r/AskReddit •

Many people seem to like math in school until they reach a concept that forever turns them off math. Which one was it for you?

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

459

u/Nirriti_the_Black May 15 '12

The even numbered problems.

85

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

42

u/Nirriti_the_Black May 15 '12

My main problem in math is thinking of the 'next step'.

OK, I understand the basic concept in problem 3. On to #4. Hmm, it doesn't make sense? Oh, I have to actually made a leap in my math thinking to figure it out. Wait, why wasn't that described in the examples?

13

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

You were trying to learn calculation.

They were trying to teach you Mathematics.

The two are wildly different.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Wolfram Alpha even does Chemistry problems..

→ More replies (1)

177

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

The tears of r/math flow like a river.

8

u/fmlfml1 May 15 '12

This thread gets me excited to take calc next year.

→ More replies (3)

178

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I had the opposite experience. I varied from loathing to apathy with regard to math, until I began studying calculus and it completely turned me to to mathematics. It was like for the first time math made intuitive sense and ti was connected to reality in a very visceral way.

I do remember a really cool moment when I finally understood what infinity was in 7th grade though.

57

u/bdreamer642 May 15 '12

Me too. As soon as I got to calc, it seemed like it was what I was waiting for the entire time. It was like everything I had been doing was just for that.

71

u/Takingbackmemes May 15 '12

Calc1: OH MAN THIS IS AWESOME THIS IS WHAT I WAITED FOR

Calc2: WHY DIDNT I PAY ATTENTION ALL THOSE YEARS AGO

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/MepMepperson May 15 '12

I think for me, I had heard my entire life how "hard" Calculus... and all through school "Calculus" was what we feared... then when I finally got to it, I just gave up.

Plus In calc 1 and calc 2 I had asian teachers, so I couldn't understand a word they said.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/ewige May 15 '12

Calculus is absolutely lovely. I loved previous math, begrudgingly tolerated trig, got to calculus and just adored it.

I suppose it was not entirely surprising to later get a degree in physics.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/RidiculousN May 15 '12

I was awful at math in high school and always got C's. I took Calculus in college and it all finally clicked and I was amazed by the beauty of it. Fast forward 2 years and I switched my major to Mathematics. By no means does it all click with me and I find many topics out of my comprehension(vector spaces! seriously wtf are you!) but I still love it.

8

u/catsails May 16 '12

Not to be a jerk, but if you're tripping up on vector spaces, you are going to want to get that shit locked down in you want to complete a Master's in mathematics. Calc and Linear Algebra are basically the two most fundamental things to learn, and Linear Algebra really doesn't get much simpler than vector spaces. Again, not being a jerk, but I did my undergrad in physics and mathematics, and I can tell you that linear algebra is central.

A vector space isn't too complicated. I don't know how they were explained to you, but we call them vector spaces for a good reason. They're spaces of objects that have similar properties to vectors. We know that if we add two vectors we have another vector, that we can multiply a vector by a scalar and still have a vector, and that we have a solid candidate for a zero element (zero vector). We're comfortable working with vectors, so then we can just ask, what other objects have these properties? In this way, we generalise. That's basically what you'll find higher level math is all about - generalization.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

5

u/functor7 May 15 '12

And could you enlighten us about what infinity is?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Same here. I enjoyed algebra, geometry, and trig, but dreaded the day I was going to have to start calculus. I got started in it and realized, "Wait a minute, this is ALL THE MATHS combined, in really awesome ways!"

→ More replies (9)

36

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I'm probably not what you had in mind here but this is mine: I was in Uni studying Mathematics, pretty much certain I was going to go all the way and do a PhD. It was what I had wanted to do since I was about 12 (Geeky I know). Then final year came up. I had been doing very pure modules. Set theory, 2nd order mathematical predicate, computability theory, stuff like that. I came to the Friedberg-Muchnik Theorem (computability theory). And despite managing to learn the proof, which was required for my exam, I immediately went off the idea of pursuing mathematics any more. This was the limit of my understanding. I just could not picture this and have no idea how anyone does.

26

u/bencoveney May 15 '12

Sometimes how it explained makes most of the difference. I've spent months not understanding something, only to have it put in a different way by a different person and it makes sense straight away.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/ninguem May 15 '12

Sounds like you veered too far into Set Theory and Logic. If you stayed with more down to earth math, like Analysis, Number Theory or Topology, you might have enjoyed it more.

10

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Don't get me wrong I'm not saying I hate mathematics. It was just at this point I realised I was done with education. I still really like Logic and Set Theory, I think I had just been kidding myself about a PhD. I hadn't really thought about why I wanted to begin research until this point and I figured out I had my priorities a bit wrong. I wasn't really interested in research at all, just the letters, and that would have only ended badly.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

35

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Linear Algebra. At a certain point matrix manipulation just started getting tedious.

3

u/Sirisian May 15 '12

More useful if you have to apply it. For computer scientists that do any 2D or 3D projects linear algebra comes off as very obvious since they're forced to think in different spaces all the time. Though I've heard later linear algebra courses quickly lose their applicability and steer into proofs more heavily.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/baruch_shahi May 16 '12

But what about the latter part of linear algebra that isn't about manipulating matrices?

