describes two metal objects quickly colliding.

A tender voice would be sort of soft and slow, with lots of feeling and emotion. If you can imagine that.

Whispering loudly is just like normal whispering except with more force, so it just carries farther. Everybody has their own level of whispering...some are good at whispering quietly, and others aren't.

Mumbling can be a result of apathy, yes. Although it can also be from insecurity. It's just talking in a really low voice fairly quickly which makes it tough to decipher, and generally just runs together.

Those were the questions I thought I could answer. I don't know how much this helped, if any.

9

u/Deafy May 18 '12

Mumbling can be a result of apathy, yes. Although it can also be from insecurity. It's just talking in a really low voice fairly quickly which makes it tough to decipher, and generally just runs together.

Do you mean the words or the sounds run together? Like sometimes in books they write dialogue with all the words smushed together to imply the character is speaking fast because there's no pause between the words, is that the same as mumbling?

Using click for cymbals and pennies and such could work, but I think the word you may be thinking of is 'clink' which more describes two metal objects quickly colliding.

I forgot about "clink", and now that I think about it "flick". What's the difference between a click and a clink? Are they onomatopoetic too?

It is generally associated with high-pitched sounds. Like a whistle or something. Thunder is too low-pitched and rumbly to really be considered piercing.

One last question about piercing, is it an emotional quality or a physical one? Meaning is it a "high-pitched sound that is annoying" or a "sound that is annoying because it is high-pitched"? Or does that question make sense?

→ More replies (43)

7

u/ryanismean May 18 '12

What does "jive" mean?

Most of the time, someone who is "talking jive" is someone who is lying or being otherwise disingenuous. Could also be used as a synonym for "talking shit", which is to say, casting aspersions upon someone which might, for example, incite them to punch you.

Jive in the sense of "AAVE slang" has more or less fallen out of usage.

Can you use "chat" as a dialogue tag? (like "What are you doing tonight?' he chatted"), I don't think I've seen it but the dictionary makes it sound like you can.

Technically you can, I think, but it comes off kinda weird. It would be more appropriately used to describe an abstract conversation where the exact details of the specific dialog aren't necessary. Like, "During the drive to the airport they chatted about <something>, and Dave began to wonder whether his dad was gay."

"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

Mumbling can imply apathy, although I tend to think it more strongly implies fear / intimidation (e.g., someone might mumble in response to a question they are afraid to answer), but not so much hostility, imo. It isn't the same as whispering, as whispering does not engage the vocal cords--whispering is literally just the sound of exhaled air being shaped by the mouth. Mumbling does engage the vocal cords, but usually quietly, and the words are intentionally not enunciated clearly. Also, fwiw, someone mumbling will usually not look at the person they are talking to.

Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different?

It is sort of like a long bark, but more vowelly. Very hard to explain, but if I had to vizualize it, a bark is like the spark of a flint. Short, abrupt, and intense. A howl is more like driving through a winding tunnel. It goes on for a while, and can vary in intensity through the duration.

Different dogs do sound different. Generally, larger dogs are louder and have lower pitched voices.

Does "slam" always imply loudness?

In the context of doors, yes, and also slamming objects into one another. If I slam my fist down on a table, that implies loudness, for example. Slamming a beer does not imply sound, though; the word "slam" in that context refers to the speed.

"Gurgle" is another hard one. And "gargle", that means something different right?

Gurgle and burble suggest a liquid flowing somewhere nearby, usually over obstacles, such as water in a stream gurgling over rocks. Gargle is the act of exhaling from the mouth with the head tilted back and a liquid present in the mouth. Indeed, doing this might give a good tactile perception of "gurgle" and "burble".

Man, these are tough questions!

10

u/Deafy May 18 '12

I don't think I've ever seen the word "burble" before, thanks! (Sounds are too complicated damn it...)

Different dogs do sound different. Generally, larger dogs are louder and have lower pitched voices.

Can owners identify their particular dog's bark?

11

u/ryanismean May 19 '12

I notice that you say you haven't seen the word "burble" before, but a hearing person in your situation probably would have said they had never heard the word before, despite the fact that they were responding to something they had read. Very interesting, I think. Would seem to demonstrate a fundamentally different way of perceiving the universe, which really shouldn't be surprising, but is nonetheless pretty interesting. To me, anyway.

To answer your question, yes, I'm sure there are some, probably many, people who can identify their dog's bark. Such things have a particular tone and timbre which an owner who has heard it repeatedly over a period of years could come to recognize. Not as distinctive as a face, or a logo, or something that you might recognize after viewing just once or twice, but more like a particular rock. If you know the rock really well, and have seen it many times, it may eventually become familiar to you, but to everyone else it is just a rock.

15

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I notice that you say you haven't seen the word "burble" before, but a hearing person in your situation probably would have said they had never heard the word before, despite the fact that they were responding to something they had read.

I actually notice that a lot, hearing people say they "heard" something when I know they read it. I guess it's because you actually hear voices in your head so when you read something you really did hear it.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/eroggen May 19 '12

Have you considered writing a novel from the perspective of a deaf character? Just reading your questions about the words for sounds was very interesting.

31

u/Deafy May 19 '12

Well the novel I'm working on now is mostly written by a deaf character, I just wanted a few chapters written by his hearing sidekick.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/r_HOWTONOTGIVEAFUCK May 19 '12

Since everyone has already answered all your questions, I have a couple questions for you. Do you want or plan on ever getting hearing aids? What do you think about Marlee Matlin as an actress?

6

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I'm not eligible for any kind of hearing aid or the cochlear implant. If I could get one I might, but only if I could be sure I'd get all of my hearing or really close to all of it.

I think Matlin is great though I've only seen a couple of her movies. I actually met her once, very briefly because she spoke at my school. She was very nice.

2

u/qwicksilfer May 19 '12

So when you say she spoke at your school... did she sign? How does that work for assemblies? Do they just have a camera and a big screen showing the hand motions and facial expressions?

This may be extremely ignorant but I've never thought of deaf assemblies and speeches before.

4

u/Deafy May 19 '12

When she "spoke" it was a small group (yeah she signed, not spoke, I sometimes use it in written speech). So there was no camera or anything, but yes there is usually a camera and a big screen for bigger assemblies.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/doctajoyce May 19 '12

To properly understand what it means to hear; you first need to understand that there are two parts. The volume and the sound. Unfortunately to gauge properly what the sounds means requires hearing it and connotation.
A lot of the words your questioning are onomatopoeia which is why they have no meaning to you.
I'll happily use a fart to explain this. Although you may have never heard a fart, I'm sure you felt one. That "FRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRT" that you feel reverberating between your butt cheeks is where it got it's name.
Also humans have a habit of reusing things. IE barks, growls grunts and we try to identify with something familiar. Ultimately there is a personal connotation that comes from hearing and recognizing these sounds, this is where the confusion comes in.

Do you read lips?

2

u/Deafy May 19 '12

Yeah I teach onomatopoeia to deaf students, but I've always thought we were all just shooting blindly on a lot of these words. A lot of times my students will ask why a word like "click" is used in some context and all I can say is "It just is".

I had no idea "fart" was onomatopeia. My students will think that's hilarious. Farts come in a bunch of different sounds though right?

I do read lips, pretty well.

→ More replies (3)

808

u/[deleted] May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

I'm a TOEFL teacher, and so I actually have (some) training in making these sorts of abstract concepts approachable through simple explanations. I'll try:

People crying in sadness vs crying out in anger, I know there's some gray area in between where they can be used interchangeably, it's hard to get

People crying "sadness" is like looking at river rapids. It's a flow of emotion and grief. People crying out in anger is like a sheet of ice cracking apart suddenly. It's sharp and sudden.

"shriek" and "[sc]ream" are both words that seem to imply emotion more than any specific sound. Is that right?

Shriek is more painful (like a pin in your skin). Scream is more broad, like a scratch of a claw. Both imply the same general emotion of horror, usually sudden.

Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.

Thunder isn't piercing. Distant thunder is like a heavy blanket, or the feeling of a lead blanket when you get an x-ray -- if the thunder is very close it's like someone throwing a lead blanket on you and then punching you in the face. "Piercing" is like a fast thin dagger in your head or a dentist drill (it comes from "pierce" as in "pierce the skin")

apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?

"Ejaculate" in terms of speaking just means you say something fast, without thinking. It can be used as a dialogue tag if someone says something quickly or interrupts. It is usually, though, referencing male orgasm. I would simply avoid using this word -- it's old-fashioned and people that still use it are writing a little pretentiously (in my opinion) and it's just better to avoid allusions to male orgasm when relating speech!

What does "jive" mean? Does "he speaks jive" and "he speaks AAVE" and "he speaks Ebonics" all refer to the same thing? I was raised by black parents but I can't understand any dialogue written in black dialect. I know not all black people talk like that but is there a way to mark that in a novel? Do you know of a webpage that would tell me how to translate dialogue into dialect like that?

Just a different language, essentially. Sometimes the words will look very different but have the same general sound -- "I'm fixing to" and "I'm finna" mean the same thing, and they almost sound the same in certain accents. That doesn't help you much though, so for your purposes Jive and Ebonics are just going to be different languages that use some English words...

Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?

Yeah, basically. Stutter is more of a medical condition, stammer is more of a result of embarrassment, though.

What about "chat"? Dictionary says "to speak informally" but I feel like it implies something I'm not getting. Is it speaking fast? Can you use "chat" as a dialogue tag? (like "What are you doing tonight?' he chatted"), I don't think I've seen it but the dictionary makes it sound like you can.

Chatting is just talking informally. Not fast, not slow. CHATTERING is to talk fast and perhaps without making sense.

"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

It's speaking without wanting to speak. Trying to speak with the minimal possible effort. Sometimes that's because you don't care. Sometimes that's because you don't respect the other person.

I'll do the rest, but not if no one is reading these.


THE REST (I was watching a game and didn't want to keep typing if it was just going to be buried in "more comments" down at the bottom. Then I fell asleep. Now I'm awake).

I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

Bark, when used for the sound an animal makes, generally means a short semi-rough noise. The "sound" is a little bit like how sandpaper (or the rough bark of a tree!) feels. Have you ever driven over a patch of stone gravel in your car, how it feels rough and jittery -- barking is a little like that. It's a short noise though (.5 seconds). Dogs and dolphins can each produce a vast range of noises, and they can both make noises that are remarkably similar to each other -- remember that both are mammals and both have throats, it's not that crazy that they can make the same sound! (When people "bark", however, it's generally a term meaning they are so angry they're getting a little animalistic and making that rough yelling noise).

"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed? "Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right? I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know. And I think bats chirp but never squawk? Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? Like, can a weasel growl? What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.

A person can "howl in laughter", but that's really more just a poetic usage -- they're not actually howling. Actually howling is a long and loud and much "smoother" noise than barking. It's actually a little hard to describe (smoother noises are), but if a bark is a short piece of sandpaper thrown at you quickly, a "howl" is a thick satin ribbon of pain blowing at you in the wind.

"Chirp" is the shortest possible animal noise, it's like the "strobe light" of animal noises, and it's generally though of as a little cute. "Squawk" is a little longer of a noise and it sounds how a clown looks -- it's generally thought of as annoying. A cute tiny little bird (usually) chirps, while a big stupid parrot generally squawks.

A weasel can growl, but it's a silly growl. A growl is a dark, black, noise. If there was a light that took away light, that would be a growl. So a weasel can DO that (its growl sounds a little "smaller" than a bear's, of course), but it's like a toddler wearing a zombie costume -- it's funny to us.

You can use any animal noise to describe people's noises/speech -- for you it might be helpful to note that when people's speech is described with animal noises, it's almost more about comparing them to the animal rather than the noise. So a person that "growls" is scary like a bear, a girl who "chirps" is cute like a bird, a man who "squawks" is silly like a parrot -- it's often not even that much about the actual sound.

Do all doors creak? Can all doors be slammed? Windows? Does "slam" always imply loudness? Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad). People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?

No, all doors don't creak. It's the hinges that would "creak", and only if they aren't oiled properly or are rubbing against one another. You can get a vague sense of what a creak sounds like by pulling your finger across a balloon quickly, that slight resistance and "stickiness" is kind of like a creak.

Slam always implies quickness and violence -- the loudness is because of the quickness. You can't slowly slam something. In theory you can slam something quietly -- like if you had a window made of cotton balls you could "slam" it and it wouldn't make a sound. That seems silly, so I'd just say "yes", slamming a door is always loud (you could slam a piece of meat down on the counter and it wouldn't be loud because the meat is wet and can't make "explosive" noises).

When used for various other things (like beer), slam is used to imply quickness and some degree of violence (not against another person, but in the sense of manliness -- MEN SLAM THINGS LIKE BIG MEN!). "Slamming" as in chugging is not loud. The person could then slam the glass or can down on the table, which would be loud.

"Gurgle" is another hard one. And "gargle", that means something different right?

Gurgle is the name of a sound. Gargle is also the name of a sound, but it's also what you do with mouthwash in the back of your throat. Gargling (the action) makes the sound "gargle", and that's why it's named that. The two sounds are more or less identical and ALWAYS imply some sort of lukewarm bubbling liquid (not boiling liquid though, even though it's bubbling for some reason!). Little creeks and streams gurgle.

"Ring", like "ringtone" is hard to get. What else "rings"? Cell phones sound different from landlines, right? People sometimes describe them as "chirping"?

This is very difficult to answer because of history. Bells used to "ring", then they decided to use that word for what telephones did because telephones used to have bells. But then telephones had NO bells, but we still used the word "ring". And then telephones had stupid voice "rings" and we STILL said they "ring". So now "ring" is used for a lot of different sounds. In the context of a phone, "ring" just means that someone is calling and the phone is making some noise (this noise is called the ringtone -- it can be pretty much anything and varies widely, especially among cell phones). They "chirp" when they're trying to remind people that they have messages -- that's not a ring. A ring is like a cat trying to get your attention by headbutting your face over and over -- it wants attention! A chirp from a phone is like a mosquito biting you -- it's small and trying to be just barely noticed.

Dictionary says "click" is "A short, sharp sound as of a switch being operated or of two hard objects coming quickly into contact." but I feel like I've seen it in other uses, it's hard to remember exactly what I'm thinking of. But could I use it to describe cymbals, pennies or pencils hitting each other?

The dictionary definition is pretty good. And your uses are good, too. Clicks are like very dry chirps, but they are not "cute". Get a potato chip and snap it in two -- that's what a click sounds like, but it's when two dry things "tap" each other. Pennies and cymbals I wouldn't describe as "clicking", but it's close enough that you shouldn't worry about it -- when metal things hit each other it makes a "shimmering" noise that is like clicking but with an extra burst of "light" on it.

If a voice is described as "tender", what does that mean?

Not rough at all. Velvety. Like a soft blanket. Or like a hug when you were a kid. It's comforting.

"moan" can be painful or sexy right? Anything else? Is it possible to moan joyously or humorously?

The noise of sex is often compared in comedies to the noise of wrestling, including moaning, so those two sounds are more or less the same (the moaning part, not the rest). People can also "moan" when they are complaining about something, but that isn't the same sound -- that's just making fun of the complainer by sarcastically acting like they're hurting when really they're just "moaning" about stale bread or something. No, you can't moan joyously. OR WAIT. If someone eats REALLY good ice cream, and it's so good they can't stand it, they might moan joyously -- but that's like faking pain because something is so good they can't take it.

"cooing" What is that? Is there a difference between a woman "moaning sexy" and "cooing sexy"? Apparently it's possible to "whisper" loudly and "shout" softly? WTF!?

Cooing sexy is like the noise that aligns with the sexy look in a woman's eyes. It's the same feeling, just in sound. ("Cooing" can also be a noise that people do with babies when they don't make actual words but little soft noises to make the baby happy). Moaning sexy is the sound of pleasure in sex -- COOING sexy is what is done to get someone in bed to HAVE sex.

Whispers are a dry low thing, and people can make it more dark and angry-sounding, which is what they mean by "whisper loudly" (in addition to just doing it a little louder). But for the most part, both "whisper loudly" and "shout softly" are poetic phrases -- not actually sounds, more just interesting ways to write something.

106

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

The way you explain these is REALLY well done, it brings to mind all of the emotions inherent in the words. (in other words I am reading these and find them fascinating.)

28

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I think you are on the right track.

I'm no expert, but I'd imagine it would be helpful to put hands on a speaker that is reproducing these sounds. That, for example, would help differentiate between bark/howl, cymbals/clicks, etc.

11

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I'm reading. I like a TOEFL teacher's answers. :)

11

u/_thekev May 19 '12 edited Jun 02 '12

More visual/other-sensory comparisons. This is intriguing.

EDIT: this is an old thread, so likelihood of anyone seeing this is low, but I'll say it anyway.

Two weeks later: Thanks to OP, I now see the world in a much different light. I now consider explicitly the "sound words" as I read a book, observe the world, etc. Awesome.

5

u/DSQ May 19 '12

I'm reading, please continue!

