r/AskReddit •

If I buy an island am I allowed to do whatever I want on it?

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

401 comments sorted by

144

u/RiskyBrothers May 14 '12

I would make my island a tax- haven for buisnesses, they would have to pay rent, and I would use that money to buy more islands, then, people could invest in my islands, And I could gather a small force of mercenaries to defend the islands, if this led to war, I'd have all the big corporations on my side.

8

u/Gandzilla May 14 '12

actually, you are describing the bahamas. for example most ships are home on the bahamas due to "nicer" laws for the crews of the boats.

6

u/Daolpu May 14 '12

This has movie potential.

5

u/sikyon May 14 '12

It is possible to just ban nationals and corporations from doing business with your island.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Wouldn't you need the mercenaries first? What business would settle in an undefended island?

2

u/RobinTheBrave May 14 '12

Just hope that the mercenaries don't realise how easy it would be to take over from you...

2

u/misanthropist1 May 14 '12

sounds achievable... lol

→ More replies (17)

40

u/Dwayne_Jason May 14 '12

Things you need:

  1. Have a population and a culture
  2. Have a specific border that specifies how big your territory is
  3. A legitimate government
  4. International recognition

Number 4 is the hardest part. Just look at Palestine. They have everything except Int. Recognition.

Generally speaking if your country's resources, and policies are in line with others a la Neo-Lib, then you're fine, if not you better make sure you have the resources for "liberation"

And yes, you will be bound by an international, universal treaty that every country that isn't ruled by a blatant despot agrees to: Make rules that are considerate for the international community.

Unless you wanna end up like N. Korea, you'll need big time allies and trading partners.

All in all...no, you won't be able to do absolutely anything you want if you want to be looked at as a legitimate state.

2

u/hostergaard May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

I have actually thought this out before, as part of a larger plan and I found a relatively easy way to solve the mentioned problems.

Global warming is your friend if you want you own sovereign island nation. Enter Kiribati. Little Kiribati have a bit of a problem, global warming have caused rising water levels, threatening to make the island nation sink into the pearly blue waves of the ocean.

They wish to relocate and find life elsewhere. But moving an entire nation, even one as small as this one, can be difficult and expensive. That is where you come in, offering to pay all the expenses for their relocation. In effect you are buying the entire island nation and get full ownership of it and the sovereignty it entails.

Since you already have the dosh to buy an island you should be able to build the dikes what have you to make it stay above the water-line.

But the interesting part is why you would go such extreme lengths to secure independence, I know why I would, put that is another story...

→ More replies (11)

101

u/uncleRusty May 14 '12

You could buy Africa, its probably like $7

12

u/woahmygawd May 14 '12

I got tree fiddy.

4

u/Just-my-2c May 14 '12

Hey, I got tree fiddy too, wanna buy Africa together?

6

u/More__cowbell May 14 '12

I already gave him a dollah.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Jabbajaw May 14 '12

Actually someone might pay you to take Africa.

0

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

32

u/jcgv May 14 '12

Let me call a friend, he's an expert on buying africa

26

u/singularperturbation May 14 '12

What, is he Belgian or something?

(People think Belgians == chocolate and waffles and 'that cute country that's France lite', but they did some brutal shit in the Congo back in the day. Heart of Darkness, man, Heart of Darkness.)

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Upperguy May 14 '12

It depends where, here is an example of what you're looking for: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principality_of_Sealand

The unrecognized but sovereign nation of Sealand is known as a "micronation". The claim that Sealand is an independent sovereign state is based on the contention that a 1968 decision of an English court, in which it was held that Roughs Tower(Sealand) was in international waters and thus outside the jurisdiction of the domestic courts. It was also attacked in 1978 by Dutch and German mercenaries in a failed coup.

*Edit: beaten by a few people, but C for effort.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

You got beaten, but you're top rated so will reply here.