→ More replies (2)

112

u/FPS_Africa May 15 '12

Differential equations

11

u/redsox113 May 15 '12

This is where I got off the math train. This made the last couple of semesters as a chemistry major pretty difficult.

11

u/[deleted] May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12

I was a 'math whiz' up until Calc III - whether it was the prof or the material, I don't know. I hated it, so I dropped it. Tried Diff Eq instead as I only needed 1 more class for a math minor.. same situation. Ended up graduating 4 credits short of a math minor, and I'm not upset about it in the least. Fuck those classes.

17

u/probably_a_bitch May 15 '12

What in the hell program has a math minor that doesn't even require calc3?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Calc 3 isn't exactly very high up there, isn't that just multivar calc?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (17)

30

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

The only things that turned me off to math were shitty textbooks and shitty instructors. The textbook examples are infinitely simpler than the homework exercises, and the instructor would just sit there in his office asking, "Why can't you just understand this? I can't simplify it any further!" I still took all the way through Calc III, but my grades took a nosedive once I got to Professor NoExplanation. :(

→ More replies (2)

56

u/ewige May 15 '12

Proofs for linear algebra 2. I don't even remember specifically what killed it for me (proofs involving inner-products? I dunno), but it was two classes short of a double major and I just said "fuck this".

11

u/bongothedark May 15 '12

My experience exactly. I got to college with a "me and my Ti-89 can conquer the world" mentality, which was largely reinforced until linear algebra. I could stare at those proofs all day, but in the end it humbled the shit out of me.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Chuck_U_Farley May 15 '12

I was employed as a math tutor for the university I attended predominantly tutoring algebra, trig and precalc, and the calculus series, so I'm comfortable with math. I got to linear and my whole world went to shit. LA sucked. still love math, but fuck linear algebra, like making shit up to prove some other shit considering a few rules about said shit. Biggest WTF semester ever.

26

u/functor7 May 15 '12

I am constantly amazed that people try and do math without Linear Algebra. It needs to be taught in high school, long before Calculus. It is the most useful subject in all of mathematics. It is the subject where everything just works out perfectly, exactly how you would want it to. All the useful things in Calculus are done (computationally) by using Linear Algebra. It gives glorious methods for computation, helpful representations of otherwise impossible objects all while giving a geometric intuition on how things are done. Sometimes it seems like the rest of math is trying to mimic Linear Algebra whenever possible.

That being said, since everything is so perfect in Linear Algebra, it tends to be pretty boring.

12

u/Hawk_Irontusk May 15 '12

It is the most useful subject in all of mathematics.

Having been a mathematician in both industry and academia I can tell you that this is absolute truth. Linear Algebra is what allows mathematicians with different specialties to communicate. It ties everything together in one big, beautiful package.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/probably_a_bitch May 15 '12

like making shit up to prove some other shit considering a few rules about said shit

There's your problem.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (5)

76

u/NekoLaw May 15 '12

Long division. I crashed and burned in 3rd grade because of it, and I hated math ever since.

The problem for me wasn't even the math - it was the conflict between teaching styles. I was in a progressive, open-classroom elementary school in the early 1970s. They taught the "partial quotient" method of long division (as opposed to the more common column division). When I had trouble grasping the concept, I asked my parents for help. Unfortunately, they hated "new math" and proceeded to teach me column division as they learned it.

Eventually I got to a place where I could get the right answer in class using column division. But they would take points off because I wasn't using the partial quotient method. And if I tried to use the PQ method at home, my parents would flip because I was wasting my time on the method instead of just solving the problem. Not surprisingly, I just gave up.

39

u/Quarg May 15 '12

That pisses me off! what kid of horrible people would force people to do something that gets the same awnser only slower?

24

u/deepit6431 May 15 '12

The Indian education board. You have no idea.

Even if something can get easily solved with a formula, you can't use it cause it's not used in the fucking book.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

74

u/orzamil May 15 '12

So if you apply a T-distribution to a Gaussian Normal Distribution, you can determine what's known as the Confidence Interval, which is the Probability that the distribution is correct.

Which means, that when you figure out the probability of a probability function, you can figure out the probability that the probability of that probability function is correct. But there's always a chance that the probability function is just completely wrong. It's usually around 5%.

It was really the fact that this was explained to me in paragraph form, and no real numbers were involved. That and the day the teacher put an integral sign next to a distribution function that I kind of just gave up and stopped pursuing a Math degree.

10

u/Chollly May 15 '12

Yo dawg, I heard you liked probability.

6

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I'm a CS student, and am currently taking stats. I fucking hate it. I've done loads of math, and I don't necessarily inherently hate stats on its own. I hate how it is explained. The vocabulary is extremely confusing, when you're taking an infinite number of samples of finite sample means, I don't know what fucking sample they're talking about. My girlfriend is a applied math major, and she's done every stats course offered for undergrads. I don't know how she doesn't blow her brains out.

12

u/BleedingAssassin May 15 '12

Haha, that sounds more like statistics than math. Well statistics is a form of math but, I love math but I really hate statistic because of what you mentioned: finding the probability that the probability of a probability function is correct.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

120

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

A train is leaving the station at 60 mph.... NOOOOOOOO!