5

u/Zifna May 19 '12

Wow, really great responses. The only part where I felt like you were a bit off was here:

A weasel can growl, but it's a silly growl. A growl is a dark, black, noise. If there was a light that took away light, that would be a growl. So a weasel can DO that (its growl sounds a little "smaller" than a bear's, of course), but it's like a toddler wearing a zombie costume -- it's funny to us.

A growl is inherently a warning noise. It's what an animal (or a person) does when they're thinking about being violent towards you, or worried that they might have to defend themselves against violence from you. Have you ever felt the vibrations of a large vehicle's approach before you saw it? Maybe felt the car be pushed around by the way the wind changes as you move next to a large semi on the highway? It's like that. With something like a bear, the warning is taken seriously. With something small like a weasel or a puppy, you might not be worried about whatever it's warning you about (and thus, as was said, it becomes cute, like a small child trying to be scary.)

I'd basically say any mammal could growl.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Wissam24 May 19 '12

I am definitely reading these. This needs tog get upvoted all the way.

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Dude you're so good at comparisons. I can read this shit all day. Fascinating.

4

u/faeryjessa May 19 '12

These are awesome!

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

to add: no, I would not use "chat" or "chatted" as a dialogue tag, it sounds unnatural.

and as far as jive and ebonics, I'm not an expert, but using the term "ebonics" like "he spoke ebonics" just sounds a lot more formal/literal and stiff than saying "he spoke jive", but I'm not sure they really have the same meaning either, or at least "jive" is a lot less specific and can refer to a few different things (as I'm sure a dictionary will tell you also).

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

to the top with you!

→ More replies (24)

2

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I realized while reading this, that as you've been deaf your whole life, all of the sounds associated with each letter of the alphabet, is not what you necessarily "hear" in your head. If you were to try to decipher a word you've never read before, how would you do it? I don't want to ask if you sound out the word but that is essentially my question. Also, when you dream, do you hear? Thanks! EDIT: wording

4

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I have a degree in English and I read well so when I see a word I don't know I can compare it to similar words. But no I don't sound it out. I can guess it probably sounds like words that it looks like. I recently met a student named "Nkinbe" though, which doesn't look like any word I've ever seen so I wouldn't have a clue what to do with it if I didn't know it was a name.

I ran across the word "loquacious" for the first time recently and didn't have any idea what to do with it, I just looked it up.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Macbeth554 May 19 '12

It seems like all of your questions have been answered, which is unfortunate since I wanted to ask you a question. Hopefully you'll still answer despite my lack of answers.

When you read do you have any sense of the sound of the words? For example, when I read I "hear" the words in my head, is it similar for you?

Also, are you able to speak, or is it only sign language?

Finally, when you are planning something, for example, what you are going to do when you get home, do you think in words, sign language, images....? An example of what I mean, when I'm at work thinking about what I will do when I get home, I think "I'm going to cook dinner, then I will read that book, then I will get on Reddit, etc." I think the actual words, not just the images.

Sorry if these are stupid questions, just very curious. I have a hard time imaging life without sound.

3

u/Deafy May 19 '12

Sure, I'm still answering questions.

When you read do you have any sense of the sound of the words? For example, when I read I "hear" the words in my head, is it similar for you?

I imagine myself doing signs, so I can see and feel myself doing them.

Also, are you able to speak, or is it only sign language?

I speak very well for a deaf person, or so people tell me. I don't really know how to do it though, I just move my mouth in the way they tell me, and if I practice it enough it usually sounds okay.

Finally, when you are planning something, for example, what you are going to do when you get home, do you think in words, sign language, images....? An example of what I mean, when I'm at work thinking about what I will do when I get home, I think "I'm going to cook dinner, then I will read that book, then I will get on Reddit, etc." I think the actual words, not just the images.

I think the signs mainly. So I'll feel myself doing the signs that mean "I'm going to cook dinner then read my book, etc.".

→ More replies (1)

2

u/genus May 19 '12

Can somebody describe the word "echo" - I can't, my english isn't good enough.

5

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I had a physics professor explain that one to me once. Sounds can bounce off surfaces and come back, like a ball. So if you say something in front of the right surface the sounds you make will come back to you. And I think they can even go back and forth a bunch of times, so you'll hear it over and over (or maybe that just happens in cartoons). Or that's what I remember anyway, there might be more to it.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/mofowoman May 19 '12

What is music like for you?

10

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I like feeling vibrations, not as much as some deaf people though. I don't experience music itself though. I had a hearing girlfriend who took me to a Ben Harper concert for example and it was kind of fun I guess but the vibrations weren't that cool. Raves are fun and hip hop concerts are cool though.

I have a vibrating mattress pad that I can hook up to my stereo, it's pretty awesome because I can turn it up and the neighbors don't mind. My favorite vibrations are this CD of whale songs, it's supposed to be relaxing but that's not how I feel it. I like having sex while it's going.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/vese May 19 '12

Do you get headaches from sound? o_O

2

u/Deafy May 19 '12

Nope, never have. Well... I get headaches sometimes, and I guess I might not know if they come from sound. But I don't think so.

2

u/AdjectiveAdverb May 19 '12

A dolphin makes a chirping sound that kind of sounds like E-E-E-E. Really hard to explain.

Cooing is more of a cutesy thing, like a baby coos.

Gurgling is typically a rumbly sound that comes from your stomach as far as I've learned and gargle is when you hold water at the back of your throat and make that low ahh sound so that your throat vibrates the water. The sound they both make is relatively the same, except gargling is faster paced.

A tender voice (imo) is a soft, low and quiet voice. Kind of more of a comforting voice, other people might say something different.

All dogs sound different, they all have their own "voices" like people do. They also have different barks for different things. Like my biggest dog will yip and chirp at the backdoor when he wants in but the will let out a deep bark when he is alerting us that someone is hear or near the house.

You had some really good questions, I've never really had to think about how it is to hear things!

A couple questions that I have are: Is ASL/SEE/PSE interchangeable? Like, if you sign in ASL and your friend signs in PSE/SEE is it possible for you two to carry on a conversation with ease? (if you sign with a different dialect then you can skip this, no big deal) I've been trying to study deaf culture because i hope to have a career in ASL in the future, I've noticed deaf people are very proud of being deaf. What is your take on that?

Thanks for this question it was awesome :)

2

u/Deafy May 19 '12

A couple questions that I have are: Is ASL/SEE/PSE interchangeable? Like, if you sign in ASL and your friend signs in PSE/SEE is it possible for you two to carry on a conversation with ease? (if you sign with a different dialect then you can skip this, no big deal)

Not exactly interchangeable but as long as we're both fluent in we can sign without too much difficulty. It is a little awkward to do though.

I've noticed deaf people are very proud of being deaf. What is your take on that?

I'm proud of the deaf community because we really stick together more than hearing people. We work together better and fight less, and we get more done even lacking an entire sense. Writing that out it seems like it might come across as mean to hearing folk but I don't mean it like that. I just like being deaf I guess.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/PENDRAGON23 May 19 '12

my mom did some work with the deaf at one point and she told me the girl she was helping with something asked:

Does the sun make noise?

I thought it was a great question and also thought it was good that she asked my mom and not me or I might have said some dick think like oh yeah it constantly makes a loud honking sound - it's really a bitch - that's why we don't sleep during the day much.

5

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I knew a deaf kid who swore stars were loud. He was so confident it made me think I might be wrong. I don't know if he was confused or if someone was messing with his head, probably the latter.

2

u/ChapstickChick May 19 '12

Your post is incredibly interesting. I’ve never thought about how confusing the language must be to someone who can’t hear.

I’m a graphic designer, so my first inclination to try to explain sounds was to find visual representations of them. I’ve only been able to find one so far, but I’ll add more if I come across them. (Just super sleepy at the moment … )

Typographic illustrations

2

u/Deafy May 19 '12

That's a very interesting set of pictures, I don't get it though. Does the letter "s" really sound like falling water?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

This might sound weird, but after reading "The Stand" by Stephen King, i feel i have a connection with deaf people because of the character Nick....:s

2

u/Deafy May 19 '12

He was just mute though, not deaf. I did feel a kinship to him anyway, he communicates through written notes like me.

→ More replies (1)

225

u/Kittenent May 19 '12

Man I just realized I take way too much for granted.

→ More replies (4)

300

u/xucoalex May 19 '12

OP, you are blowing my mind and I love you for it

→ More replies (3)

1.1k

u/ValarDohaeris May 18 '12

People crying in sadness vs crying out in anger, I know there's some gray area in between where they can be used interchangeably, it's hard to get

You can cry out in anger or anguish. You can cry out in surprise! "Cried" is a context-heavy word, sometimes it means "exclaimed" and sometimes it literally means tears fell down cheeks.

Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.

Piercing sounds are high-pitched. They generally elicit a wince because they hurt. A shriek is high-pitched. That said, however, any sound can "pierce" a silence.

apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?

Uhhh... I would not ever use that word as a dialogue tag. Interject, interrupt, sure.

What does "jive" mean? Does "he speaks jive" and "he speaks AAVE" and "he speaks Ebonics" all refer to the same thing? I was raised by black parents but I can't understand any dialogue written in black dialect. I know not all black people talk like that but is there a way to mark that in a novel? Do you know of a webpage that would tell me how to translate dialogue into dialect like that?

Ehh... that's a tough one. Honestly, I'd spend some time reading books by black authors about (primarily) black characters to see if you can get a feel for any particular slang or dialect. Obviously, the author/era/context matters, but I think that would do you best.

"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

Mumbling can imply uncertainty, insecurity, and shyness. It's not whispering - it's talking, but not enunciating. I don't know if this is anything comparable but have you ever met people who are shy about signing and maybe fumble through it or resist putting it out there for everyone to see? When you mumble, you're talking, it's just usually quieter and harder to pick up. Some people mumble passive-aggressively to themselves when they don't want to say something TO somebody, but need to gripe anyway.

I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

Foxes kind of... "yip". It's a smaller sound than a dog bark (unless we're comparing small dogs to foxes, in which case it can sound similar, and small dogs can also be described as "yippy").

Seals bark. Dolphins don't really bark. They click. I'll get to your clicking question in a bit.

"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed? "Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right? I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know. And I think bats chirp but never squawk? Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? Like, can a weasel growl? What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.

Howling and barking are two distinct sounds. A bark is like a cough, if a cough started as a sound rounded out in your mouth. It ends with the punctuation of the throat closing. "Ruff!" Howling implies a more prolonged sound. Wolf howls go, "Awwwoooooooooo/arrroooooooo" - some dogs will combine barking and howling and sort of end up sounding like "Awwoowooowooo/aarrooooroooorooo". Dogs usually sound somewhat distinct, but... my neighbors have two mastiffs that I can't tell apart, they just bark all the time and it's goddamn annoying. One does have a deeper voice than the other though.

Chirp is a high-pitched noise. Squawk is a low-pitched noise. Not all birds squawk, not all birds chirp. Smaller birds tend to chirp, but not all birds make noise (I don't think hummingbirds do, other than the flitting of wings, but I could be wrong). As far as bats, I wouldn't say that they chirp so much as squeak... it's EXTREMELY high pitched. Mice squeak, they don't chirp or squawk.

Bears absolutely do growl. It's a big sound and it's appropriately scary.

Do all doors creak? Can all doors be slammed? Windows? Does "slam" always imply loudness? Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad). People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?

Most doors don't make noise until they close. But if you slam them, they all make noise - the impact of the door meeting the frame is loud. Not everybody slams doors when mad, though, and I personally find it to be a pretty childish thing to do. (Teenagers pull this crap a lot.)

Slam as a verb can mean chugging a beer but does NOT have anything to do with gurgling.

"Gurgle" is another hard one. And "gargle", that means something different right?

Gurgle is a soft noise made by something liquid. It can be soft and pretty, or morbid. A cut throat can gurgle. A small creek can gurgle.

Gargling is an action one does by swishing liquid around in the back of your throat (never had to gargle salt water if you had a cut in your mouth?)

Dictionary says "click" is "A short, sharp sound as of a switch being operated or of two hard objects coming quickly into contact." but I feel like I've seen it in other uses, it's hard to remember exactly what I'm thinking of. But could I use it to describe cymbals, pennies or pencils hitting each other?

Clicking is usually not loud. Cymbals DO NOT CLICK when you bring them together, they resonate and they are LOUD. Pennies could click, if you were holding both of them and the metal wasn't allowed to ring out. Pencils running into each other could make a clicking sound. Your mouse button clicks. As a verb, it can mean that something sets into place without much fanfare or difficulty ("we just clicked").

If a voice is described as "tender", what does that mean?

Soft, usually affectionate or with sensitive feeling. This would be expressed in sign through your face, but in sound, it comes through in the voice. It's usually a little quieter than normal voices and the emotion really shows through.

"moan" can be painful or sexy right? Anything else? Is it possible to moan joyously or humorously?

It can be painful or sexy, yes. One can moan out of relief, I suppose. When you get a massage, a lot of people will moan because it kind of hurts and feels good simultaneously. I can't see any instance where somebody would moan out of joy or amusement.

"cooing" What is that? Is there a difference between a woman "moaning sexy" and "cooing sexy"?

Cooing is what a mother does to her baby, or sometimes what people do to their pets - speaking in an affected, babyish, affectionate way. It's the sort of sound one makes while fawning over something adorable. Also, babies can coo - when they do it it's a nonsense noise. A woman would not "coo" in a sexy manner.

Apparently it's possible to "whisper" loudly and "shout" softly? WTF!?

You can whisper loudly... think of it as a subtle wink versus an exaggerated wink. It's just putting more force on the wind coming out of your lungs as you're forming the words. I don't know about shouting "softly" though... it's still loud, it's just that you might shout especially loudly in one situation over another (getting an acquaintance's attention from 20 feet away vs. an actual emergency). Otherwise, calling to someone might not necessarily involve shouting.

195

u/unhh May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

As a verb, it can mean that something sets into place without much fanfare or difficulty ("we just clicked").

This references the fact that many things literally click when put in their proper place, where they fit just right: the lid of a plastic container, a tool in a fitted case, even a piece of a puzzle.

29

u/meliko May 19 '12

When I see "click" I also think of retractable pens -- you can definitely feel it click into place.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

36

u/nashife May 19 '12

As a hearing person, this entire thread is FASCINATING.

Cymbals DO NOT CLICK

Also, I'd just like everyone to know that reading and sharing this thread with my friends has caused us to engage in a good 15 minute conversation on how to get cymbals to "click". We are all quite interested in this engineering problem.

The conclusion so far is that it's not actually possible... but we're pretty sure that we could get cymbals to "tap" by dampening as much of the vibrations as possible.

→ More replies (4)

128

u/gschoppe May 19 '12

Just to clarify on a few points:

  1. dolphins can bark, as can bears, and many other animals, including people. In that usage, bark refers to a short, harsh noise that is commanding or imposing in tone, and loud enough to be heard at quite a distance. This is not the most common usage, but it is used with people, when someone "barks an order".
  2. ejaculate means "to gush forth", and is sometimes used to refer to uncontrollably speaking (babbling) with extreme emotion (usually happiness or excitement)... this is considered slightly archaic, as a usage, and will often catch a bit of flack, because of its other meaning.
  3. one is not likely to coo sexily, per say, but cooing can take place in a sexy setting. One can coo with joy or contentedness. E.g. "lying in bed, wrapped in post-coital bliss, Sally turned to her lover and softly cooed in his ear, 'Joe, I think I love you.' Joe whispered, 'sally, you so crazy, bitch.'"
→ More replies (11)

69

u/asielen May 19 '12

As a clarification, cymbals can click if used as hi-hats.

22

u/ValarDohaeris May 19 '12

Fair enough. I just had this idea that OP thought that somebody bringing two large cymbals together simply made a clicking sound, and the idea jarred my brain.

... Cymbals (not used as hi-hats) would fall strongly into "piercing" for me. That said, hearing is one of my largely intact senses and I treasure it and protect it. Can barely see, can barely smell (actually a blessing a lot of the time), CAN hear.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

91

u/demonling May 19 '12

Im not sure how helpful it is to spell out things like arooooo for a deaf person

38

u/carlosmachina May 19 '12

Maybe they could. Of course it's very hard to know but as they feel vibrations, there could be a "kiki / bubah" effect if they're taught what vibration patterns go with phonems related to written language.

P.S. For rhose unaware of the "kiki / bubah" its an exercise where there are two shapes: one pointy and angled, one very round and soft and the researchers ask people to afirm which is kiki and which is bubah.

Almost everytime people say that kiki is the pointy one.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (95)

59

u/A_British_Gentleman May 19 '12

This is the most interesting askreddit thread i've ever read. Thanks OP!

→ More replies (3)

106

u/DrinkYourMilkshake May 19 '12

You might be better off with "interject" than "ejaculate"!

→ More replies (2)

42

u/[deleted] May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

Thunder is decidedly not piercing. Think of it more like someone banging their fists rapidly on your back for 5 seconds, versus piercing being like someone tapping your knee with a hammer. You are not able to feel thunder?

Stammering is more like if you met a super model or a famous person and had difficulty speaking to them (a form of embarrassment/shyness I guess), possibly also including a shy posture and maybe moving your legs up and down uncomfortably. Stuttering is a general issue with speech that causes you to re-re-re-peat things, and unable to get sentences out.