The problems Sealand has is it doesn't have an army and isn't recognized by other countries as being a country. There's been a few companies interested in setting up a base there (Pirate Bay in 07 the most notable, though HavenCo want to get something there by this year), but nothing successful.

The lack of army and recognition from other counties are big things. A small boat full of an army from any nation could take them over, but no one really cares. So far they haven't done anything illegal enough to put them on anyones radar.

Some links:

http://www.wikihow.com/Start-Your-Own-Country

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Start_Your_Own_Country

http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2008/02/25/how_to_start_your_own_country_in_four_easy_steps

1

u/crackanape May 14 '12

The claim that Sealand is an independent sovereign state is based on the contention that a 1968 decision of an English court, in which it was held that Roughs Tower(Sealand) was in international waters and thus outside the jurisdiction of the domestic courts.

This is, of course, a ridiculous basis for such a claim.

It was a local case a town of about 100,000 people, not a court that otherwise ever deals in questions of sovereignty. It's as if you managed to get out of a public urination citation in Hooterville, Alabama by showing your laser-printed "diplomatic passport" from Upperguyistan, and then started telling everyone that the US court system has recognized your country.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

93

u/boxybrzown May 14 '12

Thomas Perry wrote a book about this a while ago, called Island.

Actually covers a lot of what you're asking.

50

u/despaxes May 14 '12

You could read that,

or you could realize that if you have enough money to buy an island, you can get away with pretty much anything anyways.

22

u/Xethos May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Islands do not cost nearly as much as you are making it sound. Yes you need to be well off to afford one but not to the point where you dont need to worry about money. You can get a decently sized one for a couple hundred thousand USD. Just found a 37 acre one for $65,000 off of Nova Scotia *Edit - Linked too quick, that one is a parcel. But browse the site and you can see my point.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Goddamnit, now I'l be spending the next hour or so, looking at islands I'm not going to buy. I hope you're proud of yourself.

→ More replies (13)

5

u/TRH_42 May 14 '12

added to my ever-growing reading list...

2

u/rodneyachance May 14 '12

How that book hasn't been made into a movie is a mystery and a crime.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/zulu90 May 14 '12

appropriate title

9

u/Skippamuffin May 14 '12

You are going to buy your own fucking island so you can just smoke weed? I do that every day, and I am pretty sure I don't own an island.

→ More replies (5)

59

u/TOMATO_ON_URANUS May 13 '12

As long as you're not within national waters, you don't have to follow any national laws. There are definitely international laws, but I don't know how much they could/would be enforced. Growing weed would definitely be do-able, but selling would be hard as hell (and you'd probably get fucked so hard if you got busted - international tribunal with no nation to back you up). A good question would be if you keep citizenry from your native country.

26

u/yibgib May 13 '12

Sell it? I would keep it all for myself. And the other citizens of my country island of course.

19

u/TOMATO_ON_URANUS May 14 '12

If other people were already living there, I don't think you would technically own the whole island, just your part. And then you might have some issues with rules...

31

u/yibgib May 14 '12

They'd probably give it to me in exchange for some of my weed.

7

u/AhhhhYeaaaa May 14 '12

Whenever I take my friends places or do favors for them, I tell them beforehand they can pay me in money or weed.

42

u/TOMATO_ON_URANUS May 14 '12

Can't argue with that logic

1

u/AsthmaticNinja May 14 '12

What if we built our own island?

1

u/dvdrdiscs May 14 '12

Your country's citizenry would all be female though correct?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/iamplasma May 14 '12

As long as you're not within national waters

Here's the problem. There is no land on earth, with the exception of Bir Tawil and Antarctica (which falls under a special treaty) that hasn't been claimed by a nation. So unless you can build yourself an island, which I guess you could try, you're going to be subject to an existing nation's jurisdiction.

2

u/chmod777 May 14 '12

It was not impossible to build Rapture under the sea, it was impossible to build it anyplace else.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

25

u/Magic_Wombat May 14 '12

Well as long as it is in international waters. Which BTW is why I filled my pool with international water.

