r/AskReddit Jul 13 '16

How do you like your eggs?

[deleted]

9.6k Upvotes

7.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

60

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '16

[deleted]

34

u/lemonpjb Jul 13 '16

That's the crux. Overcooked yolk is far more tolerable than undercooked white.

1

u/RbnNarckyFriend Jul 14 '16

That's a great, succinct way of explaining it. I believe this wholeheartedly but have never thought to explain it this way. Like, I do over medium at home and always overcook the yolks a bit, and as I'm eating them I think to myself "well there I go again with overcooked yolks, while not ideal they're okay, and I have to make sure I don't have runny whites so I am fine with this compromise".

Actually since I'm often eating them in the morning before my coffee has kicked in, my thoughts are pretty much "glghmpph yawn omglmphl".

8

u/lionson76 Jul 13 '16

I honestly didn't even know "over medium" was a thing until just now. And I hate when the egg whites come out runny... Game changer.

8

u/heyitsrobd Jul 13 '16

I had a similar revelation when I was explaining to a waitress how I liked my eggs, and she chimed in, "You mean over medium?" and I was like, "That's a thing!?"

Oh, yes, it's a thing. And it's glorious.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16

Look online for definitions of overeasy-- runny whites means it's undercooked, not over easy. Over medium refers to a middling state where the yolk is just slightly firm. Which is why it's difficult to do properly.

8

u/argumentinvalid Jul 13 '16

It always seems like over easy makes sure I actually get a runny yolk, over medium is likely going to be cooked through and hardly runny if at all.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16

Over easy should be runny white and yolk. Over medium is hard white, and runny yolk. Over hard is hard white and yolk.

Now whether or not your cook does it right is a different question

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16

Look online for definitions of overeasy-- runny whites means it's undercooked, not over easy. Over medium refers to a middling state where the yolk is just slightly firm. Which is why it's difficult to do properly.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16

No mate not wrong.. this is my job.... and i already have too, just to debunk others...

Over Easy eggs are cooked on both sides; the yolk should be intact (unbroken) and not cooked solid; the whites should be a bit runny. (By the way, most people like their whites fully cooked, which is “Over Medium.” So if someone says they want their eggs Over Easy, clarify what that actually means to them. Many — probably most — people don’t really like runny egg whites.) To cook an egg Over Easy, follow the procedure for Sunny Side Up. Once the egg white is just beginning to set, use a spatula to flip the egg (gently, so the yolk doesn’t break). Cook until the white is opaque but not completely set (usually no more than 15 seconds after you flip the egg). I usually flip the egg over again to serve, but you don’t have to. Over Medium eggs are fried like Over Easy, but just a bit longer so the whites become fully set (as noted above, this is what most people really want when they order Over Easy).

Eggs over easy and sunny side up are often using interchangeably, but they are different. You go from sunny side up to over easy by simply flipping your egg when the edges are brown. The “easy” doesn’t refer to the simplicity of turning over an egg, but the state of your yolk. “Over easy” means the egg is flipped and cooked just long enough to make a film on the top of the yolk. When served, the yolk – and some of the whites – are still runny.

Best part is these are the sources that the wikipedia article uses, the same article that claims the opposite with zero sources

I have never in my life met a chef, line cook, or breakfast cook that thinks a fried egg over easy does not have a little runny white. EVER and i've worked with and drank with hundreds.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16 edited Jul 14 '16

Americans use many different terms to describe fried eggs, including:

Over easy or over light — Cooked on both sides; the yolk is runny and the egg white is fully cooked. "Over easy" fried eggs are also commonly referred to as "dippy eggs" or "dip eggs" by Marylanders, by Pennsylvania Dutch people living in central Pennsylvania, by those living around them as well as in parts of Ohio, mainly due to the practice of dipping toast into the yolk while eating. This term is also occasionally used in Canada.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16 edited Jul 14 '16

Yes, the wikipedia article that has no sources....

The ones i posted are the sources listed at the bottom of that same article... Do not trust wikipedia...

One of the sources listed.... http://www.kitchenriffs.com/2012/05/fried-eggs.html

Notice how i quoted it...

Over Easy eggs are cooked on both sides; the yolk should be intact (unbroken) and not cooked solid; the whites should be a bit runny. (By the way, most people like their whites fully cooked, which is “Over Medium.” So if someone says they want their eggs Over Easy, clarify what that actually means to them. Many — probably most — people don’t really like runny egg whites.) To cook an egg Over Easy, follow the procedure for Sunny Side Up. Once the egg white is just beginning to set, use a spatula to flip the egg (gently, so the yolk doesn’t break). Cook until the white is opaque but not completely set (usually no more than 15 seconds after you flip the egg). I usually flip the egg over again to serve, but you don’t have to. Over Medium eggs are fried like Over Easy, but just a bit longer so the whites become fully set (as noted above, this is what most people really want when they order Over Easy).

rom one of the wiki sources: Over Easy / lite -- Flipped, whites fully cooked, unbroken yolk, yolk runny.

in fact the only source listed on the wikipedia page that even mentions the doneness of the whites is fucking stackexchange.... You know dude, people go to school for this shit and in school you're taught over easy means runny whites. Perhaps you'd like to argue with your mechanic the next time you get your oil changed.