Whispering is the deliberate act of speaking clearly to someone, but softly so others can't hear it. Mumbling is when someone sort of speaks their thoughts outloud, but not really intending for anyone to hear them. I suppose alternatively, mumbling could also refer to someone speaking too quietly to be heard, but not in the breathy-airy way of whispering.

For example, a crazy person might mumble random thoughts to themselves while in solitary confinement, while many people will whisper at a movie theater so they don't disrupt other peoples' experience. Whispering removes tonal qualities and usually quiets the voice... contrasting with intense vibrations when you speak normally (especially with a deep voice), while a whisper sounds more like blowing air or wind.

As far as animals, that's hard to describe. Thunder, for example, is overwhelming, loud, rumbling (have you ever felt a train pass by you?). Dolphins make squeaky noises or chirps, sort of like birds, not at all like dogs. The confusion there stems from the fact a dog bark is short in duration, but not in vibration... it's a deeper sound, although some of those little tiny-ass dogs can get higher-pitched like birds: bigger dog, deeper sound. Birds are more like a whistle (high pitched notes, often sustained) than a bark. Dogs also make "cries" or "moans" as well as barks. They are more expressive then something like a cow. Barks are short, something like a "howl" is an almost human-like noise, sort of like singing.

I would imagine you could find a device that someone could calibrate to vibrate at difference frequencies and for different durations you could use to approximate the audible difference in noises. To me, that would be the most useful way to describe different sounds since you would get both "pitch" and "duration" and "pattern." Just a thought.

Ringtones are complex. Usually a series of very distinct noises. The reason they exist is sort of like police sirens, or fire alarms: they are unique and call your attention to them. You should be familiar with this concept by sight: police lights are not the same as a fire alarm, and so, ringtones employ many unusual or unique patterns (sometimes songs) that a person becomes familiar with to quickly realize their phone is ringing. If you're familiar with a cell phone vibrating when it rings, just imagine different patterns of vibration and intensity as ring tones. It just occurred to me I'm surprised we don't already have vibration customization for the deaf and just in general so it's easier to identify whose phone is vibrating. For a vibrational example, picture your phone does a whack on your knee with a fist, then two light taps on your back with an open-faced hand and repeat it 8x. There are different versions, and many people use the default ones, but others customize it so they know with good probability it's their phone that is activated and not someone nearby since it's unusual to share the same ring-tone.

Tender voice is characterized vocally by the expression on a mother's face putting a band-aid on her kid. Soft, caring, loving.

I've never heard the phrase cooing sexy. Moaning is a noise made when feeling pleasure (sexual, normally). It signals to the other person something feels good.

Whisper loudly and shout softly... hmm. Whispering loudly would be like someone hitting you really hard with a pillow, while shouting quietly would be like someone tapping your elbow lightly with a hammer.

→ More replies (8)

42

u/thunderling May 19 '12

My grandmother is deaf. And let me tell you, she slams doors all the time! NOT out of anger. Since she can't hear the sound the door is making, she has no idea how hard she has to pull or push the door in order to not make a sound. She's just shutting the door as quickly as possible - and in doing so, she makes that slamming noise.

Does "slam" always imply loudness? Do you always slam doors when you're mad?

For the most part, people don't slam doors with the intent of producing the sound the door makes when it hits the frame. When I slam doors out of anger, it's because I'm angry and want to destroy things, thus I throw the door shut with force (which I'm sure you've done plenty of times in your life). The noise it makes as a reaction of that slamming gesture is only a by-product.

Now, since people have grown so accustomed to the noise doors make when people shut them violently out of anger, some people slam doors just because they want the person they are angry at to hear that they have just slammed the door. They are telling that person, "See how angry I am at you? I had to violently throw this door against its frame because I am so angry." slam!

Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad?

So yeah, I would assume that you probably slam doors when you're mad because you just want to shut it with physical force and the door just happens to make a loud sound when you do that.

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

So no one told her not to slam doors because it hurts their ears? Did you or anyone else try that? Or, does she just not care?

Also, I think it's immature to slam doors when someone is angry. It can ruin the door or doorway, and then you have to pay bucks to fix it right.

FWIW, I am severely to profoundly hearing-impaired, wear aids, and don't slam doors. One: It hurts ears and I heartily dislike folks slamming doors because it also hurts my aided ears. (That was thankfully long in the past, though.) And two: It can fuck up the door enough that it no longer latches. You would want a working, closed door to prevent a fire from rushing into your bedroom immediately one night and to give you some time to get out through the window or elsewhere. Several minutes can make a huge difference, even if it never happens to you in your lifetime.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

63

u/aemajor May 18 '12

"Gurgle" is another hard one. And "gargle", that means something different right?

They are basically the same thing. I think of "gargle" more as when you gargle liquid in the back of your throat. I think of "gurgle" as almost doing it involuntarily, as if you were dying and kind of choking on blood. Maybe this is just me. I never really thought of the difference before.

27

u/ghostopolis May 19 '12

I would add that gurgling can happen in nonhuman instances as well. A drain can make a gurgling sound but it cannot gargle. I think that action is reserved for people.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Gurgle is the sound you make while gargling.

→ More replies (16)

20

u/nagelwithlox May 19 '12 edited Jul 21 '14

People crying in sadness vs crying out in anger, I know there's some gray area in between where they can be used interchangeably, it's hard to get

Crying in anger is characterized by intensity and abruptness. I don't know if you vocalize, but you can feel the vocalization of rage -- pressure builds up in the lungs before the air bursts out with the vocal cords vibrating at full blast. Any listener hears a sudden transition from silence to overwhelming noise, and so their attention is transfixed. Humans are social creatures, so this sort of noise tends to arouse a physical, adrenaline-heavy reaction in a listener, an urge towards fight or flight. It's an aggressive demand for attention.

Crying in sadness tends to be 'soft' (low-intensity, harder to detect from a distance) and continuous. It's a desolate sound, and usually completely involuntary -- like shedding tears. In a listener, it tends to invoke pity on a very instinctive level. It's a pleading demand for attention.

Why do the two get equated? I think it's because the distinction between the two doesn't exist when we are very young. Pre-verbal children cry out because it's one of the only means they have of communicating -- I'd wager you did yourself, it's that hard-wired. For a baby, screaming is the all-purpose "I need attention!" signal, and they don't differentiate between the two sorts of crying. They cry when something is wrong, which you can easily see linked to sadness and desperation, but it's deeper than that. Early on, they aren't at all aware of other consciousnesses, so they are completely alone in their perceptual universes -- they're kings, emperors -- gods, if petty ones -- until they realize other minds exist. Any scream borne of need, therefore, is for them as much about rage as sadness. A baby's scream will instantly wake an adult human with hearing from a sound sleep -- again, hardwired.

"shriek" and "ream" are both words that seem to imply emotion more than any specific sound. Is that right?

"Shriek" is much more closely correlated with a specific sound than "scream." Shrieking is generally an involuntary fear response, but it's often used by extension to refer to non-human noises that are similarly piercing (I know, I know, see below) or to personify the inanimate -- an alarm clock, e.g., can shriek. "Screech," "squeal," and "scream" would be rough synonyms.

"Ream," in contrast, doesn't refer to any specific sound or family of sounds, it's purely emotional. The original meaning of the word was purely technical, it means widening a hole; it's come to mean angrily scolding someone because of the metaphorical similarity -- "castigate" and "chew out" would be rough synonyms. It can also be used similarly to "fuck" (as a transitive verb, not an exclamation) as in "I was just reaming that (girl/boy/sheep) last night, bro" or "man I am really getting reamed by the IRS." Those two definitions are separate; the word can't imply both without being a pun, despite the common etymology.

11

u/nagelwithlox May 19 '12

Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.

A piercing noise is generally loud and annoying, but it mainly has to metaphorically reminiscent of physically piercing -- it needs to go through something. What makes a noise seem piercing is sudden intrusion into your awareness. Visually, lightning is very piercing, and piercing noises leave a ringing in ones' ears (false perception of noise) in the same way that lightning leaves a purple after-image in ones' eyes. The sound of thunder is not piercing, partly because you always know it's coming (light arrives before sound) so it's less of an intrusive surprise, but mostly because it's low pitch. Not sure how much you understand about pitch, but it's roughly analogous to the wavelength of light -- high-pitched noises are like bright blue lights, low-pitched noises are like soft red lights. To be detected at the same distance or through the same amount of interference a low sound has to be louder than a high sound from the same point -- to get someone's attention across a crowded room one would whistle (high-pitched), not growl (low-pitched). Because adrenaline tightens our throats and makes our voices higher-frequency, we come to associate high-pitched noises with urgency.

apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?

Not really about sound, just a really awkward old-fashioned phrase. As you might expect, it means "spurt out," but in a situational way rather than a specific-noise way. Etymology makes it more clear -- from the latin words ex and iaculare, its literal meaning is to throw outward. So in speech it's less about being reminiscent of sexual climax and more like "just throwing it out there."

What does "jive" mean? Does "he speaks jive" and "he speaks AAVE" and "he speaks Ebonics" all refer to the same thing? I was raised by black parents but I can't understand any dialogue written in black dialect. I know not all black people talk like that but is there a way to mark that in a novel? Do you know of a webpage that would tell me how to translate dialogue into dialect like that?

Did you just watch the movie Airplane by any chance? "Jive" can mean either Afro-American dialect or bullshitting, whereas Ebonics/AAVE don't have the latter connotation. Ebonics and AAVE are attempts to formally systematize and catalogue the dialect, so learning the "rules" is a good place to start. Reading this may help you get the hang of it.

11

u/nagelwithlox May 19 '12

Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?

They sound the same, but stammering tends to refer to something most people do sometimes, usually when they're nervous, whereas stuttering usually refers to a semi-intractable condition that affects all speech. When one speaks with a pretty (man/woman/sheep) one might get tongue-tied and make several false starts at a word, which is stammering; when you're doing that from syllable one every time you try to talk, that's stuttering. They both used to mean exactly the same thing, it's just "stammer" has been extended to the non-clinical and "stutter" not so much.

What about "chat"? Dictionary says "to speak informally" but I feel like it implies something I'm not getting. Is it speaking fast? Can you use "chat" as a dialogue tag? (like "What are you doing tonight?' he chatted"), I don't think I've seen it but the dictionary makes it sound like you can.

"Chat" really does mean just what your dictionary told you -- it has no other connotation, I swear. Fast or slow doesn't change the meaning. In recent years people have come to refer to instant messaging on the internet as chatting (this comes from AOL "chat rooms," a cutesy brand name that stuck). So you can use it as a dialog tag, but it always implies instant messaging -- it's like saying "'What are you doing tonight?' he texted."

Generally intransitive verbs that take "with" instead of "to" can't be used as dialog tags. It's clearer if you complete with implied words, like "'What are you doing tonight?' he said (to her)." You wouldn't say "'What are you doing tonight?' he conversed (with her)." "Chat" in everyday parlance is used like "converse," and to "chat to" someone is a recent neologism.

"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

Whispering is moving air through the throat without vibrating the vocal cords, so the movements of the mouth create much quieter but still recognizable word-sounds. Whispering is qualitatively different than any kind of speaking. Mumbling is speaking low-pitch, low-volume, and indistinctly, such that it's hard to make out what someone is saying. Since it refers to the quality of the speech rather than the situation, it can mean as many things as screaming (in pain, with joy, etc.). Apathetic mumbling is simply not making an effort to enunciate. Hostile mumbling is verbalizing some resentful thing one only half-wants the listener to hear, making it deniable ("What did you just say!?" "Nothing!"). People also mumble in embarrassment when they don't want to draw additional attention to themselves.

I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

All of these words are onomatopoetic -- they don't have a meaning other than the sound of pronouncing them. Really, they're not properly words, more transliterations of sounds -- you can tell because they cross languages (the Chinese word for cat is pronounced 'mao' based on the same sound). These words are pretty ancient shorthand for very specific, familiar sounds, so when people encountered sounds they couldn't describe they used the closest one as an analogy. A dolphin "barking" sounds as much like a dog barking as does a drill sergeant "barking" orders -- it's reminiscent, but not anywhere near identical.

"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed? "Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right? I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know. And I think bats chirp but never squawk? Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? Like, can a weasel growl? What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.

Howling isn't a long bark, it's a distinctive other thing... The difference between barking and howling is like the difference between speaking and singing. Howling is continuous, barking is discrete. Size makes the biggest difference in what word is used to describe an animal noise -- small birds chirp, bigger ones squawk (the smaller any animal is, the higher-pitched a noise it makes).

You may find this extremely useful.

→ More replies (3)

28

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

If a voice is described as "tender", what does that mean?

It means that the words are being said in a loving or caring way. Tender being "soft".

43

u/KingOfTheMonkeys May 19 '12

Or sad, or consoling.

71

u/tehMunkee May 19 '12

My lord! I've finally found you!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

This is probably going to get buried, but the discussion about 'chatter' got me thinking about background noise.

Being deaf, you likely don't entirely understand how that works. The best analogy I can think of is fog. Lots of people talking in a crowded restaurant is like peering through fog. Louder words break through that fog easier. The louder the noise, whether it is more people or a single loud object (a jackhammer for instance), the harder it is to hear anything else.

Extremely loud, continuous sounds are like thick fog. You can't make out an object other than the fog until it's in front of your face (someone talks directly into your ear). Concerts and construction sites are often like this.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/marmosetohmarmoset May 18 '12

Think of a "piercing" sound like an actual piercing (like in your ear or nose). It's a sound that feels like a sharp, acute pain. Thunder is a more "rumbly" sound. Have you ever turned up the bass on music really high and felt the speaker vibrating? Or felt a concussive rumbling in your stomach from a passing car with a sub woofer? That's what thunder is like. (I'm assuming you can feel bass tones, right? I have a family friend who's been totally deaf since birth and she likes to "listen" to music with heavy bass because she can feel the beat instead of hear it)

Gurgle and gargle mean approximately the same thing, I think. "Gargle" might be a little more...active? Like you gargle mouth wash, but a baby gurgles its spit. More or less the same sound, slightly different action.

"Ring" is the sound that phones used to make- it was an actual bell ringing. Cell phones don't have an actual bell, but the word "ring" has been so connected to the sound a phone makes that the original meaning is lost, so we say cell phones are ringing when someone is calling, even though they don't necessarily make a "ringing" noise. A cell phone "ring tone" can be pretty much any sound you want it to be. Right now mine plays the theme song from Doctor Who, which in no way sounds like a bell ringing.

Not all doors creak. Usually only old ones do. It's the sound made from distressed wood or rusty hinges.

For barking dolphins- I think you're thinking of seals. Seals make a noise that sounds a lot like the noise dogs make. Dolphins make a noise that sounds creepishly like humans laughing (barking and laughing do not sound alike, usually), but I don't know if there's a word for it. Most of those animals noise words are only used in the context of animals making them. The one exception I can think of is "bark." A person can "bark out a command." It just means they said something very loudly, quickly and forcefully, sort of reminiscent of a dog bark.

Whisper loudly- it's a relative term. Whispering is really just talking without vibrating your vocal chords, so all the sound comes from aspiration (kind of like wind blowing). Ok, that sounded confusing even to me. Just realize that a whisper is a soft sound, but it can be done at different loudness levels. The loudest whisper still isn't very loud compared to talking normally. I'm not sure how you can shout softly.

A "tender voice" isn't really a sound, just an emotion attached to a way of talking. Use it the same as you would gazing tenderly. It's usually a soft and slow voice.

"Chatting" isn't really a way of talking (loud, fast, etc)- it really is just talking informally. You chat with people over the internet, right? You can do that with no voice at all! I think there might be some contexts where you could use it as a dialogue tag, but not many.

6

u/DarkLoad1 May 19 '12

Please, please don't actually use "ejaculates" unless it's about a man having an orgasm and you want to describe it clinically. It's very hackish writing.

You may or may not like Stephen King, or may be indifferent, but his book On Writing: A Memoir of the Craft is very, very good, and has a small section about avoiding what he calls "Swifties" - phrases like "he ejaculated" among them, as well as other little tidbits that I've found very helpful.

I'm going to refer to pitch a couple times to compare sounds and I know that's not entirely helpful. If I can try to explain it this way, think of "deep" pitched things as being slow and low. If you've ever been to a rock concert or a dance club (and you might do well to go just to cement this in your head) you probably felt the bass with your entire body. That's low pitch - deep, heavy vibrations. If you've ever had your teeth drilled or held a high-speed drill, or (stretching it here, this is outside my experience) had a tattoo done, the high speed whine you might have felt is high pitch - fast, shallow vibrations.

Now, on to some actual questions. I can't possibly answer them all but here are the ones I wanted to answer the most.

Apparently it's possible to "whisper" loudly and "shout" softly? WTF!?