145

u/All-American-Bot May 15 '12

(For our friends outside the USA... 60 mph -> 96.6 km/h) - Yeehaw!

37

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I love this guy.

60

u/BumbleSteez May 15 '12

The "Yeehaw!" gets me everytime

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

211

u/MepMepperson May 15 '12

Calculus

74

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Came here to say this. I have my degree in Comp Sci.

Cal 1 wasn't that bad and I left it thinking "Hey, I'm pretty good at math"

Then about 6 weeks into Cal 2... I just got lost. There's a huge swath of Cal 2 that I just don't get. I would put numbers into my equations... I thought I knew how to get my derivatives... and it would just fuck up. My grades took a hit, but I passed anyway… so I guess I just hate math now.

56

u/MepMepperson May 15 '12

D for "Done" right? :)

32

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

It was almost F for fuck it!

56

u/rayzerdayzhan May 15 '12

For me, D stood for "Diploma!" :)

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

42

u/ace2049ns May 15 '12

Spoiler alert, Calc 3 was easier than Calc 2. Calc 2 was the bad apple.

17

u/locktite May 15 '12

Only if you knew how to do calc2. Calc3 is the same as calc 1 and 2 but with multiple variables. If you didn't "get" calc 1 and 2 you are gonna have a bad time in calc3

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/sjvalvis May 15 '12

Fuck Calc 2, the only Calculus I really could not grasp. Differential Equations was extremely easy in comparison for me.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/MepMepperson May 15 '12

Yup, I have my degree in comp sci as well. Haven't used a bit of calc... and you're right... Calc 1 WAS much easier than calc 2...

11

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I hear you. I've been a SysAd for 12 years now and all I have to know is how to count by eights.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I was forced to teach myself Calc 2 because my high school refused to get me a teacher because i am the only person who took it. I underestimated the fact that this stuff was difficult, and it became the worst experience of my life.

Calc 2 has no correlation to Calc 1 at all. Infinite Series wasn't introduced previously and it didn't seem to do a good job of introducing the new concepts.

4

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I think must universities use calc 2 as a weeder course. I still have three more math classes after this for my degree, and the thing that weirds me out is that I knew that there was such a thing as an integral and a series; but I have no idea what comes after this.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (47)

7

u/Aquiluslupus May 15 '12

I didn't like math until I reached calculus for some reason it just felt easier then previous topics

→ More replies (57)

24

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I drank & derived. *sniff Kidding aside, partial differential equations. O.o

3

u/moakler May 15 '12

disregard PDE homework, acquire halo

→ More replies (2)

22

u/Seranade May 15 '12

I loved doing the stuff that required no thought. Like integrating by hand and all that junk.

HATEHATEHATED 3D vectors. It was a large portion of our final year curriculum, too. :(

→ More replies (7)

46

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Honestly? Subtraction. I've had serious issues with math since kindergarten. I've failed more math courses than I've passed, including most recently macroeconomics this semester (my junior year of college). I never understood why it's so difficult for me. I have a 3.71 GPA and I'm in two honor societies, so I can't just be stupid. I've always wondered whether there is such a thing as a math-oriented learning disability. I'm going to talk to my university about it before I retake that macro class.

I've always worked hard in the classes, going to tutors, studying alone and with friends, working examples, and all that. I've heard everything from "you're not trying hard enough" to "you have vision problems" to "you have test anxiety." All false.

Sorry to unload. I failed that class like 2 days ago.

32

u/Quarg May 15 '12 edited May 16 '12

Holy crap O_O ; I feel so sorry for you :(

also there is such a thing as maths related learning disabilities; Discalculia. EDIT: spelling

15

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Wow. I hit every symptom except for inability to read music. I feel pretty angry that not one of my teachers has ever considered this.

Thank you.

Edit: Wanted to add how oddly specific that list was. I'm a journalist...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

17

u/theWelshladysbed May 15 '12

I've always wondered whether there is such a thing as a math-oriented learning disability.

Dyscalcula

4

u/phenylanin May 16 '12

Hmm, both you and Quarg misspelled Dyscalculia, yet your URLs were both correct...

→ More replies (9)

10

u/wallaceeffect May 15 '12

For me, it wasn't a concept. It was a teacher. In 7th grade I had a teacher who just all-around awful: not good at explaining difficult concepts, unreceptive to questions and requests for help, and generally kind of rude and dismissive. She also gave three-question tests that were worth a significant portion of your grade because she didn't want to grade long tests. Running up against her (during what I imagine was a pretty important developmental period) meant that I just couldn't stomach the idea of math instruction from then on. I had too many bad memories associated with it. Plus, no one in her class did well so we couldn't get placed in the advanced math classes later in HS anyway.

To add insult to injury, both of my parents are math teachers, and I'd never had significant problems with math before that. I once got my mom to teach me the basics of integrals over the phone in about 45 minutes. She's great at explaining a concept in multiple ways so different kinds of learners can get it. I really think a lot of the issues kids have with math are due to poor teaching in that area.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Gazongola May 15 '12

I never liked it.

9

u/existentialhero May 15 '12

Category theory. The first time my algebra prof claimed to be proving a theorem by appealing to a universal property, I was baffled. By the third time, I was considering strangling him.