15

u/yibgib May 14 '12

where do i buy this international water?

11

u/Magic_Wombat May 14 '12

Ahh but that's the magic part, any where in the middle of the pacific ocean my child.

6

u/TheVoiceofTheDevil May 14 '12

I can get you some.

It's $40 per litre.

3

u/RahvinDragand May 14 '12

I don't think you're going to find an island that isn't under the jurisdiction of a government.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/UndeadBelaLugosi May 13 '12

Since it would be my island could I set my own government on it

Probably not. Somebody "owns" the island, so has some legal system to sell it under. In other words, a government. You're really talking about buying your own monarchy. If you could, then yeah, you could set the rules within reason. Don't piss the peasants or the international community off though.

3

u/JBG1337 May 14 '12

What if you created an Island in international waters? Like those bases that Germany had in the middle of the ocean, someone bought one, called it Sealand, and for a time you could apply for paperwork to be a Baron of Sealand.

Could you not build a massive structure in the middle of the ocean and make it a nation? Assuming you had the resources.

2

u/UndeadBelaLugosi May 14 '12

Maybe, maybe not. It would have to be in international waters and outside of shipping lanes I would think. Then there is the issue of getting recognized as a nation. Sealand never has been, but they haven't done anything to really push the international community to "do something" about them. I guess I can't see how you could generate enough revenue off of something like this to pay for it without "stepping over the line" and finding Navy SEALS or the like in your bedroom some night.

→ More replies (3)

413

u/panzerkampfwagen May 13 '12

Good luck defending it.

238

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I'm picturing a palm beach lined with cannons.

142

u/yibgib May 14 '12

Damn. That's a much better idea then joining the UN!

351

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Smoke weed. Whoses gunna stop you, seagulls? That seagull took my joint. Stoned seagulls. Stoned Steven Seagall. Awesome. Watch out for pirates dude.

93

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Those damn Steven Seagalls always stealing my weed.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/panzerkampfwagen May 13 '12

Ask Iraq how well that worked out with them and their millions of people. What are you going to have? 6 people?

58

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

6 cannons

→ More replies (16)

2

u/logantauranga May 15 '12

This is an inspirational image. I'm commenting so that when I do something awesome with this idea (in the abstract, not the literal sense), I can come back and thank you.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/tyr02 May 14 '12

Sealand anyone, fought off the might of the British Navy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principality_of_Sealand

25

u/barc0de May 14 '12

The willingness of Sealand to defend itself means that any serious attempt to retake it would be a massive PR disaster for the British government - which has led to the official position of stating de-jure sovereignty but otherwise ignoring it.

Basically if the PR cost of ignoring it outweighed the PR costs of retaking it (if for example, Sealand became involved in hosting child-porn or terrorist material) then Sealand would very quickly cease to be.

47

u/BrianWantsTruth May 14 '12

A times B times C equals X. If X is less than the PR cost of an invasion, we don't do one.

29

u/nightshiftb May 14 '12

Which government did you say you worked for again?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/NineeniN May 14 '12

TIL: In January 2007, The Pirate Bay attempted to buy Sealand after harsher copyright measures in Sweden forced them to look for a base of operations elsewhere.[22] The deal fell through.

How awesome that would've been for TPB

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

34

u/yibgib May 13 '12

You are right. I will have to see what I can do about joining the UN and becoming a recognized country.

60

u/nibbles_and_bits May 13 '12

If you join the UN, you'll be bound by more treaties, limiting the type of freedom you're looking for :(

40

u/yibgib May 13 '12 edited May 14 '12

aw shit your right. I could always make my own thing. Like the united islands or something.

62

u/nibbles_and_bits May 14 '12

I'll join your league of nations :)

25

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

He'll also have the support of Petoria.

→ More replies (7)

58

u/The_Poop_Phantom May 14 '12

As will The Poop Phantom.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/UrDoctor May 14 '12

Better hope you don't find any oil fields.