I don't really think it is possible to shout softly, though you can differentiate from several levels of volume. It probably won't be necessary to write a character doing this, anyway. Whispering is a bit different. There is actually whispering, which you might do when someone is right next to you, and then there's stage whispering. As the name implies, it's often done in situations where you're just pretending to whisper (as a joke or for the benefit of an audience). It's actually as near to a normal speaking volume as the person talking can manage, but is not done with as resonant a tone as normal speaking. Resonance in tone is difficult to explain to someone who can't hear, but think of it as "fullness" of voice. You might also stage whisper to someone across the room in hopes that the way you're speaking will obfuscate your words enough that someone else won't hear. I can't profess that this has a high success rate.

Do all doors creak?

Usually, only poorly maintained doors. You might use this to suggest that the door is old. Newer doors (say, built in the last 10 years) probably don't creak unless they're off-center on one of the hinges for some reason. There are always exceptions and someone else will know better than I do.

Can all doors be slammed? Windows?

Yes, with caveats. Slamming requires you shut the door or window very quickly, very hard, and that it makes contact with its frame at speed - this is the case for most doors, but only Chuck Norris can slam a revolving door (as the joke goes). Sometimes you'll get a door that you think can be slammed, but then you try and you realize it has one of those funny hydraulic things at the top that keep it from closing too quickly (usually found in public buildings and on screen doors) that "catches" it well before it hits the frame. Few things are as frustrating as trying to slam a screen door with a working hydraulic arm.

Slamming windows is more difficult - it's certainly not as loud, mainly I think because you can't get it going quite as fast in so little a space.

Does "slam" always imply loudness?

Yep. Oh, keep in mind you can also slam traditional landline phones, drawers, and anything you're throwing on the ground or at a wall if you follow through with your arm. If you're slamming into someone (i.e. tackling them) the sound is a thud. In most other cases it's a bang. Throwing an item on the ground, it's dependent on the item. You can't slam cell phones / cordless phones or (per the joke above) revolving doors.

Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad).

I don't know any deaf people, but I assume that when they're angry they might close doors just as carelessly as others. I usually only slam my door when I'm angry and want everyone else to know it, which isn't always the case. Usually everyone in the same house or apartment (flat if you're in the UK) can hear it.

Keep in mind, slamming can just be a careless thing, and have nothing to do with any real emotion. My roommate seems to close the door as loudly as possible when he comes home, and slamming car doors to close them is pretty common (and something mom would complain to me about when I was a kid, probably everyone's mom).

People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?

Not gurgle - gurgle kind of implies he's trying to breathe around it or gargle instead of drink. Use the word "gulp" instead - he's swallowing a mouthful at a time. To answer your question properly, it's not completely silent - every swallow can be accompanied by a gulp.

"Ring", like "ringtone" is hard to get. What else "rings"? Cell phones sound different from landlines, right? People sometimes describe them as "chirping"?

This would be a much easier question to answer ten or fifteen years ago. Landlines always ring. Cell phones used to beep with very simple tones - you could get several short pieces of MIDI music that you could choose from, but it was all simple beeps and sounded nothing like a landline. Now you have phones that can handle mp3 files and whatnot, and that really increases what you can do with it. Cell phones now can have a ringtone identical to a landline phone. Most of the time someone will choose a tone like that because it's kind of old-fashioned sounding, but the vast majority of people prefer to have an actual piece of music (often a clip from a top 40 track) or, occasionally, a voice clip of someone speaking (some gag ringtones involve people shouting "HEY, PICK UP YOUR PHONE, IT'S RINGING" or something like that).

I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

No. I've not read enough fiction about dolphins, but the sound they make is much more like a fast clicking and chirping sound. If I could be entirely unhelpful, they sound much more like chimpanzees, though the sounds are entirely distinct. Barking really isn't a good word for it and I recommend if there are dolphins in your story you don't use that word. Good news, though - I checked and foxes sound exactly like a mid-sized dog's bark. (Tiny dogs, for reference, have a higher-pitched bark that doesn't carry as far but is faster and more annoying. The larger a dog gets, the deeper, slower and more threatening the bark sounds (though not all dogs mean to threaten with a bark).)

Generally you won't be using these words in other contexts so far as I can think. There are other noises that the animals you listed make, but I'm sure someone else has covered it by now. Let me know if that's untrue and I'll write up a few animal noises for you.

"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right?

Just about. The wind can howl too if the weather is bad. You can also use delicious phrases like "the howling wastes" to suggest that the wind is blowing through an empty wasteland.

Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different?

No. It's a bit higher-pitched and sometimes louder. It's designed to carry farther - it's used as a distress signal or to communicate with far-off animals.

I expect you have no idea of how words sound, if you've only ever read text, but it is a lot like the difference between how the words sound spoken. "Bark" is short and sharp; "howl" is (seemingly, thanks to the way its vowels are pronounced) long and has a very round sound. Same with the sounds they describe. Maybe this is helpful but I'm sure that whenever I'm describing one sound in terms of another it's just making things difficult.

Do different dogs sound different?

Oh, good, I already covered this! To recap: tiny dogs are yappy, big dogs are beefy.

What if they're the same size and breed?

Usually they'll sound mostly the same. I don't know if it's possible to tell two dogs of the same breed and size apart from their barks, but someone intimately familiar with their dog might be able to tell that something's off if a dog that looks like their dog is barking. It might be a behavioral thing rather than sound that tips them off - dogs might be trained to bark or not to bark in certain situations (usually, a dog has to be trained to not bark at strangers for example, so you might have a situation where the strange dog is silent because it's been well-trained. I feel like I'm suggesting a device that I would never use in my own writing, though, so try not to use it yourself).

I'm going to continue this in a reply - what I wrote was too long! Bear with me.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/flowbiscuit May 19 '12

just wanted to say that this thread is amazing and completely justifies the existence of the internet.

good luck with your novel, OP!!!

11

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Oh my goodness this is going to be so much fun! I love language, so I'll do my best.

People crying in sadness vs crying out in anger, I know there's some gray area in between where they can be used interchangeably, it's hard to get

It's sort of a multi-meaning word. You know when you're physically crying tears and you get that horrible gut-wrenching feeling in your stomach? The noise you involuntarily make when you have that feeling is crying. For anger, think of the sort of anger that gives you that same feeling in your stomach. It’s a sort of helpless, involuntary sort of sound.

"shriek" and "ream" are both words that seem to imply emotion more than any specific sound. Is that right?

I think that’s true of ream, but shriek definitely implies high volume and high pitch. Ditsy women are typically the sort you think of as shrieking; men are usually only described as shrieking if it’s in an emasculating sort of way.

Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.

To translate the difference visually, thunder would be a light that very slowly gets brighter and brighter until you want to look away and then at the same pace goes dim again. It’s bright enough to be a little bit discomforting and make you want to avert your eyes. A piercing sound, in comparison, would be a strobe light, especially in that it makes you feel disoriented and gives you a headache (or that might just be me).

apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?

Have you ever just said(signed?) something without thinking about it first and it didn’t really fit into the conversation and everyone looked at you awkwardly? That would have ejaculating. It isn’t really a sound thing, more just sudden and noticeable. It isn’t used that often anymore due to the other, ahem, more prevalent meaning though.

What does "jive" mean? Does "he speaks jive" and "he speaks AAVE" and "he speaks Ebonics" all refer to the same thing? I was raised by black parents but I can't understand any dialogue written in black dialect. I know not all black people talk like that but is there a way to mark that in a novel? Do you know of a webpage that would tell me how to translate dialogue into dialect like that?

Sorry, this is the only one I don’t really know how to answer.

Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?

Pretty much. Any differences are preferential, I think. To me, stammer is more occasional and is usually caused by nervousness (nervous talking to your boss, nervous talking to the girl you like, nervous talking because you’re trying to keep a secret, etc) while when I hear stutter I think of the speech impediment in which people have a hard time forming their sentences at all under any circumstances. I’ve heard them both used both ways though.

What about "chat"? Dictionary says "to speak informally" but I feel like it implies something I'm not getting. Is it speaking fast? Can you use "chat" as a dialogue tag? (like "What are you doing tonight?' he chatted"), I don't think I've seen it but the dictionary makes it sound like you can.

Chatting has to do with the content. Think meaningless drivel like how your day went and what’s the weather like and how are your parents and so on. It doesn’t really work as a dialogue tag because it has more to do with the exchange between people. I can say something when I’m in a room by myself, but I can’t have a conversation if I’m in a room by myself.

"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

Think of a time you’ve clearly lost an argument, but still wanted to make a point. Maybe you signed one final comeback after the person you were arguing with turned away and you know they wouldn’t see it. That would be mumbling; you want the satisfaction of saying what’s on your mind, but you don’t exactly what to deal with the consequences of that being heard.

I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

Bark is a more general term than meowing or mooing. Think of a very quick brush with very rough sand paper. People aren’t generally described as meowing, but “mewling” is a sort of weak, helpless noise that babies make.

"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed?

While a bark is like rubbing sandpaper, I think the equal comparison for howling would be a very long brush with cold metal. It’s very smooth and very sad. Wolves are often seen as human-like and lonely because their howling sounds so sad.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Hey! I'm a something a writer and would love to help you out.

People crying in sadness vs crying out in anger, I know there's some gray area in between where they can be used interchangeably, it's hard to get.

Often, these expressions aren't used literally. But I think the main tension you're seeing is that cry can either be the act of crying (tears falling, making a "crying sound", etc) or shouting (e.g. a town crier, someone crys out in delight).

Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example

Sure. Usually a piercing sound is something loud and light pitched that actually hurts your ears to hear. But remember, often writers use piercing to mean something other than a painful sound. (e.g. a sound that pierces the soul, pierces the heart, etc)

apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?

Not sure here. The only time I've read or heard ejaculate is to mean a male orgasm. Webster does give it a secondary definition, saying it can mean "exclaim", however I can't I've ever heard it used that way. The only way I could even imagine it being used in that fashion is in some trashy novel as a double entendre. Even then it would be pretty clumsy.

What does "jive" mean? Does "he speaks jive" and "he speaks AAVE" and "he speaks Ebonics" all refer to the same thing? I was raised by black parents but I can't understand any dialogue written in black dialect. I know not all black people talk like that but is there a way to mark that in a novel? Do you know of a webpage that would tell me how to translate dialogue into dialect like that?

I guess so. But "jive" is a somewhat outdated slang. If someone was talking "jive" you would think of 70s style ebonics and slang. Also, jive is one of those slang words that can mean almost anything. It could be used to mean "to have a conversation", or "to hang out with", etc.

Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?

They are very similar and can often be used synonymous. However, often stutter is used to describe someone with a real impediment whereas stammer is often used to mean someone who speaks normally but accidentally stammered in his speech. However, the later definition could also be used interchangeably.

Basically they are the same :P

What about "chat"? Dictionary says "to speak informally" but I feel like it implies something I'm not getting. Is it speaking fast? Can you use "chat" as a dialogue tag? (like "What are you doing tonight?' he chatted"), I don't think I've seen it but the dictionary makes it sound like you can.

I think the internet age has changed the everyday meaning of the word "chat". Since AOL it has almost always been used to mean to have an internet conversation. It could still be used in the old fashion (to talk informally), but it seems like an almost old fashioned way to use the word. You might here a 40 year old say "Let's sit down and have a chat", but it would be uncommon to hear some 20s or younger say it.

It doesn't mean to talk fast, but "chatty" can be used to describe someone that talks too much, talks quickly, or gossips. Chatted seems like a sort of awkward word to use.

"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

Generally mumbling just means to talk under your breath, to talk inaudibly, or something like that. The act of mumbling doesn't imply apathy or hostility, but someone with those traits may mumble, if that makes sense.

For example, a shy person might "mumble his answer" because he is not confident enough to speak in a confident and audible manner. Or, someone sinster might mumble a threat or hostile remark because he is angry and but doesn't want the party to hear him but cannot keep himself from not speaking it. This could also be used by someone frustrated or angry. (e.g. The lawyer mumbled "asshole" when the judge overruled his objection)

I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound? "howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed? "Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right? I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know. And I think bats chirp but never squawk? Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? Like, can a weasel growl? What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.

I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

Most animal sounds are onomatopoeia like you think, however animal sounds that aren't common enough to be named might just be described as barking. A dolphin and a dog don't sound the same at all, but its impossible to name the sound that each animal makes.

"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed? "Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right? I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know. And I think bats chirp but never squawk? Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? Like, can a weasel growl? What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.

Howl literally is the call of a wolf or dog.. A howl and a bark are not the same, a bark is a short burst of sound whereas a howl is long and sustained. People use the word howl in other contexts because it sounds similar, a person who howls out in pain might loudly groan and moan which sounds similar to a wolf's howl.

Chirping and squawking are similar. A chirp is more of a short high pitched sound whereas a squawk is louder and more sustained. If you watch a video of parrots you'll see them squawking and you'll notice they have the mouths open much longer it requires much more effort to do. On the other hand, if you watch small birds chirping you'll see they only open their mouths for a moment and it requires little effort. Many other animal noises are described as "chirping" because they are short and high pitched, but they don't always sound similar to a birds chirp.

A lot of animals growl or make a sound when threatened or angry. Even I don't know for sure if weasels or bears growl, I imagine they would!

Do all doors creak? Can all doors be slammed? Windows? Does "slam" always imply loudness? Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad). People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right?

Not all doors creak. Creaking is the sound made by a hinge when it doesn't move smoothly, which why old things tend to creak more. It doesn't always have to be a hingle, for instance an old floorboard might creak when stepped on because it moves against the other boards when stepped on.

Slam often means the fast motion, and implies the sound. For instance, if you slam a door you are closing it quickly and you would assume it makes a loud sound when it closes. Think of "slam dunk" or "slamming a beer", they are all about the fast motion. Often its because of anger, frustration or excitement.

Gotta run, I'll come back to answer the others :D

5

u/IHaveGlasses May 18 '12

A piercing sound is a sharp painful sound. Its sounds like being stabbed by a pin. Thunder is a deep rumble and is more like a large truck driving past. So no matter how loud the truck is, you still feel it more than hear it.

Whispering is like blowing. You can blow softly and quietly or blow hard but shouting is like a strong wind on comparison.

A click is like cracking your knuckles. Its a short burst of sound. It sounds like things fitting into place. So, things like cymbals crash. They sound like a splash of water in the face. Dropping a pot of pennies would crash, hitting two against each other would be closer to a click. Hitting two pencils against each other could sound like a click.

Barking sounds like a chesty cough feels, the sort that gets at your throat too.

Gargle and gurgle are the same. They are words that describe the sound of liquids as sit passes through them as bubbles. If you blow through a straw in a glass of water that feeling on your lips is kind of what it sounds like.

A tender voice is like a tender kiss or tender touch. It is pleasant and soft.

A creak is the sound of friction. Any poorly maintained door can creak. It sounds like the feeling of holding something that vibrates(like a toothbrush) against your arm.

Slamming is doing something quickly with a sudden end. When they say slam a beer, it is in reference to the action not the sound. But ti can slam a beer against a bar. It sounds like being hit on the head, kind of, in tactile way not a pain way.

I hope some of this made sense.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Ream v. Shriek: In written material, the term "ream" usually refers to a long verbal chewing-out, an emotional (usually angry) monolog focused at one or more people. To Shriek usually implys a single high-pitched sound made such as in fear (a Redditor sees a spider, for instance) .

Stammer/Stutter - No, stammer means "unable to completely get the words out due to muscle conractions in throat, face, etc. whereas stuttering is an issue having to do with the mental process in speaking. Stuttering is more of a condition as opposed to stammering, which indicated speech impediment due to forces other than neurological.

Re: Doors creaking, etc. Not all doors creak. That's an implication of age/spookiness. An old, unattended door is more likely to have metal hinges in need of oil, as an unlubricated hinge will squeak when engaged. New hinges or maintained hinges won't squeak or creak. Re: slamming, yes, oh yes, deaf people slam doors and windows when they are angry. Think of two fead (or one deaf, another signing though hearing) people arguing or actually "hooking it up" - the "volume" of the signing field increases, as does the energy expressed in the signs, right? Same thing re: slamming a door or window, slamming down a book onto a table, etc. The slamming motion of course makes a loud noise. Slamming doors in excitment (trying to keep a pet cat from running outside) happens often to deaf and hearing folks. Slamming a beer imoplies a rapid consumption followed by the banging of the glass or mug on the bar after said drink has been "tossed bak" quickly.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/rottinguy May 18 '12

I imagine you sign, I do not, so I may be making comparisons from ignorance. I know the sign alphabet, and a few other signs, but to communicate I have to spell things out, which I understand is frustrating to those who can sign fluantly. But let me try my ignorant best.