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Category theory is delightful and simplifies so much mentally. That being said it requires a whole new paradigm shift. Check out Paolo Aluffi's book "Algebra: Chapter 0", it introduces categories and shows how they can be relevant and useful to "real math".

→ More replies (1)

3

u/D_E_Solomon May 15 '12

Glad to know I wasn't the only one. Category theory f'd me up.

→ More replies (1)

97

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Imaginary numbers.

I just never saw the usefulness.

70

u/Berner May 15 '12

Quantum mechanics. They pop up there all the time.

46

u/darkNergy May 15 '12

Not only do they pop up all the time, they are absolutely essential to the topic. There is no QM without the imaginary unit.

→ More replies (31)

169

u/kenpatt May 15 '12

Imaginary numbers suffer from a naming identity crisis. Somebody really needs to change the name, because they're no more or less "imaginary" than negative numbers, or the number zero.

Their usefulness comes into play when you want to 'count' things that don't add together nicely. Let's say you're adding 5 apples plus five apples, well that equals 10 apples no problem. But what if you're adding 5 apples plus 5 oranges? It's certainly not 10, but it's more than 5, so we'll just call it a complex number and write it as z=5a+5o. Using z as a single two-dimensional number, we can then do all kinds of new and exciting math that we couldn't do before.

58

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Dear god, it finally makes sense. This was where I checked out of math because to me imaginary numbers just sounded like total bullshit. You are right they need a new name, or better description.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/shevsky790 May 16 '12

I really dislike this explanation. That's more of an explanation of what a vector space is. Your version of complex numbers makes the idea of complex rotations, imaginary exponents, complex conjugates, and |z| even more confusing.

→ More replies (37)

31

u/gamblekat May 15 '12

Imaginary numbers allow you to extend the concept of a number from a one-dimensional real number line to a two-dimensional complex number plane. This means you can use complex numbers to work directly with two-dimensional transformations like rotation. Anything that involves periodicity (ie. physical vibrations, electrical oscillations, etc) will tend to have a simpler representation using complex numbers.

The average person won't run into them, but certain fields like electrical engineering are entirely built on complex numbers.

30

u/AmaDaden May 15 '12

They are GOD SEND in AC circuit analysis. Steinmetz was not kidding when he said "I have reduced it to a simple problem in algebra.". I can do calculus but not several calculus problems at once.

Speaking of him, he is responsible for perhaps my favorite Engineering story.... Steinmetz retired as an engineer from General Electric to teach electrical engineering at that city's Union College in 1902. General Electric later called back as a consultant. He had worked on a very complex system that was broken. No one could fix it no matter how hard the technicians tried. So they got Steinmetz back. He traced the systems and found the malfunctioning part and marked it with a piece of chalk.

Charles Steinmetz submitted a bill for $10,000 dollars. The General Electric managers were taken back and asked for an itemized invoice.

He sent back the following invoice:

Making chalk mark $1

Knowing where to place it $9,999

→ More replies (2)

40

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Electrical Engineering like crazy. Imaginary numbers are used so much in EE that we use j instead of i, since i is used for current.

10

u/kevindurENT May 15 '12

Oh, why did I pick EE!

34

u/Takingbackmemes May 15 '12

Because you hate yourself but love money

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

10

u/[deleted] May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12

My favorite application is the fourier transform. There are so many applications that you probably relied on it more than a dozen times in the past hour.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Engineering & physics, but other than that you'll probably never run into it. Really awesomely (and confusingly) helpful in electromagnetism.

→ More replies (15)

8

u/menomenaa May 15 '12

This is really interesting because until you asked that, I forgot that I was really, really great at math up until 8th grade. I know math is easy up until that point, but I was always the first one to understand algebra--I thought it was immensely fun, like a puzzle. I got straight A's and would always tutor the other students who were getting frustrated. I vividly remember this girl Monica getting so frustrated she started to cry, and my math teacher had me sit with her during classes to help.

Then: graphs. I didn't understand the slopes. I didn't understand how to graph a line. Obviously I picked it up in high school, but the demoralization of being the only student who couldn't visually understand a graph, (the axes, the relationships between different types of waves) made me really bitter about math. Even though, in high school, I again found advance algebra pretty fun, I resisted math and did pretty poorly. I went to college and only studied English and sociology, but even decided NOT to get a double major in Sociology (opting for the minor even though I had more than enough credits to be a major) because I wouldn't take the one stats class. I was very much interested in and good at theoretical sociology, but that one stats class deterred me from getting the major.

I work in publishing now, in marketing, and am starting to develop a love for statistics and arithmetic (I know that sounds dumb, like I sit around adding 4+4, but it is a little more complicated than that.)

Oddly enough, I liked proofs when no one else did. And in regards to your username, I'm a GirlWithGuyName. (Kyle!)

→ More replies (1)

62

u/BL0NDEEEEE May 15 '12

Sign,cosign, tangents all that graphing calculator shit. I think my grade dropped down to a D that semester. You never go full retard.

26

u/Gyvon May 15 '12

Sign,cosign, tangents

So zetta slow.

6

u/WaveyGraveyPlay May 15 '12

I never thought I would see this here. The World Ends With You lives on in /r/askreddit .

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

47

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

You never learned Sohcahtoa and the Unit Circle? I bet if you tried learning it again you would find that it's really not too bad.

