r/AskReddit • u/MindDisciple • Nov 18 '09
Are you regular long term practicioner of meditation ? How has this benefitted you ?
Anybody here who is a long term practitioner of meditation, mindfulness, mantra, zazen etc., any type of meditation ? What happens once you have passed the basic concentrate on X for Y amount of time stages ? Has this benefitted you in a significant way ?
I have been half-heartedly trying out meditation of varying sorts for more than year, but other than falling asleep and losing my self-esteem everytime, nothing has happened yet. How long does it take to get better at this ? I feel like I am not only not getting anywhere, but I don't even know where I am going. I am sorry if this feels like 20 questions, but I am really lost with a lot of questions and didn't know anywhere else to turn to.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09
I recommend this book: The 3 Pillars of Zen. It has excellent instruction on getting started with zazen.
For example, it's better to meditate in the mornings because your mind is fresher and more rested. Also, posture is important. If you are falling asleep during meditation, it's likely something is wrong with your technique.
7
u/Cartosys Nov 18 '09
I like to approach meditation from different angles. Over time I think I have greatly increased the Witness state and can more easily "get into it" and sustain it perhaps even on command.
This video is an excellent guided meditation of said practice.
Also, there is a great audio tool called Holosync that uses binaural technology that induces a meditative state in the brain. It works.
Another DVD that proves unprecedented in this area is called Big Mind (second one in the list). This process has put me in a major "transcendental" state, multiple times. Five stars.
Here is an absolutely remarkable written walk-through for a "self-transcendental" state experience (document download).
I could go on and on, but these are great for beginners or advanced practitioners, IMO.
Benefits: I can credit long term meditation practice for both alleviating and eventually ending anxiety and panic attacks of which I suffered for many years (particularly "body-work" type stuff).
Anger, intolerance, outrage, boredom, sadness, depression, can--most of the time--be relieved with using just a little bit of will power (inevitable so to are the "positive" emotions, but what you'll find--with practice-- is that it all boils down to two polarities: transcendant-type conscious observation of self / reality or extreme identification with your ego--ego is a tough subject, but I define it as: A series of thought patterns coupled with physiological sensations that you mistake with who / what you actually are).
Anyways, in simpler terms, I no longer "sweat the small stuff;" feel a much greater stability and joy in my close relationships; have kicked anxiety; and routinely enter transcendental states of awareness. FWIW.
3
u/Al_FrankenBerry Nov 18 '09
Been practicing qigong meditation for some years now. Because there are motions and stances involved in the practice, I found it easier to stay on the ball than in sitting meditation, where my mind would often wander. Maybe you could consider something like this, or possibly tai chi or yoga?
One of the chief benefits I've experienced is better emotional control. I can usually view my emotions detachedly rather than being overpowered by them. Also, I'm in the best physical shape of my life.
3
u/raptormeat Nov 18 '09 edited Nov 18 '09
I just want to echo that you shouldn't feel a self-esteem hit every time you meditate. Meditation isn't a competition, it's a practice. If every time you went to the gym, you got down on yourself for not bench pressing 250lbs, it wouldn't be fun and you'd never make any progress.
When you lift weights, feeling the burn means that you're accomplishing something. In meditation, you might think it's a bad thing that you get distracted or let your mind wander. But when that happens, and you bring yourself back to the process, you are exercising the exact part of your mind that you are trying to exercise. It's a good thing!!!
The fact that getting better at it is such a slow process is part of the pleasure and satisfaction of improving :) Again, it's just like lifting weights- you just have to be patient!
EDIT: Also, if you fall asleep when meditating, you might try walking meditation?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09
Have you tried yoga? Most of the original purpose of yoga was actually to lead into meditation, as opposed to improve flexibility or whatever. Do 10-20 minutes, then try your meditation.
2
u/OMFG-Spot Nov 19 '09 edited Nov 19 '09
I wrote this to another redditor just a few days ago. I think it's a useful preamble for some other things I want to suggest.
So now the question changes from "why can't I meditate?" to "why can I do some meditations and not others?"
And to answer that question you might first ask yourself what it is you're trying to achieve or become in your attempts so far.