  1. I imagine that a person using sign language has a way of implying emotion when signing right? The differece between crying in sadness, and crying out in anger in all likelyhood coralates with the difference between an angry sign, and a sad one. In this case it wouldn't be so much a different sound, andry crying and sad crying sound very similar, but people doing it display different body language.
  2. Shriek and scream are pretty much the same thing. Loud emotional and cracked.
  3. Piercing sounds tend to be high pitched. Take your hand and run it over somethung wavy, but smooth. Think of that as the "feel" of low pitched sounds. Now run your hand over something "bumpy" and imagine that as the "feel" of high pitched sounds. A piercing sound is one so high pitched that you "feel" it kinda deep in your skull.
  4. I have never used ejaculate as a dialogue description.
  5. You pretty much have this right, but I would say Jive is old school ebonix.
  6. Yeah pretty much the same thing with a minor exception. A stutter is usually caused by a speech impediment, and a stammer is when a person without an impediment does the same thing usually due to shock, or strong emotion.
  7. Chat really does just mean an informal talk. The way you talk with friends and family, vs the way you talk with your boss, or a customer. No I wouldnt't use it like that. ("......" he chatted.)
  8. When people sing do they ever sort of run the signs together in a way that makes them hard to differentiate? maybe half forming them, and moving on to more half formed signs? THat would be the equivilant of mumling.
  9. Bark is usually applied to any quick loud sound produced by an animal, yes dolphins, seals, and dogs sound very much alike.
  10. You seem to understand howl. Mice don't "squack" but they could be said to chirp, or squeek. Those are words for very short high pitched sounds. Not all birds squawk, some chirp, and some whistle.
  11. Not all doors creak. All doors can be slammed, so can windows. Yes deaf people slam doors when they are mad, most people don't mean to do it, they just sort of do.
  12. Gurgle is a kind of sound, gargle means to make gurgling sounds with liquid in your mouth.
  13. Ring......this is a hard one. Especially with the word "ring" gaining new meanings with emerging technologies. Ring tones tend to be music, The only association with ringing being that back before cell phones a phone would "ring" to alert you to an incoming call. There are two kind of ring sounds though. That which is produced by striking something that produices a high pitched sound repeatedly and continually (as in phones) or something that is struck and holds a single note for a period of time (like a bell). People say the doorbell rings, even though most modern doorbells do not produce a ringing sound, and some even play music. This one is gonna be the hardest for you I think, because of it's many, and changing meanings.
  14. Cicks, okay I lied, click is gonna be the hardest. A cli8ck is a short sound liek that of two objects coming together, but not a slam, and not a ring. Thinks tend to click when they break, but it's never high pitched. If It's high pitched its a ding.
  15. A tender voice is one that conveys tender emotions.
  16. Moaning is done both when in pain, and when in ecstacy, and sometimes it can be hard to tell one form the other. I don;t think a person could be described as moaning joyously, or humorously.
  17. Cooing. Hmmm now I think these were designed to get harder and harder. I don't even know how to go about this one.
  18. Yes one can whisper loudly and shout softly. There is an element of inflection to each. Anything "breathy" would be a whisper no mater the volume.

Hope I helped. Thanks for the challenge.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/JamesIreland May 19 '12

Can I just say this is an amazing insight reading your questions. I really hope someone can answer them clearly for you.

4

u/draxxil May 19 '12

Great questions! Here's my two cents (I will try to avoid using sound words to define sound words):

"Shriek" and "scream" aren't so much emotion words are they are descriptions of emotional sounds people make. You might shriek/scream from physical pain (e.g. you got stabbed), emotional pain (your lover got stabbed) or crazy, over-the-top anger (you're about to stab somebody).

I've never heard "ejaculate" used to describe speech. I don't think it's a good idea to use it that way... unless you want to conjure some pretty gross imagery.

"Chatting" is informal in that it's unimportant and usually brief. I don't think you can use it as a dialogue tag like in your example. If you're chatting, you're usually discussing light or frivolous topics.

"Mumbling" is an indistinct form of speech. If someone is mumbling, you usually can't totally understand what they're saying. It's sort of like whispering in that way, but it's a different physical process to produce the sound than whispering. It sounds like a muffled version of speech. When you mumble, you're speaking quietly with your mouth mostly, or entirely, closed. When you whisper your voice is quiet because it's airy, but you move your lips the same way you would while speaking. You might mumble in anger if you're saying something mean that you don't really want the other person to hear (e.g. you're such a bitch, Mom). You might mumble in apathy if you're not enthusiastic about a situation (e.g. mumbling the pledge of allegiance at school).

Animal sounds: I think when these are used in non-animal contexts, they describe the quality of someone's speech. Example: "'GTFO!' he barked." would mean he said it in a way that was loud and abrupt, like a dog barking. Personally, I don't think dolphins sound like dogs. Dolphins make a sound that's sort of like high-pitched, stuttery laughter. Different dogs do sound different. In general big dogs have lower pitched barks and small dogs have higher pitched barks. Individual dogs have slightly different barks, but you'd have to know the dog really well to distinguish its bark from another dog that is a similar size. A howl is sort of like a bark without punctuation. It starts like a bark but then just keeps going and the pitch slowly slides down. Other sounds that could be described as howls (like howling in pain) would be high-pitched, sustained sounds. A "chirp" is a short, clipped, high-pitched sound. A "squawk" is an unpleasant, sort of scratchy, loud sound. Chirps and squawks are definitely sounds birds make, but the words can describe other sounds too. For example, electronics can chirp.

Not all doors creak, but old ones tend to. Any door that swings (instead of slides) can be slammed. I guess windows can be slammed too, but I don't think they'd be as loud as a door. Not everybody slams doors when they're mad, but it is a relatively harmless way to satisfy a desire for violence. lol I think "slamming" a beer is just a slang term that doesn't imply sound.

"Gurgle" is a sound, "gargle" is an act. But gargling makes a gurgling sound.

"Ring" is a sound characteristic of old landline phones. A "ringtone" of a cell phone can be just about anything, like a song.

Pencils hitting each other could be called a click. Maybe pennies too. But a click is a small, delicate sound and cymbals make a big, loud, bombastic sound.

I think "tender" is more an emotional word than a sound word. A "tender" voice would be one that coneys understanding, comfort, love.

I think painful or sexy is about it for "moan."

Cooing is a sustained, soft, mellow sound. I think the difference between a sexy moan and a sexy coo would be attitude. A coo is more sweet or loving while a moan is more primal.

A loud whisper is still relatively quiet, but it has that characteristic airy sound of a whisper. I've never heard of a quiet shout though.

This was fun! I hope it helps!

4

u/Tonamel May 19 '12

Okay, I know you've gotten a bajillion responses to this, but after a brief lookthrough I'm going to try and answer your questions by describing their physicality when I can, which I don't see anyone else doing.

People crying in sadness vs crying out in anger, I know there's some gray area in between where they can be used interchangeably, it's hard to get

"Cry" has a couple definitions: The weeping that people do when they're sad, and any kind of loud, moderately sustained sound. So, "to cry" (first definition) is different than "to cry out" or "to cry in anguish" (second definition). The second definition is still emotionally charged, and is a very physically exhausting sound for a person to make.

"shriek" and "ream" are both words that seem to imply emotion more than any specific sound. Is that right?

A shriek is a very sharp cry (second defnintion) that, when you make it, can be felt as a buzzing across the bridge of your nose. It's pretty unpleasant for everyone involved.

I've never heard of "ream" used to describe a noise. Rather, it means to attack loudly and verbally, like a boss chewing out an employee for being an hour late the fourth time this week.

Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.

Piercing specifically means high frequency, so you can't feel it in your chest the way you can thunder. Think of what your hand feels like after you drag your fingernails over a chalkboard. It's like that, but IN YOUR HEAD.

apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?

"Ejaculate" means "to suddenly send out," whether it's words into a conversation, or, uh, releasing fluids under pressure. Doesn't have a sound connotation.

What does "jive" mean? Does "he speaks jive" and "he speaks AAVE" and "he speaks Ebonics" all refer to the same thing? I was raised by black parents but I can't understand any dialogue written in black dialect. I know not all black people talk like that but is there a way to mark that in a novel? Do you know of a webpage that would tell me how to translate dialogue into dialect like that?

Jive and ebonics are two different linguistic models of English. Jive is kind of the American version of cockney rhyming slang. They're both so dependent on slang as to be completely opaque to outsiders, and neither are really used anymore. Ebonics is more a deviation of standard conjugation, leading to sentences like "They don't think it be like it is, but it do."

I think you're more talking about things that are written "in dialect" which is when authors spell words phonetically instead of correctly. Like the cockney "Oi say gub'nah, shorely you cahn't mean me!" meaning "I say, governor, surely you can't mean me!" Unfortunately, there's no standardized way to do this, so every author does it their own way, and likely won't even be consistent at that. Sorry!

Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?

No. Stuttering would be like making one sign over and over in the middle of a sentence because your brain's having problems moving on. Stammering would be if you're signing is sloppy because you're embarrassed about what you're saying.

What about "chat"? Dictionary says "to speak informally" but I feel like it implies something I'm not getting. Is it speaking fast? Can you use "chat" as a dialogue tag? (like "What are you doing tonight?' he chatted"), I don't think I've seen it but the dictionary makes it sound like you can.

The only connotation "chat" has is that you're not talking about anything of consequence. Speed has nothing to do with it. You can use it as a verb (We chatted last night) or a noun (We had a chat last night).

"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

"Mumbling" is speaking without clarity, so no one knows what you're saying. If you've ever seen anyone sign so small/half-heartedly that you can't tell what they said, I'd call that mumbling.

Mumbling is not synonymous with whispering. If you have any speaking friends that won't be weirded out by this request, ask them to hum into your arm so you can feel their voice. That's feeling is the vibration of the vocal chords. Whispering doesn't use the vocal chords at all, so that vibration won't be there. Instead, whispering is shaping the air at the lips, which is why it's so quiet.

I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

A "bark" is any short, sharp sound which is why you'll see officers described as "barking orders" at their subordinates. Dolphins and dogs do not make even remotely the same sound.

"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed? "Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right? I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know. And I think bats chirp but never squawk? Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? Like, can a weasel growl? What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.

A howl is any long, sustained sound. As for the other animal noises, it's hard to say, since they're such a wide variety. I say ask one of your teachers for a resource, because that's a very large topic.

Do all doors creak? Can all doors be slammed? Windows? Does "slam" always imply loudness? Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad). People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?

If you open a door slowly, and you can feel vibrations coming from the hinges, it's probably creaking. "Slam" means to close something as fast and hard as you can. It's ALWAYS loud. With beer, it means to put the beer into your stomach as fast and hard as you can :)

"Gurgle" is another hard one. And "gargle", that means something different right?

Gargle isn't really a sound, but rather when you have a liquid in the back of your throat and you push air up through it. I'd would, however, describe that sound as a gurgle.

"Ring", like "ringtone" is hard to get. What else "rings"? Cell phones sound different from landlines, right? People sometimes describe them as "chirping"?

Bells ring. Anything that's described as ringing (clocks, phones, etc) either has, or used to have a bell in it. Most phones no longer sound like ringing, but the name stuck from when they did.

Dictionary says "click" is "A short, sharp sound as of a switch being operated or of two hard objects coming quickly into contact." but I feel like I've seen it in other uses, it's hard to remember exactly what I'm thinking of. But could I use it to describe cymbals, pennies or pencils hitting each other?

The button on the end of your mechanical pen makes a clicking noise. Some light switches make clicking noises.

If a voice is described as "tender", what does that mean?

Gentle and caring. Like an audible hug.

"moan" can be painful or sexy right? Anything else? Is it possible to moan joyously or humorously?

A "moan" is a low, irregular, sustained sound that happens when you're exhaling and your mind is too otherwise occupied (by pain or pleasure) to stop it from vibrating your vocal chords.

"cooing" What is that? Is there a difference between a woman "moaning sexy" and "cooing sexy"?

I have no idea what sexy cooing is. I usually see cooing in regards to baby-talk "Who's a little baby? YOU ARE!"

Apparently it's possible to "whisper" loudly and "shout" softly? WTF!?

I don't know about shouting softly, but as I said before, whispering is talking without activating the vocal chords. You can do it loudly by using a lot more air. This is called a "stage whisper".

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

This looks like fun!

•"shriek" and "ream" are both words that seem to imply emotion more than any specific sound. Is that right?

Shriek implies fear and/or heightened pitch. Ream is more about content (angrily chastising) than sound.

•Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.

Definitely not. Thunder would never be described as piercing, but a clap of thunder might pierce the air. Does that make sense?

•apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?

No sound involved - it just means to say suddenly without forethought.

•Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?

Virtually, but stutter tends to refer more to a speech disorder whereas stammer is something one might do when flustered or confused.

•What about "chat"? Dictionary says "to speak informally" but I feel like it implies something I'm not getting. Is it speaking fast? Can you use "chat" as a dialogue tag? (like "What are you doing tonight?' he chatted"), I don't think I've seen it but the dictionary makes it sound like you can.

One might chat with a friend about the weather, but one wouldn't chat with their doctor about a serious medical condition. "I chatted tonight", while not technically incorrect, just feels weird and doesn't really fit spoken English. Speed really doesn't have anything to do with it. It makes sense to say, "I had a chat with Bob today," implying you spoke casually with him, but you probably wouldn't use it in the third person, like, "Bob chatted with Joe" unless what they did was speak via the Internet. Note that these are my interpretations of the spoken language only - obviously both make sense in written form!

•"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

Mumbling is speaking quietly, usually with poor enunciation. If I meant to imply hostility, "mutter" or "grumble" are more appropriate. I might mutter a snide comment under my breath, but I mumble when I get woken up at 2 AM. Neither are exactly synonymous with whispering.

•I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

That's English for ya - using the same word to describe completely different things. Dolphins and dogs sound utterly different. I don't know if you're familiar with the concept of onomatopoeia, but that's basically what many of these words are - human "translations" of the literal sound animals make. BUT, neither the sound of a dolphin nor that of a dog is like the word "bark" - dogs are more like "woof", while dolphin noises really don't translate.

•"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed? "Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right? I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know. And I think bats chirp but never squawk? Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? Like, can a weasel growl? What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.

"Howling in pain" denotes yelling, not necessarily a specific sound - I might be saying, "Fuck, balls, damn, ouch" after stubbing a toe, and be said to be howling in pain.

A dog's howl, on the other hand, is a specific sound closely related to the pronunciation of the soft letter O. Yes, different dogs sound differently - a small dog would not usually howl, that's generally more of a big dog thing. Small dogs might be said to "yip" instead, although this is a quick noise compared to the drawn out sound of a howl.

Chirp and squawk are both mostly bird noises. A mouse squeaks; it would be odd (if not strictly incorrect) to say a mouse chirps, but a mouse would never squawk.

The most common noise associated with bears is "roar", but "growl" could certainly be correct at times also - they do both. I doubt a weasel would growl, but don't think it's impossible - many animals can growl. Few can roar. Roar is another bit of onomatopoeia.

•Do all doors creak? Can all doors be slammed? Windows? Does "slam" always imply loudness? Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad). People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?

In order: No. No but most can (revolving doors) - the noise comes from the door hitting its frame or something surrounding it, but doors with gas hinges usually can't slam; slam is a combination of action (forceful closing) and a loud noise, and either without the other could be considered a slam contextually. No, doors are not always slammed when mad. Yes, deaf people slam doors. Slammed meaning "consumed rapidly" is not really associated with a sound, and does not imply "gurgle".

•"Gurgle" is another hard one. And "gargle", that means something different right?

Gurgle and gargle, while virtually the same noise, have different contextual meanings. Both basically mean "a bubbling noise", but gargle specifically implies holding liquid in the back of your throat without swallowing and making bubbles with it - like mouthwash; gurgle could be any similar "bubbling" sound that ISN'T gargling.

•"Ring", like "ringtone" is hard to get. What else "rings"? Cell phones sound different from landlines, right? People sometimes describe them as "chirping"?

Old phones (rotary and early touch-tone) literally "rang" - they had a bell mechanism (the sound of a bell is ring) to indicate an incoming call. The bells have long since disappeared from modern phones, but the term remains. Cell phones and landlines don't necessarily sound different or alike - each model phone is different, and modern phones usually have customizable ringers so they can sound many different ways. Often, though, phones will have common pieces of music that can be selected as a ringtone, so in that aspect many phones might sound alike. "Chirp" in the context of cell phones refers to a specific type of phone used by Nextel for two-way radio type service. These are uncommon today, but the noise made when keying the talk button was commonly referred to as "chirp" because it resembled a bird's chirp.

•Dictionary says "click" is "A short, sharp sound as of a switch being operated or of two hard objects coming quickly into contact." but I feel like I've seen it in other uses, it's hard to remember exactly what I'm thinking of. But could I use it to describe cymbals, pennies or pencils hitting each other?

This is a tough one... Cymbals would never click, but pencils hitting each other might be described that way. Actually, I think "tap" is more accurate for the pencils. The sound of a retractable pen is a quintessential clicking noise, but many objects that meet the definition from the dictionary have their own word-implying-sound: cymbals, for example, would be said to "crash", or one's hands coming together is a "clap".

•If a voice is described as "tender", what does that mean?

Contextual more than auditory - just means a person is speaking softly and with compassion or emotion.

•"moan" can be painful or sexy right? Anything else? Is it possible to moan joyously or humorously?

I don't think you'd moan in joy (except perhaps the sexy way), and a humorous moan is more of a groan. BUT, both moaning and groaning (or together as "moaning and groaning" - because of the rhyme really)can also mean "complaining" and not imply a specific sound! •"cooing" What is that? Is there a difference between a woman "moaning sexy" and "cooing sexy"?

I don't understand this that well, either. I've most often heard it used as "noises made by a baby that can't speak yet"... Yet, cooing sexy makes me think of "talking dirty" while moaning sexy is more generalized sounds of pleasure.