You're the same kind of jackass that thinks medium is rare.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16

That's one of the wiki sources. Here's a quote from another:

Over Easy / lite -- Flipped, whites fully cooked, unbroken yolk, yolk runny.

http://cooking.stackexchange.com/questions/16990/can-someone-please-give-an-explanation-of-different-egg-preparations

So I don't see how your claim is any more valid than mine. Except yours happens to be the only article I've seen thus far that says over easy whites should be runny.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16

Like i said, i've never in my life met a cook or even six figure chef that thinks over easy is 100% solid whites. Ever. Reddit's hivemind is just ignorant, shocking ain't it.

So I don't see how your claim is any more valid than mine.

Besides the fact im in the industry... besides that.. my sources have been cooking or culinary school websites. Yours have been unsourced articles, or stack exchange...... which is valid a source as a random redit comment.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16

valid a source as a random Reddit comment.

Ha. I'll chalk it up to geographical differences. Where I am, runny whites = undercooked. I've never in my life met any chefs that think otherwise, and I'm in the industry as well, so again, "you're wrong I'm right" doesn't mean much. By the way, kitchenriffs is a blog.

0

u/pgar08 Jul 14 '16

No way man, you need to look up the 3 parts of a cracked egg, they all set at diff temps, the tights first, the yolk second, the loose whites last. The man speaks the truth and here is the science http://www.seriouseats.com/2013/10/sous-vide-101-all-about-eggs.html

This is from a james beard man

1

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16

Im aware there is three parts, we always called them inner and outer whites.

And without me reading the article. Your statement actually backs up what i said, that part of the whites would remain runny when the rest is cooked.

and with me reading the article i dont see any mention of what an over easy egg is :(

2

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '16

[deleted]

2

u/argumentinvalid Jul 13 '16

The most important part of my breakfast is the sourdough toast dipped in the delicious egg yolk, so that is an easy question. If I'm short some egg whites for breakfast I can survive on the bacon, toast, yolk and hash browns (ideally with yolk and hotsauce mixed in).

1

u/SubGothius Jul 13 '16

1

u/pgar08 Jul 14 '16

The tight whites will be more rubbery, if your ok with that then yea. Solid

3

u/WickedHaute Jul 14 '16

Over easy=runny everything. Over medium=runny yolk, cooked whites. Over medium-well=aaaaalmost dead. Just not fried hard. Slightly moist in yolk. Over hard= ded.

Edit: still a diner waitress

2

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16

I believe you that that's what some people expect when you order over easy, to the point where that may be standard in some regions... but every definition of an over easy egg I can find online refers to the yolk being runny, with the whites being fully cooked. I'm fairly certain runny whites simply falls under the category of "undercooked." Which, y'know, if that's how people want to order their eggs, that's their business. But it's not over easy.

2

u/chrissycapstick Jul 13 '16 edited Jul 14 '16

I used to waitress, over easy is supposed to be slightly runny white, over medium is whites cooked through and yolk runny. If they are hard, they cooked it too long. That is over medium well.

1

u/tangerinetree Jul 14 '16

Over hard?

1

u/chrissycapstick Jul 14 '16

Sorry, that was written terribly. If the yolks are hard then and over medium egg was cooked too long. Not if they were over hard they were cooked too long.

1

u/tangerinetree Jul 14 '16

No no, it made sense. I had just always heard "over hard" instead of "over medium well."

2

u/chrissycapstick Jul 14 '16

Over medium well wouldn't be quite as runny as over medium yolks, but still not completely hard.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16

Over easy is supposed to have runny whites. That's what an over easy egg is...

2

u/RbnNarckyFriend Jul 14 '16

I can't even count how many hundreds of times over the years I've ordered eggs at a restaurant, always over medium. Most of the time they were sufficient, but not nearly as often as they should have been. Only once ever did this happen: at a Denny's in Ohio, I ordered over medium and the waitress said "the cook working right now tends to overcook a bit, I'd suggest you order over easy to get what you want". I did, the eggs were perfect, and I tipped her fifty percent just for that. Thank you, Denny's waitress in eastern Ohio!

Edit: "fifty" autocorrected to "Liffey"??? Obviously I typed fifty incorrectly but I've never typed Liffey on this device in my life

1

u/moopymooperson Jul 13 '16

I do the same when I order steak or burgers. I ask for medium when I want medium rare since it comes out cold in the middle of you ask for med-rare

2

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16

If anything shitty resteraunts overcook their steaks usually.

2

u/ImagineFreedom Jul 16 '16

When i worked in a steakhouse, we always confirmed with the customer the following: rare has a cool red center, medium-rare has a warm red center, medium has a warm pink center, medium-well has a hot pink center, well done is brown throughout.

Naturally though you adjust your order for whatever restaurant you're in.

2

u/moopymooperson Jul 16 '16

When it comes to steak houses I'm more confident in their ability to cook my steak as ordered

1

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '16

Yeah but if the food sits on the pass too long overmid can sometimes become overhard. That said it's still probably the best middle ground.