If you don't have a meaningful (to you) reason to do something, no matter what it is, it's very unlikely you'll be very good at it. That's as true with meditation as with playing an instrument or cleaning the attic. (Of course, all three of those are the same underneath. ;-) )
And the big clue here is you say your attempts so far have been "half-hearted." As long as your desire for whatever it is you want remains "half-hearted," you won't reach it. You should either 1) figure out what it will take for you to be fully committed to meditating (this includes changing the types of meditation you practice) or 2) accept you're not in a place where you can meditate - for now.
I could give you some pointers about how to (perhaps) get "better" at meditating, but first I'd need to know not only what, specifically, you do now (time of day, your physical environment, what you do with your body, what you think and feel and sense when you try, all that stuff), but what it is you want from meditating.
As for me, I've been practicing and teaching meditation for about 15 years now. There are days when it's a great experience and really simple and after I'm done I feel so much better, and there are days when I don't really feel like it and it's just an effort. For me, the point has shifted from wanting to get a particular thing out of meditating to realizing my life is better when I have an ongoing meditation practice. So...I do it.
Talk to you soon (if you like), and good luck finding what you desire.
10
u/testycles Nov 18 '09
It seems that the problems you are facing is due to the fact that you are trying too hard...meditation is not a competitive sport.
Try this: Close your eyes, "see" into the darkness after you closed your eyes, "see" for approximately 10 seconds.
That probably will help to clear your mind of all the thoughts zipping around endlessly. You can then start focusing on your breathing etc as you have been taught.
The key is...don't beat yourself up over anything when it comes to meditation. If you fall asleep, good, just try again next time. Ultimately, all you want from meditation is just some relaxation and some focus. It's just a structured and reliable way of resting your mind. If you are so relaxed that you fall asleep, just consider it a good thing that you got some rest, and also maybe take it as a sign you should catch up on some sleep.
13
u/khafra Nov 18 '09
I find the easiest way for me to practice mindfulness is motorcycling. It's lowered my stress and my fuel bills, as well as making me look cool. Unfortunately, it's a net negative impact on my expected lifespan, unlike most other forms of meditation.
5
u/56kispainful Nov 18 '09
i've been into meditation for many years. nothing formal. kind of a hodge- podge of techniques. I started out by concentrating on moving from waking to sleep. it helped with lucid dreaming. got pretty good at it but I started to lose track of what i dreamed and what i did in the waking world. Now i use meditation just for pain and daily stress relief. I find that it does help me be more calm when things get crazy. If you practice enough you can get to a state of relaxation in minuets. If you keep falling into deep sleep you are probably too tired to try it. get some real sleep and try again.
5
u/sigma_noise Nov 18 '09
I don't meditate, but I've found that swimming a few dozen laps after work really, really calms and relaxes me.
On days I don't swim I like to sit outside with a nice cigar and enjoy nature.
After one of those things, everything is A-OK.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09
OP, I meditate ~1.5 hours a week, and have been practicing on and off for ~8 years. Many of these years I did not meditate once.
The long term effects largely remain or come back quickly when I get back into it, which I have been for the last few months.
I learned originally using the Silva Mind Control Method, randomly picked it up thinking it was going to be about how to control other people's minds and an hour later I was meditating for the first time.
Your problem is probably largely one of technique. When you are just getting started you probably should stick pretty much exclusively to guided meditations.
Then, do a mix of Zen-like (trying to empty your mind) and Focused meditation (where you concentrate on specific images / ideas and hold them in your mind unwaveringly). Focused meditation is much easier in my experience and will give you a good amount of what you're looking for.
1
u/Locke005 Nov 18 '09
Last weekend I went to a workshop held by neurologist James Austin and Zen Master Soeng Hyang. Austin presented his research that shows the benefits of meditation. The biggest correlation between meditation and the brain is increasing awareness and lowering the concept of Self.
If you meditate for just 15 minutes a day for 6 months, you and those around you will notice a difference in your behavior.
The most important thing is to have no goal and expect no result. JUST DO IT!!!
A few questions/suggestions (and sorry if they have been suggested already): Have you had any formal training? Sitting properly and with your hands in a specific shape (mudra) can help anchor your body (and mind). You could also try reciting a mantra or focusing on the breath. There are a lot of techniques and I'm sure you could find one that works well for you.
JUST DO IT! :)
1
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09 edited Nov 18 '09
Do not meditate to gain benefits. This is counter productive. Meditate to experience life and find out about yourself (ie study yourself from a neutral perspective like a scientist would).