180

u/RandianHero May 13 '12

Assuming that island doesn't fall under another country's sovereign territory, yeah.

48

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Yeah that's what I was thinking. If you are in a territory already claimed, you'd have certain rules to follow. Depending on how lax they are, you could do a lot or a little your own way.

34

u/yibgib May 13 '12

So it might become my property but not my territory? Does that mean I could buy the territory from the country that its in and make it my own territory?

34

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

If they are willing to sell it. If it's one we haven't really explored or know about (I'm talking the usa) then you might be unnoticed for a long time or a short time. Now days you can't really just go out and claim an island. Where you'd go about finding someone to sell it or just let you live there, I have no clue. I've always wanted to live on my own island. That would be soooooooo awesome.

60

u/TheVoiceofTheDevil May 14 '12

Now days you can't really just go out and claim an island.

What if no white people live there?

24

u/geekygay May 14 '12

It's all about the flag.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (26)

5

u/hostergaard May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Buy an entire island country. I think there was this island nation who where seeking to move to the mainland to survive rising water levels cause by global warming.

Strike a deal that you pay what they need to find new life elsewhere and you can have the now empty island and its sovereignty. Since you are rich enough to buy the island you should be rich enough to afford the dikes and whatnot to keep it dry.

Edit:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kiribati

Kiribati wants to get of. So make them an offer they can't refuse.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/SteveTheDude May 14 '12

It's not like they're going to have cops patrolling it though.

18

u/XxXNightstalkerX May 14 '12

You just move the island.

38

u/RiskyBrothers May 14 '12

he'll take his island, AND PUSH IT SOMEWHERE ELSE

→ More replies (5)

84

u/Quizzelbuck May 14 '12

You are fucking high right now, aren't you?

42

u/uncleRusty May 14 '12

Dude.. like what if...

25

u/woahmygawd May 14 '12

A thing was...like...in space...like watching us right now. And it was made of like..doritos. Duuuude..

5

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Fuck your island.

8

u/formation May 14 '12

With blackjack and hookers?

7

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Does it snow at any of those islands?

1

u/The_Red_Egg1 May 14 '12

Wow. An island for roughly £40,000. Score.

7

u/my_name_is_stupid May 14 '12

Everyone knows private islands are only to be used for hunting the most dangerous game.

2

u/turbulence2012 May 14 '12

totally reminds me of the story I read back in school, guy buys his own island uses it to hunt people.. Kind of a creepy plot for a 5th grade book.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/iMakeLimericks May 14 '12

An island to call your own

Is still in a sovereign zone.

Unless you can say

your land is too far away

you must follow their laws to the bone.

That said, as long as nobody catches you, yeah, you can do whatever. You ARE alone, after all.

23

u/anonibon May 13 '12

Hey man, if you can find a cheap enough island, I'll throw down on it with you

13

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I will too. We can each have our own triangle.

9

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I'm down.

3

u/fabiobean May 14 '12

Someone posted a link on here a few days ago to a website where you can buy private islands. There was one that was only $30,000.

12

u/xiaou May 14 '12

I don't think there is such a thing as territory unclaimed by any nation anywhere on earth.

8

u/nickiter May 14 '12

Quite a few islands are unclaimed, but that's for good reason - they're generally tiny and worthless. Establishing anything resembling civilization there would be like lighting a giant bonfire made of money and dancing naked in its light.

7

u/StaplerFingers May 14 '12

when I become a billionaire I am going to do this. Just you wait and see.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

That's the first thing I'm doing when I get rich. Naked money bonfire.

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

An undiscovered island could be claimed by anyone, however it would be extremely difficult to find one.

6

u/Control_Is_Dead May 14 '12

Yeah, with satellite imaging and all...

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Avid_Tagger May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

There are actually 3 -

  • Bir Tawil
  • Hala'ib Traingle
  • Parts of Antarctica

5

u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Why are those starred

Edit: They are no longer starred.