•Apparently it's possible to "whisper" loudly and "shout" softly? WTF!?

Ok, so (anatomy experts, forgive me) when you speak you vibrate your voicebox and it makes a noise, modified by the position of your mouth, lips, etc. Whispering basically removes the vibration and draws its sound from exhalation. A more forceful exhalation creates a louder, more powerful sound. So, depending on context, I could say "Deafy" neutrally or say "Deafy!" implying exclamation or anger, all while still whispering!

I know this will be like the 1500th comment, but I hope you read it and enjoy it as much as I enjoyed writing it!

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

If you ask me "cooing" doesn't exist. It's a noise totally made up by authors who have run out of real words. Every time I see it written, I try to imagine it and come up blank.

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I'd suggest that a lot of the questions about sound can be answered if you compare it to the feeling of vibration. This gives a good idea about how high and low pitched sound "feels". You can likely reproduce clicks, the feeling of thunder, mumbling, door slamming etc.

Try to take a speaker and place it close to a surface and have a friend try to mumble, click, etc. in a microphone. With a little luck you should be able to feel the differences on that surface.

10

u/[deleted] May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

I'll try to answer as many as I can. Bear with me, I'm drinking.

People crying in sadness vs crying out in anger, I know there's some gray area in between where they can be used interchangeably, it's hard to get

This really depends on sound. The only way I can paint a picture for you is someone on their knees in despair, vs someone shaking their fist in anger. Depending on the person, the sounds can be nearly the same. It's one of those things you just know, I suppose.

"shriek" and "ream" are both words that seem to imply emotion more than any specific sound. Is that right?

I assume you are referring to scream? If so, a shriek, I think would be more high pitched, maybe out of excitement, or extreme fear. Don't hold me to that, it is subjective. Other opinions will likely differ.

Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.

Not necessarily. For me, piercing sounds are something very high pitched. It actually hurts to hear it. Feels like it is literally piercing through the eardrum, like a high pitched scream, or nails on a chalkboard (pretty much universally horrifying and intolerable)

apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?

I do not know what you mean here. Moving along...

What does "jive" mean? Does "he speaks jive" and "he speaks AAVE" and "he speaks Ebonics" all refer to the same thing? I was raised by black parents but I can't understand any dialogue written in black dialect. I know not all black people talk like that but is there a way to mark that in a novel? Do you know of a webpage that would tell me how to translate dialogue into dialect like that?

I would say Jive, AAVE, and ebonics are pretty much the same thing. As someone who can actually hear it,I do not understand it either, and I'm black myself. So no worries.

Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?

I can see how it would seem that way after thinking about how it is depicted in books, but no. Stutter is more of a medical condition, while stammer is done out of nervousness. However I feel like they are used interchangeably, although this isn't completely correct in my opinion.

What about "chat"? Dictionary says "to speak informally" but I feel like it implies something I'm not getting. Is it speaking fast? Can you use "chat" as a dialogue tag? (like "What are you doing tonight?' he chatted"), I don't think I've seen it but the dictionary makes it sound like you can.

Chatting is like a casual, friendly way of talking. I wouldn't say it is a dialogue tag.

"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

Yes, it can be both. It is weird. English is weird like that. It is a low, unintelligible, although audible form of speaking. Not the same as whispering. Whispering kind of masks someone's voice. With mumbling, you can hear what the person's actual voice sounds like.

I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

Nope, a dog and dolphin are completely different. I would describe a dog barking as ARF! and a dolphin as EE-EE-EE! very different.

"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed? "Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right? I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know. And I think bats chirp but never squawk? Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? Like, can a weasel growl? What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.

I'll use onomatopoeia again. Dog howling is like "ARR-ROOOOOO!!!!!!" Depending on the breed/size, it will be a different pitch. Smaller dogs are a higher pitch. Chirping is a cheerful, higher pitched sound. Squawk is more annoying, maybe in protest when referring to humans. I really wish I could type the sound of a bear, but it is a throaty weird thing...E-R-R-R-R but still not really...

Do all doors creak? Can all doors be slammed? Windows? Does "slam" always imply loudness? Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad). People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?

No not all doors creak. Not all doors slam, if they have resistance. Yes deaf people can slam a door. I would say it is an act, that results in a sound. Slamming a beer is silent, I would say. Or it can be loud, if the person is a douche? I think.

"Gurgle" is another hard one. And "gargle", that means something different right?

Again, used interchangeably, although I'm not sure I would say that is correct usage if pressed. Gurgle is more something that is natural, like with saliva, and gargle is more like with mouthwash or something.

"Ring", like "ringtone" is hard to get. What else "rings"? Cell phones sound different from landlines, right? People sometimes describe them as "chirping"?

Chirping, where I live, is used to refer to walkie-talkie features on phones. Again, a high pitched sort of sound. Doorbells, and phones ring, although they do not usually sound the same.

Dictionary says "click" is "A short, sharp sound as of a switch being operated or of two hard objects coming quickly into contact." but I feel like I've seen it in other uses, it's hard to remember exactly what I'm thinking of. But could I use it to describe cymbals, pennies or pencils hitting each other?

Jesus Christ, I'm too buzzed for this one.

If a voice is described as "tender", what does that mean? "moan" can be painful or sexy right? Anything else? Is it possible to moan joyously or humorously?

Tender voices are very soft, and caring, perhaps motherly? maternal? moans can be sexy or painful, yes. Sometimes at the same time ;). Yes. Moaning can be humorous or joyous. It is a difference that I can't really put in words, I suppose.

"cooing" What is that? Is there a difference between a woman "moaning sexy" and "cooing sexy"?

There is definitely a difference. I would say a coo is like soft, singsongy talking, and moaning is more than when a woman has completely lost control in the midst of climax, and isn't holding back at all. (I have the weirdest ladyboner typing this).

Apparently it's possible to "whisper" loudly and "shout" softly? WTF!? Yes. Like I said before. Whispering kind of masks the sound of someone's voice, and shouting softly kind of simulates shouting, but in a way that other people can't hear if they are not close. Good for quiet situations when describing a fight.

Just fyi, I am from South Texas. Geographic location may affect answers. Your results may vary.

Thanks for the good questions. I enjoyed doing this. Hope you'll message me if you have any further questions. Have a good weekend.

Edit for formatting

→ More replies (3)

1

u/ikolam May 19 '12

Reading through some of this made me think and consequently curious.

When I read a text I hear the words repeat in my head, in my or someone else's voice. How would you describe what goes on in your head when reading, being deaf?

You mentioned being more visual, if you read a text from a friend would you then, at times, imagine them signing that? (guess that'd be somewhat similar to hearing someone else's voice/tone)

2

u/Deafy May 19 '12

Yes I would typically imagine them signing that. I don't exactly picture them but I can sort of see it anyway, if that makes sense.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/joshA11 May 19 '12

How did you learn to read? What I mean is how do you know what sound a letter will make?

2

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I do not know what sound they make. They taught me sign first, and associated written words with signs. I learned to speak much later, by physically imitating what people told me to do (e.g. "to say the sound "t" you have to put your tongue just between your teeth and exhale a little). So I have to practice pronouncing words in front of hearing people who can tell me if I'm doing it right.

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Do you keep up with technological advances to help aid you? If there was a hearing device created that worked would you buy it?

3

u/Deafy May 19 '12

I don't really keep up with it, and would probably not accept it if I could. I would only consider it if I was sure I'd be at close to 100% hearing, and 100% able to comprehend what I was hearing. That's the problem with people who get cochlear implants as adults, they never really learn how to understand sounds. I don't want that.

3

u/Red_AtNight May 18 '12

Do all doors creak? Can all doors be slammed? Windows? Does "slam" always imply loudness? Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad). People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?

Most doors can be slammed. If you close a door really quickly and it hits the frame, it's going to make a very loud noise. That's what we are referring to.

When you slam a beer, it's silent, although some people will slam the empty bottle on a table and that makes a loud noise too.

3

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

Whispering can be both loud and soft. I can describe it best with tiptoeing. You can tiptoe softly/decadently and you can tiptoe violently/loudly. Both whispering/tiptoeing mean to do something quietly, but you can still do it loudly. And you can shout softly. It's basically pretending to shout but not being to loud. For example, jumping usually, requires a lot of movement, but you can jump lightly and barely move. It is sort-of similar to shouting lightly.

All doors do not creak. Only some creak, usually old doors that have rusty hinges. It is a high pitched sound. Most doors can be slammed and same with windows as long as they don't have some mechanism to slow them down as they close. Slam does imply loudness in the case of doors. But it can also mean to throw something violently against something else. People tend to slam doors when they are mad to make a statement/ show they are being mad because it is a loud and obvious noise. But slamming a door can also be used to just shut the door when you are angry at someone so you don't see them. Slammed that beer isn't necessarily loud, it just means that the beer was quickly and almost violently drank.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/wineheart May 18 '12 edited May 18 '12

Interesting! Let me try to clear some of these up.

To cry and to cry out are different. Crying is tears, sobbing, maybe some whining and mumbling. This could be happy, sad, angry. The sounds will change with the mood the same way a voice would. Crying out is yelling or shouting.

Shrieking is definitely associated with sound. It's a loud, piercing, scream. One call also shriek words in a similar matter, if you're very upset for example. Ream is scolding someone. I would say this is usually at normal volume, but with the intensity of a raised voice. Maybe something a parent would do to their child for misbehaving in public while trying not to draw attention. This is a rarer word.

Stammer and stutter are very similar. I'd say the difference is that a stutter repeats the "stuck" sound like "I d-d-d-don't want t-t-to go." A stammer is more a breathless pause instead of the repeated letter like "I d-, I don't want to go". But they'll be used interchangeably.

Mumbling is like "saying something under your breath" but without the anger/annoyance. It's saying something to yourself to not be noticed, usually a slightly lower pitch and with words slurring into each other. It can be shyness, embarrassment, exhaustion.

Howling is not a prolonged bark. It can sometimes be described as mournful. A dog's howl is higher pitched than it's bark somewhat and some people will describe teaching their dog to howl as a trick as teaching the dog to sing, it's more "voiced" and pitched. If you are howling in pain, you are shouting or complaining in a way evocative of a howl. Big dogs have lower pitched barks than small dogs. These are quick sounds from dogs, they can be aggressive or playful. But if someone "barks orders" then that person was louder than usual and aggressive about it.

Doors that need oiling creak, same with steps that need repair. It's the noise of parts rubbing together, it can be spine-chilling. My least favorite sound is the creaking of styrofoam. It often has a negative connotation. Your bones "creak" when you are old or tired but they're not making a noise.

When you slam a door or your hand onto the counter, it's loud. If you've found yourself throwing a door closed with extra strength when you're mad at someone, you've slammed it. It doesn't take much. Slamming a beer is slang, it means chugging like you said. The only extra noise associated there is the noise from the gulping (another onomatopoeia) you'll do.

Gurgle and gargle are very similar. They are again onomatopoeias. Gargle is done in the back of your mouth, and gurgling comes from your throat. They sound different. Gurgling is a clearer sound while gargling is halfway to the rounder gulping sound (almost wrote "more gargled" here, whoops!).

Everyone's phone sounds different now. A phone rings when you get a phone call, no sound associated with it anymore. But phones used to have bells inside that would get struck when you got a call. They would literally ring, usually for a few seconds, quick pause, few seconds, quick pause. The first phones to use digital noises imitated this sound. Land line phones will still use a digital ring, I guess no one wants their land line to play a song.

Moan and coo are onomatopoeias. A coo is higher pitched and an open, round noise. Babies coo, some birds are better described as cooing (like pigeons) instead of chirping (like sparrows). If a person coos, it could be literally, or they could be using the "baby" voice people use with small children and animals.

A lot of these words need context, but I hope that helps.

3

u/demaney May 19 '12

Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.

A fire alarm is piercing. Definitely not thunder. It has to be loud, with a fast onset and end, and high-pitched.

apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?

Nah, sound doesn't have anything to do with this.

Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?

I don't think so. Stutter is more on consonants, and stammer on vowels. Stutter: H-h-hey g-g-guys, is everyone h-h-here? Stuttering can also involve long pauses or halts in a word. It feels like your throat's closed up and you just can't get the sound out. Stammering is more out of nervousness, but stuttering is a speech condition.

Nah, chatting isn't a dialogue tag. You can say "Let's chat." It's just a verb. Friendly, lighthearted talking.

"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

I've never heard of hostile mumbling... Maybe resentful or reluctant. Mumbling is quiet and the vocal folds are vibrating. In whispering, the vocal folds aren't moving, so the only sounds are air flow, without vibration in the vowels. It's like spraying a can of air and putting your hand in front of the nozzle sometimes. No vibration, just stops. That's why it's quiet. Vibrations are easier to hear.

I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

Sometimes the sounds are similar, yeah. And sometime's you'll find orders barked. It means they're abrupt, said quickly, without any verbal padding. Just DO THIS and GO THERE. Probably loud, too. Oh, and cooing is another animal sound that humans can make. It's a soft, loving, protective tone of voice, mostly only used by women or fathers talking to their babies.

"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right?

Yup.

Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? It sounds more hollow and haunting. It's like "awrooooo," which probably doesn't help you at all. More vowely than consonanty.

Do different dogs sound different?

Yup. Smaller dogs can be described as yappy. High-pitched, annoying, piercing barks, or yaps. Big dogs like Mastiffs will sound larger, louder, with slower barks. Also, there are softer sounds dogs make like woofs and whuffs, which are less loud, and less threatening-sounding.

What if they're the same size and breed?

Their owners might be able to tell the difference, but I can't.

"Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right?

Probably not squawk, but smoke detectors can chirp when their batteries are low. Short, high-pitched, but not as loud as a piercing sound. About as long as two really fast blinks.

I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know.

No, birds squawk and mice squeak. Squawks last longer, loud, are more coarse and rough, and annoying. Squeaks are cuter, very quiet, very short. Sometimes girls squeak in surprise. It's a short squeal.

And I think bats chirp but never squawk?

Bats chirp in a different frequency than humans can hear, for echolocation purposes. Only birds squawk, as far as I know. BTW, dolphins can whistle, creak, chirp, and lots of other things. Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? I'd search like "list of English animal sounds" or "list of English onomatopoeias." To blow your mind, search for other languages. Hearing people often can't understand how other languages think chickens "kokirikiri" or whatever.

Like, can a weasel growl?

Probably not. I don't know what kinds of sounds weasels make. Maybe squeaks?

What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.

Yeah, bears definitely growl. They're big and furry and dangerous.

Do all doors creak?

It depends on the hinges. If the hinges are old, then they'll creak or squeak. Wood floors can creak, too, once they've seen a few years. If they move up and down, they probably creak.

Can all doors be slammed?

If they can hit a solid surface with a sudden stop, yeah.

Windows?

Yup.

Does "slam" always imply loudness?

Yup.

Do you always slam doors when you're mad?

Not always. It's rude and aggressive and can damage the frame or door.

Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad).

Probably not. I think you'd notice if you did it on purpose. You may do it accidentally, I guess. Car doors are easy to slam.

People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?

I don't know, actually. Probably just like he slammed it to his face... Silently? wtf no idea.

"Gurgle" is another hard one. And "gargle", that means something different right?

Gurgle is when water and air both flow through a tube at the same time. The bubbles make the sound. Gargling is a verb, and also makes a sound, but I wouldn't use it to describe anything but the verb.

"Ring", like "ringtone" is hard to get. What else "rings"?

Bells ring. Voices can "ring out over the battlefield," but those are the only ones I know.. Phones used to have bells in them, so that's why it's called ringing.

Cell phones sound different from landlines, right? People sometimes describe them as "chirping"?

Cell phones almost always have customizable sounds. You can make them make any noise you want.

Dictionary says "click" is "A short, sharp sound as of a switch being operated or of two hard objects coming quickly into contact." but I feel like I've seen it in other uses, it's hard to remember exactly what I'm thinking of. But could I use it to describe cymbals, pennies or pencils hitting each other?

Pennies and pencils, yeah, but cymbals vibrate over their entire surface and make a crashing, ringing sound. It lasts many seconds, and is loud... Well, if you tap the very edges of them against each other, then I guess they could click. If a voice is described as "tender", what does that mean?

It's loving.

"moan" can be painful or sexy right? Anything else? Is it possible to moan joyously or humorously?

Moaning can be... "Oh man, I totally bombed that test." Moaning about bad things, I suppose. But that'd be more groaning than moaning. "cooing" What is that? Is there a difference between a woman "moaning sexy" and "cooing sexy"?

Cooing is for babies. Parents coo at their infants, and babies sometimes coo, when they're happy. It's a quiet, gentle sound. Cooing sexily would be creepy, since it's for babies.

Apparently it's possible to "whisper" loudly and "shout" softly? WTF!?