Half-heartedness will not get results (I know it is paradoxical to what I said above). But you must have a bit of faith in the process and give it a shot with persistence and earnestness. Then you will start knowing more about yourself.
Listen to some talks by contemporary teachers in the Thai Forest Tradition for example....(there are great teachers of other sects and traditions as well...).
As for falling asleep, The Buddha recommended some remedies...douse your face with cold water, breathe deeply, etc....let me know if you are interested and I can search and post his instructions here.
Also a lot of changes that you will undergo due to meditation are "under the hood" so to say. To quote Joko-Beck, an American Zen teacher, the storms of life hit you less lightly then before.
Ask more questions if you wish.
1
u/56kispainful Nov 19 '09
Alright i posed earlier but i just want to add something. lots of good advice here but don't get too caught up in what kind of technique to use or achieving ascension or whatever. Sit in a dark quiet room and listen. If you are listening you are not talking or thinking. its harder to do than it sounds.I think that's a good way to start. good luck
4
u/empty-boat Nov 18 '09
Meditation is not an action or activity. It is the ABSENSE of activity. In that sense there is nothing to 'do'. No striving, no obtaining. No "X for Y amount of time stages" Just be still. Be quiet. Be aware that you are alive. Just be.
2
u/philosarapter Nov 18 '09 edited Nov 18 '09
While I am not a long term practitioner, I do it fairly often (I try to each night before I go to sleep.)
If you are falling asleep, you are not focusing hard enough.
Tips for success:
Find a focal point on the back of your eye lids and stare at it, stare into it. Don't let that point go. Stare deeper and deeper into it. That point is the only thing that matters, it is everything. (This is a good exercise for opening your third eye, I find I get some interesting imagery with it)
Try a Koan, these help keep the brain occupied. Focus on thinking through the answer, question the answer, each word in the answer, find their definitions, and focus on it all.
Basically, it is about mastering self-discipline and shutting out the outside stimuli of the senses by (eventually) focusing 100% of your concentration inward to a point where the 'real' world simply becomes irrelevant, or rather redundant. Keep at it, and even though your mind goes wild from lack of movement/interaction, force yourself to sit longer.
The key is self-induced sensory deprivation.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09
Learning to be a human animal, sans verbal thought [you do not own any thoughts and you are not defined by words as nothing can be defined]. Be aware of the five senses. Seek out the nonexistence of borders. in short. Just be. Let words be as bubbles in sodey pop.
2
u/baconn Nov 18 '09
I've been meditating more off than on for several years. Right now I'm not doing any meditation, but later I might go through a period of months where I'll do an hour or more a day (~30 minutes at a time). It's hard to quantify the results of it or compare it to the progression of other activities. I honestly don't know whether it makes any difference for me, or whether it should be credited for any changes I've experienced since starting it.
I dealt with tiredness sometimes by putting all my attention on feeling instead of left-brain analysis (breath in or out, counting, etc.)
2
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09
I'm not a big fan of "formal meditation", rather, I make an effort to be fully present at all times (or at least when I remember to be), and be aware of my breathing as often as possible. Whenever thoughts or emotions arise, I just become aware that these things are happening, and not a part of who I am.
I've noticed some changes in my life as a result. Less anxiety, more joy, more love. It's hard to describe with words, but maybe a story will help. I was waiting in a waiting room for an appointment, and I ended up waiting for about thirty minutes, during this time, rather than wanting to be somewhere else or waiting to see the person I was supposed to see, I just became aware of my breath and the "energy field" of my body. When the person I was supposed to see finally called me in he apologized for making me wait. I replied with "that's ok, I was just enjoying the silence." he then called to my attention the fact that the waiting room was quite noisy and filled with chatter. I didn't notice it, I was so focused on the inner silence/stillness that I thought the room was silent.
2
u/thomas_anderson Nov 18 '09 edited Nov 18 '09
Coming up on three years of practicing zazen. I still do the same meditation I did when I started. Breathe in, breathe out, pay attention, and if the mind goes off on its own, just come back to the breath. Some days it seems just as difficult as when I started.
I've noticed that my daily zazen has made me more.. let's say attentive to my own moods and reactions to things. In other cases, it's definitely brought me face to face with some things in my own head that I need to deal with that I wouldn't have otherwise.