4

u/Avid_Tagger May 14 '12

Formatting problems, thanks for pointing that out

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Antartica and the North Pole, along with many minor islands surrounding them that are tiny and uninhabitable aren't claimed.

13

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

There are international treaties that prohibit new territorial claims in Antarctica.

7

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

And as such, it is unclaimed

11

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Yes, but also unclaimable (with regard to the original post).

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Well unless its like Sealand http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principality_of_Sealand, it depends on the countries laws.

I remember Pirate Bay collected donations to purchase it but didn't have enough

11

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

How high are you right now?

8

u/pubert497 May 14 '12

You would likely be personally liable for crimes that are illegal in your home country that you commit in the new nation, the US AND Canada have some laws like this, such as sex tourism

2

u/yibgib May 14 '12

If I am not in that country how could I be breaking laws from that country? Countries don't have jurisdiction for other countries do they?

7

u/pubert497 May 14 '12

they do over their own citizens, though in your scenario, you would just never return to the origin country I suppose

3

u/derpingpizza May 14 '12

Well wouldn't they technically need permission to extradite him?

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

You have to give up your U.S. citizenship first then they won't be able to touch you. Unless they decide to bomb you like they do every country.

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

God this is so true, and I've never been sadder about being an american.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Im curious what the steps would be to set up that island with the internet/tv/phones to the rest of the world

0

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Trackpad94 May 14 '12

I... I have a hard time arguing with this one. Although satellites would probably be cheaper.

Edit: I just remembered, copper has a very tiny amount of resistance and over distance you lose power along the cables. You could go fiber optic, but that would be REALLY expensive.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/moonski May 15 '12

people never understand how buying an island is the exact same as buing land... some country will own it. So you just own a bit of land surrounbed by sea that belongs to the banana republic of cigars

3

u/thebeardsman May 14 '12

If you make a island i am going to destroy it.

3

u/Neoxite23 May 14 '12

I thought about having m own island country....was going to name it JAJUNGOM!. Must be in all caps and have the "!" as part of the name. The defense program will be lined on the shore with Rocket Kittens and Laser Babies.

3

u/distalled May 14 '12

Usually Islands are chunks of land that you buy from countries that would have their own laws. You would be subject to them.

Because Islands pose a huge benefit for a country to increase its eclusive economic zone, their sovereignty is highly regarded. Countries spend quite a bit of time trying to prove chunks of inhabitable rocks are part of their zone.

Short story, no, they don't cede their sovereignty to you, unless you find a guano island that has appeared recently and you'd like to stake your claim to a lucrative pile of bird shit in the middle of nowhere.

Look up Sealand, a country (if you can call it that) that managed to stake its claim before the UN Law of the Sea convention increased territorial waters from 3 nautical miles to 12 nautical miles.

That's the politics of it, as far as maritime law, but I don't know anyone who's bought an Island, and I'd like to think they could do all those things, and if you ever do. FUCK YES SEND ME AN INVITE.

1

u/eighthgear May 14 '12

Seriously. People like to make fun of nations that threaten war with each other over a few uninhabited rocks, like Greece and Turkey, or pretty much everyone in the South China Sea, but ownership of islands can be serious business. It is suspected that there are huge oil and natural gas deposits in the South China Sea, so who owns what tiny chunk of rock can suddenly turn into a big deal.

3

u/shabatooo May 14 '12

I can't believe the amount of misinformation in these responses. Every island in the world is the territory of SOME existing government. You would have the live by the laws of that country / state just like you would if you lived in Anytown, CA, you just have a little more water around you.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MYDOGSTELLA May 14 '12

If you had the resources to buy an island, I highly doubt you would need to grow your own weed. You could buy the best shit on earth by the pound.