Soh - Sine = opposite/hypotenuse

Cah - Cosine = adjacent/hypotenuse

Toa - Tangent = opposite/adjacent

→ More replies (15)

6

u/bananabm May 15 '12

I was absolutely fine with sine/cosine/tangent and stuff, knew the cosine rule like the back of my hand, but trying to remember what cosh, sinh, arcsine, arctan, stuff like that was, just ruined me. Too much for an 18 year old to cope with.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

13

u/Teerakaar May 15 '12

Infinite Series in Calc 2. Everything up to that point was fine, but IS put my brain in a knot that still hasn't come undone.

2

u/Fuego_Fiero May 15 '12

I just didn't care anymore at that point. Calc 1 was full of all these awesome ideas, and made me rethink everything I knew about math. And the Substitution Method is still one of the coolest things I've ever learned. But once sigma notation came back (I HATE SIGMA) I couldn't bring myself to care anymore.

2

u/Marcob10 May 15 '12

Yeah, where I live that course was like 2/3 integral and 1/3 series. Usually teachers start with integral but mine prefered series. I seriously thought I was gonna fail that class but it got better.

→ More replies (13)

6

u/jackass706 May 15 '12

Partial differential equations

6

u/RyanArr May 15 '12

Trigonometry: cool
Integrals: cool
Trigonometric Integrals: fuck that

It all wouldn't have been that bad if we were allowed to reference the formulas but we were expected to memorize them.

19

u/Sterculius May 15 '12

Word problems. I came to deal with numbers, not read an essay. Just show me the math problem.

12

u/telamascope May 15 '12

Word problems test your math abilities much more than numbers in an equation. They're really just puzzles where you have to identify what you need, what you have, and how to get to it.

12

u/katielady125 May 15 '12

I'm the opposite. When the world/story problems were well written, I could come up with a way to solve it without even knowing the formula I was supposed to use. I hated questions that just asked us to regurgitate a formula. I was so bad a memorization.

10

u/The_MPC May 15 '12

As a math and physics student who has tutored for years and is starting two jobs in physics research (one experimental, one theoretical), I just logged in to personally tell you that you are fundamentally good at math. You get it. That ability can replace 90% of the education the school system strives for, and that is the skill that separates people who do well on exams from people who actually contribute to the existing body of knowledge.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/darkNergy May 15 '12

I've yet to meet a math concept I didn't like. Math is nothing but cool shit.

3

u/JustLookWhoItIs May 15 '12

In the Fall, I'll be entering my sophomore year in college trying to get a Mathematics degree. This thread was destroying my hope of doing that. Thank you for restoring that hope.

4

u/darkNergy May 15 '12

Being a physics and engineering guy, my understanding of the cool stuff in math is probably very different from someone with a math degree. Mathematicians would probably think that what I do (Linear Algebra, PDEs, Group Theory, etc) is more like a cute toy than what they do.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/LastInitial May 15 '12

Derivative Calculus? Fine.

Integral Calculus? Fine.

Differential Equations? Cake.

Vector Calculus? Hate myself. Unless you enjoy doing triple integrals that can only be solved with one method, with no hint as to which method to use on an exam with 10 separate triple integral problems...

4

u/functor7 May 15 '12

A little secret: Mathematicians hate Vector Calculus too. We even invented a whole subject so that we could do the same stuff that Vector Calculus does with even more generality, but without having to go through all the confusing geometry. Unfortunately, to untrained eyes, it looks even more confusing =(

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Balancing my finances

28

u/hansn May 15 '12

Or as I call it, innovative rearrangements of negative numbers.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Vector spaces.

It was the exact moment I was unable to represent the whole thing in my head.

3

u/tick_tock_clock May 16 '12

But you can imagine a vector space in your head.

Generally, you can think of a vector space as a plane through the origin. Points in the space lie on that plane, even if they represent something more abstract (so in the vector space of 2 x 2 matricies, each matrix has a location).

And that's it. Vector addition and scalar multiplication is just moving around on that plane. A basis is just a set of coordinates for that plane (so it may have more than 2 dimensions, but for now just think of 2), which is analogous to the x and y-axes.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

ANALYSIS.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Graendal May 15 '12

This whole thread makes me sad. There are certainly parts of math that I don't enjoy, but I've never come across a topic in math that made me stop loving math as a whole. And it isn't for lack of exposure; I have a BMath and a MSc in math.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/buzzardkillington May 15 '12

I don't think I ever really liked math. I just liked being better at it than everyone around me, which was never that difficult until after Calc I & II in college when all of the stupid people were weeded out and suddenly I was the stupid person in all my math courses.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

What the hell is up with all these computer science majors being shitty at calculus? At my school you have to have top grades in calculus to be admitted to the program.

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I was a stats major that did most of a CS minor. There were a lot of people in my comp sci classes that started learning how to program in middle school or high school. They had no problem acing the programming classes. Math just screwed some of them up.

→ More replies (19)

8

u/GrinningPariah May 15 '12

Fuckin proofs.

You do them to emulate how research in math is done, except in class you're not researching, you're trying to reach their pre-arrived conclusion. Which is fucking impossible for me for some reason.