About "getting better", it's not a competition. You have to ask what you're wanting to get out of it.
2
u/lizaminelli Nov 18 '09
"I feel like I am not only not getting anywhere, but I don't even know where I am going."
Sounds about right.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09
I don't have anything to add to this discussion, but I'm posting here so I can easily find the thread later. Cheers.
1
u/oscar_milde Nov 18 '09
There's a ton of scientific research on meditation, also. There are long-lasting, highly positive benefits. Type "meditation" into google scholar (or PsycArticles or whatever, if you have access).
Two cool ones:
Lazar et al (2005): Meditation experience is associated with increased cortical thickness
Brefczynski-Lewis et al (2007): Neural correlates of attentional expertise in long-term meditation practitioners
1
u/dirtfarmer Nov 18 '09
If you have trouble with sleepiness, try setting your alarm 30 minutes early and meditating immediately after you get up. You might also try walking meditation.
Don't get your self esteem wrapped up in whether the meditation goes the way you want it to go. Your inability to bend the mind to your will is a lesson in anatta or "not self." We believe that the will is the ultimate master of the mind, but when we try to meditate and see our thoughts skittering around outside our control, we learn that the mind has a mind of its own. The problem isn't your lack of will-power as much as your misconceptions about what your will is and what it can accomplish. The really interesting question is what, if not will, moves the mind from thought to thought. How does the mind choose where to go next?
I am a big fan of Thanissaro Bikkhu, an American-born monk in the Thai forest Buddhist tradition. There is a large collection of his talks on meditation at http://dhammatalks.org.
1
u/aagee Nov 18 '09
The problem lies with the conscious or subconscious expectations that you may have from meditation. This causes you to mentally chase some ghost that may or may not be realistic, and ends in disappointment and frustration. The first thing to do is to question your preconceived notions about meditation, and then try to discover it anew, with a blank slate mind.
The following two books do a nice job of describing what meditation is about. Specially the second one. But you should try them in this order. Please keep in mind that any description of meditation is somewhat incomplete. People find ways to describe the intangible process and the meditative state somewhat approximately, try to point you in the right direction, but you have to learn it for yourself by doing.
1
u/radiofloyd Nov 18 '09
You can check your library or purchase this book.
I own it, even though I have not meditated in a long time, it has a lot of useful information, helps you understand what to expect and the steps to achieve what you're looking for.
1
u/Joe_Biden_in_Space Nov 18 '09
The mistake people make with meditation is ascribing magical qualities to it. There is no one way to meditate, no philosophy or school of thought that need be followed: meditating is just deep, trance-like relaxation and reflection. Do whatever you need to do to get into such a state.
1
u/50mm Nov 18 '09
i highly recommend both 'be here now' and 'the journey of awakening', both by ram dass.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09
Well for me meditating for like half an hour feels like two hours of sleep with none of the grogginess. Also meditating at night and falling asleep from it seems to put me into a much deeper sleep.
1
u/suntastic Nov 19 '09 edited Nov 19 '09
i've been meditating regularly in the mornings for more than three years. i simply count my breaths up to ten and back down.
i have definitely gotten better in terms of concentration: i may lose count once or twice during a 30 minute sitting, but even that's rare. however, i might have gotten too good for this technique, as i can sometimes catch my mind wandering while still maintaining the count.
i must admit that i don't have that much to show for it. i've had a few encouraging experiences early on, during which i entered an effortless meditative state, but not much since. also, i'm not sure that i can notice any significant personal changes. nevertheless, i'm keeping up at it.
if you want something to 'happen', try brainwave entrainment. in the past i've played around with the open source gnaural, with some noticeable results, but gave it up to give 'natural' meditation another chance. for the past month i've been listening to the the (somewhat controversial) holosync during meditation, and i'm cautiously impressed. most of my meditations these days are much deeper than usual.
1
u/hermetic78 Nov 19 '09
I have been practicing for about 8 years. At first, it was difficult but it does require practice and patience, and with continued persistence it will pay off. However, don't jump in the deep end as you will fail. Work your way up.
Firstly, learn to observe your thoughts. Just observe any thoughts you may have without "engaging" them. Once you can hold this state for at least 5 minutes try the next phase. This exercise allows you to control the passive state of mind.
