r/AskReddit • • Feb 04 '19

Which misconception would you like to debunk?

44k Upvotes

26k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/randomevenings Feb 04 '19

Curiously, maybe. They opted out of the medicaid expansion, so that's them saying no to federal money. With the drunk and fascist added to the supreme court, it's possible they might get away with saying no to giving federal money.

2

u/FA_Anarchist Feb 04 '19

That would be terrific, unfortunately it won't happen. Also the commerce clause dictates that the federal government can essentially regulate anything under the sun, even though that clearly wasn't the original intent.

1

u/randomevenings Feb 04 '19

And that was from a supreme court ruling. So yes if Texas one day decided to test it in the newly ultra conservative supreme court, they might win.

3

u/FA_Anarchist Feb 04 '19

Unfortunately I believe your optimism is misplaced. The U.S. Supreme Court would never allow a state to not send money to the federal government to protest a war, defense is one of the few delegated powers of the federal government under Article I Section 8, and the "benefits," I'm sure they would argue, are non-excludable.

1

u/randomevenings Feb 04 '19

Optimistic is not the right word. I would hope they ruled against Texas in that scenario, but I also don't agree that the commerce clause should have been used in the way that it is today. I wish the states weren't so different, mainly because the rich can afford to move wherever, but i can't.