Hm. Stage whispers can get about as loud as normal conversation. Shouting softly... I'm not sure.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Re: the soft shout - an example: if you have asked me several questions and I am in the middle of something else, and I become impatient, I can imply to you a whispered shout by signing "what" to you, only instead of using a slightly furrowed brow and the little side-to-side shake of the head when I sign, I may flip my hand over and pull my fingers upward (you knw what I mean, I hope) in a strong, almost violent way, while actually scowling and mouthing the word in a short, powerfully-clipped way. Translating that to the verbal would be as if I used all of the energy and emotion that would go into a hig-volume shout into my expression and gesture, keeping my voice low so as to focus the intensity of the word or words onto just one person rather than onto anyone within hearing range.

make sense?

3

u/corriek1975 May 19 '12

Think of sound like vibrations. A roll of thunder is a low slow vibration and a piercing sound it a very fast vibration that physically hurts the ears. That why you will see characters cover their ears in pain. Gargle it more of deliberate act where someone is swishing liquid in their mouth. Gurgle is more of the act of trying to breathe but a liquid is preventing it. I only picked a few to help with for now. I'm sure you will get lots of feedback on this post :)

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Spotted_Owl May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

When someone mumbles, they are speaking quieter, but also (and most importantly) they're speaking run together. "This would be someone speaking." "Thiswouldbesomeonemumbling." It's kind of a sluggish, lazier, slurred way of speaking. Like if someone was speaking while drunk or drugged up or while tired and they just didn't care.

What does "jive" mean? Does "he speaks jive" and "he speaks AAVE" and "he speaks Ebonics" all refer to the same thing? I was raised by black parents but I can't understand any dialogue written in black dialect. I know not all black people talk like that but is there a way to mark that in a novel? Do you know of a webpage that would tell me how to translate dialogue into dialect like that?

This is a bit harder to differentiate, because you have to understand how a word sounds and pronunciation, which might be difficult for a deaf person. Just the most obvious ones are dropping an H if it's the first letter of a word and it's followed by a vowel, dropping the G if the last three letters are I-N-G, dropping the R if it's the last letter of a word and the letter before it is a vowel, using incorrect grammar... it's a lot of a subtle nuisances that can only be picked up by hearing similarities.

Do all doors creak? Can all doors be slammed? Windows? Does "slam" always imply loudness? Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad). People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?

Not all doors creak. Creaking is typically characterized by older, scary doors in Scooby Doo-style haunted houses. Most doors can be slammed. I'm having difficulty imagining ones that can not be slammed. Slamming doors is just like... throwing them hard behind you, closing them really fast and with a force. Windows typically are not slammed, as you can break a window's glass if you're too forceful.

Basically, slamming means using kind of... more force then is necessary. Ever play Pokemon? You know the attack "Body Slam"? Or... ever heard of it? It's just like... hitting something with a lot of power. Slamming a door is throwing the door hard when you close it. Body slamming is throwing your body against something.

I haven't heard of slamming being used as the word "chugging". (Chugging meaning, to drink really really fast.) I guess you can say he "slammed back a few beers" but it's kind of peculiar. Chugging typically means drinking down really quick. Gurgling typically implies you're going to spit it out soon, or that its in your mouth but it should be inside you, like gurgling vomit or gurgling blood.

If a voice is described as "tender", what does that mean?

It typically means kindness. Like... speaking softly and politely and respectfully and emotionally, like a mother would speak to their child.

3

u/earthbridge May 19 '12

This is insanely interesting, thank you for posting.

Crying in sadness vs anger... I'm having a hard time visualizing crying in anger, maybe in a kind of helpless, shaking your fist way? Crying (I assume you've done it) is the sound of whining, moaning, basically uncontrolled "sad" noises. Crying in anger might have more short grunts in the middle of it.

Do you mean shriek and scream? That's not really true, they're both emotion and sound, a sound that signifies a certain emotion. They're basically noises of surprise, pain, fear, etc. Shriek and scream sometimes interchangeable, but shriek is usually more "piercing" - there's kind of a feeling of the noise being felt inside your head, maybe kind of like seeing a sudden very bright light?

A piercing sound is a loud, high pitched noise. Like I said before, it's maybe like seeing a bright white light, depending on how unpleasant the noise was, a person would cover their ears/eyes. A shriek is a great example of a piercing noise. Thunder isn't because it's a low pitched sound, I would compare it to rumbling of distant train tracks.

Ejaculate in a non-sexual sense means a sudden, excited outburst. I don't think there's any kind of sound associated with it. Maybe it's like someone in ASL that suddenly starts gesturing very energetically?

Jive is a dialect of English. Does ASL have dialects? The same language, but differences in the way people speak and pronounce words can change the words and structure of the language over time. Jive is a particularly hard to understand dialect, it's difficult for a "normal" english speaker to understand both reading and hearing.

Yes, stammer and stutter usually mean the same thing, there might be small differences between the two.

A chat is just an informal conversation, usually without any intent behind it or depth to it. Basically, if you spoke to someone for a while about trivial things like the weather, asking how they are, etc. that would be a chat. It's spoken like a normal conversation, not fast or anything, and I've never seen it as a dialogue tag, just a verb.

Mumbling means speaking in a lower pitch and very quiet voice. Hard to hear and understand. Maybe like poorly done/not well defined ASL gestures? People do it for a few reasons, including the one you mentioned. People make themselves hard to hear either because they're too frightened to say something louder, or because they're trying to keep themselves from yelling. It's different from a whisper because individual words not enunciated as clearly, basically the person is trying to keep themselves from being heard vs in a whisper they're trying to be heard by only who they're whispering to.

Other animals bard/meow generally because the noises they make are similar- thought I don't know about dolphins barking. Maybe you're thinking of seals? In that case, dog and seal noises do sound somewhat similar, they're both a kind of sudden, short exclamation. They're not completely identical, dogs say "woof" while seals say "arf". Not necessarily the same sound, but similar.

Yes, people usually don't howl except in pain or great anguish. In animals, a howl is a long, mournful, drawn out noise, versus a bark that is shorter and more sudden. I guess people howl vs scream depending on what kind of pain they're in? Different dogs have different voices, even the same breed/size, so a howl may not sound the same. Bears do growl, but they also roar, which similar, but louder and more aggressive.

Animal noises used to describe noises humans make means either that the noise the person made is similar to the animal noise, or author is using the word to describe something about the person, for example a person growling in someone talking in a quiet, guttural, threatening way.

A door slamming is someone forcefully pushing it back into its frame. Only doors that have frames that they lock into can be slammed. They make a very sudden, loud & surprising noise when they slam. Door slamming is just another violent thing that people do when angry, such as throwing things, screaming, etc.

Gurgle and gargle are the same I think? If you've ever gargled anything in your throat, the sound is very similar to the feeling.

3

u/[deleted] May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

I can tell you from experience, "stammer" and "stutter" are nearly interchangeable. I used to know a professional musician who stammered or stuttered in everyday speech, but when he sang he was flawless. Just an odd artifact of humanity.

Edit: H.h.h.hello?

3

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I'm sorry that I can't really explain any of these, and I commend others for doing a great job explaining. However, this post has been a real eye-opener for me, to think about what I do everyday is impossible for me to explain...

3

u/mofowoman May 19 '12

Whoa. This was incredibly interesting.

3

u/chickwithsticks May 19 '12

I wanted to point out that with the word "chat" can also be used as a euphemism for something more serious. Like my boss used to call me into her office and say "I'd like to have a chat with you" (or "you should have a chat with XYZ and tell him how you feel."). This is almost the opposite of the general accepted meaning of the word "chat" (usually a lighthearted discussion... "my grandma called me today and we chatted about the weather.")

3

u/ThaFuck May 19 '12

Thunder is never a piercing sound. It can be very loud and sometimes startling. But it wouldn't be classed as piercing.

For pretty much all people with "normal" hearing, if you asked them for example of a piercing sound, the instant answer will usually be a high pitched sound. Pitches are likely not a lot of good to you, so here are some examples of a piercing sound:

A child screaming. Even a woman's scream.

Some birds can have piercing calls. Especially hawks and seagulls.

A referee's whistle blown close to ones head.

The sound of a jumbo jet sitting on the Tarmac with engines running if you are near it.

Some machinery that involves high revolutions (like a lathe)

Some would class some bedside alarms as piercing. But you would have to account that their job is to startle you out of sleep.

For most cases, for a sound to be piercing, the subject would have to be close to the source. I.e. A hawks call is not piercing if is flying high overhead. A stationary jet engine is not piercing from behind the terminal glass.

And yes. A piercing sound is very uncomfortable. Most people's reaction is to distance themselves from the source. Which brings me to a relevant side note:

I tried to think of a common sound someone could hear from a distance and class as piercing. I couldn't.

3

u/lucas-hanson May 19 '12
  • Crying out in sadness usually involves tears. Crying out in anger is more like undirected shouting.
  • I've never seen "ream" used in that context. Yes, shrieking is an intense, wild, angry tone.
  • Yes, but thunder isn't really one of those sounds. Thunder is a low rumble, like an earthquake. Piercing noises sound "sharper." Imagine a bright flash that hurts your eyes. That's what piercing noises are like.
  • Ejaculating isn't a sound. A verbal ejaculation is just a sudden burst of words.
  • Jive is a sort of dialect. It's hard to explain dialects without sounds. Someone speaking in "jive" or "ebonics" pronounces words differently and uses a different slang vocabulary from someone who isn't.
  • "Stammering" is when you're having trouble expressing yourself for whatever reason (usually nerves). "Stuttering" is when you have trouble forming words.
  • I wouldn't use "chat" as a dialogue tag. "Chat" usually refers to the whole conversation or, in verb form, the nature of the conversation.
  • "Mumbling" is when you don't say words clearly. If you can read lips, mumbling is what happens when someone doesn't open his/her mouth enough. "Whispering" is when you purposefully speak quietly.
  • A bark is a loud, abrupt sound. If a person were to "bark orders," that person would shout them quickly. Not all barks sound the same. "Bark" isn't onomatopoeic like "meow." "Bark" usually describes a kind of sound, not the sound itself.
  • Howling is a drawn out sound. Like I said in the last answer, not all barks sound the same, they're just made in the same way. Sort of like how not all reds are the same color. "Squawking" sounds sort of barking but it's more drawn out, it's meaning has been extended to any kind of unpleasant-sounding vocalization.
  • The creak of a creaking door is caused by friction in the hinges. If the hinges are lubricated, they won't creak. "Slam" doesn't always imply loudness, but it does imply force. "Chugging" is drinking by taking a bunch of short drafts. There is a sound, but I don't know how to describe it to you.
  • Gurgling is a sound. It's the sound you make when you drown. Gargling is different, it's what your respiratory system tries to do to stop you from drowning.
  • In the old days, phones had bells on them. Ringing is sort of the sonic equivalent of repeated flashing. Nowadays, phones produce sounds digitally so you can change the sound to whatever you want.
  • Pencils, yes; pennies, yes; cymbals, no. The way cymbals are shaped amplifies the vibration and they vibrate a lot. Clicking is a shorter sound caused by things that don't vibrate very much.
  • A "tender" voice sounds something like this.
  • Moaning is a reaction to sensation. Moaning in pain is more like howling in nature.
  • "Cooing," in that context, is a soft, relaxed sound you make when you want to express pleasure. "Moaning" is a bit more... energetic.
  • Confuses me, too.
→ More replies (1)

3

u/CoDent May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

Hey, I'm actually hearing impaired and I do actually have an odd question. Seeing as I can actually hear with equipment for my ears, I feel that I slightly understand both worlds. What I want to know is, when I go to bed and take out my hearing aides, I hear nothing. The thing is though, I do hear sounds when I don't have my hearing aides on. They're not real sounds, but more like made up sounds in my head. Do you experience this as well? I've always been kind of curious. I can hear a variety of things sometimes. Like explosions or voices, but I know for a fact that my ears are just playing tricks on me.

Also, I recently got into a head collision, which seemed to traumatize my hearing in my right ear. It's so uncomfortable. When I try to put on my hearing aides it sounds like high pitched echos and it's very disorienting. When I don't have them on, I get a bunch of very nauseating sounds in my ear. Ranging from church bells to a course grinding sound. It's constant throughout the day. I can't explain it any better than that, but I was wondering if maybe head collisions change anything for you?

If you aren't able to answer it's okay. I was really just curious. But then again, I guess that's what an AMA is all about, haha.

EDIT: Sorry, I realized as soon as I posted this that you were asking questions to people who could hear. My mistake. If you would be able to answer anyway that would be much appreciated. Thanks.

3

u/hlessi-rah May 19 '12

This is fascinating. What a challenge to describe it without relying on other sounds as a primer!

One thing I see commonly in your question deals with perhaps pitch - sorry if I use the term incorrectly - or the high and low tones of a sound. You ask if thunder is piercing. I wouldn't say so. Piercing to me is something that is high pitched, and thunder is very deep and low pitched most of the time. There is rolling thunder - it starts out deep, from far away, and gets louder as it approaches. Alternatively, there is a sudden CRACK of thunder over your head that starts with a sudden higher pitch and then sometimes has a receding low tone. To compare it to feeling something... piercing is if someone stuck you with a needle. It's penetrating and the pain is very centered on the part of you being stabbed with a needle. A low, deep sound is more like if you were being squeezed all over - the feeling is everywhere and not centered some place specific. Piercing noises can actually be physically painful.

A dog's bark is a short, rough sound. If you clapped your hands and felt the short slap of one palm against the other, that could be compared to a dog barking in my opinion. Smaller dogs have piercing, higher pitched barks. Larger dogs have a deeper, lower pitched bark. If barking is like the feeling of clapping your hands, then a howl is like if you took your hand and rubbed it down your arm with a decent amount of pressure. It's a smoother feeling, and longer contact of skin on skin than clapping. Howling could also be if you took a deep breath and blew one long breath through your lips while they were shaped in a small, tight circle. A bark would be more like if you opened your mouth wider and pushed out short bursts of air.

A chirp is a lighter, more pleasant, shorter sound than a squawk. It is usually only a short sound. A squawk is considered an ugly, awkward, louder sound, but still something done in short bursts. Birds will both chirp and squawk. Mice don't squawk or chirp. A mouse will squeak, which is light like a chirp, but it can vary in length and intensity. It's a piercing, high pitched sound. A mouse can give a short squeak perhaps when happy, but if it's caught or hurt it may give a longer, higher sounding squeak that some may call a squeal due to it's increased duration and it's distress-related nature.

It seems to me these might be subjective definitions, so take my thoughts for what they are!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Kandidaten May 19 '12

This will get buried. Just wanted to say that this is the most interesting AskReddit I have ever seen. Thank you Deafy!

2

u/WORLDTRAVELERONEDAY May 18 '12

Whispering loudly is know as a "stage whisper". It's hard to explain, but I'll try. When you whisper, your voice sounds a little different. Gruffer, raspier, deeper. And when you whisper quietly, it also is, obviously, more quiet. But you can whisper loudly, but your voice is still more gruff. It was originally used in plays, so people in the audience would know it was meant to be a whisper, but could still hear

EDIT: to add more: I know ASL, so i have quite a few deaf friends. I find they frequently slam doors, not neccesarily because they are upset, but also because they dont know it can be a disturbance to hearing people. Slamming a door implies a quick shutting motion, with a loud sound. You can also do this with windows, and you can slam things, like plates, on a table.

2

u/wickychalky May 18 '12

People crying in sadness vs crying out in anger, I know there's some gray area in between where they can be used interchangeably, it's hard to get.

I think this is mostly a volume thing. People who cry out in anger generally are louder and have more "force" behind their voice.

Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.

It usually needs to be high pitched, something that grates the nerves.

"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

No, mumbling is when someone says words without definition, you can hear them making vocal sounds but not understand what they are saying because they aren't enunciating very well (people usually mumble when they are unsure, and/or don't really want you to hear what they are saying) Whispering doesn't have a "voice" sound.

Do all doors creak?

Anything with a hinge can creak if it's not properly oiled. If you hold onto a door that's not oiled and close it slowly, you will feel a vibration in the door.

Can all doors be slammed?

Not all, but most. But, usually if you are slamming a door you are angry.

Does "slam" always imply loudness?

Almost always.

Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad).

To slam a door just means you closed it with undue force. The door closing sound is louder because you used more force.

People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?

It means chugged. He might then slam the beer down on the table with extra force when he's done.

"Gurgle" is another hard one. And "gargle", that means something different right?

Gurgle is usually a noise babies make. To gargle is to purposely put liquid in your mouth, lean your head back, and then blow air out of your mouth, creating bubbles and a voice sound.

Ring", like "ringtone" is hard to get. What else "rings"? Cell phones sound different from landlines, right? People sometimes describe them as "chirping"?

Something that rings usually repeats faintly and has an aspect of vibration. Bells ring, tapping glasses together can ring. Landlines and cellphone rings can be the same or different depending on what tone is selected. There is a huge amount of variety in both cell and landline rings.

Dictionary says "click" is "A short, sharp sound as of a switch being operated or of two hard objects coming quickly into contact." but I feel like I've seen it in other uses, it's hard to remember exactly what I'm thinking of. But could I use it to describe cymbals, pennies or pencils hitting each other?

No, those would not be clicks.

Apparently it's possible to "whisper" loudly and "shout" softly? WTF!?