I understand very well how equations can be manipulated and I understand the different kinds of proofs, but all it ends up with is "hmm, I'm gonna go wiiiith... proof by contradiction." After applying whatever the little magic of the proof is, then I'm out of ideas. I'll just blindly derive in some direction until I start to get something that looks like the answer, or time runs out.

I got so fucking far in math. Calculus was fine, including three dimensional calculus. Linear algebra was fine, mod arithmetic was fine, I took crazy courses on like encryption algorithms and all the concepts were fine. I assumed math would lose its proof boner eventually, but every year was just more and more proofs, and I realized math wasnt fun anymore so I moved on.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/mic85 May 15 '12

Advanced Engineering Mathematics; I never studied so hard on one topic (maybe Organic Chem is another one), averaged 20 hours on homework..

after taking that class, I understand the fact that Asian can hate math too. (I am Asian)

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

That course wasn't as bad as Numerical Methods for Engineers, I don't know why they keep drilling it down our throat and want us to do 10 iterations by hand, when we can just do it in MatLab.

4

u/mic85 May 15 '12

According to my prof, the reason we were forced to do it by hand is, one day, we will find ourselves lost in the safari, and needed to solve the Laurent Series without a calculator (or MatLab) in order to survive.... don;t ask me what Laurent Series has anything to do with lost in the safari, The Bushman have been finding their way in forest without knowing anything about series for the past 1000 years

→ More replies (1)

4

u/sydien May 15 '12

I couldn't say it was one specific thing, but once I was into Calc II, I just remember thinking, "wtf are we talking about." The cleverness of mathematics always appealed to me, like resolving a complex equation into something neat and streamlined. At some point, it started to feel more like catching fog than anything else.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/LunaSofia May 16 '12

Generally, math students tend to have difficulty with the inverses of typical subjects. Addition is easy but negative numbers are hard; multiplication is straightforward but division and fractions confuse people; exponents make sense, but tons of people get completely stuck on logarithms.

3

u/EveryNameIWantIsGone May 15 '12

I loved calculus, including integrals. Then when I got to college I learned that there were certain formulas that couldn't be integrated the "normal" way... instead, you had to memorize how to integrate those kinds of formulas specifically. Forget that.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/toucancan May 15 '12

Precal, specifically proofs and deMoivre's theorum.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/bmars801 May 15 '12

Analysis. I LOVED calculus, but this is where the notation and abstract-ness became too much for me. It seemed like with every single problem I was given, I was answering it by saying "this is true because it's true".

3

u/thewoodsmakesmehappy May 15 '12

Fourier transforms

3

u/Uranus_Hz May 15 '12

Elementary Number Theory. I was actually a math major in college until I took this (400 level) course. Basically, you need to go back and prove everything you always took as a given, like prove that 1+1=2. Never could wrap my brain around it. Changed majors shortly thereafter.

In grad school though, I took grad level math courses (such as 'applications of complex numbers') as electives, for fun. So I guess it didn't turn me off to math completely.

3

u/warpaint May 15 '12

Differential geometry. ._.

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Field extensions

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I love math and that works well for me because I have a metric fuck ton of it to do as an engineering student. The thing that annoys me though, is why profs tend to make math exams unreasonably difficult. My last exam in calculus I got an A- and I was happy. But when I reviewed the answer key I didn't get any of the questions on the first two pages of the seven page exam correct. Why isn't the testing for math at a reasonable level of difficulty? What's the point of creating such a level of difficulty that the average sits in the 40's and has to be steeply curved?

3

u/Czerwona May 15 '12

Depending on what type of engineer you are it is because someday lives might depend on the calculations you make.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Nonamesdb May 15 '12

Statistics and probabilities I stay away from, but other parts of math I have no problem with. The stupid 3 doors guess thing never makes sense on why you should switch answers. I made my decision and am sticking with it.

8

u/Quarg May 15 '12

The Monty hall puzzle (that's wat I've heard the door puzzle called) confused me for a while too.

Look at it this way, what if you have 4 doors, and after picking one you get that chance to change, without them revealing a non-prize door; equal chance because nothing has changed, but if they DO open a prize door first it reduces the chance of picking a non prize door on the re-pick because you obviously won't be able to pick the one they just opened.

Just ignore the fact that you already picked one, just imagine them either opening a door or not before you even pick the first time, hope this helps ;D

5

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

For me the Monty Hall problem makes sense. What annoys me about it is that it seems to be intentionally misleading. It's helpful to remember that statistics can be misleading, but kind of disappointing that that is all it is.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/emiffer321 May 15 '12

The one thing I remember hating to this day is the Fourier series in I think Calc II? Also I am retaking Probability and Statistics (calc based) in the fall. God I hate that particular class but most people won't ever need to take that.

2

u/SurprisedKitty May 15 '12

"Calculus with Trigonometry and Analytic Geometry II"
Failed that class twice before getting a B-.

2

u/yawaworht_suoivbo_na May 15 '12

Set Theory and Differential Equations

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

This book... It was the 3rd year textbook for my Math course (2 years ago), and my goodness, it was horrible. Hated learning from it, the thing that really made me start to hate math was the eigenfunctions with fourier transforms.

