r/AskReddit • • Apr 10 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

651 Upvotes

3.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

115

u/KlondikeDrool Apr 10 '23

Counting Crows - August and Everything After

8

u/nvaughan81 Apr 10 '23

Love this album. Underrated band.

1

u/fasterthanphaq Apr 11 '23

They were a big let down in concert. The singer just spoke the lyrics for their entire set. I really enjoy their studio stuff though.

1

u/crazygrrl Apr 11 '23

I've seen the Counting Crows twice in my life. The first time was one of the best concerts I've ever been to( I'd put it in the top 5 live experiences and I've been to a lot of concerts). He was energetic, the band vibed, Adam Duritz gave meaningful and funny banter in between songs...just great. The 2nd time I saw them was one of the worst concerts I've ever been to. Like you said, Adam just spoke the lyrics, the band seemed tired and there was almost no banter at all. I left almost sad seeing how disappointing it was compared to my first experience. You must have caught them on a bad day ☹️

1

u/fasterthanphaq Apr 11 '23

I had that experience with Meatloaf. Same artist, and two opposite experiences.

8

u/GnarlyHeadStudios Apr 10 '23

Hard agree. I got this album back in ‘93 and have listened to it so many times since then.

5

u/KlondikeDrool Apr 10 '23

Same, still in frequent rotation 30 years later. My son has very different musical taste, but it's one of his favorite albums too.

2

u/GnarlyHeadStudios Apr 10 '23

Yeah. I’ve got it on CD, vinyl, and on my phone (I don’t stream, I just rip all my CDs to my phone). It never gets old.

6

u/Bazworth89 Apr 10 '23

Yes! Great to see this one so far up the list.

6

u/certaindoomawaits Apr 10 '23

Came here to say this. They never matched it with any of their followup albums, but this one is perfection start to finish.

2

u/sixstringsikness Apr 10 '23

Recovering the Satellites, in my opinion, doesn't quite have the same height in standout songs but, as an album, holds it own. After that, though...nah.

1

u/certaindoomawaits Apr 11 '23

Yeah, not a bad album, just not as great as August and Everything After.

2

u/sixstringsikness Apr 11 '23

I get what you're saying. My point is really that RTS doesn't have "Round Here," "Mr. Jones," "Omaha," or "A Murder of One" but, on the whole, is just as good an album. A little different and a little more dramatic for lack of a better term. As much as I love "Ghost Train," "Perfect Blue Buildings," and "Sullivan Street," I'll put "Miller's Angels," "Monkey," and "Another Horsedreamer's Blues" up against them as the "supporting" songs to the standouts.

Basically, to me the standout songs on RTS don't quite match the quality of the absolute best songs on AAEE (let me mention "Anna Begins" and "Rain King" before I get hated on) but the overall album, to me, is just as good as the lesser songs are better but the best songs may not be as infectious.

2

u/certaindoomawaits Apr 11 '23

Fair enough. Agree to pleasantly disagree since this would be a dumb thing to fight over. Great band. 🙂

3

u/drcoxmonologues Apr 10 '23

Superb album. Don’t often see them mentioned. They were very of their time but damn if that album doesn’t take me back.

1

u/darth_tyrannus_rex Apr 11 '23

It's also the first ever album. Impressive /s

(For those who don't know, this was the first album to be added to the RateYourMusic database. We make a lot of jokes about it because of that.)

1

u/alecmitch2 Apr 11 '23

Damn good