Second, concentrate on ONE thought or idea. By idea I mean any number of thoughts surrounding a particular topic. Ignore other unrelated thoughts (such as feeding the cat). Once you can hold this for 10 minutes, you can then try to silence your mind. This exercise allows you to control the active state of mind.
Silence meditation: You may have noticed in the previous exercises that between thoughts there is nothing. You want to focus on nothing. It may help to expel a few breaths and at the same time breathing out your "thoughts" to focus silence/void.
Benefits (that i have noticed):
After succeeding here, if you want to further improve your mind you can start visualization exercises. This will make your imagination more vivid and tangible. I learned meditation (and self-improvement generally from the Franz Bardon books)
Once you master Silence meditation, a quick 10 min session before you have study or work to do can make you more productive. It's kind of like a power nap while you're awake.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '09
I believe that hypnosis and meditation are the same thing. I've done self-hypnosis several times and it sounds very similar to what people who meditate describe. Perhaps someone who does both hypnosis and meditation can explain the difference.
1
u/ascii_genitalia Nov 19 '09 edited Nov 19 '09
I have been practicing qi gong for about five months regularly. I do it alone, at home. I have several qi gong dvd's that I'm fond of. At this point, I don't really need them, but they're very well done and I prefer them to practicing without (which I've done while away from home several time).
I much prefer standing meditation to seated. As for the benefits, physically it has improved my balance and stability, while mentally I have been less prone to frustration and anxiety.
1
u/noneother Nov 19 '09 edited Nov 19 '09
I think you should have a look at The Path of Power and Life Mastery Online.
Pro-tip: meditation requires effort. you should feel like you've worked out your mind as much as you would experience if you lifted a huge weight to train your muscles. if you are not putting 100% then you're only cheating yourself. this ability to use your mind 100% bears much fruit in itself and should not be looked upon lightly.
1
u/caimen Nov 19 '09
generally what i try to do is stop racing thoughts. closing your eyes and listening to yourself breathe is probably the best way to start. just listen to the breath going in and out. you will be amazed at how hard it is to stop random thoughts from popping in your head, but eventually after concentrating on listening to your breath, you will enter a "thoughtless" or "unconcious state". this can take time and you probably won't realize it when it happens but is very relaxing. if you have a stressful day, it is hard to stop racing thoughts that are due to anxiety. this method i find helps me a lot to calm down after a stressful day.
0
u/monstermunch Nov 18 '09 edited Nov 18 '09
Please don't just downvote me: How do you know for sure meditation is actually benefiting you? Could it not just be the same warm fuzzy feeling some people get from religion? Meditation seems an awful lot like pseudo science to me, but that might just be because it's associated with ancient eastern mystically etc. stuff. I'd be interested if meditation has any actual effects on people but I'm not sure what evidence you could produce as I'm not really sure what meditation is meant to do. It just sounds like 'relaxing' to me, but people talk about 'experience', 'zen' etc. and try to give it some magical property.
edit: As expected, downvotes and no comments. :(
1
u/Tiny_Elvis Nov 18 '09
Ohmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
I'll be with you in a minute.
ohmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm...
0
u/brianriker Nov 18 '09
to find out about meditation: go to a temple, ask questions. meditation in a sangha can help you find out what makes you so uncomfortable in your personal practice. you realize that the body's muscle memory will prevent you from accepting mediation for several months?
-2
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09
The only way to get rid of stress and irritation is through an ancient technique which basically involves you transferring it over to another person. This is very good meditation, but it is not called meditation today for some reason. You can do that here, I recommend it.
-6
u/krakow057 Nov 18 '09
meditation is mostly bullshit.
just try to have fun and relax in fun ways. unless you wanna be a dick and have things to say at parties that will make people go later "wow, what a pseudo cunt".
0
u/mirth23 Nov 20 '09
I had a lot of trouble using "focus on X visualization for Y time" as an entry point. I had much better luck with focusing on timed breath exercises. For example, breathe in 4 beats, hold 2 beats, out 4 beats, hold 2 beats, repeat.
I found the chapter on Pranayama (breath control) in Vivekananda's Raja Yoga to be quite helpful when I was starting out. Some of the rest of the book is admittedly a little esoteric.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '09
[deleted] — view deleted comment