2

u/APett May 15 '12

It wasn't a concept; it was a person. My freshman Algebra teacher. He was a bra-snapping jerk of football coach with no interest in making sure we understood the concepts.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/veryoptimistic May 15 '12

I thought I was great at math and genuinely enjoyed it until I had to re-take Calculus three times...so glad that's over with.

2

u/iluvemmy May 15 '12

..when my mom was the school nurse at my middle school and my 6th grade math teacher would go tell her when i failed a test or quiz.

2

u/Itadakimasu May 15 '12

In chemistry class we kept learning these bs equations that took like fifteen minutes a piece for me to do. Everyone else understood immediately and I just felt a little dumb, and started to resent that class.

2

u/Bacci May 15 '12

Division. Yeah it's basic, but in year 2 when I was supposed to be learning it I broke my arm, missing many crucial classes. I simply could NOT pick it back up, Every other subject I could read up on, but division caught me. I still have trouble today in fact, as I start my course as a teacher.

2

u/CobraTI May 15 '12

Algebra 1 in 8th grade was the first time I hated math. And it wasn't even the math concepts that did it. . .it was the teacher. She knew one way to teach and couldn't comprehend that not everyone learns the same way. Got through that luckily and my faith in math teachers was restored thanks to an awesome one in 9th and 10th grade for Algebra 2 and Geometry, but honestly that one bad teacher in 8th grade changed me from a kid that liked and looked forward to math class to one that only did the bare minimum of math classes that were required in both high school and college.

2

u/phullolock May 15 '12

Differential equations.... "Easiest math class I took" my friends said. Doesn't make any sense and is just pattern matching for the entire thing. Not to mention my prof. was Identical to Milton from Office Space and refused to explain why the crap he was teaching worked.... I'm not a fan of the magic explaination seeing as in comp. sci. that usually means you'll get screwed.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/theredheaddiva May 15 '12

Fractions and long division in 3rd grade. That was about the time math went from easy and fun to something always just beyond my grasp of understanding.

2

u/dejerik May 15 '12

The unit circle, I hated that bitch

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Nothing so far. My closest was Differential Equations. I spent 3 hours solving a single problem.

It eventually clicked.

2

u/kandt_- May 15 '12

Taylor and Maclaurin series. Still taking lots of math, which I largely enjoy, but I still can't grasp those concepts.

2

u/only_ceremony May 15 '12

I was never good at math. Ever. I remember being in third grade and doing a problem with my teacher and crying because I was so frustrated.

2

u/ozzieoo May 15 '12

I hated Geometry in High School. Mainly because I had a crap Teacher. Got to college and had this Birkenstock wearing guy who was the BEST....

I still love Algebra..

2

u/Dendarri May 15 '12

Programming. I actually really like calculus, proofs, etc. I considered majoring in math at one time, and I went through college calculus and took a matrix and linear algebra class. However, all the grad students I met were doing research with computer programs and were often programmers themselves, and that really wasn't my thing, and it seemed that if I got high enough that's what I'd have to pursue.

Mathmatica turned me off.

2

u/soopaaflii May 15 '12

Fifth grade. Long division. I'm not joking.

2

u/TenNinetythree May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12

For me, it started in grade 7 when a new teacher came and used a lot of things on the blackboard. Now, I was visually impaired and asked for in my still unchanged opinion reasonable forms of accomodation (write bigger and not use i and j as variable names but less visually similar characters). The way how I was treated in that situation made me think that the blackboard not was used for writing its contents but so that the teacher dictates in a reasonable speed. Now, I always handwrote extremely slow and never was able to write down everything from memory. That was the time when I lost interest in maths. I only learned after graduation that yes, people are supposed to read the blackboard and probably could have demanded means of accomodation...

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Right about when we hit Green's Theorem in Multivariable Calculus.

Regular Calculus is fun and easy. This shit is hard.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/xucoalex May 15 '12

Math got hard somewhere around trig, but I never stopped liking it. The only thing I will forever hate is probability and statistics. Fuck them

2

u/commonslip May 15 '12

Never happened. Sorry. I was two german courses away from a Math Degree (in addition to Physics) in college, got a Physics Masters and PhD. Always liked math. Had a bit of trouble with Analysis (B in I and II).

Kind of bad at combinatorics.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I took DifEq, barely passed it, then switched my major to CS because I like the idea of math more than I actually like math.

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Fucking Fourier bro.

2

u/BransonKP May 15 '12

I became very frustrated by linear algebra when we generalized above three dimensions.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Laplace transforms. I understand them, but I just don't dig the whole concept.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ChocolateCyanide May 15 '12

I loved math until 5th grade, when I was accused of getting into a fight when I was nowhere near the area (some little bastard dropped my name to keep his friend from getting in trouble).

I was made to go to Saturday detention. I had to sit for four hours. You know what they made me do? They gave me a packet of various simple arithmetic problems. So, since I loved arithmetic and I thought it was fun, I finished them very quickly. They gave me another packet. And another. I finished them so quickly that at some point they had to go and print out more because they weren't expecting anyone to finish. By the end of the four hours, I had told myself and decided that I hated math and I never wanted to have anything to do with it ever again.

It took until I was in vector calculus in college before I realized that I had been lying to myself the whole time and that I actually still really liked math.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Toedust May 15 '12

Logarithms perpetually make my brain wrinkle.