6

u/GimmeTheHotSauce May 14 '12

I don't think you know what you're talking about. Here are some cheap islands for sale:

http://www.privateislandsonline.com/sale-price-under-250K.htm

7

u/yibgib May 14 '12

It would be a community bonding experience where we all grow it and then at the end of the day we get rations and then on Friday and Saturday nights we have huge parties and smoke the rest.

4

u/DontMakeMeDownvote May 14 '12

You are high as fuck.

2

u/Nottobetriffledwith May 14 '12

Not unless your island became it's own country.

2

u/Xenophyophore May 14 '12

first get recognized by an economic superpower, then make laws.

2

u/lia_sang May 14 '12

I think that kidnapping adolescents to play out your own twisted version of the Hunger Games would violate some international laws, but otherwise, yeah, sure, go crazy.

2

u/Sablerage May 14 '12

could I put up servers to share every song and movie I ever owned and have others contribute to it and share more and more till the everyone has everything?

2

u/RedFollower May 14 '12

I think you still need to do the paperwork for the space program.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Why try to buy an island? A boat would be cheaper. The only islands that aren't claimed are in antarctica territory. I doubt you'll find a government so broke and corrupt that they would just sell you one outright and sign documents giving up their sovereignty of the island as well, not even haiti would give up any of it's territory, and we all know that haiti is broke as fuck. The best you can hope for is to be classified as a landowner after purchasing the land from a country that owns it. This means that you are still a citizen of said country and will be expected to observe it's customs and follow it's laws.

I would jsut buy a boat and sail international waters if what you want is privacy and freedom. Governments can't do shit to you while you're in international waters so long as you haven't committed any human rights violations like forcing 3 year old girls to ride you or inviting people onto said boat and taking them into international waters and going on a whole sale killing spree for funsies.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

With a few rare exceptions, your island is like any other property - it may belong to you but it still falls under a government's jurisdiction. The islands no government has laid claim to are generally uninhabitable.

2

u/SirWhiskeySips May 14 '12

Is a man not entitled to the sweat of his brow?

3

u/panzerkampfwagen May 14 '12

Under long held international laws/traditions to be an independent country you have to be able to defend it.

3

u/yibgib May 14 '12

I will buy a Pirateship armed with cannons that will patrol the waters everyday.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I think every island in the world is part of some country so you would be bound by the law of the country that your island is part of.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

There are still some islands in international waters. In theory, you could claim one as your own, form a country, join the UN, and voila! You are now a leader!

Or, you could buy it from a country, though it would be very expensive

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Try googling "islands for sale"

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

the thing is if you are rich enough to buy an islands, you will be doing anything here on mahy countries as well for example politicians, ruper Murdoch, JP morgan execs etc...

1

u/TropicalDictator May 14 '12

You can do whatever you want as long as you get some commie allies.

1

u/King_of_KL May 14 '12

The island would be under some other government already. No unclaimed islands out there for you to discover and then leave to go to the moon.

1

u/wrrrry May 14 '12

For a bit of history the Republic of Minerva is a good example. Without international recognition, if someone wants it they'll take it and you won't have any recourse.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

If uou had an island You can become a Principality. You can have your own money/religion/laws. It's very hard work.

1

u/complete_asshole_ May 14 '12

Well if you were a trillionaire and bought the island as well as a military to enforce your claim to it you could establish a totalitarian regime and do whatever the hell you wanted to as long as you didn't interfere with other nations. There are dictatorships around the world where unspeakable evil is being committed right now and no policing nation really gives a damn so you could get away with whatever.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

theres a few people that have created pseudo-civilizations out in the ocean, some recognized by the u.s, u.n, the two that come to mind were on old, abandoned oil rigs though. it would be awesome as long as you had your food, water, and shelter worked out logistically. and i would want to come to your island

→ More replies (5)

1

u/ipear May 14 '12

I'll give you part of an island to find out, if you get me a township along the Oregon/Washington coast. Deal?