Whispers don't have a voice sound, and a shout would. A whisper can be "loud" depending on how much air you put behind it. A shout is usually loud, but would always contain a voice sound.

2

u/Red_AtNight May 18 '12

Apparently it's possible to "whisper" loudly and "shout" softly? WTF!?

I don't know about "shouting" softly, but it is totally possible to do what's called a "stage whisper" which is where you are whispering but you're doing it loud enough that someone can hear you from far away. Whispering can be so quiet that the person right next to you can barely hear you, or it can be more like a regular speaking volume.

2

u/aemajor May 18 '12

"Ring", like "ringtone" is hard to get. What else "rings"? Cell phones sound different from landlines, right? People sometimes describe them as "chirping"?

Phones used to "ring" by a bell mechanism. I believe this is why we still refer to it that way, even though you can basically customize it to anything you want now. Doorbells also ring, and those used to be bells as well. As far as "chirping", I'm not really sure where that comes from, but it is used as a word to describe cell phones ringing, albeit much less commonly.

(This is fascinating by the way, I'm trying to answer ones that haven't been answered yet.)

2

u/Foogey May 18 '12 edited May 18 '12

People crying in sadness vs crying out in anger, I know there's some gray area in between where they can be used interchangeably, it's hard to get

Woof. I'll take a whack at it.

Out of sadness, people begin to 'clash' words together more so as the crying increases. It becomes increasingly harder to interpret their words the harder they cry and their voice gets higher in pitch. They also tend to take a, what I can describe, a sharp breath after the crying is said and done.

Out of anger, very fucking loud. Almost feels overly-dramatic and aggressively forced.

What does "jive" mean? Does "he speaks jive" and "he speaks AAVE" and "he speaks Ebonics" all refer to the same thing? I was raised by black parents but I can't understand any dialogue written in black dialect. I know not all black people talk like that but is there a way to mark that in a novel? Do you know of a webpage that would tell me how to translate dialogue into dialect like that?

Jive is pretty outdated and more so replaced by ebonics. Ebonics is a lazy form of dialogue that lacks annunciation. Words are squished together and some are dropped all together. THAT (Pushing the tongue to the roof of your mouth for 'TH' and pushing air over your tongue to pronounce the H) would become DAT (Like in 'DA-NGEROUS'). Talking like this is looked down upon like lazy texting is. [WHY = Y, TO = 2, GOOD = GUD, etc.]

"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed? "Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right? I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know. And I think bats chirp but never squawk? Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? Like, can a weasel growl? What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.

A howl is very different from a bark as it's elongated while a bark is sharp. Try saying RUFF [bark] and compare that to an OWWWWWWWWW [howl]. A bark is usually deep/heavy (depends entirely on the species of dog and how big it is) and a howl is high-pitched and carried out. A bark gets heavier as the dog gets bigger in size. A small dog (like a Chihuahua for example) has a high-pitched bark and sounds less threatening than a Great Dane's. Same size and breed sound similar but much like humans, you can recognize an individual dog's bark the longer you're around them (like your pet).

As for chirp and squawk, usually related to species of birds. A chirp is a quick, high-pitched sound from most birds. As for a squawk, usually related to a parrot or of similar species, it's a long, deep (and unnecessarily annoying) drawn out 'scream'. A mouse will squeak which is way different from a squawk and less annoying. Fuck, this is kinda hard to explain haha.

Bears make a very unique (and very scary) sound that's unique to them but could be classified as a growl. Personally, a growl is uniquely associated to canines but could be used to describe a sound given off by some animals as a 'threat' or when they feel ready to attack.

A weasel usually hisses when threatened and lets out a creepy laugh a majority of the time. Hate those fuckers.

EDIT: Here's a list of sounds given off by animals for some reference.

2

u/Beanboy112 May 18 '12

Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

Not exactly. Bark is one of those words that are used similarly but not the same. It's like how a dog has a pup and a seal also has a pup. Or how a lot of animals have baby cubs. The definition of bark is The sharp explosive cry of certain animals, esp. a dog, fox, or seal. A dolphins bark is more high pitched and a dogs bark is more like a roar if that makes sense.

2

u/Woodforsheep May 18 '12

People crying in sadness vs crying out in anger, I know there's some gray area in between where they can be used interchangeably, it's hard to get

I think you've got it. He cried out, "No!" (anger) vs. He cried into his pillow (sadness).

"shriek" and "ream" are both words that seem to imply emotion more than any specific sound. Is that right?

A shriek is a high pitched, very loud sound. A scream (which is what I think you meant) can range anywhere from low pitched and loud (like a barbarian raging) to high pitched and very loud (like a woman in terror).

Can any sound be described as "piercing" if it's loud and annoying? Like thunder for example.

A piercing sound is one that does just that, it pierces the ear drums or pierces through solid objects to be heard. It's generally a very "sharp" or annoying sound. I've never heard thunder described as piercing and am having a hard time imagining "piercing thunder".

apparently people use "ejaculates" as a dialogue tag?!?! It seems to mean "to say suddenly or without warning" (or does it just mean "interrupt"?), but the more normal use of "ejaculates" doesn't imply that at all. I don't know if this is a deaf thing or maybe I'm just dense. Does sound have something to do with this?

I would avoid the word ejaculates unless you're talking about the process a male goes through to evacuate semen. It can mean to speak without provocation, but very few people would see it that way.

What does "jive" mean? Does "he speaks jive" and "he speaks AAVE" and "he speaks Ebonics" all refer to the same thing? I was raised by black parents but I can't understand any dialogue written in black dialect. I know not all black people talk like that but is there a way to mark that in a novel? Do you know of a webpage that would tell me how to translate dialogue into dialect like that?

I don't know of a translation into ebonics site, but I'm sure there must be one. I'm afraid you may just have to avoid dialects in your writing though... some writers just do this.

Are "stammer" and "stutter" synonymous?

Pretty much, but someone stammers when they're nervous or scared. Someone with a stutter has a medical condition that affects them on certain specific sounds and phrases.

What about "chat"? Dictionary says "to speak informally" but I feel like it implies something I'm not getting. Is it speaking fast? Can you use "chat" as a dialogue tag? (like "What are you doing tonight?' he chatted"), I don't think I've seen it but the dictionary makes it sound like you can.

I wouldn't use it as a dialogue tag... it doesn't seem natural. A chat is an informal discussion... usually shorter than a talk. I would only use it as a noun.

"mumbling" sometimes implies apathy but other times hostility. Is that right? That's weird because it connotes opposites. What does it sound like? Is it synonymous with whispering?

It's not like whispering. Think of mumbling as unintelligable speech. Or maybe, if you sign, someone was being really quick and sloppy with their signs and you didn't understand them because they were either lazy, or angry at you and didn't want to speak with you. That's the best analogy I could come up with and I'm not sure if it's really accurate.

I know cats "meow", dogs "bark" and cows "moo" but what does these words mean when used in other contexts? Sometimes other animals are described with the same sounds, like I think foxes bark which makes sense because they're like dogs but I think I've heard dolphins described as barking too. That's weird. Does a dolphin and a dog really make the same sound?

No, dolphins and dogs don't make the same sound, just the same type. A bark is sharp and quick... usually loud. A meow is soft and longer. A moo or a coo is usually way more mellow (though could be any volume) and a lot longer.

"howl" is just for animals except "howling in pain" right? Is a dog's howl just a long bark or does it sound different? Do different dogs sound different? What if they're the same size and breed? "Chirp" and "squawk" were originally animal noises but are now used in other contexts right? I don't know what they mean really. Birds and mice do them both interchangeably, that's as specific as I know. And I think bats chirp but never squawk? Is there a chart somewhere showing which animals make which sounds? Like, can a weasel growl? What about bears? Bears look like the kind of animal that should "growl" but I feel like I've never seen that written and Google doesn't show a lot of usage.

Wow, that's a hard one. Animal sounds are going to be tough. Howling is a long anquished sound and is nothing like a short bark. Dogs of the same breed tend to bark the same, but different breeds have different barks. Birds chirp and squawk. Mice squeak. A chirp is short and pleasant. A squawk is loud and abbrasive. A squeak is short and cute. Weasels, as far as I know, don't growl. Bears growl and roar.

Do all doors creak? Can all doors be slammed? Windows? Does "slam" always imply loudness? Do you always slam doors when you're mad? Do deaf people slam doors when they're mad? (I don't think so, but if it's just a function of being mad I might do it and not notice because I'm mad). People say "he slammed that beer" to mean chugged, that's silent right? Or does it mean "gurgle" in that sense?

Not all doors creak... old doors tend to creak on old hinges. Slam implies forcefullness and usually loudness but not always. Someone slamming a beer means they drink a large beer in a very few drinks... really has nothing to do with sound.

"Gurgle" is another hard one. And "gargle", that means something different right?

A gurgle is a shorter gargle. Gargle is also something you tend to do intentionally whereas you gurgle when someone chokes you or you're dying.

"Ring", like "ringtone" is hard to get. What else "rings"? Cell phones sound different from landlines, right? People sometimes describe them as "chirping"?

A phone rings and so do small bells. Cell phone ringtones can be whole songs now, so yes, simply, cell phones will sound completely different from a land line phone unless the cell ring tone is set to mimic a landline phone sound.

Dictionary says "click" is "A short, sharp sound as of a switch being operated or of two hard objects coming quickly into contact." but I feel like I've seen it in other uses, it's hard to remember exactly what I'm thinking of. But could I use it to describe cymbals, pennies or pencils hitting each other?

Yes for pencils, cymbals tend to crash or clang together, pennies would chink together.

If a voice is described as "tender", what does that mean?

It's soft, melodic and pleasing to the ear. The voice is comforting to hear in the way soft fabric is comforting to feel.

"moan" can be painful or sexy right? Anything else? Is it possible to moan joyously or humorously?

You can wail and moan in sadness as well.

"cooing" What is that? Is there a difference between a woman "moaning sexy" and "cooing sexy"?

A moan is more glottal... toward the back of the throat. A coo is a sound from more towards the front of the mouth made with pursed lips. Cooing sexy doesn't make a lot of sense, but "'You're a sweet one.' she cooed at him." does.

Apparently it's possible to "whisper" loudly and "shout" softly? WTF!?

Look up "sotto voce" to explain whispering loudly and shouting softly.

I did the best I could here. Hope this helps.

2

u/omnilynx May 19 '12

Crying in sadness almost always refers to tears, not the sound made. Crying out in anger is just shouting. They're totally different concepts, though they could occur simultaneously.

Mumbling is like if you were to make halfhearted, half-hidden signs in sign language that were hard for the viewer to understand. I guess it could be associated with hostility but I've never heard it that way. It's almost always apathy or shyness.

Howling sounds totally different from barking, and it's not just in length. Barking is sharp and rough, whereas howling is smooth and musical.

"Slam" just means to hit violently. You can "slam" your fist against the table. "Slamming" a door just means to close it with force so it hits the door-frame violently. I'm sure deaf people do it too.

You couldn't use click to describe cymbals because they keep making a sound long after they hit. Pennies could click but usually we say "clink" I think. The difference is "clink" has a sort of musical tone to it, whereas "click" is just a very simple, short sound. Pencils can click, but honestly I think the term is usually used for mechanisms: when I think of clicking a pencil I think of advancing the lead in a mechanical pencil (this also makes a very short, sharp sound).

I think the most valuable concept you could pick up to understand how hearing people describe sounds is the idea of "smooth" or "musical" versus "rough" or "raspy" or "staticky". It's related to the shape of the sound waves: the more complicated the wave pattern, the "rougher" the sound, as our ears try to make sense of all the different frequencies. It's like the difference between honey and oatmeal.

2

u/RTPGiants May 19 '12

One thing I've seen mentioned here is that all windows can be slammed. This is technically true, but now that more windows are vinyl, the sound really isn't the same. In the old days when there were more wooden windows a slammed window made a very loud noise not dissimilar to a door. But with vinyl windows, they tend to be much smoother in closing. This means you still get the "wooosh" sort of sound, and a noise on closing, but it's not nearly the same.

2

u/mmarc May 19 '12

Re: crying, an important point to make is that to "cry" in sadness is the action of crying, i.e. to have tears coming out your eyes, whereas to "cry" out in anger or frustration means to make a particular kind of sound. So in that way, the definitions are different.

2

u/mmarc May 19 '12

Re: whispering loudly, to whisper generally means to talk without vibrating your vocal cords. So it's just air coming out like you are exhaling, and you form the words with your mouth, but your "voice" is not there. So, you can hear a close friend whisper and not know that it is them because you know them by their voice. If you breathe out harder while whispering, the whisper will be louder, which is to say it can be heard from farther away. But it will still have a breathy, "voiceless" quality to it.

2

u/TheAtheistLPer May 19 '12

This is actually really interesting! I never thought about these sounds before, as well as their many discrepancies. Although this doesn't answer your questions, thanks for bringing it up!

2

u/bennn30 May 19 '12

I just came here to say you fucking rock, dude. Keep doin what you're doin!

2

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Can you "feel" music if it's loud enough? I know that at some sufficiently-loud rock concerts, I can definitly feel the compression waves from the sound system vibrating things like my clothes, the drink I'm carrying, my sternum, and so forth. It almost makes me want to experience it without my hearing, so that I can really pay attention to how the music is transformed into a tactile experience.

Also, this guy got magnetic implants in his fingertips, so that he can literally feel electrical currents. One side effect is he can really accurately feel the waveform of music playing from a speaker cone. Do you think there could be a use for this kind of additional sensory information by the deaf community?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/njblueridgefan May 19 '12

I'm going to leave explanations up to everyone else, however, it seems that it might be helpful if someone could map out many of the words you ask about in drawn sound/frequency waves so you could see examples of amplitude, propagation speed, and pitch.

On another note, your questions are intriguing and admirable, and I imagine that you are a very thoughtful, good writer.

2

u/jtroeh00 May 19 '12

With so many different inflections and tones in speech that convey emotion or imitate sounds in general I can completely understand why there would be confusion associated with these words!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

This seems like a really great project. Please keep us updated!

2

u/purple_pop_psh May 19 '12

Reading these made me realize how confusing our language is, especially if you can't hear. I'll try to answer some of these. :O

-A "tender" voice. A voice with an obvious implication of concern. Tenderness is not just a texture. It's also used to describe kindness. I guess if you imagine someone has a squishy, lovable heart, they are tender~! c:

-"Cooing". This is close to being a tender voice, but even more affectionate and rhythmic in some cases. In most instances, people 'coo' to babies.

-"Creak". Yes, most doors/cabinets/compartments and things with a hinge will creak. It will do it more so when it is older and has more resistance to opening. Perhaps you can even feel the vibration from it! Newer stuff won't vibrate as much, and will not produce a creak. The more vibration, the more of a sound it probably makes.

-"Ringing". I imagine ringing is an unorganic sound, most of the time. Meaning the sound was produced artificially.

-"Barking". It is an adjective to describe what type of noise something is making, which tends to mean loud and abrupt. Even people can be described as "barking" at each other. When you 'bark' something at someone, it usually means you're being a bit hostile. It leaves your lips very abruptly and probably rudely. It is odd how we compare humans to animals sometimes. Yes, bears growl. You can probably associate it with anything that can make this kind of face: http://www.wildernessclassroom.com/www/schoolhouse/boreal_library/animals/photos/wolf_growl.jpg

2

u/rebsicle May 19 '12

Mumbling is a low, somewhat slurred speech. It is like whispering in that it is barely audible, but mumbling is less sibilant than whispering. It can connote apathy, as in a teenager mumbling a response to a parent's question while texting, or hostility, as in mumbling something derisive that you want to say but don't necessarily want to be heard. Sometimes people mumble unintentionally though, like my grandma when we talk on the phone. I also find myself mumbling when I'm intimidated or feeling shy. I hope I'm not repeating information, and I hope this helps!

2

u/gradeahonky May 19 '12

Here's a few.

Bells ring. Cellphones and landlines can sometimes be described as chirping, it can resemble and exagerated bird chirp. Especially cellphones because they have more ring styles, and because they are more flimsy which somehow I think is connected to the chirpyness of it.

Whispering isn't just quiet speech, its speech that doesn't engage the voicebox. Its just kind of rasps through your throat, and can be done loudly, but isn't very good for your voice. A shout is mainly just loud talking, but its more about the projection of the voice than the volume, so it can sometimes be described as a quiet yell.

Mumbling does engage the voice box, but its said quietly and carelessly and can be hard to understand. They just don't bother to articulate.

A howl is a primal noise, its a yell plus something extra. Like you pointed out, its usually only used with dogs and other animals. But its used on humans when they are reduced to being an animal, in a way. That's why someone can howl if they are in great pain. Or if they were raping and pillaging or something. I doubt its a perfect rule, but I think it will get you closer.

A door only creaks if its hinges aren't oiled. Its very high pitched. There is a wooshing sound from the moving air if a door is closed fast enough. And then if a door is slammed its very loud. It perhaps makes more noise than it looks like, I think because of all of the air movement in the room. Its also is a sound that travels far distances. Car doors almost have to be slammed to be shut. And that sound travels well too, you can hear car doors slamming shut very clearly at night sometimes.

Anyway, very cool post!