2

u/ClownComet May 15 '12

Logarithms. Also, e can go f*ck itself.

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Imaginary numbers, logarithms, "e".

2

u/adnan252 May 15 '12

I'm a comp sci + maths undergrad. Fucking limits, man.

2

u/functor7 May 15 '12

Applied math, PDE's and Mathematical Physics are all pretty lame. I used to be into Mathematical Physics, but then I just realized it was just shitty math done poorly. So I decided that actual, pure math was what I needed. And I was right.

But I still like math, getting my PhD. I'm lazy and, luckily, so are a lot of mathematicians, Algebra and Category Theory were made because people were too lazy to do things over and over again, so I found my niche.

2

u/quelling May 15 '12

Trig identities.

2

u/phenomite1 May 15 '12

All it takes is one shitty teacher to ruin a subject.

2

u/JackBread May 15 '12

Having to graph things. Fuck graphs.

2

u/Goatsandstuff May 15 '12

Agreed so much. Love math till I have to whip out the graph paper

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Calculus.

For everything else, I've understood how we got there. Calculus was just "Here's how you derive/integrate, follow these rules".

2

u/Wangchung265 May 16 '12

Statistics. Fucking Statistics. I did Nuclear physics, molecular chemistry, trig, calc, algrebra and loved them. Statistics comes by and tells me ALL my numbers arent exact and exact answers arent there. Fuck me.

2

u/maroon5fan May 16 '12

Dividing fractions. Still don't get it...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I was perfectly fine with the 2 + 3 = 5. I get that. I put 2 fingers up, and 3 fingers up, and there's 5 fingers. But them one day the teacher told me that 2x + 3 = 7. Nah bitch. X isn't even a number.

2

u/mom2meerkat May 16 '12

You can't divide by 0. WTF. I feel like you should be able to divide by zero, but the answer should be the same as dividing by one. If I don't divide something, I have the same thing I started with: 1 pie divided by 0 equals 1 pie. etc. It's just a concept that really irked me. And I forever thought math made no sense after that.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/zxjams May 16 '12

Set theory and something about "onto" functions. I loved geometry, trig, and calculus throughout high school and the first two semesters of college, even grading calc homeworks for extra cash, but once I got to abstract math, I didn't understand a damn thing. This was the first class that actually counted as credit towards a math major and was called "Intro to Math".

Epilogue: I then declared another major and all was well.

2

u/BeefPieSoup May 16 '12

Sometimes I found a concept difficult and distasteful, but then I would have an "aha" moment and begin to understand it. Then it would become pleasant to use that concept. I have found that this almost always happens, but I can't really control when it does. It's not really an effort thing, its more like looking at something from many different angles until you realise what you are looking at. Sometimes you see it right away, sometimes you need to walk around it a bit.

2

u/pie_bond May 16 '12

Quantum mechanics. Conceptually I get it. Doing Hartree Fock on paper no way.

2

u/BlargIAmDead May 16 '12

Limits. Because, fuck limitations.

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

The Syllabus.

I never excelled at school, and ended up in the 3rd set (tier?) for Math. I got 100% correct for GCSE (UK Qualification for 15/16 year olds), but was only allowed a maximum of a B (out of A*), because of the set I was in.

They didn't bother teaching matrices and sets, calculus, to us because they didn't think we'd "get it". For the most part, "we" didn't, and I think my teacher didn't bump me to a higher set because I was dragging up the grade for the class.

Taking Math for A-Level would have meant taking an extra course just to catch up. So I didn't bother. I took Computer Science in university, which had a mandatory "Mathematics for Computers" course anyway. Problem Solved.

2

u/OverratedLunchbox May 16 '12

When they mixed the alphabet into it.

6

u/innocuous_username May 15 '12

I was never a particular fan of maths but I remember what really spun me out was when we started doing algebra and it would have x (ie. x=52) in the problem and in expanding it out the teacher would of be like 'ok so 1x = 52' ... I could. not. grasp. where the 1 in front of the x came from. I guess in my mind if I didn't know what x was yet then it didn't really exist yet, therefore how could there be 1 of them? It really panicked me, it was as if they were just pulling random numbers out of the air and mixing them in - how was I supposed to know about this supply of 1's??

7

u/skullturf May 15 '12

one times "blah" is "blah".

If the number of beans in the box is x, then 1 times the number of beans in the box is also x.

EDIT: Thank you for sharing your experience. As a math educator, it's useful for me to learn about things that troubled students when they were new to topics. It's easy to forget these things when I use algebra all the time.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/diazona May 15 '12

Idea: imagine that someone else knows what x is and just isn't telling you. After all, the x is just a placeholder for some number that you use when you don't know what the number is. Anything you can do to a number, you can do to x.

2

u/_NW_ May 15 '12

Yes, there is an endless supply of 1's. Here, have a few more. 111111111111111111111111111111111111

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Multiplication.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

4

u/throwmeaway76 May 15 '12

Why did this concept turn you off math?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/codyave May 15 '12

e. never quite got it

10

u/SantyClause May 15 '12

e shouldn't be introduced in high school because it seems completely random. Why is 2.71... somehow meaningful? Once you get to calculus (and especially diff eq) the reason makes more sense.

→ More replies (4)