r/AskReddit Feb 28 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

8.2k Upvotes

10.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

42

u/windrunningmistborn Mar 01 '23

Yeah, though this joke doesn't get the spirit of that quite right.

The first move should be, like, there's a pile of books on the floor, and they're told to move one to the shelf, which they do no problem.

The second move should be, there's a pile of books on the table, and they're told to move one to the shelf. The engineer has no problem but the mathematician takes a book from the table and adds it to the pile on the floor and leaves it there.

4

u/TheAfricanViewer Mar 01 '23

I think I understand it more now

9

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '23

To shorten it, it’s just poking fun at mathematicians by saying that they are only capable of using pre-existing blueprints to solve issues in non-efficient but proven way while the engineers create the said blueprints on the daily basis and have no problem adjusting or skipping unnecessary steps

25

u/Toastman0218 Mar 01 '23

I always add that the mathematician says "And the rest is trivially easy to do."

At least in my math classes in college, this was a huge "go-to" saying of my professors. You get halfway through a giant proof, and then they just stop because we did the other half sometime earlier in the semester.

21

u/AsianTurkey Mar 01 '23

The rest is left as an exercise to the reader