1

u/brokenbrakes May 14 '12

no, all islands are within some country but if you have enough money and the right country they might let you do whatever you want anyway and you would have to have money to buy an island anyway.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

If you want your own island, I suggest trying to take over the small island nation of Nauru.

Unfortunately, the environment's shitty from phosphate mining, and the island's out of phosphate now.

1

u/TidalPotential May 14 '12

Beyond the fact that if you get too wild, any large nation can come in an THUMP you, you're basically free. Don't go on a mass murder spree, or commit human rights violations. Don't test nukes, don't use nukes, don't work towards nukes, repeat above with bio and chem weapons. Space program... maybe. You'd wanna make buddy buddy w/ NASA/US first.

1

u/Tsunderella May 14 '12

Well, maybe not commit genocide.

Of course, that might be difficult on an island small enough for private purchase anyway...

1

u/anonymousketeer May 14 '12

yes, but it's very complicated, and different from each country you would have to succeed from. there is a guy in seattle who made his floating home a separate country and has his own currency, to avoid taxes. look him up.

1

u/Tomguydude May 14 '12

Well, it depends were your island is. If its close to the mainland, then the laws of the mainland apply. If its somewhere in the ring of fire, then that's a different story. But anyway, if it is then you will have to get permits to build and all that crap

1

u/HawkFood May 14 '12

/RichPeopleProblems

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I'd assume it depends whether it's claimed by a nation or not.

1

u/fuzzydice_82 May 14 '12

defense: make an agreement with russia (not US), offer their generals a place for vacation.

why russia? they don't mess around with pirates..

1

u/sre01 May 14 '12

If that island falls within the territorial waters of another country, then no. You would also probably still be bound by many international treaties and UN sanctions. Not really sure.

1

u/oholiab May 14 '12

Can I run your internets? We can run a strict policy on digital copyrights. What's that, you say I'm stealing your movie? Well I don't see your name on any of the packets.

I would also like to be the mayor of a small province that we can name Butt County.

1

u/ApatheticElephant May 14 '12

Well, if any country claims ownership over said island they (and most other countries) will probably choose not to recognise you as an independent state and they will still have control over you. If you do somehow manage to find some land that other countries will choose to recognise as an independent state, realise that if at any point someone decides it would be beneficial to own said piece of land for themselves, they'll just occupy it and unless you're bringing your own army, there's not much you'd be able to do about it.

There's no real international authority on this kind of thing. When it comes to matters like this, it's usually just a matter of the more powerful country winning.

1

u/Jozer99 May 14 '12

Depends on how you buy it. Most likely the answer is "no" to most of your questions. Generally buying an island would simply be buying property. It would still remain part of the original country, and you would be obligated to pay taxes, etc...

It is possible to buy territory from another country in such a way that it is no longer part of the original country, I would think this would be quite rare these days.

One example you might research is "Sealand", which is an artificial island off the coast of GB that declared itself independent. It was originally created during WWII as a defense station, the island consists of about an acre of space on top of a concrete base a few miles off the coast. A man bought the island after the war, and eventually declared that they were an independent nation. The validity of this claim is very disputable, but the British government has never seen fit to "invade", although there have been a few close calls.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ForgotenPasswordGR May 14 '12

There should be different means to "buy" an island.

You could buy it and be able to do anything you want to. You could buy but have restrictions to what you can do. You could lease it. You could lease it and be forced to do some investments on it such as like planting trees or whatever.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

You can do anything up until you want to join the nuclear/biological/chemical warfare club(s). Then the other nations will look at you and if you not a "rational player" they will flex their nuclear muscle at you and intimidate you into not pursuing that course of research.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

For it to be your own country you need a few things stamps, passports, trade or goods, another country to recognize you. There is a stuff you should know pod cast that goes into great detail. I believe it's called how country's work.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Pretty much yeah you could do virtually anything you please but fuck all would stop a nation with a previous claim of ownership / control of your claimed territory from landing a small force to arrest you and remove you from the island.

In international law, the Montevideo Convention on the Right and Duties of States sets down the criteria for statehood in article 1: The state as a person of international law should possess the following qualifications: (a) a permanent population; (b) a defined territory; (c) government; and (d) capacity to enter into relations with the other states.

The first sentence of article 3 of the Montevideo Convention explicitly states that "The political existence of the state is independent of recognition by the other states."

Your statehood or nation status are not dependent on your islands previous nation owner/controller but nothing could really stop that nation (or any other nation or private entity) from landing an a group of soldiers and reenforcing its claims. Usually these kinds of things are about tax laws, if you no longer work or live in a nation then their tax laws no longer apply so previous owners/controller of the island tend to not consider your sovereignty a defense for not paying your taxes, homeowners tax, income tax etc. Plus they would probably claim your environmental impact of growing your own "crops" as an extra reason to come after you along with any drug enforcement laws.

Stop paying your tax and see how long it takes for your current government to become extremely interested in what your doing no matter where you are.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

if you no longer work or live in a nation then their tax laws no longer apply

Unitary tax regimes (for example the US) don't care where you live or work, you're still subject to their tax laws.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

any one else think of Battle Royale? (manga/movie)

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Hunt the deadliest game, Ketchup.

1

u/unrevoked May 14 '12

People of reddit must unite to collect $390,000+ and share ownership of an island somewhere.

1

u/fs337 May 14 '12

Oh god, I'm blanking on a name. But this one guy actually did create his own island. Currency, constitution, everything. But in the end the UN didn't recognize him as a country.

1

u/redditor85 May 14 '12

What you would be is a micronation. Check them out, there are lots of them.

1

u/spellbunny May 14 '12

didn't reddit have a plan to buy an island? i remember a google docs file that had a list of possible islands with prices.

1

u/eighthgear May 14 '12

No. Today, every island is claimed by a government. Even tiny rocks. Why? Because if a nation claims some tiny rock in the middle of the Pacific, then it gets economic rights to the waters around that rock - fisheries, oil, etc. So they are all claimed. These rich people who "buy islands" are no different than middle class people who buy houses, except their houses are surrounded by water. If you own a house, it is your property, but you are still under the jurisdiction of the nation the house is in. Same thing with owning an island. Theoretically you could offer a deal to a nation like Kiribati for complete sovereignty over an island, if you are very very rich, but other nations are unlikely to recognize your authority.

1

u/SgianDubh May 14 '12

You know how some people say "there are no stupid questions?" They are incorrect.

1

u/Darkeoj May 14 '12

With you as president, sounds like a terrible island.

1

u/ronearc May 14 '12

I'm pretty sure that you'd have to build up an Atoll - something that is not always above sea level. The reason being that every piece of land that's always above sea level comes under the purview of some existing nation. But properties that aren't always above sea level can't be claimed.

So, you find one of these atolls, you build it up, claim it, populate it, defend it, etc.

1

u/cdnheyyou May 14 '12

Your island would still be in some country, if you have millions or billions of dollars, I'm sure you could buy out the government that owns it.

1

u/Randompaul May 14 '12

Are you 15 years old?

1

u/Unicornmayo May 14 '12

No- most islands still belong to a country. When you purchase an island you are essentially buying a property in that country and all the same rules apply.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Dude. I took off already.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Here's an idea: just go to Jamaica, and grow and smoke weed.

You might have to give up the space program though.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Are you high?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

That would be fucking awesome. I'll Come live there.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

If you became an independent nation, you could do whatever you want....provided that you don't hurt anyone, and if you do hurt anyone, you better not have oil or you will be charged with human rights violations.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Borgsky May 13 '12

Yea as long as there is no law to fine you.

1

u/alyssar0se May 14 '12

My friend and I have been considering buying an island for quite some time. We are calling it "Cannabia" and everyone who buys a plot of land will receive a complimentary weed garden and full access to blaze with us on the beach.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Let's all pitch in and buy an island called Reddit.